Posted on 01/04/2007 2:31:14 PM PST by skeptoid
A fellow called Rush today about "THE Bridge to Nowhere".
There are actually TWO proposed bridges; one in Ketchikan in the very southern southeast tip of the state, and the Knik Arm Crossing Project on the northwest edge of Anchorage. The Ketchikan bridge (Gravina Access) would serve less than 14,000 people because Ketchikan is on an island and the nearest continental highway is 90 miles away in Canada. In order for anyone but the 14,000 locals to use the proposed bridge, they would have to arrive boat or aircraft.
The Knik Arm Crossing (Anchorage) would serve well over half the population of the state (i.e. 350,000) that lives within commuting distance and is connected by road to the rest of North America.
Click thru to my comment for graphics and links.
Note the locations below on the inset maps of Alaska......they are about 700 miles apart.
At this point, the funds from Congress have been allocated and it's up to the State of Alaska how the funds will be used, but the amount is far less than needed for either project.
For facts and figures, see the official Knik Arm Bridge and Toll Authority or Knik Bridge Facts, (for alternate view)
.
.
.
.
The official Gravina Access site and an alternate view
Currently, arriving and departing passengers must use the ferry to cross the strait and reach the airport (or the city).
While a modest inconvenience, we're talking mere minutes here. And, indeed, the ferry trip probably doesn't take any longer than the roundabout road trip would.
Spending $315 million to alleviate a modest inconvenience for 13,000 people is (or should be) obviously beyond the pale.
If we really must do something for the good people of Ketchikan, I propose offering a federal subsidy that would make the ferry free to all users. The cost would be an inconsequential fraction of the bridge's cost.
I'm less familiar with the Knik Arm bridge...but it certainly appears to be more justified than the Gravina Access bridge.
I'm not implying I support a bridge to nowhere, but have you been to Katchikan? I have, and if they ever want to grow as a community they have to be accessible. They aren't now and the only way in is by boat or plane. I'm not privy to Alaska's planning but it would not surprise me if they are considering a road there in the future.
It's easy to say the bridge is not necessary when you aren't one of the 14,000 people.
Why should I subsidize those folks?
They are the ones that want to live there.
The airport, BTW is served by a car and passenger ferry every 30 minutes or less.
I agreewith your take ...... I'll bet the local gov't and residents could use a little help on the ferry cost. i wonder how such a small community could even justify the maintainence costs of such a bridge.
Haven't the good folks of Alaska received an annual check for years as a share in oil revenue. Let them pay for their own bridge.
...and when you ARE one of the tax payers whe were being tapped to pay for it. Alaska gets a lot of money from their oil industry that's paid directly to it's citizens every year. Use that money to pay for the bridge and leave mine alone.
bookmarking
I just recently flew into Ketchican on my way back from Juneau.
When I saw the ferry crossing, my first thought was...
...how stupid. They should build a bridge.
For the $230 million that is the cost of this bridge (never mind what it would cost after the usual overruns) I'd be willing to bet they could almost build another "almost equivalent" airport on the other side of the river.
looks like they need to move the runway and build a single bridge directly to t he airport (or maybe a tunnel to come out on the other side of the existing runway).
Everything costs more in Alaska, except the salmon.
If some of the oil revenue that is taken from the State were allowed to remain in the State and if some of the 99% of the State that is off limits to the private sector were released to the private sector, Alaska could do all this and a lot more. As it is, Alaska is effectively economically strangled.
Well said and true, RightWhale.
It is interesting that there appears to be an endless supply of people who just don't get it. Happy New Year!
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.