Skip to comments.Napoleon's Mysterious Death Unmasked
Posted on 01/16/2007 4:07:54 PM PST by blam
UT Southwestern Medical Center
Date: January 16, 2007
Napoleon's Mysterious Death Unmasked
Science Daily A new investigation into Napoleon Bonaparte's cause of death might finally put to rest nearly 200 years of lingering mysteries about the illness that killed the French emperor during his island exile, a UT Southwestern Medical Center scientist reports.
Dr. Robert Genta, professor of pathology and internal medicine, helped investigate the cause of Napoleon Bonaparte's death nearly 200 years ago by applying modern pathological and tumor-staging methods to historical accounts. (Image courtesy of UT Southwestern Medical Center)
American, Swiss and Canadian researchers applied modern pathological and tumor-staging methods to historical accounts and found that Napoleon died of a very advanced case of gastric cancer that stemmed from an ulcer-causing bacterial infection in his stomach, rather than a heretofore belief of a hereditary disposition to the cancer. The analysis, which also refutes rumors of arsenic poisoning, points to gastrointestinal bleeding as the likely immediate cause of death.
The report, available online and in the January edition of Nature Clinical Practice Gastroenterology & Hepatology, indicates that the despot's demise was imminent.
"This analysis suggests that, even if the emperor had been released or escaped from the island, his terminal condition would have prevented him from playing a further major role in the theater of European history," said Dr. Robert Genta, professor of pathology and internal medicine at UT Southwestern and senior author of the study. "Even today, with the availability of sophisticated surgical techniques and chemotherapies, patients with gastric cancer as advanced as Napoleon's have a poor prognosis."
Napoleon, born Aug. 15, 1769, ruled France in the late 1700s and early 1800s. He conquered much of Europe, but he was ultimately defeated at the battle of Waterloo in 1815. The British then exiled him to St. Helena, an island in the South Atlantic Ocean.
He died May 5, 1821.
The cause of his death has been highly scrutinized over the years. Dr. Genta and his colleagues, whose research focuses on gastritis and gastric cancer, investigated the case because of their interest in the way disease affects the behavior of historical figures and, in turn, the course of history. In Napoleon's case, they were intrigued by a popular notion that Napoleon could have altered the balance of European power had he escaped his exile.
An autopsy at the time cited stomach cancer as the cause of death. A study done in 1938 indicated that Napoleon's father died of stomach cancer. In 1961, an elevated level of arsenic was found in hair taken from Napoleon, inspiring rumors of arsenic poisoning.
To find answers, Dr. Genta and the other researchers combined current medical knowledge and autopsy reports, memoirs of the physicians who treated Napoleon on the island, eyewitness accounts and medical histories of family members.
Autopsy and physician descriptions revealed no telltale signs of arsenic poisoning, such as hemorrhaging in the lining inside the heart, and no skin, lung or bladder cancers were present.
Gastric cancer was more likely at fault, Dr. Genta said. Other scholars have recently found that the plump emperor lost at least 20 pounds in the last six months of his life, a sign of gastric cancer. The autopsy descriptions show that Napoleon's stomach was filled with a dark material that resembled coffee grounds, an indication of gastrointestinal bleeding that likely was the immediate cause of death, Dr. Genta said. The most important description was of a large, ulcerated lesion on his stomach, and a smaller ulcerated lesion in another part of his stomach that had penetrated the wall and reached the liver.
The researchers -- obviously unable to observe the body -- compared the original descriptions of the lesions with modern images of 50 benign ulcers and 50 gastric cancers. They determined that no benign cancer could look like the lesion described in the autopsy.
"It was a huge mass from the entrance of his stomach to the exit. It was at least 10 centimeters long. Size alone suggests the lesion was cancer," Dr. Genta said.
They then used a state-of-the-art tumor-staging method from 21st century pathology and determined that Napoleon had at least T3N1M0, or Stage IIIA, gastric cancer, which is very severe. The method grades severity on a 1 to 4 scale, with 4 being the worst case. The "T" designates cancer size; the "N" designates the presence of lymph nodes, which are associated with tumors; and the "M" designates metastasis of the cancer to other organs. The autopsy and other accounts indicate that the cancer was large, lymph nodes were present around the stomach and there were no tumors in other organs. Only 20 percent of patients with Stage IIIA gastric cancer survive five years if treated with modern surgery and chemotherapy.
But what might have caused Napoleon's cancer?
Risk factors for gastric cancer include male gender, genetic susceptibility, chronic gastritis and infection by the bacteria Helicobacter pylori.
Although genetic susceptibility is a possible cause, it's not likely, Dr. Genta said. That's because the autopsy of Napoleon's father described a tumor that might have been something other than gastric cancer. And because autopsies were not performed on other Bonaparte family members, their causes of death can only be speculated upon based on symptoms or medical reports.
Instead, the ulcerated lesion on the emperor's stomach suggests a history of chronic H. pylori gastritis, which might have increased his risk of gastric cancer, Dr. Genta said. The risk might have been further increased by his diet full of salt-preserved foods but sparse in fruits and vegetables -- common fare for long military campaigns.
"Even if treated today, he'd have been dead within a year," he said.
Dr. Genta completed some of the work for this report while at the University of Geneva. Researchers from the Aarau Cantonal Hospital and the Institute of Pathology at the University Hospital of Basel, both in Switzerland, and McGill University in Montreal also contributed.
Note: This story has been adapted from a news release issued by UT Southwestern Medical Center.
But he is still dead..right? 200 years ago, right? mmmmm did Bush have anything to do with this? Where was Rove?
I have laid awake for my whole life worrying about this. Now I can sleep.
Thankf you, I rest my case, lets move along....
Sure, by 1821, Napoleon was hors combat, but suppose he'd escaped in, say, 1818, with 3 years to live. His son lived, an Austrian Prince.
It is conceivable that the French, disatisfied by the return of the Bourbons, may have flocked to the ill Bonaparte again. And by 1818, Europe's armies that had fought at Waterloo or were moving towards the French frontiers had been decommissioned. Sure, they could have been raised again, but it would have taken time.
And an astute Bonaparte, conscious of the dual role of his son as a French prince AND a Habsburg prince, may have very well been able to solidify a deal to the liking of the Habsburg's whereby Napoleon II would assume the throne of a France joined by close royal marriage and lineage to Austria.
The same may have been true even as late as 1820. Indeed, the farther the war receded, the more likely that an ill Napoleon could have struck a deal with the Hapsburgs, especially if he didn't do anything crazy like launch the armies at the frontiers again.
I always heard he died of a broken heart. Damn those evil medical scientists.
I gather my "Dog Gone Potato Chip Diet" book just took a hit.
looks to me like a white shirt and a big red X on it.
B.S. He's alive and living in Argentina under an assumed German name.
I heard on "The Apprentice" Sunday night, that pink is the new black. (Goes with everything). Of course the guy that said it was a guy man who thought that a pink, paisley, tight, tiny, spandex bikini swimming suit was a "sure sell" for a man to wear.
I do believe you are right. :)
"Napoleon died of a very advanced case of gastric cancer"
Which would explain his hand in his vest?
And a few minutes later, your alarm clock will go off. Trust me on this.
Damn, you have no idea how many years I have been without sleep!
I thought it was already "proved" he was slowly poisoned through his wine by examining his hair samples.
The guy is dead...a long time ago...let it go already!
So that explains why he always had his hand on his stomach in all those paintings.
Sorry Doctor. It was a joke.
He's holding his pants up. He always was misplacing his suspenders.
"According to two French forensic specialists in Strasbourg, tests on five strands of Napoleon's hair preserved since his death confirm "major exposure to arsenic"."
They wanted to make sure he stayed dead!
You were wonderin' when somebody was gonna post that, didn't ya!
I may croak if I discover "Grant Money" was the reason this "Study" was initiated.
I swear... Government will be the Death of me
He was shot from the grassy knoll.
***"Even today, with the availability of sophisticated surgical techniques and chemotherapies, patients with gastric cancer as advanced as Napoleon's have a poor prognosis." ****
Tell that to Fidel Castro.
Everybody knew the man had an ulcer (and yes, that's why he kept his hand in his vest), it got worse and worse, and when he began losing weight rapidly and having constant pain and anemia, everybody knew it had "turned."
Here's the original article: Napoleon Bonaparte's gastric cancer: a clinicopathologic approach to staging, pathogenesis, and etiology
It's a good read, actually, if you're interested in histori/medical detective stories.
The absence of hemorrhages in the heart absolutely rules out arsenic poisoning, according to the article. Trace amounts of arsenic in the hair mean nothing, because of the ferocious patent medicines in general use at the time.
But since he had pre-existing gastric ulcers, much more likely.
Maybe Montholon, his alleged assassin will be cleared now but he remains a sinister cypher in my book.
He was born November 13, 1769. Throws the entire article into doubt for me.
Please FREEPMAIL me if you want on or off the
"Gods, Graves, Glyphs" PING list or GGG weekly digest
-- Archaeology/Anthropology/Ancient Cultures/Artifacts/Antiquities, etc.
Gods, Graves, Glyphs (alpha order)
"Napoleon later adopts August 15 as his birthday, to coincide with the Catholic Feast of the Assumption."
UT Southwestern Medical Center is great on Nobel Prizes and spending beaucoup bucks on etherial studies. Your government at work.
Thanks for the ping. I didn't know that an autopsy was done. Modern analysis of the autopsy report makes this a very substantial diagnosis.
I think this report is pretty cool.
The alarm clock doesn't care.
Politicians need to know!
(Besides it doesn't cost them anything, since they do not produce anything, earn anything or deserve anything)
Have you read about that urologist who bought Napoleon's penis, and displayed it in his office? I always thought that was a weird thing to remove at autopsy.
Personally, I think he died of ovarian cancer. :P
I can think of a lot better ways to spend 3 large, can't you?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.