Posted on 12/20/2006 5:52:03 AM PST by ShadowDancer
Well. That's subjective. My personal opinion is that he was a complete and total hack compared to people like Paul Simon. I've always disliked his music, even in 5th grade.
But an ability to write music does not in itself, translate into an ability to perform music competently. It's actually not the least bit abnormal for a skilled composer to not be a skilled performer: composing and performing are two different disciplines.
Do you think Mccartney was also tone deaf?
Lets just say I respect Lennon more than McCartney. Especially after watching a special a couple years ago where McCartney proved, on film, that he couldn't actually write music but rather, had to dictate how he wanted the music to sound to an actual composer who was able to score it for him.
I just sat and laughed to myself.
What made it doubly amusing was that he had already been knighted for his so-called musical skill.
But then again, he's got a gagillion dollars more than me, so he's been successful at something and I have to respect that about him.
Thanks...
Lennon had a unique voice that people have tried to imitate ever since. His vocals on 'Twist and Shout' and 'Money' are regarded as among the best in Rock history. Paul Simon couldn't really sing. He did the best he could with an extremely limited vocal range.
I suppose I should make a distinction between composing and being a tunesmith. None of the great Tin Pan Alley writers orchestrated either (Irving Berlin). Most of them anyway. Gershwin wasn't the best orchestrator but he was getting better.
"Especially after watching a special a couple years ago where McCartney proved, on film, that he couldn't actually write music but rather, had to dictate how he wanted the music to sound to an actual composer who was able to score it for him.
I just sat and laughed to myself.
What made it doubly amusing was that he had already been knighted for his so-called musical skill."
The joke's on you.
McCartney's father taught him music. He had piano lessons as a child. Plus plenty of other music classes in school.
He can read and write music.
He chose/chooses instead to play and compose "by ear." (Something a lot of jazz and folk musicians have often preferred.)
McCartney was by far the most accomplished musician of the Beatles. And certainly the group's most sophisticated composer.
"I should never have put that in about Chairman Mao. I was just finishing off in the studio when I did that."
Another quote is,"...the original version which ends up on the LP said 'count me in' too; I put in both because I wasn't sure....On the version released as a single I said. 'When you talk about destruction you can count me out.' I didn't want to get killed.
Also, " It's a yin-yang thing. We all have a streak of violence underneath."
John didn't see Julian for about three years until he separated from Yoko and lived with May. Julian visited John about three times in a one-year period. When John went back to Yoko, Julian only visited about three times in the last five and a half years. The last time Julian saw John was in Palm Beach in March 1979. John never visited England for the last nine years of his life, but he had no problem flying to Japan as well as going on "around the world" trips directed by Yoko's astrologers.
I understand if you play the file backwards, it sounds like Lawrenece Welk.
Just play "Revolution Number Nine" backwards and you'll find out!
Turn me on deadman.
"an unnamed foreign government" MI6 and John Lennon... Shagadelic Man!
You don't have to have a clue about music theory to be a great tunesmith. He's also a world class bassist.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.