Skip to comments."United 93" reminds a forgetful nation of 9/11 tragedy
Posted on 04/30/2006 8:47:12 AM PDT by Daniel T. Zanoza
On Friday, April 28th, the movie "United 93" was released in theaters across the nation. The Universal Studios film is a fictional rendition of the events which occurred on the fourth airplane high-jacked by Islamic terrorists on September 11th, 2001. Paul Greengrass, who wrote and directed "United 93," depicts how heroic passengers attempted to regain control of a doomed aircraft which hijackers were planning to crash into the Capitol building in Washington, D.C. Those who acted on that day may have saved hundreds or even thousands of innocent lives. United Airlines flight 93 ended up slamming into the ground in a Pennsylvania field, killing all aboard, but leaving a legacy which will be remembered in American lore for years to come.
Though I have not seen the film, reports indicate the movie is powerful beyond description. Producers of "United 93" made the effort to interview family members of every crash victim. Ten per cent of the film's first weekend revenues will be added to a fund for a memorial created to honor the memory of what happened on that fateful day.
Unbelievably, there have been some who call the film controversial. Though filmmakers carefully consulted family members of victims, researched material from authorities pertaining to what took place on Flight 93 and consulted those who grappled with the situation on the ground, some critics have found other reasons to suggest the movie is inappropriate for viewing at this time.
Those who follow this logic claim the picture is too painful and was made too soon after one of the greatest tragedies in American history. They say those who see the film are forced to relive the troubling emotions of 9/11. Though nearly everyone reports "United 93" was done with taste and respect for those who died in the crash, detractors say Americans are not ready to relive the event.
In retrospect, I believe the movie is exactly what Americans need to see. Most will admit the public has a short memory and, at times, this is a good thing when it comes to some tragedies. There is no need to rehash over and over events like acts of God or negative experiences which could not be prevented. But there are times when it is important to understand and remember what happened during catastrophes like 9/11 and the showing of "United 93" surely serves that purpose. The film should shake the memories of the public and remind us of the fact that we are at war against a ruthless enemy that thinks nothing of killing innocent men, women and children.
We all remember our feelings of pain and outrage when the events of 9/11 unfolded. But Americans also should be reminded of the patriotism and togetherness we all felt in those days. This is a good thing.
However, there are those who do not want the nation's memory jogged. They believe, in some cases for political reasons, the events of 9/11 are best forgotten. Often, this mindset results from the hatred of George W. Bush and the policy involving America's war on terrorism. Sadly, in other situations, people do not want their lives complicated by being forced to relive something that makes them uncomfortable, even though it didn't touch their lives directly. But 9/11 did have an impact on most Americans on a personal level and it is important to remember why.
The showing of "United 93" is not controversial. Though it is reported the film depicts great violence, that's what happened on a fateful day in 2001. It is a good thing Americans not only remember those who perished on Flight 93, it is also a good thing the country remembers what they perished for.
All members of Congress and the Senate should be forced to watch this movie even if they have to duct tape and toothpick their eyes open with side blinders to make them look forward at all times.
No tissues allowed no hankies they should taste every tear the American people have tasted and it should burn into their skulls like a brading iron never to forget why we are fighting for America !
A movie so powerful it opening third this weekend behind "Stick It" and "RV."
I blame the advertising. The trailer (which shows quite often around here) makes it look rather like a made-for-TV movie.
I am going to watch it myself. Remember the people who were clamoring to Farenheit9/11? Same people are now saying "it's too soon"
My wife doesn't want to watch the movie... then I get this mental picture of an ostrich with its in the sand when I look at her.
Word-of-mouth will tell more.
Buzz on RV: "It sucks."
Buzz on F/93: "Gotta see this!"
I think word of mouth will build the audiences for this movie, which I saw last night. Very moving. Very powerful. Very well done. Reawkened some very angry feelings for the demented Islamofascists. "Religion of Peace" my @$$.
You must persuade her to go. Bribe her if you have to. She will not regret it.
I was shocked since we have never really talked politics and I had no idea she thought that way. What a let down from a freind.
A movie so powerful it opening third this weekend behind "Stick It" and "RV."
It opened 3rd in total gross, but it didn't open in as many theaters as the top 2 films. It actually grossed more per theater than the top 2.
Great flick!!!! All Americans should see it. Note the evident transfer of mood and action from pre 911 to post 911 in the military, the air controllers and the doomed passengers on United Flight 93. Although the film is totally apolitical, anyone with half a brain could see the country and key operating people did not have a clue that something like this would ever happen. You can thank Bill, Hilllary Clinton and the entire Democrat Party for that. Yep, and vote 'em again, you soon get a taste of Iranian supplied Nukes. Your kiddies and wives will just love that!!! Yeah, America, you don't have a clue as to what's coming. Your Democrat Party is and has actively aiding and abetting our enemies form the gitgo!!!!
Tell her, if Bush just wanted an excuse to go to war, the 2 towers crumbling to the earth would've been excuse enough for him.
And I like the excuse that Bush went to war in Iraq for the oil - if so, why are the gas prices so high.
I intend to see this, but my wife doesn't want to. She is very courageous and well aware of meaning of it all. Don't be too hard on your wife. I suspect that many people don't want to relive this tragedy though they are not lacking in courage or awareness.
Your friend is a sick woman. Encourage her to get help.
But a movie about Bush "lying" about 9/11 is made instantaneously.
It's all Democrat propaganda--either the lying leaders or the mindless morons who follow and parrot them.
When the movie ended last night, the theatre was black and silent. A man stood up and loudly proclaimed "THIS WILL HAPPEN AGAIN IF THE BORDERS ARE NOT SECURED".
the estimates are that the movie will be #2 for the weekend with slightly less than 1/2 of the number of screens as #1.
I have not seen the movie yet but friends who have seen it say it is a painful must see
I saw the film this afternoon and I can truthfully say it was probably the hardest film I've ever watched, but it needs to be seen. Americans who have incredibly short memories need to be reminded of the horrors of 9/11 and the moronic thinking of the Arabs who manned those planes. WE MUST NEVER FORGET.
I wonder about the screen number. Is it a limiting factor, or does it merely mirror audience projections? The audience demographics are likely very different for this movie. They were at the showing I attended.
by number of screens, I simply meant that the #1 movie was showing at twice as many theaters as "United 93".
without knowing number of seats etc etc, you really can't measure it but it is an indicator the movie industry uses
The theatres are out to make money. The # seats and frequency of showings usually reflect the projected audience for the flick. If this projection is accurate, i.e., if there aren't any sold-out shows, I have to wonder if these variables really affect the attendance/rating....
Of course, the random walk-in viewer would ordinarily increase with increased showings/seats, but I suspect this movie doesn't get too many of these....
Be careful with those tag lines Fiddlstix, I have a staff of attorneys monitoring for copyright infringement. LoL!
Also read here on FR that Bush needs to show this film every year instead of having a State of the Union address.
It definitely is NOT too soon to go see this movie.
Tell Mrs. Cinnamon that jimfree cried for 3 weeks in September 2001. I had to see this flick because I needed to be distubed in that way again. I needed to do it to honor the Flight 93 passengers. I needed to do it to emphasize what side of this fight I am on.
Thanks for the review. Definitely want to see it. Just need to find the time. I think it's the kind of movie that needs to be seen on the big screen first.
You are correct...see it on the big screen.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.