Posted on 10/08/2006 6:33:32 PM PDT by SandRat
The Soldiers from 589th Brigade Support Battalion, Fires Brigade, 4th Infantry Division, have collected and delivered clothes, toys and other items to the clinic at the Civil Military Operations Center in the Radwaniya Palace Complex for nearly six months.
The effort started when Staff Sgt. Valrica Pollard, re-enlistment and medical logistics noncommissioned officer-in-charge, 589th Brigade Support Battalion, met Soldiers with the 414th Civil Affairs Battalion, out of Utica, N.Y., who were living and working near 589th BSB Soldiers.
Pollard had received a box of toys and said she and her colleagues were interested in adopting a school or getting involved in the community in some other way.
The 414th CA Bn. Soldiers took Pollard, a native of Akron, Ohio, to the clinic, where a local Iraqi doctor teamed with U.S. military doctors to treat local nationals. After the Iraqis were treated, they were presented supplies from the donations.
Is this the job of a US soldier?
It is sweet but it enrages me.
Whaaaaaaaaaaaat??????? But...but...I thought our soldiers were TERRORIZING and KILLING them? WHERE do you get your obviously propagandic information...
/s
In the modern world, yes. It IS the job of the American soldier. Don't let it enrage you...these people are the face of America to many parts of the world...it is either that or Hollywood, and I will choose the American Military any day of the week.
The world will hate or admire us without turning an army into social workers.
I would rather soldiers shoot, bomb, scare and command respect. I want the world to tremble at the thought of the US army arriving.
I want fear and respect from the world. Frankly they may never like us. They envy us. And our soldiers joined up to fight and defend us. Not deliver toys.
They are not our PR specialists.
Just my opinion of course.
Yes, it is. Because you can't win a war with only guns.
Ah, the "hearts and minds war",,it really helped us in VN didn't it?
Of course you need more than guns. But war really hasn't changed much other than the technology.
You need guns, bombs, antiaircraft carriers. drones, marines, things that blow up big stuff.
Soldiers delivering toys is nice but not war. And I don't think it is winning anyone's heart.
I respect your opinion, since many people feel as you do, but, actually...the members of the US Military ARE our PR. There are many, many people around the world whose only exposure to an actual American is a Soldier or Sailor of the US Military.
And they do command respect. The battle hardened US Marines practice PR, because they know that is the way to go. And you better believe their opponents fear them greatly, for good reason.
Lately, the unofficial motto of the Marines, after "Semper Fidelis" is "No Better Friend, No Worse Enemy".
In this world of media and Internet, the US Soldier has a more demanding job than ever before. They can change the world in an instant with a miscalculation, because it all gets out there to the world so quickly. And they all have training on how to deal with it.
I bet you're too young to remember stories of GIs and chocolate bars...and the good will that brought us all over the world.
I guess I feel pessimistic than no matter what we do, no matter how decent and generaous we are,,people in that part of the world dance when we die.
It hardens me. Lately I don't care what the rest of the world thinks. I feel like an ancient Roman. I just want blood of our enemies.
My dear, I am ancient. We conquered people like us. The world was much different.
I was born at the onset of WWII.
Then ENLIST...it's a volunteer fighting force.
Ah, you posted before I posted. I am about to turn 65, am grey haired and wrinkled.
The enlisting officer would get a kick out of it I do believe.
Well, short of prosecuting absolute war (which Clausewitz posits as unreasonable) what we're doing makes perfect sense. While I must say the ROP is like a rabid dog which must be put down, it's simply not feasible to suppress the islamic world through force (against unless we want to do things the absolute way).
Were we to "cry havoc," all we'd accomplish is pissing off people at home (and considering that our military is subordinate to civilian authority that's not something we'd want to do), alienating other countries in our coalition, pissing off the survivors (kinda like Rome's subjugation of the Iberian peninsula--sure they eventually gained full control, but at a pretty stiff price).
You mention that we need war materiel and vehicles. Well, we'd also need men and women to used them. In today's media-drenched world how many young people are going to answer the call to deliver a world of hurt on people both innocent and bad (that's what tends to happen when you "blow up big stuff"). Sure maybe in the future more things will be automated, but as of right now we don't have the manpower available to take on the entire islamic world.
Sure it's nice to have a big stick and to be able to use it, but often the carrot is the more economical and reasonable option.
I agree that we've been to soft in our prosecution of this war (i.e. not ensuring there's no safe haven for insurgents, punishing Syria and Iran for their meddling, offing mookie, using harsher methods when necessary), but this isn't one of the things I'd criticize.
BTW, I want an "antiaircraft carrier" whatever that is. ;)
"I just want blood of our enemies."
Yeah, so does everyone else on this board (I'd think).
However, who are those enemies? Are those little girls our enemies? Hopefully, thanks to the efforts of SSG Pollard and servicemen and women like her, they won't be.
"I just want blood of our enemies."
Yeah, so does everyone else on this board (I'd think).
However, who are those enemies? Are those little girls our enemies? Hopefully, thanks to the efforts of SSG Pollard and servicemen and women like her, they won't be.
Nice story and pictures. These are support battalion and civil affair soldiers. One of their primary missions is to help establish and organize structure in cities and neighborhoods, whether it be iraq or afghanistan. Certainly they are soldiers first, but humanitarian assistance is their speciality. There is nothing "soft" or "weak" about that.
And many of our troops know that it's the kids that will one day inherit their country, if you treat them with kindness maybe they will pass it along one day.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.