Skip to comments.The End of Christianity in Iraq
Posted on 07/26/2006 9:31:27 AM PDT by OrthodoxPresbyterian
by Glen Chancy
July 24, 2006
Christians of Iraq.Com
The news from Iraq has been especially grim of late. Daily it seems violent death is everywhere in the form of car bombings at mosques and other public facilities, ethnic cleansing carried out by militias roving about the streets seeking victims, even soldiers and police doubling as sectarian enforcers. The statistics themselves tell a grim tale. Baghdad's morgue is receiving nearly twice as many dead Iraqis each day as it did last year. In June 2005, the Baghdad morgue was receiving 700 to 800 bodies a month, or an average of between 24 to 26 a day. In July of 2006, this number has shot up to an astounding 50.
This increase in the death toll is happening despite two events that were supposed to reduce the level of violence. First, almost 100,000 new U.S.-trained troops have been added since last year. Second, the U.S. military has an ongoing security "clampdown" in Baghdad designed to reign in the violence in the capital. Unfortunately, both the new troops and the "clampdown" have failed so blatantly, that even the US military was forced to admit that the level of violence in Baghdad has been hardly unaffected by its efforts.
Of course, the carnage is not limited to Bagdad alone. Nationwide, the situation is hardly any better. The United Nations mission in Baghdad recently reported that 2,669 civilians were killed across Iraq during May and 3,149 were killed in June. In total, 14,338 civilians were killed from January to June 2006.
Life across Iraq in the midst of growing sectarian violence is only becoming more dangerous for Iraqi civilians. Sunni insurgent attacks on U.S. and Iraqi forces have been increasing at an alarming rate. Attacks on American and Iraqi troops in June 2006 grew 44 percent from 88 from 61 compared to June 2005. While the number of American troops killed by hostile fire has declined, life is just as dangerous for them as it has ever been in post-Saddam Iraq.
All of this violence and mayhem is tearing the country apart at an increasing rate. In Baghdad, the Tigris river has become a dividing line between the Sunni west and Shiite east. This divide is stranding many of the city's seven million on the "wrong"; side, making even their daily trips outside for shopping or to work into dangerous missions in enemy territory. To stay alive, many Iraqis have turned to fake IDs that can be used to fool sectarian militias out hunting for victims. For $35, those with easily identifiable sectarian names can get false documents that might mean the difference between life and death on an Iraqi street.
Other Iraqis have simply packed up and fled religiously mixed areas for what they hope will be safer ground among their co-religionists. The number of Iraqis who have registered for assistance as refugees within Iraq since the 22 February bombing of a Shiite shrine at Samarra stands at 162,000 people. Many of them live in 11 new tent camps. They include Abd Hammad al-Saeidi, who said that, "Gunmen told us to leave or they would kill us." The farmer from just south of Baghdad now lives with his family of 11 in a tent.
Obviously then, Iraq is rapidly becoming a nation of refugees. Sunnis and other minorities are leaving the south, while Shiites have been fleeing the areas around Baghdad and the north. For both the Sunni and Shia civilians caught in this cauldron of violence, the situation is tragic beyond description. However, as bad as things have been for Muslim Iraqis, for one vulnerable group of Iraqis, life inside "free" Iraq has been even more difficult. For the Assyrians, who are both Christian and the indigenous people of Iraq, the aftermath of Iraq's "liberation" has been downright catastrophic.
The Assyrian Christian population of Iraq has been brutalized by both ethnic and religious attacks since the US-led invasion in 2003. Glyn Ford, a UK Labor member of the European Parliament and member of the "Save the Assyrians" campaign, recently laid out a litany of woe that has befallen the Assyrians. Ford reports that torture, kidnapping, extortion, harassment, church bombings, forced religious conversion, political disenfranchisement and property destruction are just some of the deliberate human rights violations that are both ruining and taking the lives of Assyrians in Iraq.
The President of "Save the Assyrians", Andy Darmoo, told a news conference in New York: "Today, the situation is the worst we have ever lived in Iraq."
Christians accounted for somewhere between five and twelve percent of the pre-war Iraqi population of 26 million. Most Iraqi Christians are Assyrians whose native language is a form of Aramaic. Over half of the Assyrian Iraqi community resides in the north, primarily in the Nineveh Plains and its surrounding areas. This location puts them at the mercy of America's allies, the Kurdish Regional Government (KRG), which has been anything but kind to the Assyrians.
Shamiran Mako, an analyst with the Council for Assyrian Research and Development (CARD), a Canadian-based think-tank, told the IPS that since the "liberation" of Iraq, oppression has become more prevalent in the North.
Recently, there have been systematic measures taken by the Kurdish Democratic Party (KDP) officials, under the Kurdish-controlled areas to marginalise and suppress Assyrians through the dictatorial policies of the KRG.
The remaining Assyrians living elsewhere in Iraq have faired little better, of course, as they have been frequently targeted by the insurgency, by religious extremists, and even by criminal gangs bent on earning ransom money. As Halfath Hamama, an Iraqi refugee who fled to Syria explained, "Our children, wives, and family members are kidnapped every day. They send us a note telling us to give them fifty thousand dollars or they will kill our family. They send us their fingers or toes, pictures of them beaten and bruised, and tell us we bring this on our head because we are Christians and collaborate with the Christian Americans."
Anecdotal evidence aside, one must turn to the hard numbers to get the true measure of the Christian catastrophe unleashed by the U.S. invasion of Iraq. Statistics from the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) in October 2005 show that around 700,000 Iraqis took refuge in Syria alone between October 2003 and March 2005. Of this number, fully 36 percent were Iraqi Christians, an astounding rate given their small percentage of the overall population of Iraq.
In total, over 250,000 Christian refugees are now stranded in Syria, Jordan and Turkey. This is not even counting those that are displaced within Iraq itself, many having fled north trying to find some measure of safety among other Assyrians. Despite the scale, however, of this human tragedy, the Assyrians have largely been left to their own devices.
While the Kurds, for example, have received millions of dollars in aid following the end of Saddam's regime, aid to the Assyrians has been almost non-existent. This has resulted in many refugees living in appalling conditions. It was even recently reported that some of the Assyrian refugees in northern Iraq had been reduced to sleeping on bare dirt in Christian cemeteries.
Since 2005, the Council for Assyrian Research and Development has sought to record the abuses endured by Assyrians through the Assyrian Human Rights Documentation Project. The first outcome paper produced by the group pulls no punches in its grim assessment. The paper warns, "At the current rates of ethnic cleansing, forced assimilation and migration, the indigenous Assyrian Christians will be fully eradicated from the new 'democratic Iraq' in less than 10 years... the Kurdification, Arabisation, and Islamification of Iraq have left an ancient people at the doors of extinction."
The Assyrians have been calling for assistance, and these pleas have largely fallen on deaf ears. What is most needed is an Assyrian Administrative Unit, a safe haven that would be administered and guarded by the Assyrians themselves. While international groups such as the European Parliament have issued declarations and resolutions of support, the actual power in Iraq, the United States, appears to have already relegated the Assyrians to the dustbin of history. Unless the American people themselves choose to demand a policy reversal, it is unlikely that the Bush Administration will become interested in the fate of Iraqi Christians on its own accord.
It is doubtful that George W. Bush will be remembered as the American President who brought Jeffersonian Democracy to the Middle East. But it appears that at least one historic achievement is well within his grasp. It is quite likely that "W" will succeed where the Arab Caliphate, the Mongol Empire, the Ottoman Empire, British colonialism, and decades of Ba'athist misrule all failed: When "W" finally saunters off the world stage... the Assyrian Christian community in Iraq will probably be gone as well.
And the world will be a much poorer place because of it.
Who Would Jesus Bomb?
The Assyrians and Chaldeans have survived quite a lot in the 2,000 years of their amazing Christian history. They will survive the current crisis. The above piece makes valuable points, but its doom-laden, handwringing tone is overwrought.
Ah, for the glorious days of Saddam. No corpses at all in the morgues...that's what mass graves are for.
And a news flash: the persecution of Christians isn't exactly unusual in the world.
Not good news for the Assyrians, regardless.
The problem here isn't our policy in Iraq. It is Islam.
How dare you pretend to speak in Jesus name??? Do you think Jesus would prefer to leave people oppressed under one of the most murderous tyrannts in world history, or a country that was supporting Al Qaeda as Saddam's own intelligence files show???
Present difficulties notwithstanding, Iraq will one day be free and peaceful and Christianity will again flourish. But it will be no thanks to weaklings like you who think freedom not worth fighting for. And don't bother responding, I have nothing more to say to you.
That's the real problem, and it's the whole world's problem.
And by the way, since you're part of the "Blame America First Crowd," why don't you stop the preachiness long enough to see that it is AL QAEDA, not the president nor the US responsible for driving out Christians. The president is trying to make Iraq a safe place for all systems of belief even as people like you stand in the way and embolden the same people who are targetting Christians. But I see you have no words of condemnation for what Islamic terrorists are doing. It's all about attacking the president isn't it???
Yes, things are difficult for Christians in Iraq and they have my complete sympathy...but it's not due to the president or the US. When Iraq is one day secure, and it will be, they will be far better off than had they been left under Saddam's boot. Apologists for Saddam like you have the gutless intellectual promiscuity to believe people were better off under Saddam because you were never put into one of Saddam's rape rooms, or endured your body being put into a plastic shredder by his secret police, or had to watch a relative murdered merely for having spoken a word against Saddam or seen your village gassed by Saddam or witnessed your wife or children being raped by Saddam's maniacal prison keepers, or had the fear of Saddam's secret police knocking on your door at night, never had your nation invaded and raped by him, etc.
"Is there a place in the Arab world Christians would be safe?"
Well, I say... damn the "Nation-Building" Neo-Conservatives, and the addlepated goat they rode in on. My years on Free Republic have served to refine my thinking on Foreign Policy into a rarefied amalgam of George Washington's Isolationism and the Christian Emperor of Constantinople's defense of Christendom:
George Washington and Constantinople. I don't think you can GET any more "Conservative" than that. Next time I vote in a Presidential Election, I think I might just write in "Patrick Buchanan in 2000".
Or maybe -- Archbishop Herman of Philadelphia, Primate of the Orthodox Church in America, for President in 2008!
If we "American Christians" really do want a "Christian President" and all, howzabout we stop paying lip service and Elect someone who actually does give a damn about World Christendom?
Hopefully, Jim Robinson will continue to tolerate my Old-Right, Ultra-Conservative, Reactionary Utopian perspective on his website. It's his Property; I'm just a Calvinist fly in the Modernist ointment.
Do you even know why the coalition fought against the leadership of Iraq? I didn't think so. Idiot.
Respectfully, "karnage", it's pretty easy for us -- as rich, well-fed American Christians sitting in our comfy recliners -- to accuse the persecuted Christians of Iraq "hand-wringing" when we still possess, you know, both hands.
"They send us their fingers or toes, pictures of them beaten and bruised, and tell us we bring this on our head because we are Christians and collaborate with the Christian Americans."
This is real. This is not just some black and white HTML cut-and-paste on an American Internet Bulletin Board, this is actually happening. Right now.
The Christians of Iraq are not engaging in "handwringing" -- they are being Raped and Murdered. By the Hundreds of Thousands.
This is really happening. NOW.
War is Evil.
God hates War.
The damage that Saddam would have done is far worse. Assyrians in America strongly supported this invasion.
The answer to this difficulty is victory.
Thank you, my sentiments exactly.
It is a LIE that George Washington was an "isolationist" read the Farewell Address (written by Hamilton) again. It is concerned about the dangers of destroying the Union through taking sides in the European conflict thereby plunging the US into a civil war.
There has NEVER been ONE of our major leaders who were isolationist certainly not the Founders.
And stop pretending that your cowardly and false view is shared by John Calvin.
Isn't there some undiscovered Biblical spirituality message board far away from here that you could be inflicting yourself upon?
Seriously, who is anyone to claim to know that Jesus either supports or is against George W. Bush?? Christ was not a politician or a pundit. His mission was to save souls. I think other than that he was content to "render unto Caesar" which to me also means giving Caesar the earthly government while reserving to Himself the head of His spiritual kingdom. Christ will ultimately judge those who mis-rule. But it's not for this left-wing agendized poster to determine who that will fall against or based on what policies.
And I see nowhere in the Bible where Christ enjoins against resisting evil with force. Yes, we are told to turn the other cheek, but that CLEARLY was a prescription for personal behavior, not on how governments should act towards one another. I see nothing in that which says "Don't respond when people fly planes into your building!" Sheesh.
A very loved fly however.
Or leave the Jews in the gas chambers and concentration camps, etc.
You are scripturally incorrect.
Mal 3:6 says: "For I [am] the LORD, I change not; therefore ye sons of Jacob are not consumed."This passage indicates that God does not change from year to year or day to day. And yet....
Exodus 15:3 says "The LORD [is] a man of war: the LORD [is] his name."There are many other passages that indicate you are hopelessly wrong.
Exodus 17:16 says "For he said, Because the LORD hath sworn [that] the LORD [will have] war with Amalek from generation to generation."
Numbers 10:9 says "And if ye go to war in your land against the enemy that oppresseth you, then ye shall blow an alarm with the trumpets; and ye shall be remembered before the LORD your God, and ye shall be saved from your enemies."--which indicates approval for war.
As I remember from way back, you always were more obsessed with your perceived ability to "know" the Lord's will that in actually following His will.
Pride is a terrible sin.
I dare, because I am called by His Name -- i.e, "Christian". Therefore I am under a Moral Obligation to attempt to read His Word as closely as I can, and advocate policies based thereupon.
Do you think Jesus would prefer to leave people oppressed under one of the most murderous tyrannts in world history,
I know for a fact that Jesus Himself could call twelve legions of angels right now, and destroy all the world's tyrannies in one fell swoop -- if He so commanded.
I also know for a fact that Jesus Himself was oppressed (and murdered, in fact), by THE "most murderous tyrannts in world history", the incomparably-vicious Roman Empire -- whose expertly-trained Crucifixioners make Saddam's most malefic torturers look like pissed-off valley girls having a bad hair day.
My question is this: GIVEN THAT the Christians of Iraq had managed to survive the oppression of their Islamic overlords and keep their Faith for a thousand and more years, UNTIL NOW -- are we American Christians willing to admit that the US occupation of their country has made their situation FAR WORSE?
I mean, they say so, and they're the ones being raped and kidnapped and murdered, so maybe they have some better sense of the situation "on the ground" than do jingoistic American War-Idolaters... so are we willing to ADMIT FACTS, or not?
To me, Christianity is about historical Facts -- like the historical Fact that Jesus rose from the dead. It's not a matter of wishy-washy Easter Bunny "Faith", it's about FACTS. And the Fact is, Christianity in Iraq is being Destroyed, directly as the result of the US Occupation (nothing ELSE in the last 1,400 years has damaged Iraqi Christendom so badly, so WHAT CAUSED THE CURRENT EFFECT? A sudden inexplicable hemmorhoid epidemic??)
Kick in a snake's nest, and guess what -- you'll get snakes!!
Present difficulties notwithstanding, Iraq will one day be free and peaceful and Christianity will again flourish.
No, it WON'T.
HERE is the reality of the situation:
Some 3,149 people were killed in June alone, or more than 100 a day, and the figure is likely to rise higher this month because of tit-for-tat massacres by Sunni and Shia Muslims. Some 120 Shias were killed in two attacks earlier in the week and gunmen yesterday kidnapped 20 employees of a government agency in Baghdad looking after Sunni mosques and shrines. That figure would be the equivalent of 161,500 in the United States. Can you imagine the state of mind of Americans if Protestants and Roman Catholics were killing each other in these numbers? We would call it a return of the Thirty Years War (161848), in which half the population of Germany died in religious war. That was the most devastating war on civilians in European history. ~~ Gary North, "Tossing Greenbacks Into the Tar Pit"
I am beginning to think that the die-hard supporters of the War in Iraq are deluded -- actually, psychologically, DELUDED -- beyond the scope of rational discussion.
When are you people -- by which I mean the whole gamut of World-Policing, Nation-Building, Messiah-State Neo-Conservatives -- finally going to understand the basic wisdom of Scripture, and come to terms with the fact that Islam is a SATANIC Religion!? It is a False Religion, it is a Christ-Denying Religion, it is a Bible-Perverting Religion... Islam is nothing but a particular Denominational form of SATANISM, alright?!
You CANNOT build a functioning, Western-style Democracy upon a foundation of SATANISM, fer' crying out loud!! When a People are enslaved to Satanism, and you give them "Democracy", they WILL vote Hamas and Hezbollah into Power.
Happy Ashura, everyone!!
Provide the Muslims with "Democracy", and you will get MORE of the above, not less. The Blood-Cultists are NOT the "extreme", "radical" fringe of Islam; they are, in fact, the devout, faithful, normative tradition of Islam.
Just call me the sand in the oyster, kemosabe.
God makes the pearls; my job is only to provide the irritation.
Your post is offensive and very un Christ like, give it up. You aren't winning any souls for Jesus, but then that wasn't really your purpose in all of this, was it?
Apparently God has decided to leave a billion people in darkness and damnation. All the more glory when he redeems them I suppose.
Though no one has claimed Islam to be positive OR a basis for democracy.
Or maybe Christianity isn't wanted there, Y'think? It's a Muslim country, they look at christianity the same way you look at Islam, that it's a false religion. We don't want Muslims around they don't want Christians around. Pretty simple solution.
Sorry, but we didn't liberate Iraq to "spread democracy" but to destroy our enemy.
America's interests come first.
aka: The Bible As Blunt Instrument Method.
I've known OP for six years. He's hardly an "idiot." Not everyone who disagrees with you does so from ignorance.
Why? Christian Right - Pat Robertson, James Dobson, and their nefarious ilk - do so with impunity.
That'd make us terrorists. No thanks.
That would have been actual progress if we were serious about achieving our war aims.
Being serious about the war doesn't require that we commit atrocities. It would have required more ground troops to stabilize the region and keep law and order, and forestall the sectarian violence we now see.
I'm not convinced God hates war - He sure ordered His share of it, and in Luke 3:14, the soldiers weren't told to quit, but just not to oppress.
Personally, I take the Augustinian-Aquinas viewpoint - that war is sometimes the lesser of two evils, a measure of last resort to prevent the greater harm of loss of innocent life. From that thesis logically follows my requirements of both justice in cause and justice in actions (jus ad bellum and jus in bellum). This, I believe, is the historically Christian viewpoint.
As applied to Iraq, that's a thornier question. This was a preemptively defensive war, started under the mistaken assumption that Saddam had WMD's and he would use them against us. This proved not to be true, but it sure seemed plausible at the time.
Hey OP, who's really in charge?
Maybe the poster only speaks for blonde Jesus.
Your Jesus looks Scandinavian.
Pride is the cancer of Sin.
Your heavy use of bolding and shouting reeks of self-importance.
Two wrongs don't make a right.
We tried islolationism in the 30's.. Guess what it failed..
ISLAM IS THE PROBLEM!
You don't know OP very well. He is not a self-important person, but quite humble and open.
Good post you made with that observation. That is the very point I was going to make but you beat me to it. They knew to take a clue from Solomon - there is a time for war.
Augustine understood the fallen nature of man was a reality through dealing with people's troubled lives as a spiritual light. He eventually saw people as they really are and it took a toll as he saw that fallen nature played out in the inevitable conflicts that resulted.
That same fallen nature leads not just to everyday conflicts but to wars.
The thing is, OP indicates that the reason we're in Iraq is merely Bush's "good intentions." There were a variety of valid reasons we entered into war against the leadership of Iraq, and it wasn't on some whim or mere "good intentions." It's a difficult situation, and saying "Bush's fault" is just sloppy reasoning.
What do you know about James Dobson? Give me only one example of his being "nefarious" and I'll eat my PowerBook and never post another thing on FR. Your ridiculing him tells me a lot about you, Jude24.
It sure is easy to attack high-profile Christians....