Skip to comments.DEAR CONGRESSMAN MURTHA...(FReepers, Please Read...)
Posted on 04/04/2006 3:26:43 PM PDT by Fintan
ISAW YOU ON TV recently. With all the venom and bile you could muster, you pronounced, "This is George Bush's war."
I understand fully what you were saying. You were telling the country and - more import- antly - our enemies, that this is not your war, that you do not support it.
More than that, you were saying that it is not your party's war. And, you were telling Abu Musab al-Zarqawi, Osama bin Laden and their jihadist allies that it is not America's war: "This is George Bush's war!"
You are wrong, congressman. Dead wrong. You are wrong on three levels: institutional, historical and moral.
On the institutional level, Congress voted to authorize this war. Virtually every prominent Democratic politician spoke in favor of its objectives - Hillary and Bill Clinton, John Kerry, Madeleine Albright and Joe Lieberman, to name just a few.
Many now conveniently ignore or seek to rationalize their vote. A few courageously stand by it.
But, it is not Congress' war, either. When Congress voted to authorize the war and the commander-in-chief gave the order to initiate it, it became our war. Ours: yours, mine, the country's. Our war, sir, not George Bush's.
You are wrong, too, about history - past and future. You were referring, of course, to the Iraq "war." However, history tells us that this is one battle in a larger war against radical, fascist Islamic fundamentalists who seek to conquer.
Do you know your history, sir?
Do you listen to what our enemies say?
Listen, they will tell you: They seek to restore Islamic rule and sharia law over that portion of the world that they regard as historically "theirs."
They mean not only the Mideast, but northern Africa, central Asia - and even Spain.
Then, they seek to expand that rule by imposing the same regime on any country where there is a significant Muslim population, anytime. They mean Europe, Nigeria - keep your eye on Nigeria, congressman, it is already happening in that most populous country of Africa - and, yes, the United States.
Do you deny any of these things? On what basis, sir?
They rightfully identify the United States as the sole power capable of standing in their way, of marshaling opposition to them.
Calling this battle "George Bush's war" won't blunt their strategy. No, it supports it.
Have you forgotten the other Islamic fascists' battles against us, indeed against the world?
Do you remember the airplane hijackings, the bombing of the Marine barracks in Lebanon, the USS Cole, the bombing of a barracks at a U.S. air base in Spain, bombings of U.S. embassies in Kenya and Tanzania, the World Trade Center in 1993, in 2001?
They all are part of this war that George Bush did not start.
Yet they are not even the beginning of this war, congressman. This war has been going on for centuries, and it is not going to end if we retreat now, as you advocate.
Finally, you are wrong on the moral level.
Let me explain, lest you think that you have a monopoly on morality.
My son is now preparing for his second combat deployment in this battle. He will tell you that it is his war.
In his first combat tour, my son wrote: "I truly see this as a battle between the forces of good and evil. How can anyone not? Good brings hope to a whole people that have never known any and evil cuts the heads off innocent civilians on TV."
THAT SORT OF sums up the morality that our soldiers see. He and his comrades would like to think that they are not fighting this alone, that this is not just their and George Bush's war.
They would like to think that they fight for this country, including you, congressman.
It is their war, it is my war, and it is this country's war.
My son's life, and the lives of all the men and women fighting this battle are too precious to be endangered by politicians who give aid and comfort to our enemy in order to score rhetorical political points.
If you will not desist, I can only hope that responsible members of your party will repudiate your dangerous rhetoric and condemn your assistance to our enemies.
John A. Lucas, a lawyer in Knoxville, Tenn., is a West Point graduate and was an infantry platoon leader in Vietnam, where he earned four Bronze Stars.
Great letter. Too bad it's wasted on John Murtha and his ilk.
A great one. Should be framed.
I like it! ;o)
Thanks for posting this. And to think Flight 93 is in this A-Hole's District. Wondering if he has ever been there?
murtha : Pay attention
You have been hanging around to long with cut and run hanoi kerry
The Brothers and Sisters on The Wall know what you have done.
And before you complain about me, I was there also.
GOP Congressman and Former POW Rips John Murtha
Rumsfeld slams war statements by Murtha
Young Marine Blasts Rep. Murtha at Town Hall Meeting
Murtha's War Hero Status Called Into Question
Thanks for the ping; you just made my entire day.
My very best Bravo Zulu to Mister Lucas, his son and all the troops.
We should tattoo the entire text on Mothra's broad butt.
Well said Mr. Lucus
I need five minutes alone with this guy.
You'd beat up a demented, old fart? (Good for you - he deserves it).
Murtha is dissing our troops who are bravely fighting the WOT. He has no honor. This POS has caught traitor disease from Kerry.
Murtha called our troops "the enemy". For this reason, he should resign--- and the title of this article should drop the "DEAR".
I don't believe Mr. Murtha's party has enough "responsible" members left to make a phone booth crowded.
And I'd also say that I seriously doubt that the venom spewing from Murtha represents "his views". The man's history in Congress from ABSCAM in the 80s where he barely escaped the net to today shows that he is only motivated by pork, kickbacks and contracts to his brother's lobbying firm. Conscience, higher ideals or intellectual dissent have never been part of his operating agenda. What he is spouting are words dictated to him by those who have the goods on him and are extorting him with that evidence.
I can only hope that the good patriotic Pennsylvanians in his district kick his sorry ass out of office in November.
CLICK THE PIC