Skip to comments.Man did not rescue child for fear of 'pervert' slur
Posted on 03/21/2006 6:38:34 PM PST by iPod Shuffle
Man did not rescue child for fear of 'pervert' slur
A BRICKLAYER who passed a toddler walking alone in a village shortly before her fatal fall into a pond said yesterday he did not stop to help in case people thought he was trying to abduct her.
Clive Peachey, from Cornwall, told an inquest jury in Stratford-upon-Avon that he had passed two-year-old girl, Abby Rae, in his van shortly after 10am on 28 November, 2002.
This was just moments after the toddler disappeared from the Ready Teddy Go nursery in the Warwickshire village of Lower Brailes, according to staff.
Abby was found an hour later in an algae-covered garden pond and rescued by her mother, Victoria Rae.
She was taken to Birmingham Children's Hospital by air ambulance but was pronounced dead.
Mr Peachey, of Liskeard, told the inquest he had passed the little girl as she tottered towards the road in High Street.
He said: "I kept thinking I should go back. The reason I didn't go back was because I thought people might think I was trying to abduct her.
"I was convinced her parents were driving around and had found her."
Mrs Rae, 36, wept as Mr Peachey gave his evidence to the packed hearing.
She had earlier read emotionally from a statement as she relived the moment she dragged her daughter from the pond.
Two nursery employees had gone into the garden during their search but told the inquest they did not see the pond because it was covered in green vegetation.
The inquest was adjourned until today.
This story is so tragic, yet I understand his thinking.
Still, in this day and age, can you fuly blame him?
Weird story i bet theres alot more to this than meets the eye I will stay tuned thanks
Are you really looking for an answer?
All the bad ones are, in hindsight.
A very sad story. The responsibility for the little girls death must be shared by every child molestor that ever lived.
About a year and a half ago, I was involved in an incident like this. Driving through a residential neighborhood early in the morning, I came across a small boy about 5-6 years old, obviously lost and confused. I pulled over and asked him where he lived so that I could take him home. Then I realized that if I put him into my car, I would probably have a lot of explaining to do. Fortunately I had a cellphone so I called 911. A police car showed up and I explained what had happened. The police officer looked at me very suspiciously and asked me a lot of questions before he finally let me go. I have no idea how the child got home but I'm thinking I made a wise choice not to get more actively involved in the situation.
That is a cop out.
I disagree. It was not stupid. Just sad.
I see exactly why he did what he did. THAT is what demonization of men has done.
And a society that forgets "innocent until proven guilty" and declares guilt on the 24 hour news networks.
Very sad for the girl :(
In France, he would have been arrested. In France, there is a legal duty to aid others, and it is a crime not to.
Not so in Anglo-Saxia.
If the man had a cell phone, he could have called Police, or he could have immediately alerted others to the child and let them call police.
Stop child, call police, end of story
Had he helped the child and one person screamed J'accuse! he'd be on Greta Van Susteren or Nancy Grace's show faster than you can say satellite uplink.
How sad that we have come to this.
No, just a terrible indictment of what has come to be!
When anyone has to weigh political correctness against right and wrong, it is a sorry state of affairs!
Have you, personally, got the balls, to do right, in the face of all adversity? How much of your secure life, are you willing to risk?
Tell that to the French Jews who were deported to Auschwitz without a peep of protest from the French.
This is the cost of being an "evil white male".
>>>Have you, personally, got the balls, to do right, in the face of all adversity?
Real men do.
They don't stop and look for public opinion for justification and security in their actions.
Why not hold the girl in broad daylight and ask somebody passing by to call the police? I would have stopped if I saw a two year old running around unsupervised.
60 years ago. Not relavent to the present discussion.
sign of the times...
At my age.......that would never happen to me. No cop would think twice.....
Very good point.
No good deed goes unpunished.
Bank on it.
But to know those were the choices he'd've had to know the future.
It's brutal, but I can't argue it. I don't blame anyone who doesn't want to get caught up in a modern suburban version of a Kafka novel.
That's so sad.
I can somewhat understand his position. The local neighbor girls who must be under 10 or so run a lemonade stand and hang out outside my drive since my road is dead end. Once a year, I stop by and buy it, but I find myself reluctant to do more because I don't want anyone to suggest I've taken interest in the children. I'd protect them to the death from perverts but if something were ever to happen, I'll be damned if someone suggests "well that guy seems to be around them all the time". Sad state of affairs.
I do look out for them. If I ever saw something odd, I'd intervene or call the cops, but I pretty much won't interact with them except very rarely.
"you'd have to be out of your mind to even touch someone else's naked child in this day and age, no matter his or her condition."
Oh yeah? I still remember a murder more than thirty years ago, a l0 year old girl who escaped from her kidnapper and went running naked along a highway - many motorists saw her and didn't stop - "I thought she was using the bathroom or something" - kidnapper caught her again and finished the job.
For God's sake, help the child. Wrap the child in a towel, sit on your front porch and wait for the police.
I completely understand his thinking. My husband, who loves kids (we have five), has been very stand-offish towards little kids for this very reason.
A very, very sad situation.
You got it. If doing the right thing was easy and without risk, we'd all do it all the time.
I shall echo Calpernia - Real men do.
When I am home alone on Halloween, which is often the case, I don't answer the door to the little trick or treaters.
Actually 'innocent until proven guilty' only means that during trial the prosecution has to make the case of your guilt. In other words, you don't have to make the case that you are innocent.
Many believe it to be that you should not be under suspicion if you are arrested. However, if people really believed that the police were in the habit of arresting innocent people, there would be revolt against police corruption.
I had some random four to five year old child show up on my doorstep, just about out in the middle of nowhere, around 11:30pm this past Halloween. I had a bit of a personal crisis deciding what to do with it.. :)
In any case, I told her to (a) keep her distance; and (b) hang out on the deck while I called 9/11. She proceeded to cry while she did that. *sigh* The cop that showed up very suspiciously took down an incident report (and absurdly asked if he could come in while he did it ... um, no). So, to make the long story short, I can certainly understand this guy's thinking.
PS. And I also made a point of getting the cop's info and calling the PD afterward to inform them of who took the child and when. My motto is: Trust no one!
I am very saddened (to coin a phrase) to see how many would need to make an 'ology of this.
Study the situation, take a poll, create focus groups....
'What would be the popular opinion?'
The best approach is to begin to help and bring in other adults as they become available.
Then again, I tend to underestimate kid's ages, so she might've been six or seven.
Well, 7 would be a real surprise - let's just say 4-6! LOL
Hindsight is perfect, eh?
Years ago my wife and I had a 3 year old foster daughter. We took her to a park one day and she walked in front of another kid on a swing and got kicked in the chin causing her to bite her tongue.
Not a terribly serious injury but she just wouldn't stop bleeding. We took her to the emergency room and I was holding her, we were both covered with blood and it looked terrible. She was calm by then and the nurses wanted me to step out of the room. I knew the purpose of that, they wanted to ask her if the big bad man had abused her.
They had to call it quits in that effort because every time I got out of her sight she wouldn't stop screaming for me and they were unable to question her because of it.
If IFS and BUTS were HOS and SLUTS we'd all have AIDS.
This was truly a horrible decision by the guy.
People are crazy and times are strange Im locked in tight, Im outta range I used to care, but things have changed.
(Bob Dylan Things Have Changed)
The mother acted kind of like I was crazy. That was before cell phones and reporting everything to child protective services.
I used to get away from my mother a lot when I was little (hyperactive), and kind strangers always "rescued" me. Once they stood me on a display table in a department store where there were a lot of people milling around. Finally my mother spotted me among the fuss. Even at that young age, I was embarassed.
It is horrible that it has come to this. A little girl fell through the bleachers at a race (I saw that happen once myself at a stock car race) and was bleeding badly. My son grabbed her and ran with her to an ambulance he had seen near the entrance of the track. I suppose that is different, but I think the father (who was kind of stunned) didn't know what to do and appreciated the help.
He knows how careful he has to be because I drummed it into his head when he was still at home. With women it isn't quite as bad, but it is still a problem.
I did follow up on it and found out the girl had been with some group of kids in a car and had evidently wandered off a couple hours earlier when the rest went up to a door, along with the chaperone. Then, they drove off without realizing the girl had fled and couldn't find her when they went back soon thereafter.
As for when she was up on my deck, she pretty much cried the whole time so all I got out of her was that she was alone and lost, which was easy enough to see anyhow, not that I cared to ask many questions to begin with. I just wanted it to go away with minimal drama. :)
PS. I really do like kids; I'm just not stupid..
A personal story. Several years ago my wife and I went to the White Mountains of New Hampshire to see the plume (?spelling). We were with friends. There was a little girl near the rushing water crying she was lost. I picked her up, sent my wife and friends ahead and behind to see if they could find her parents. Her father came to me and looked at me hatefully. He took her from me, turned and walked away, never saying anything to me. I am a grandfather, blessed with 10 little ones, and I would be reluctant to help now. I know I would but I would still be concerned!
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.