Posted on 01/26/2007 5:34:43 AM PST by OESY
... then we should really re-examine our testicular fortitude. Der Spiegel excerpts passages from Henryk Broder's new book on the Western response to radical Islamism, pungently titled, Hurray, We're Capitulating! The book has not yet been published in English, but DS gives us a translation on their English-language site. It cogently and somewhat angrily notes the low points in Western dhimmitude:
"Objectively speaking, the cartoon controversy was a tempest in a teacup. But subjectively it was a show of strength and, in the context of the 'clash of civilizations,' a dress rehearsal for the real thing. The Muslims demonstrated how quickly and effectively they can mobilize the masses, and the free West showed that it has nothing to counter the offensive -- nothing but fear, cowardice and an overriding concern about the balance of trade. Now the Islamists know that they are dealing with a paper tiger whose roar is nothing but a tape recording. "As different as the West's reactions to the Muslim protests were, what they had in common were origins in feelings of powerlessness and helplessness. Critical souls who only yesterday agreed with Marx that religion is the opium of the masses suddenly insisted that religious sensibilities must be taken into account, especially when accompanied by violence. The representatives of open societies reacted like the inhabitants of an island about to be hit by a hurricane. Powerless against the forces of nature, they stocked up on supplies, nailed doors and windows shut and hoped that the storm would soon pass. Of course, whereas such a reaction may be an appropriate response to natural disasters, such a lack of resistance merely encourages fundamentalists. It completely justifies their view of the West as weak, decadent and completely unwilling to defend itself.
"Those who react to kidnappings and beheadings, to massacres of people of other faiths, and to eruptions of collective hysteria with a call for 'cultural dialogue' don't deserve any better."
Read the entire excerpt -- it's a bracing essay on Western fecklessness. Broder makes the point that the very silliness of the Prophet Cartoon controversy should have alerted us to the power play from the radical Islamists. While the Danish tried to stand up for free speech, most Western nations couldn't wait to scold them for their insensitivity. Instead of scolding the Islamists back over the absolute lunacy of rioting over a few drawings, political leaders in Europe and the US issued worried pronouncements over their respect for Mohammed and the bad manners of those darned Danes.
At least in the US, we mostly realize that we're facing a larger and protracted conflict, even if we're less than united on confronting our enemies. Broder castigates Europe for willfully denying that the conflict exists. Political and cultural leaders insist that they can appease the radical Islamists by apologizing and making demonstrations of sensitivity towards Muslims. In the meantime, they rush to highlight every nuance of statements by terrorist groups like Hamas, and Broder specifically points out the celebration over Hamas' supposed recognition of Israel last year -- when it turned out that they had done no such thing.
Our enemies have learned that we have no stomach for confrontation. We have grown so content within our material success that we view all conflict as economic problems to be solved through concessions and compromise. Broder wonders what Europe and the West will sacrifice next for appeasement. Who will be the next Czechoslovakia -- France?
I'm wondering why Broder's book hasn't been translated into English. It would make for required reading for anyone serious about the war with radical Islamist terror.
Well, our surrender monkeys are shooting from their congressional roof top
The Dims are at this moment working hard to embarrass the US even further. If they succeed, it is quite likely Saudi Arabia and Iran get into it as they move to protect their political interest in Iraq. And, as goes democracy in Iraq, so goes democracy in Lebanon and Afghanistan. Serious people understand this. There are very few serious people in the Dimocrat party as they prefer to be whores to popular public opinion (an opinion which they themselves created in the MSM).
"Objectively speaking, the cartoon controversy was a tempest in a teacup. But subjectively it was a show of strength and, in the context of the 'clash of civilizations,' a dress rehearsal for the real thing. The Muslims demonstrated how quickly and effectively they can mobilize the masses, and the free West showed that it has nothing to counter the offensive"
The Muslims have the same advantage the left in this country has had, the ability to moblize vast numbers of people, such as for the cartoon fiasco, to blindly, cluelessly do their bidding.
We try to be neither blind nor clueless and end up being both.
The answer to the question posed in the first sentance can be answered in the second. Because there are certain elements who WANT us to lose, for various reasons. Because of their overriding hatred for President Bush (for their own, myriad reasons), for their hatred of the US, for their hatred of "the west." There are so many reasons, most of which conflict with each other (if one of those groups would come to power, they'd outlaw and persecute the others), like the jihadists, the only thing they have in common is their hatred.
Mark
We're not "surrender monkeys"...we're "redeployment monkeys" if the American people are ignorant enough to go with the advice of demoRats.
bfl
So a German has the guts to tell it like it is, and he's right. At least it wasn't a French guy, as that would be embarrassing. BTW, the author is a big supporter of the Iraq war and our efforts to eliminate fundamentalist threats. That he's a Jew probably helps this view.
I love the text at the top of his home page, "It's your own fault if you write me."
A large number of German newspapers actually did just that: They reproduced the cartoons, something many American news outlets shied away from.
One of the results was that a young Pakistani muslim tried to stab an editor of one of these newspapers. He was apprehended before anything could happen and shortly after that commited suicide in his prison cell.
That story actually created a major uproar in Pakistan back then with accusations of Pakistani MPs that German intellegence had murdered the moron in his cell.
I have heard this commetary on the Rush Limbaugh show today.
ON THE NET...
http://www.truthusa.com/MoreThanCartoons.html
Horsehockey. Concessions are dhimmitude.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.