Skip to comments.ABC 9/11 Docudrama's Right-Wing Roots (Free Republic Mentioned)
Posted on 09/12/2006 7:08:38 AM PDT by Mr. Brightside
ABC 9/11 Docudrama's Right-Wing Roots
Mon Sep 11, 6:28 PM ET
The Nation -- On Friday, September 8, just forty-eight hours before ABC planned to air its so-called "docudrama," The Path to 9/11, Robert Iger, CEO of ABC's corporate parent, the Walt Disney Company, was presented with incontrovertible evidence outlining the involvement of that film's screenwriter and director in a concerted right-wing effort to blame former President Bill Clinton for allowing the 9/11 attacks to take place. Iger told a source close to ABC that he was "deeply troubled" by the information and claimed he had no previous knowledge of the institutional right-wing ties of The Path to 9/11's creators. He reportedly said that he has commenced an internal investigation to verify the role of the film's creators in deliberately advancing disinformation through ABC.
After stating that she was "looking into" my questions about the production of The Path to 9/11, ABC Vice President of Media Relations Hope Hartman declined to comment on this story.
All week, ABC has withstood withering criticism for The Path to 9/11's imaginative screenwriting that depicts Clinton and members of his administration either ignoring threats from Al Qaeda or botching operations that could have eliminated terror-master Osama bin Laden. Iger conceded in a September 5 press release that key scenes in The Path to 9/11 were indeed fabricated, calling the film "a dramatization, not a documentary." Behind the scenes, Iger reportedly made personal assurances to some of the film's most prominent critics that those scenes would be edited out. But even though some deceptive footage was cut from the original, much of its falsified version of events leading up to 9/11 remains.
Iger now bears ultimate responsibility for authorizing the product of a well-honed propaganda operation--a network of little-known right-wingers working from within Hollywood to counter its supposedly liberal bias. This is the network within the ABC network. Its godfather is far-right activist David Horowitz, who has worked for more than a decade to establish a right-wing presence in Hollywood and to discredit mainstream film and TV production. On this project, a secretive evangelical religious right group long associated with Horowitz, founded by The Path to 9/11's director, David Cunningham, that aims to "transform Hollywood" in line with its messianic vision, has taken the lead.
Before The Path to 9/11 entered the production stage, Disney/ABC signed David Cunningham as the film's director. Cunningham is no ordinary Hollywood journeyman. He is in fact the son of Loren Cunningham, founder of the right-wing evangelical group Youth With A Mission (YWAM). According to Sara Diamond's book Spiritual Warfare, during the 1980's YWAM "sought to gain influence within the Republican party" while assisting authoritarian governments in South Africa and Central America. Cunningham, Diamond noted, was a follower of Christian Reconstructionism, an extreme current of evangelical theology that advocates using stealth political methods to put the United States under the control of Biblical law and jettison the Constitution. Cunningham instilled his radical ideology in young missionaries by sending them to "Discipleship Training School." A former student of Cunningham's school claimed "similarities between cult mind controlling techniques and the [Discipleship Training School] program instituted by YWAM."
When the young Cunningham entered his father's ministry, he helped found an auxiliary group called The Film Institute (TFI). According to its mission statement, TFI is "dedicated to a Godly transformation and revolution TO and THROUGH the Film and Television industry." Cunningham has placed over a dozen interns from Youth With A Mission's Discipleship Training School in film industry jobs "so that they can begin to impact and transform Hollywood from the inside out," according to a YWAM report.
Last June, Cunningham's TFI announced it was producing its first film, mysteriously titled Untitled History Project. "TFI's first project is a doozy," a newsletter to YWAM members read. "Simply being referred to as: The Untitled History Project, it is already being called the television event of the decade and not one second has been put to film yet. Talk about great expectations!" (A web edition of the newsletter was mysteriously deleted last week after its publication by the blogger Digby, but has been cached on Google at the link above).
The following month, on July 28, the New York Post reported that ABC was filming a mini-series "under a shroud of secrecy" about the 9/11 attacks. "At the moment, ABC officials are calling the miniseries 'Untitled Commission Report' and producers refer to it as the 'Untitled History Project,'" the Post noted.
Early on, Cunningham had recruited a young Iranian-American screenwriter named Cyrus Nowrasteh to write the script of his secretive Untitled film. Not only is Nowrasteh an outspoken conservative, he is also a fervent member of the emerging network of right-wing people burrowing into the film industry with ulterior sectarian political and religious agendas, like Cunningham.
Nowrasteh's conservatism was on display when he appeared as a featured speaker at the Liberty Film Festival (LFF), an annual event founded in 2004 to premier and promote conservative-themed films supposedly too "politically incorrect" to gain acceptance at mainstream film festivals. This June, while The Path to 9/11 was being filmed, LFF founders Govindini Murty and Jason Apuzzo--both friends of Nowrasteh-- announced they were "partnering" with Horowitz. Indeed, the 2006 LFF is listed as "A Program of the David Horowitz Freedom Center."
Since the inauguration of Bill Clinton in 1992, Horowitz has labored to create a network of politically active conservatives in Hollywood. His Hollywood nest centers around his Wednesday Morning Club, a weekly meet-and-greet session for Left Coast conservatives that has been graced with speeches by the likes of Newt Gingrich, Victor Davis Hanson and Christopher Hitchens. The group's headquarters are at the offices of Horowitz's Center for the Study of Popular Culture, a "think tank" bankrolled for years with millions by right-wing sugar daddies like billionaire Richard Mellon Scaife. (Scaife financed the Arkansas Project, a $2.3 million dirty tricks operation that included paying sources for negative stories about Bill Clinton that turned out to be false.)
In the immediate wake of the 9/11 attacks, Horowitz led the right's campaign to pin the blame for attacks on Clinton. On February 19, 2002, Horowitz's organization mailed 1,500 lengthy pamphlets to major media outlets which claimed to expose how "the left" in general and Clinton in particular had "undermined America's security," thus causing 9/11. Two years later, Horowitz penned a lengthy manifesto for his FrontPageMag blaming Clinton once again for having "accepted defeat" in the fight against Al Qaeda. Horowitz singled out Clinton's National Security Council Director, Samuel "Sandy" Berger, as especially culpable for allowing the terror threat to fester, casting him as "a veteran of the Sixties 'anti-war' movement" who "abetted the Communist victories in Vietnam and Cambodia."
This year, Horowitz's Hollywood hothouse finally spawned his most potent anti-Clinton propaganda device. With the LFF under Horowitz's control, his political machine began drumming up support for Cunningham and Nowrasteh's Untitled project, which finally was revealed last August as The Path to 9/11.
Like Iger, Horowitz has pleaded ignorance about the sectarian agenda of the film's creators. Responding to an article I wrote for the Huffington Post exposing Horowitz's involvement in The Path to 9/11 (on which this article is adapted), he claimed in a blog post, "In fact, I never heard of David Cunningham or his group before reading about them in Max's hilarious column."
However, Horowitz's public relations blitz on behalf of the film began at least a month ago with an August 16 interview with Nowrasteh on his FrontPageMag webzine In the interview, Nowrasteh described how The Path to 9/11 was filmed "under the very able direction of David L. Cunningham." (Doesn't Horowitz read his own magazine?)
Nowrasteh also foreshadowed the film's assault on Clinton's record on fighting terror. "The 9/11 report details the Clinton's administration's response--or lack of response--to Al Qaida and how this emboldened Bin Laden to keep attacking American interests," Nowrasteh told FrontPageMag's Jamie Glazov. "There simply was no response. Nothing."
A week later, ABC hosted LFF co-founder Murty and several other conservative operatives at an advance screening of The Path to 9/11. (While ABC provided 900 DVDs of the film to conservatives, Clinton Administration officials and reviewers from mainstream outlets were denied them.) Murty returned with a glowing review published by FrontPageMag that emphasized the film's partisan nature. "The Path to 9/11 is one of the best, most intelligent, most pro-American miniseries I've ever seen on TV, and conservatives should support it and promote it as vigorously as possible," Murty wrote. As a result of the special access granted by ABC, Murty's article was the first published review of The Path to 9/11, preceding those by the New York Times and Los Angeles Times by more than a week.
Murty followed her review with a blast e-mail to conservative websites such as Liberty Post and Free Republic on September 1 urging their readers to throw their weight behind ABC's mini-series. "Please do everything you can to spread the word about this excellent miniseries," Murty wrote, "so that The Path to 9/11 gets the highest ratings possible when it airs on September 10 & 11! If this show gets huge ratings, then ABC will be more likely to produce pro-American movies and TV shows in the future!"
Murty's efforts were supported by Appuzo, who handles LFF's heavily-trafficked blog, Libertas. Appuzo was instrumental in marketing The Path to 9/11 to conservatives, writing in a blog post on September 2, "Make no mistake about what this film does, among other things: it places the question of the Clinton Administration's culpability for the 9/11 attacks front and center.... Bravo to Cyrus Nowrasteh and David Cunningham for creating this gritty, stylish and gripping piece of entertainment."
When a group of leading Senate Democrats sent a letter to Iger urging him to cancel The Path to 9/11 because of its glaring factual errors and distortions, Apuzzo launched a retaliatory campaign to paint the Democrats as foes of free speech. "Here at LIBERTAS we urge the public to make noise over this, and to demand that Democrats back down," he wrote on September 7. "What is at stake is nothing short of the 1st Amendment."
At FrontPageMag, Horowitz singled out Nowrasteh as the victim of an unconstitutional crime. "The attacks by former president Bill Clinton, former Clinton Administration officials and Democratic US senators on Cyrus Nowrasteh's ABC mini-series The Path to 9/11 "are easily the gravest and most brazen and damaging governmental attacks on the civil liberties of ordinary Americans since 9/11," Horowitz declared. The next day, Horowitz reposted his 2004 manifesto holding Clinton responsible for 9/11, explaining that, "With tonight's premiere of the ABC-TV movie The Path to 9/11, the truth [sic] impact of the Left's policies in bringing about the nation's worst terrorist attack is finally coming to light."
Although Iger and ABC trimmed as much as thirty minutes of deceptive footage from Sunday's episode of The Path to 9/11, it appeared nonetheless as a mostly faithful adaptation of Horowitz's anti-Clinton essay. Indeed, The Path to 9/11 still contained its most egregiously false scene, in which Sandy Berger refuses to authorize a CIA officer's request to capture bin Laden, who is completely surrounded by rival Northern Alliance soldiers. After the halted (and totally fictional) operation, "Kirk," the (completely imaginary) CIA op played by Donny Wahlberg of New Kids on the Block fame, stands on a hilltop beside the Northern Alliance's quixotic warlord, Ahmed Shah Massoud.
"Are there any men left in Washington?" the script has a frustrated Massoud asking "Kirk." "Or just cowards?"
"Cowards?" The question is quietly being raised in the corridors of ABC-TV's headquarters in Burbank, California. Besieged in his lush office, Iger privately agonizes that he was complacent about an attack on his network's reputation by a band of political terrorists. But when faced with his own version of the Taliban, he appeased them.
I forgot who was the one threatening Disney? Oh yeah. The left.
Ask the guy on the ground that Berger hung up on if it was fabricated or not, jackass.
Look, if anyone starts referring to Disney or ABC as "right wing" you know they are a nut.
Well, we can't have political bias in media now can we?
The left would never dream of....oh wait....sorry...never mind.
I guess Disney will have to throw another gay orgy at Disney World to distract the left wingers from the flick.
The Left needs a Boogeyman.
I'll have to check my blast e-mail in-box again. Musta missed it.
OwOOOO!! That's SCARY!
Bet he's got some relatives spinning in their graves about now.
Is this what happens to you when you go to Hollywood ~ that you develop Stockholm Syndrome?
This guy doesn't seem to realize that we all lived through the 90's and witnessed much of what was in the movie. Another thing. It seems all the Left has left is conspiracy theories. How about the stuff in the movie that was in the 9/11 Commission report or the book The Cell. Are they in on it, too?
Whatever happened to the liberal montra: "It raises awareness...it gets people talking. And, thats the most important thing"?
Tell me why the right wing would want to glorify Clark?
What a sick and disgusting double standard. This is SO transparant. If the US general public can't see through this then we are done. We can't survive as a nation if our memories of historical events doesn't stretch past the last 5 years!
Too too bad. There's conservatives getting involved in the entertainment business therefore it must be a nefarious cabal. Hah!
"Knowledge is ignorance."
-George Orwell and Max Blumenthal
Yup. Their position isn't defensible so all they can do is go on the offensive.
So which one of them blew up the towers? moron
Rush said only one minute was trimmed from the first episode. This liberal says thirty minutes was chopped...and the episodes did not fill their time slots. I think Rush was wrong on this one.
I'm waiting for the unedited version to come out on CDs and will definitely buy it.
How dare the program imply that Clinton was in office for 8 years, and presided over the unimpeded rise of Al Queda! Oh, wait, that actually did happen? Well, then, how dare it not paper over the facts to make Clinton look good!
The minions of Beelzeflubba are seethig!
He (Max) is in fact the son of Sidney Blumenthal, founder of the left-wing Clinonista kook group Clinton's Trying To Rewrite History.
They are strong proponents of THEIR free speech.
And how about an expose of the political leanings of ALL OTHER film-makers and porducers.
I would love to see the similiar homework go into the people involved in Oliver Stone's movies, CBS's Reagan movie, and every other political film Hollywood produces.
I may get flamed for this, but it's pretty well conceded that was a fabricated scene. Or do you have evidence that most people don't have access to?
Good drinking game to be had here. Every time the term right wing mentioned, drink!!!
Drunk in no time at all....
Is this someones feable attempt at humor?
What this says is...that only Liberals can make Documentaries or movies....period...
I think they cut out more from the second episode. If they didn't, then I don't understand how they could interrupt it with Bush's speech and still end it at 10:25, approximately.
I heard it was more like 60 seconds that got cut.
Don't care anyway. Might have watched it if on anything other than the Alphabet Channels. ABC and CBS have been blocked on my channel list for years. Not like I'm gonna manually push 05 on my clicker
That's not to say he created the terrorists, they were out there and hated the US just fine without Clinton, but his inactions and his administration's policies were significant in allowing 911 to happen. Thank you Gorelic, for instance, for your wall of separation of information that hamstrung the intelligence communities.
That's great stuff. I wonder if they sacrificed a goat or a virgin when they finished it.
Coincidentally, David Horowitz has been busy exposing left-wing operations via books and his website Discover the Network.
Bill Clinton's LEAGACY......
.....THE PATH TO 9-11
The other liberal mantra: "It's the seriousness of the charge that warrants an investigation" and "fake but accurate".
My understanding was that the CIA character was a composite, which would imply that all the scenes involving him really happened--just not to the same guy.
There definitely is video available of Clinton giving a speech in which he admits he "had" Bin Laden, but failed to give the order. After he realized how bad this made him look, he backed away from that admission.
I don't buy this analysis, but even if it were true, so what? Don't conservatives have First Amendment rights?
"If this show gets huge ratings, then ABC will be more likely to produce pro-American movies and TV shows in the future!"
It shouldn't matter what ratings this show got to produce more "pro-American" movies. ABC= American Broadcast Corp.!!!
A lot of oinking out there from our liberal buds.
Of course, only those on the left are allowed to write screenplays. If you're on the right and you write a script, you are suspect.
Let's don't forget why "The Wall" was there to begin with.
Couldn't have the FBI and the CIA sharing info about illegal ties to the Communist Chinese by the Clintonista, now could they?
Yeah. Conservatives were all over the 9/11 commission.
A Clinton chop job from the get-go.
I am surprized Max did not blame the joooooooze and say it was really an inside job.
The attack that failed in Syria today has images with a car with ball bearing holes in it. Those ball bearings were not "peaceful ball berrings".
We have an election in november, we have PRIMARIES TODAY. The democrats are aftraid of people connecting the dots.
No matter how you slice it, the documentary shows it is a MULTI-FRONT WAR. It is not one dimentional linear as the democrats try to Goebles.