Free Republic
Browse · Search
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Cathedraltown: suburbia with a twist
Globe and Mail ^ | 18 August 2006 | JOHN BENTLEY MAYS

Posted on 08/18/2006 9:31:17 PM PDT by Lorianne

It's hardly news that the town-planning fashion called "new urbanism" -- with its emphasis on gracious, walkable boulevards and old-fashioned streetscapes -- is taking firm root in suburbs across North America. Of more interest, however, are the surprising things that happen when this philosophy hits the ground.

Take Cathedraltown, a 2,000-unit residential project now under construction in the Toronto suburb of Markham. Like U.S. developments executed under the rubric of new urbanism, Cathedraltown intends to defy monotonous sprawl and feature a mix of homes and shops, live/work spaces and offices, all within walking distance of each other. It's to be a pleasant blend of the ingredients, in other words, that make up any successful town.

But livability is where the comparison of Cathedraltown with American models ends. The U.S. versions of new urbanism seek to evoke small Southern towns at the turn of the 20th century, with their white frame façades, sociable porches, Fourth of July picnics and so forth. In sharp contrast to that brand of nostalgia, Cathedraltown offers its own: 19th-century European this time, with robust little buildings standing proudly around a central square dominated by a great church.

I suspect that everyone who's been up the 404 between Toronto and Newmarket has seen the church at the heart of the Cathedraltown scheme. It's the imposing, baroque Cathedral of the Transfiguration, rising from a pasture just east of the expressway, which was begun in the early 1980s by late industrialist Stephen Roman on his Markham property. (The interior of this structure, which Mr. Roman meant to be the mother church of Canada's 30,000 Eastern-Rite Slovak Catholics, is still incomplete.)

As explained to me by Helen Roman-Barber, who is developing Cathedraltown on the site of her father's cattle ranch, the project will introduce a strong grid of through streets lined, in the cathedral quarter, by mixed-use buildings up to six storeys tall. A straight high street, with shops and services, will extend westward from the church toward the 404. Shorter structures, mainly residential, will dot the grid as it falls away from the cathedral, creating an attractive, staged transition from high and ceremonial -- the church's golden domes are as tall as 20-storey buildings -- to the intimate scale of two-storey residences. A low-shouldered lake, now under construction, will provide further counterpoint and visual balance to the soaring church.

Cathedraltown is more, of course, than an attempt to replicate an old-world plan on new-world soil. To help with the fashioning of the project's stylistic look, Mrs. Roman-Barber has commandeered the talents of a somewhat unlikely designer: Donald Buttress, senior partner in the British firm Buttress Fuller Alsop Williams, and from 1988 to 1999, the official architect of Westminster Abbey. Dr. Buttress's best-known architectural work so far has been the restoration of the abbey's famous and magnificent west front -- not exactly the kind of thing you'd expect to find in the résumé of a designer of suburban houses on Ontario farmland.

But Mrs. Roman-Barber has large ambitions for Cathedraltown. Drawings by Dr. Buttress on the development's website show a dignified, compact town centre, with august Georgian buildings topped by domes and spires echoing the towers of Transfiguration cathedral. One cannot imagine a Blockbuster outlet in such a serious place, let alone a Mac's Milk store. It will look more like a Cambridge college than anything I've ever seen on the outskirts of town.

Will Cathedraltown work as a living community? We'll get an answer when it is built out and complete, some five years from now (if all goes according to the developer's ambitious timetable). There are reasons to be cautious, however, having to do with the portion of Cathedraltown that's largely finished and now being occupied.

There, on the northern edge of the project, the high style and period flair Dr. Buttress has lavished on the future town centre is largely absent. The note struck by the variously designed houses along the avenues -- the street names, by the way, come from prize-winning heifers and bulls raised by Mr. Roman -- is Georgian or early Victorian: sturdy, dressed-down, businesslike. To work as an urban form, Georgian needs oomph and big-city attitude it doesn't have here. And the developer's neglect of retail -- even a milk store -- in this part of the project means that, so far, Cathedraltown is looking a lot like the monoform, car-dependent suburbia it's trying so hard not to become.

Though I am usually dismayed by architectural nostalgia of any kind, I'll be watching the rollout of Cathedraltown with interest. The Georgianism and Europeanism of it all is surely part of the marketing strategy, but I find the approach -- as expressed in Dr. Buttress's sketches -- to be more earnest and principled than mere salesmanship. Cathedraltown is suburbia with an engaging twist -- hence its durable interest to everyone fascinated by what's new out on the ever-evolving city's edge.

TOPICS: Business/Economy; Canada; Culture/Society; Foreign Affairs
KEYWORDS: suburbs; urbanplanning
Here is the Catherdraltown website

1 posted on 08/18/2006 9:31:18 PM PDT by Lorianne
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | View Replies]

To: Lorianne
I've had a dream of a development for a long time:
The central portion is a pond with trees and a grass berm around it, the ground rising, with a path about the lake and the street. Cast iron lamps recalling gaslights would line the street.
The houses would be in Tudor/Tudor Revival style, with narrow pitched roofs, green lawns.:

2 posted on 08/18/2006 9:43:18 PM PDT by Tench_Coxe
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Tench_Coxe

very nice

3 posted on 08/18/2006 9:50:19 PM PDT by Lorianne
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: Tench_Coxe
You can find homes like that in an older gated community right outside Manhattan near Montclai, NJ....

The only draw back in NJ are the property taxes....which are ludicrous...probably why the homes themselves aren't one can afford to pay any higher taxes.

4 posted on 08/18/2006 9:57:32 PM PDT by Katya (Homo Nosce Te Ipsum)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: Katya
Some nice homes.

I had more in mind more of a late 1800's look (with all the modern upgrades, of course). I had in mind sort of a close community where the yards aren't 5 acres, but more like an acre or so each. Would be interesting in an urban/suburban setting to turn the corner (without going through a gate) and suddenly get transported back.
This house was kind of cool from that site:
4 Ashley Road

5 posted on 08/18/2006 10:04:52 PM PDT by Tench_Coxe
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 4 | View Replies]

To: Tench_Coxe

Ooops. Messed up the link. But the address is correct.

6 posted on 08/18/2006 10:06:00 PM PDT by Tench_Coxe
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 5 | View Replies]

To: Tench_Coxe

Llewlyn park has alot of homes built in the late 1880's on about 1 to 1.5 acres....many are tudors, they're just not on the market for sale. Actually between Montclair and west orange NJ you will find some splendid communities. But the price of taxes is crazy money...the property taxes in 2005 on the Ashley rd property were $20,000....but they were based on the last appraised property value. If someone bought the house for 1.2 mil, they'd go up substantially, probably phased in to at least $25,000.

7 posted on 08/19/2006 8:05:48 AM PDT by Katya (Homo Nosce Te Ipsum)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 6 | View Replies]

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794 is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson