Here's a link to Social Security's take on the matter. http://www.ssa.gov/pressoffice/factsheets/USandMexico-alt.htm
It has some interesting explanations.
The way this works...because I'm a US citizen working in Germany...is that I get a five year exemption from Germany...to keep paying into the US pot of social security. When that five year exemption runs out...which it did last year for me...I must start paying German social security (which is 2 percent higher than I was paying into the US pot). If I choose to leave Germany...whenever...I can have the money I put into the German pot...transferred over to the US social security side. The plus side is that I still keeping into some pot somewhere.
When you measure the deal with Mexico...which is basically the same deal...I'm guessing that every Mexican in the US refuses the five year exemption deal and immedately starts paying into the US pot. After working 15 years in the US system...you have a tremendous amount of retirement income at 65....compared to what you'd have in Mexico. Would matter if you worked another day in the US after 15 years....that retirement check at 65 would guarantee you a mountain of retirement cash...which you'd never get in Mexico.
As for us losing something out of the system...maybe...but then social security is bankrupt...as is the German social scurity program....and all the rest of these deals. So people can whine all they want...it doesn't make much difference. The only complaint you can make is that this is all part of globalizaion in some fashion. Where it leads to in 30 years will be the interesting part....people who born in one country...then migrate and work in another country....then retire in a 3rd country.
Since the late 1970s, the U.S. has established international social security agreements that coordinate the U.S. Social Security program with the comparable programs of other countries.
These international social security agreements are called totalization agreements and have two main purposes:
Eliminate dual social security taxation that occurs when a worker from one country works in another country and is required to pay social security taxes to both countries on the same earnings. As a result of existing totalization agreements, U.S. workers and employers currently are saving about $800 million annually in foreign taxes they do not have to pay.
Help fill gaps in benefit protection for workers who have divided their careers between the U.S. and another country, but who have not worked long enough in one or both countries to qualify for social security benefits. With totalization, workers are allowed to combine work credits from both countries to become eligible for benefits. The benefit amount paid is proportional to the amount of credits earned in the paying country.
An agreement with Mexico would save U.S. workers and their employers about $140 million in Mexican social security and health insurance taxes over the first 5 years of the agreement.
An agreement would also fill the gaps in benefit protection for U.S. workers who have worked in both countries, but not long enough in one or both countries to qualify for benefits.
Mexico is the second largest trading partner with the U.S. Agreements are already in effect with Canada, the largest trading partner with the U.S., and 19 other countries.
Thanks Clara.