Free Republic
Browse · Search
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Anti-Zionism Equals Anti-Semitism
Cross Currents ^ | July 23, 2006 | Yitzchok Adlerstein

Posted on 07/25/2006 6:51:17 PM PDT by Presbyterian Reporter

What is the likelihood that the op-ed writer, or cartoonist, or university professor who rants about the evils of Zionism is really an old-fashioned Jew-hater? Much better than most of us thought, according to a study in the August 2006 issue of The Journal of Conflict Resolution.

Goebbels was right. Repeat a lie often enough, and people will believe it. This seems to be true even in regard to Jews believing lies about themselves. For decades, so many of us heard pious protestations that strongly held views about Israel had nothing to do with attitudes towards us, that we started to believe it might be true. We didn’t want to believe that classic anti-Semitism was alive and well. It is Israel and the accursed Zionists they were after, not the Jewish people. The Soviets thundered this from the podium at the UN; leftist intelligentsia fed it to their students in the classroom and their readers in the Guardian and listeners to the BBC. Neturei Karta was stupid and/or treacherous enough to fully embrace it.

It isn’t true. Those who hate Israel, hate Jews, according to Yale researchers Edward Kaplan and Charles Small.

Even after controlling for numerous potentially confounding factors, we find that anti-Israel sentiment consistently predicts the probability that an individual is anti-Semitic, with the likelihood of measured anti-Semitism increasing with the extent of anti-Israel sentiment observed.

Kaplan and Small compared respondents in ten European countries (500 in each) on two series of statements, one that measured distaste for Israel and her policies, the other about the nature and behavior of Jews. They controlled for other factors, such as hostility to all members of “outside” groups. They did find less anti-Semitism in women, and people with better education (with the apparent exception of college profs and French and British politicians). They also showed that hostility to Jews correlated well with negative feelings about immigrants.

Can one be a critic of Israel and indeed not harbor anti-Jewish feelings? Categorically yes – if the criticism of Israel is not particularly pronounced. In their words:

It is noteworthy that fewer than one-quarter of those with anti-Israel index scores of only 1 or 2 harbor anti-Semitic views (as defined by anti-Semitic index scores exceeding 5), which supports the contention that one certainly can be critical of Israeli policies without being anti-Semitic. However, among those with the most extreme anti-Israel sentiments in our survey (anti-Israel index scores of 4), 56% report anti-Semitic leanings. Based on this analysis, when an individual’s criticism of Israel becomes sufficiently severe, it does become reasonable to ask whether such criticism is a mask for underlying anti-Semitism.

You are reading this prior to its discovery by the general media. Watch for it. It is hard to believe that this study will not make the circuit of print media and talk shows in the coming months.

A complication of this study is that we may not be able to do much with it. Many of our non-Jewish friends tell us that Jews use the anti-semitism charge so frequently, that others mistrust it. They, too, have bought into the idea that you can criticize Israel without hating Jews. Unless the findings of this study become widespread and survive criticism, it may be counterproductive to yell louder about Jew-hatred outside our own community.

At the Simon Wiesenthal Center, we borrowed a bit of phraseology from an unknown donor, and it has resonated with many non-Jews. We have repeatedly talked about “functional anti-Semitism.” This means taking positions that treat Jews differently from others (e.g. Natan Sharansky’s 3D rule: double-standard, demonization, delegitimization), even when no animus of Jews is involved. It is a point worthwhile pondering, and incorporating in conversation with others. Apparently, folks who are uncomfortable about thinking that some of their friends and associates may be bigots are willing to consider that certain positions amount to the same, even absent the sentiment.

Sometimes those of us involved with non-Jewish groups must make hard decisions even without invoking labels. Consider the reactions of liberal Protestants to the war, and the undeniable and unfortunate suffering it has caused to civilians on both sides. (Denying that is both morally wrong, and damaging to our cause.) For many historical and theological reasons, it is not at all unexpected that liberal churches should lean towards the Palestinian side; should seek an early end to hostilities; should offer assistance and succor to the Christian community in Lebanon. While many Jews unacquainted with Protestant thinking might be horrified at the lack of overt support for Israel, I can live with it without liking it. At least, that is, if they do not turn a blind eye to Israel’s plight, and her right to defend her citizens from a storm of rockets aimed at her citizenry. When each of the denominations issued statements tilting towards the other side, I did not get all exercised over it, since they also did acknowledge that Israel was entitled to some sympathy as well.

Each denomination, except one. John Thomas of the UCC has a long record of hostility towards Israel, and his letter was so over-the-top (it was called to our attention by people in his own church), that we took our gloves off, which we rarely can do, but felt that we had to in this case. The response has been unexpectedly positive. (We were even linked by Little Green Footballs!) We apparently touched a real nerve in people in both the UCC and other liberal denominations, who have long been unhappy with the political extremes of their leadership that have sounded more and more like leftist dogma, and less and less like balanced moral thinking. They were tickled pink that we said things that they have felt, and never had the opportunity to publicly express. My favorite (Admission: I composed it myself) was a question about whether John Thomas’ theology had replaced G-d with Che Guevara.

TOPICS: News/Current Events
KEYWORDS: antisemitism; ecusa; elca; israel; jew; jewish; judeophobia; ncc; pcusa; swc; ucc; umc; wcc
The Journal of Conflict Resolution study is exposing the left's position that being anti-Israel is not being anti-semitism is bogus.
1 posted on 07/25/2006 6:51:20 PM PDT by Presbyterian Reporter
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | View Replies]

To: Presbyterian Reporter


2 posted on 07/25/2006 6:52:09 PM PDT by Sam Cree (Don't mix alcopops and guns)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Presbyterian Reporter

I think this has been clear for some time.

3 posted on 07/25/2006 7:03:06 PM PDT by Bahbah (Beat them into the ground, IDF. G_d bless Israel)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Presbyterian Reporter

Not strictly to the point, but the title reminded me of one of my favorite moments from the original incarnation of Saturday Night Live, the "Weekend Update" item on the U.N. General Assembly resolution equating Zionism with racism:

"Sammy Davis, Jr. was heard to say, 'What a breakthrough! Now I can hate myself.'"

4 posted on 07/25/2006 7:03:10 PM PDT by RichInOC ("What time is it?" "I dunno." " unpimp ze vorld!")
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Presbyterian Reporter
I disagree. Anti- Semitism is hostility toward or prejudice against Jews or Judaism based solely on the fact that he is Jewish.
You can be Jewish and not be Israeli.
5 posted on 07/25/2006 7:20:25 PM PDT by LauraleeBraswell (Try reading the article before you post)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Presbyterian Reporter

Well, this new confict is bring out the true anti-semites. The masks are begining to come off.

6 posted on 07/25/2006 7:35:08 PM PDT by Biggirl (A biggirl with a big heart for God's animal creation.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: LauraleeBraswell

". . . You declare, my friend, that you do not hate the Jews, you are merely 'anti-Zionist.' And I say, let the truth ring forth from the high mountain tops, let it echo through the valleys of God's green earth: When people criticize Zionism, they mean Jews--this is God's own truth.
"Antisemitism, the hatred of the Jewish people, has been and remains a blot on the soul of mankind. In this we are in full agreement. So know also this: anti-Zionist is inherently antisemitic, and ever will be so.

"Why is this? You know that Zionism is nothing less than the dream and ideal of the Jewish people returning to live in their own land. The Jewish people, the Scriptures tell us, once enjoyed a flourishing Commonwealth in the Holy Land. From this they were expelled by the Roman tyrant, the same Romans who cruelly murdered Our Lord. Driven from their homeland, their nation in ashes, forced to wander the globe, the Jewish people time and again suffered the lash of whichever tyrant happened to rule over them.

"The Negro people, my friend, know what it is to suffer the torment of tyranny under rulers not of our choosing. Our brothers in Africa have begged, pleaded, requested--DEMANDED the recognition and realization of our inborn right to live in peace under our own sovereignty in our own country.

"How easy it should be, for anyone who holds dear this inalienable right of all mankind, to understand and support the right of the Jewish People to live in their ancient Land of Israel. All men of good will exult in the fulfilment of God's promise, that his People should return in joy to rebuild their plundered land.

This is Zionism, nothing more, nothing less.

"And what is anti-Zionist? It is the denial to the Jewish people of a fundamental right that we justly claim for the people of Africa and freely accord all other nations of the Globe. It is discrimination against Jews, my friend, because they are Jews. In short, it is antisemitism.

"The antisemite rejoices at any opportunity to vent his malice. The times have made it unpopular, in the West, to proclaim openly a hatred of the Jews. This being the case, the antisemite must constantly seek new forms and forums for his poison. How he must revel in the new masquerade! He does not hate the Jews, he is just 'anti-Zionist'!

"My friend, I do not accuse you of deliberate antisemitism. I know you feel, as I do, a deep love of truth and justice and a revulsion for racism, prejudice, and discrimination. But I know you have been misled--as others have been--into thinking you can be 'anti-Zionist' and yet remain true to these heartfelt principles that you and I share.

Let my words echo in the depths of your soul: When people criticize Zionism, they mean Jews--make no mistake about it."

From M.L. King Jr., "Letter to an Anti-Zionist Friend," Saturday Review_XLVII (Aug. 1967), p. 76.
Reprinted in M.L. King Jr., "This I Believe: Selections from the Writings of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr."

7 posted on 07/25/2006 8:11:49 PM PDT by HockeyPop
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 5 | View Replies]

To: Presbyterian Reporter

I ran across this segment relates to Zionism vs Israel.

I have also read that some Zionists'religion includes the use of Kabbala which is a satanic source Alester Crowley
(the beast) used it in his terror/magik rituals.

Also I question - Why did our congress make PL 102-14 on 3-26-1991 to recognize the Seven Noehide Laws quote: "as the ethical basis upon which our great nation was founded." Passed in honor of Rabbi Menachem Schneerson (Lubavitch/Zionist)

As a Christian,I was taught that the Ten Commandments were the moral basis upon which our great nation was based.

8 posted on 07/25/2006 8:35:35 PM PDT by juzcuz
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Presbyterian Reporter

Did the study consider that people migh be anti-Israel because Israel doesn't have a zionist government?

9 posted on 07/25/2006 8:46:41 PM PDT by Rightwing Conspiratr1
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: HockeyPop
From M.L. King Jr., "Letter to an Anti-Zionist Friend," Saturday Review_XLVII (Aug. 1967), p. 76.

This article is bogus. Saturday Review is a weekly magazine, not a monthly, and no article by Martin Luther King on Zionism or any other topic was published during the month of August. Alleged "Letter to an Anti-Zionist Friend"

The author of the alleged "Letter an an Anti-Zionist" was not written by Dr. King.

10 posted on 07/25/2006 8:54:33 PM PDT by Alouette (Psalms of the Day: 140-150)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 7 | View Replies]

To: Presbyterian Reporter
Oh my, it seems Zionists are anti-semetic
see Jews against Zionism:
11 posted on 07/25/2006 9:45:54 PM PDT by juzcuz
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

Comment #12 Removed by Moderator

Comment #13 Removed by Moderator

To: Presbyterian Reporter

This has been clear for quite some time, but I guess liberals will need a study before they'll believe they're bigots. Should send a copy to the PCUSA.

14 posted on 08/11/2006 12:27:17 PM PDT by colorado tanker
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794 is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson