Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Illegal Immigration Is Not a Civil Right
Human Events ^ | April 21 2006 | Ian de Silva

Posted on 04/22/2006 12:05:03 PM PDT by Reagan Man

Liberalism's delusions have reached their most ridiculous extreme in the protests by illegal aliens. It was ridiculous enough that American liberals thought they were entitled to things that other Americans had worked for and earned, but now America is being told that illegal aliens -- people who have no right to be here at all -- should have the rights of citizens.

Illegal aliens and their supporters claim this is a civil rights issue. Balderdash. It is a desperate -- and despicable -- attempt to put a moral veneer on morally bankrupt protests. If illegal aliens have a moral claim to civil rights, then a band of burglars marching down the street protesting tough burglary laws also deserve moral respect.

Lest I am accused of being a racist or a xenophobe (epithets that are routinely hurled at conservative critics of immigration), I should perhaps provide a few personal details. Ideally, the legitimacy of your argument should not depend on who you are; rather, it should depend on the logic of your argument. But regrettably, in this age of political correctness, you are presumed to have no credibility on minority issues unless you are of a minority.

A Third World immigrant who went to a great deal of trouble to come here legally, I arrived here as a lone young man, brown-skinned, with very little money and a thick foreign accent--but a legal arrival nevertheless. I got my green card not by protesting down the street, but by waiting in line for years and obeying the rules. I never received any food stamps or welfare checks. Not a dime. A naturalized American, I am extremely proud of my U.S. citizenship since I know I obtained it the right way.

I graduated from a historically black college. My first career was as a high-school teacher (math and physics), and two of my ten years in teaching were spent in a very poor, predominantly black district in the South. There I saw intractable black poverty. I saw where the civil rights struggles had made a difference -- and also where they had made no difference whatsoever. I saw where personal responsibility improved lives, and where entitlement destroyed lives.

In any case, it is a shameless travesty of the civil rights movement of the 60s when illegal aliens claim that theirs is the latest struggle in civil rights. This is very much like burglars claiming that having to disarm high-tech alarms and breaking through double-paned windows is the latest struggle in their line of work.

There is absolutely no moral equivalence whatsoever between the civil rights movement and the illegal alien protests of today. In the first place, that movement was the natural culmination of deeply moral arguments made over three centuries against patently immoral practices -- first slavery, and then the forced segregation of a whole race of people.

But there is nothing in our laws that bars Hispanics from coming here legally. So it is not as if our immigration laws exclude a whole race of people. In fact, the number of Hispanics admitted legally is far greater than that of any other race. For instance, in the five years from 2000 to 2004 inclusive, legal immigrants from Mexico totaled almost 900,000 (890,953, to be exact), while immigrants from India, the second highest, totaled 303,929. The trouble is that for every Mexican who comes here legally, five of his compatriots come here by simply jumping over the border.

(By the way, immigration from historically high European sources -- e.g., Germany, Ireland, and Italy -- is very low now. For instance, during the same five years, immigrants admitted from these three countries combined totaled only 57,710. So much for the liberal notion that immigration laws favor whites over nonwhites.)

The civil rights movement was launched by people who had every right to live here. After all, Rosa Parks, Martin Luther King, and other civil rights pioneers were not foreigners. They were Americans. They considered America their homeland. They spoke English, and spoke to the whole country. They did not march down the street waving African flags. They did not ask for special treatment from the law -- they only asked for equal treatment under the law.

But illegal aliens have no right to live here. They entered our country by jumping a fence in the dark of night. They are marching down our streets waving Mexican flags. (Though many of them have begun carrying the Stars & Stripes in the more recent marches, they have done this only after their own organizers told them about the bad publicity generated by the Mexican flags.) As their protest speeches indicate, they take ethnic pride in speaking Spanish; thus they speak only to one another, alienating the vast majority of Americans. No matter what they say, they are not seeking equal treatment under the law -- for if that is what they sought, they would have waited for their turn in the immigration lines, as countless legal immigrants have. They are asking for special treatment from the law -- that is why they want us to just forget about their illegal arrival and change our laws to suit them.

It is a point worth repeating -- what illegal aliens demand is special rights. Perhaps the liberals who support these fraudulent protesters should read some history. Rosa Parks did not ask the bus operator to take a special route just for her; having waited in line, she only asked that she be treated the same as other passengers.

The civil rights pioneers were descendants of people who were brought here against their will. But illegal aliens are people who came here willingly -- and willingly violated our laws. Theirs is not an involuntary condition, as involuntary servitude was for blacks. Illegal aliens chose to put themselves in the illegal condition. They cannot claim to be victims when their condition is self-induced.

By insisting that every American citizen be treated the same, the Civil Rights Movement brought change that uplifted both the letter and the spirit of the law. But what illegal aliens seek is change that will corrupt and destroy the law. In fact, if they get their Third World way, America will eventually have no laws. There will only be corruption and lawlessness just like in Mexico.

Given the fraudulent attempts by illegal aliens to arrogate civil rights, it is puzzling indeed to see the conspicuous silence of major black organizations. These organizations, the putative trustees of the civil rights movement, are being spectators while the house they built is being ransacked by squatters. Their inaction is particularly egregious considering that the people who will lose the most from uncontrolled immigration will be poor, unskilled blacks. After all, a basic knowledge of economics will tell you that the presence of a vast pool of cheap alien labor will only exacerbate the poverty of blacks by depressing their wages.

In fact, the late Barbara Jordan, undoubtedly one of the best-known black politicians of all time, who also chaired the U.S. Commission on Immigration Reform in the 1990s, was among those who warned about the adverse impact of cheap alien labor on blacks. She was hardly a conservative, yet she advocated restrictions on immigration.

Here is a telling example from recent days. The Washington Times reported that an Alabama employment agency sent 70 workers, predominantly black, to work for contractors involved in the rebuilding after Hurricane Katrina. The men were to be paid $10 per hour. But they were sent home after just two weeks -- the contractors had found Mexicans who would work for smaller pay.

Such instances would be a routine occurrence if illegal aliens are legalized. Once legalized, the ten million here could bring their relatives, and the final influx could easily reach thirty million or more. Poor, unskilled blacks would be pushed out of work in their own country by people who have no roots here. It would be a cruel irony if such a plight were brought about by the inaction of the very organizations whose self-proclaimed charge it is to protect the civil rights of blacks.


TOPICS: Editorial; Foreign Affairs; Government; News/Current Events; Politics/Elections
KEYWORDS: aliens; amnesty; borderlist; illegal; illegalaliens; illegalimmigration; illegals; immigrantlist; immigration

1 posted on 04/22/2006 12:05:06 PM PDT by Reagan Man
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | View Replies]

To: Reagan Man
Liberalism's delusions have reached their most ridiculous extreme in the protests by illegal aliens.

This is going to be a tough sell if they are granted any form of amnesty.

2 posted on 04/22/2006 12:09:37 PM PDT by manwiththehands ("'Rule of law'? We don't need not stinkin' rule of law! We want AMNESTY, muchacho!")
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Reagan Man
America is being told that illegal aliens -- people who have no right to be here at all -- should have the rights of citizens.

If that were true we would have neither legal our moral authority to maintain a border at all. Just throw open the border to the poor, oppressed, and diseased of the world. After all we did it before but still had health standards and required naturalization for citizenship.By the way the Black Death (Bubonic Plague) has broken out in LA. Anyone for Leprosy?

3 posted on 04/22/2006 12:11:14 PM PDT by luvbach1 (More true now than ever: Near the belly of the beast in San Diego)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: neverdem

ping. please ping the others.


4 posted on 04/22/2006 12:20:28 PM PDT by King Prout (The UN 1967 Outer Space Treaty is bad for America and bad for humanity - DUMP IT.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Reagan Man

In fact some illegals have more rights thancitizens. Some States give illegal students a Resident Status at paying for college while out of State "American" students pay more. if that isnt the stupidest thing you ever heard i dont know what is.


5 posted on 04/22/2006 12:24:03 PM PDT by sgtbono2002
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: luvbach1

"By the way the Black Death (Bubonic Plague) has broken out in LA. Anyone for Leprosy?"

You jest, but surely everyone does know that the reason you have to take a TB test now for employment at many places is because there is a rather large number of people in Mexico who are TB carriers and they are bringing it into the U.S.

But, of course, the people who hire them are NOT in the group who test for TB.


6 posted on 04/22/2006 12:25:37 PM PDT by no dems (Condi Rice will never pick cotton on the Democrats' plantation.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 3 | View Replies]

Comment #7 Removed by Moderator

To: HiJinx

ping


8 posted on 04/22/2006 12:33:04 PM PDT by DumpsterDiver
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: sgtbono2002

Illegals also qualify for "free down payments" and home loans at below standard interest rates offered by FHA, pay no taxes, penalty or interest. They are also not subjected to a "9 day demand letter" from the IRS until they attach homes, cars and bank accounts for those who simply disagree with what IRS "claims" they owe.


9 posted on 04/22/2006 12:35:04 PM PDT by zerosix (Romans 5:8)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 5 | View Replies]

To: Reagan Man
"There is absolutely no moral equivalence whatsoever between the civil rights movement and the illegal alien protests of today."

Not only that, the ILLEGALS want to change OUR COUNTRY to suite them. They don't want to adopt OUR LANGUAGE. They want to turn the US into MEXICO. Thanks, but NO THANKS! Maybe they should spend more time trying to change MEXICO instead of trying to change the US!

Either speak English dammit or go home! I don't want to search for ten minutes looking for ENGLISH instructions to put something I bought together. When I walk in an US bank I want to READ ENGLISH since I am in AMERICA, NOT MEXICO!

10 posted on 04/22/2006 12:45:19 PM PDT by kcvl
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: sgtbono2002
Some States give illegal students a Resident Status at paying for college while out of State "American" students pay more. if that isnt the stupidest thing you ever heard i dont know what is.

How about institutionalizing it on the federal level?

Hidden Bombs (Extremely Important Article on Immigration)

The second nasty surprise? Just before the committee approved the bill on the evening of March 27, Sen. Richard Durbin (D-Ill.) offered the "DREAM Act" as an amendment. It passed on a voice vote.

The DREAM Act is a nightmare. It repeals a 1996 law that prohibits state universities from offering in-state tuition rates to illegal aliens. The principle, of course, is that no illegal alien should be entitled to receive a taxpayer-subsidized benefit that out-of-state U.S. citizens can't get. But the committee's bill allows illegals to be treated better than those U.S. citizens on tuition.

This is an ammendment to the Kennedy/McCain bill. You may have seen photos of protesters with "Dream Act" signs.

11 posted on 04/22/2006 12:52:57 PM PDT by TigersEye (Sedition and treason are getting to be a Beltway fashion.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 5 | View Replies]

To: TigersEye

My boys Kennedy and Mcpain again.

Two Pieces of Shiite if there ever were any.


12 posted on 04/22/2006 12:55:33 PM PDT by sgtbono2002
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 11 | View Replies]

To: Reagan Man

Are all these people swarming in from Mexico the victims of some sort of political persecution? Is there a famine, or some other great natural disaster, now going on in Mexico?

If either of these conditions exist, there is great justification for entering that country with a large enough military force to successfully suppress the political persecution, even if that means removal of the current government, and installing one that can restore the internal balance of the nation. If Mexico has deteriorated to the point that there is widespread social disintegration and loss of civil order, through some calamity, then they desperately NEED our help, and should get it immediately.

Of course, these foreign expeditions do cost a good deal of money, so in exchange, we would accept Mexico's kind offer to repay us with adequate supplies of crude and refined petroleum products. As part of the deal, the US corporations will be extended the right to set up domestic operations, which will employ large numbers of the Mexican native population.

In fact, it makes enormous good sense to adopt the policy of making Mexico a protectorate of the US, and annex their entire territory, giving the Mexicans the same rights as Puerto Ricans now enjoy.


13 posted on 04/22/2006 1:06:11 PM PDT by alloysteel
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: sgtbono2002
Did you say you don't like McCain?
14 posted on 04/22/2006 1:06:54 PM PDT by TigersEye (Sedition and treason are getting to be a Beltway fashion.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 12 | View Replies]

To: alloysteel

Let's roll!


15 posted on 04/22/2006 1:08:30 PM PDT by TigersEye (Sedition and treason are getting to be a Beltway fashion.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 13 | View Replies]

To: Reagan Man

This article makes abundant sense, except that he mentions several times the impact on 'poor, unskilled' black men. They are poor because they are unskilled and, yet, for some unexplained reason they remain unskilled. Time to change that, IMHO.


16 posted on 04/22/2006 1:19:06 PM PDT by JustaDumbBlonde
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: TigersEye

Kinda opens your eyes doesnt it?

Does a America really need a Manchurian candidate?


17 posted on 04/22/2006 1:35:35 PM PDT by sgtbono2002
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 14 | View Replies]

To: JustaDumbBlonde
This article makes abundant sense, except that he mentions several times the impact on 'poor, unskilled' black men. They are poor because they are unskilled and, yet, for some unexplained reason they remain unskilled. Time to change that, IMHO.

Illegal immigration only makes things worse for them, but they are two much like sheep to buck the self-anointed 'Black Leadership' in bed with the Democratic Party.

18 posted on 04/22/2006 2:02:06 PM PDT by nosofar
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 16 | View Replies]

To: no dems
"By the way the Black Death (Bubonic Plague) has broken out in LA. Anyone for Leprosy?" You jest...

I don't jest. Just Google it.

19 posted on 04/22/2006 2:17:20 PM PDT by luvbach1 (More true now than ever: Near the belly of the beast in San Diego)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 6 | View Replies]

To: alloysteel

"In fact, it makes enormous good sense to adopt the policy of making Mexico a protectorate of the US, and annex their entire territory, giving the Mexicans the same rights as Puerto Ricans now enjoy."

Wouldn't that be blanket amnesty as well?

Puerto Rico is not merely a "protectorate". It is a territory of the United States, U.S. soil under the sovereignity of Congress and those born here are born citizens of the United States of America.

The United States of Mexico should get their act together and stop pretending that the United States of America take care of their indigent population.


20 posted on 04/22/2006 2:23:04 PM PDT by cll (Carthage must be destroyed)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 13 | View Replies]

To: luvbach1
From the Irish Times: Bubonic plague is not contagious, but if left untreated ...

That can't be right.

21 posted on 04/22/2006 2:26:35 PM PDT by luvbach1 (More true now than ever: Near the belly of the beast in San Diego)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 19 | View Replies]

To: no dems; All

And who brought the mumps into our country again?


22 posted on 04/22/2006 2:28:13 PM PDT by uncitizen
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 6 | View Replies]

To: JustPiper

Ping!


23 posted on 04/22/2006 2:36:23 PM PDT by TheLion
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 22 | View Replies]

To: Reagan Man
A "civil" right, by definition, is for citizens only.

civil
Pronunciation: 'si-v&l
Function: adjective
Etymology: Middle English, from Middle French, from Latin civilis, from civis

1 a : of or relating to citizens

24 posted on 04/22/2006 2:50:25 PM PDT by Gelato
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Thanx A. Lott

Any "GUEST WORKER PROGRAM" is AMNESTY, PERIOD! How do they expect to find a guest worker when his time comes up to leave. One week before his/her scheduled departure they will simply slip into oblivion in the land of milk and honey.


25 posted on 04/22/2006 2:52:34 PM PDT by doc
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 7 | View Replies]

To: Reagan Man
In fact, the late Barbara Jordan, undoubtedly one of the best-known black politicians of all time, who also chaired the U.S. Commission on Immigration Reform in the 1990s, was among those who warned about the adverse impact of cheap alien labor on blacks. She was hardly a conservative, yet she advocated restrictions on immigration.

Barbara may have been a Liberal but she was also a very good American. If only the Black Caucus would use her as a role model.

26 posted on 04/22/2006 2:53:06 PM PDT by Mike Darancette (Proud soldier in the American Army of Occupation..)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: King Prout

bfl


27 posted on 04/22/2006 3:00:02 PM PDT by neverdem (May you be in heaven a half hour before the devil knows that you're dead.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 4 | View Replies]

To: doc
How do they expect to find a guest worker when his time comes up to leave.

Our previous guest worker program handled that quite nicely. Typically, up to 1/2 of their wages were withheld until they arrived back in their home town.
Also, employers were penalized for hiring anyone who wasn't a legitimate guest worker.

If there is a legal way to be a guest worker, there's a lot that can be done to prevent illegals from ever working here. With no hope of employment, few would come.

28 posted on 04/22/2006 4:10:04 PM PDT by speekinout
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 25 | View Replies]

To: luvbach1
If that were true we would have neither legal our moral authority to maintain a border at all. Just throw open the border to the poor, oppressed, and diseased of the world. After all we did it before but still had health standards and required naturalization for citizenship.By the way the Black Death (Bubonic Plague) has broken out in LA. Anyone for Leprosy?

Agreed - I still have a problem with allegiance if there is not borders. To become a citizen you are supposed to believe and pledge this: "I hereby declare, on oath, that I absolutely and entirely renounce and abjure all allegiance and fidelity to any foreign prince, potentate, state or sovereignty, of whom or which I have heretofore been a subject or citizen.”(US Oath of Allegiance)

29 posted on 04/22/2006 4:40:47 PM PDT by p23185 (Being trashed by the Stone Age Press should be worn as a badge of honor by Repubs and Conservatives)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 3 | View Replies]

To: Gelato

So border-jumping Mexican citizens have civil rights--in Mexico! And to protect those civil rights, I suggest they scurry back there and vote AGAINST the communist candidate for President. If Mexico reverts to communism, then we will get a run of refugees crossing the border that we cannot return humanely to their homeland. Mexico first delved into the evil of Communism after their 1917 Revolution and only recently has returned to freedom (excluding Oaxaca and Chiapas).


30 posted on 04/22/2006 5:02:20 PM PDT by dufekin (US Senate: the only place where the majority [44 D] comprises fewer than the minority [55 R])
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 24 | View Replies]

To: Reagan Man

This is a point that needed to be made. I was around for the civil rights movement.

And I am sick of every new breed minority grievance group that comes along and claims their "cause" to be equal to the civil rights movement of the '60s.

They none of them have any idea or concept of the real grievances and sufferings of blacks in America prior to that time. There was outright, unequal racial segregation in the South, as well as the KKK, and there was more subtle discrimination in the cities of the North.

No group of immigrants to this country has suffered on such a scale, and no other rights-demanding group can claim moral equivalence. Period.


31 posted on 04/22/2006 6:14:07 PM PDT by La Enchiladita (God Bless Our Troops...including U.S. Border Patrol, America's First Line of Defense)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

Comment #32 Removed by Moderator

To: Reagan Man; All
The Hispanic Challenge (To America) A MUST READ Samuel Huntington (Long But Good)

The Mexicans are unlike previous immigrants. This Huntington article definitely needs to be read by everyone at least once! It should be linked on pertinent immigration threads. Here's an interesting link about Samuel Huntington:

"Strangely enough, despite the fact that he was buddies with Henry Kissinger at Harvard, he is registered as a member of the Democratic Party, and has written foreign policy speeches for Adlai Stevenson, Hubert Humphrey, and Jimmy Carter."

THREATS AND RESPONSES: LEGISLATION; SENATE VOTES, 90-9, TO SET UP A HOMELAND SECURITY DEPT. GEARED TO FIGHT TERRORISM

Senator Phil Gramm of Texas, the president's chief Senate supporter in changing the Civil Service protections in the bill, acknowledged that Democrats had written 95 percent of the bill and acknowledged the paradoxical role of small-government Republicans like him in advocating for such a large department.

And which party is now making it useless.

Bush: Democrat killed immigration bill

In private as well as public, Reid and Sen. Charles Schumer, D-N.Y., who heads the party's campaign effort, said they did not want to expose rank-and-file Democrats to votes that would force them to choose between border security and immigrant rights, only to wind up with legislation that would be eviscerated in future negotiations with the House, which has passed a bill limited to boosting border security.

Harry Reid: now and then

Path to Deportation Can Start With a Traffic Stop

33 posted on 04/23/2006 6:19:46 PM PDT by neverdem (May you be in heaven a half hour before the devil knows that you're dead.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: AdmSmith; Berosus; bigheadfred; Convert from ECUSA; dervish; Ernest_at_the_Beach; Fred Nerks; ...

Note: this topic is from 4/22/2006.
34 posted on 06/14/2009 8:20:12 PM PDT by SunkenCiv (https://secure.freerepublic.com/donate/__Since Jan 3, 2004__Profile updated Monday, January 12, 2009)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson