Posted on 06/22/2006 7:05:09 PM PDT by Reaganesque
More, more, more!!
C'mon, you know the answer. The left will not come out and say "Great, this is a big step forward and proof of American ingenuity".
No, the left will say: "Why do we not have enough of these to protect all Americans in Iraq? Why has Rumsfeld been so slow in ordering the Cougars? The President should have known we needed the Cougar before we went into Iraq?"
And on and on and on...................
It's a complete waste of time to try to respond to the nonsense from the Left.
The cougar is a good vehicle, but only available in small numbers due to production limitations.
However, there is no such thing as an IED proof vehicle. None of these have been lost yet, but they will be. Put 500 to 1000 lbs of high explosive in a roadbed and detonate it at the right moment and no vehice will survive. Physics rules here.
not to be an asshole but that doesn't look very tactical. I mean with the hummer they can be in and out of a situation but this thing looks like it would be a sitting duck.
Also how do troops get out of this thing quickly without getting hurt?
other than that I'm all for protecting the troops.
I'm no expert, but I'm thinking all vehicles are going to have to make some kind of compromise in combat situations.
Hopefully with enough choices, the best vehicle can be chosen for the jobs needed to be done.
No, it is not completely bomb proof. What is? (BTW, Wouldn't an IED with 500-1,000 lbs. of explosives be rather large and easier to spot?) Anyway, the point is, we're doing something about the biggest threat our troops face and we are seeing success, however slowly that may be.
It certainly raises the ante, but the VLIED (Very Large IED) are, in fact, the big killers today. They will take out anything, up to and including an M-1 Tank. They are concealed in drainage pipes underneath roadways, or in another technique - pour gasoline on the asphalt roadway, light it. Then scoop away the soft asphalt, dig a hole to bury your IED and then recover with asphalt. Wait for patrol.
I'm not trying to badmouth the Cougar. I wish we had more, but I'm just tired of hearing gutless politicians use something like the Cougar to attack the military because every supply clerk and chaplain's assistant doesn't have his own personal Cougar.
Try hiding that much explosives.
Mines are small so they don't leave
an obvious tell-tale sign of disturbed earth.
I don't think you are vey well informed about the current situation in Iraq. Very large IED's are the number one killer of American soldiers and have been for months.
awsome.
That was actually the Army. The system was sent to Iraq for evaluation. The results weren't good. Not ready for prime time. Maybe in another time and in another Galaxy, that solution will be ready. Just not now.
OK, so you can build a bomb big enough to blow up anything. So I suppose we shouldn't do anything more to protect the troops, just give up and get out?
Of course not. I'm just saying that there are no Silver Bullets. Pay attention.
Well said. We have largely neutralized the single 155 round. The larger devices are harder to hide, harder to emplace, and more likely to be discovered. However, when they do get lucky, you have 3/4 KIA. No point in treating for shock.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.