Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Modern Predestination - The dangerous notion that misconduct is genetic
City Journal ^ | 6 February 2007 | Theodore Dalrymple

Posted on 02/08/2007 4:09:57 PM PST by neverdem

How do bad ideas spread and enter the general stock of received wisdom?

One culprit is sloppy or uncritical newspaper reporting. For example, a recent small item on the front page of the Sunday Times, the largest-selling serious Sunday newspaper in Britain, insinuated something both false and dangerous to believe.

The headline ran: WANT A FIGHT? SCIENTISTS SAY IT’S ALL IN YOUR GENES. The story begins: “Scientists have discovered an answer to one of the most intractable squabbles in family life—argumentative children are born and not made.”

According to the article, new research has found antisocial traits to be inherited rather than acquired (actually such research has been going on for a long time, and the ideas behind it are nothing new). The implication of this research, the newspaper says, is that a bad child would be bad however he or she was brought up.

What a relief to parents, then! It no longer matters how they raise their children: whether they coddle them, abuse them, neglect them, discipline them, or let them run wild, it’s all the same. There is no such thing as parental responsibility, except perhaps in material provision. The good will be good and the bad bad.

The article cites the work of a professor at the Institute of Psychiatry in London, to the effect that “men with a mutation in a single gene were predisposed to be violent.” The same professor also allegedly discovered that antisocial behavior is largely inherited. The only faintly contradictory note in the article occurs when the professor argues that “an early diagnosis of a child who is predisposed to bad behavior be the key to offering them treatment to stop such tendencies developing.” So perhaps the way children are brought up is not quite so unimportant after all. The professor is unlikely to be quite the idiot that the paper presents her to be.

Our search for, and apparent willingness to believe in, or at least give credit to the possibility of, “the” gene for complex social behavior suggests that credulity and inability to think critically did not die out with the advent of the Enlightenment. The will to believe is as strong as ever. We are like creatures so dazzled with our own technological prowess that we no longer think it necessary to consider the obvious.

Genetic variation might explain some of the difference within a population, but it is most unlikely to explain differences between populations. It is unlikely to explain why, for example, the rate of criminality has increased in Britain by something like 35 times since the end of World War II. In short, genes (except in a few rare cases) are not destiny: character is destiny, and character is made as well as born.

The article, probably read quickly and without much reflection by hundreds of thousands of the best-educated people in the country, will give aid and succor to a government that has, like several previous governments, almost systematically neglected its primary and most undeniable duty, to maintain the safety and property of citizens as they go about their lawful business. If bad behavior is genetic, over to the doctors—and, eventually, to the eugenicists. For, as Goethe once remarked, when disorder reaches beyond a certain point, people begin to long for the man on the white horse—or in this case, in the white coat.


TOPICS: Crime/Corruption; Culture/Society; Editorial; News/Current Events
KEYWORDS: anthonydaniels; dalrymple; genetics; health; medicine; predestination; theodoredalrymple

1 posted on 02/08/2007 4:10:06 PM PST by neverdem
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | View Replies]

To: neverdem
How do bad ideas spread and enter the general stock of received wisdom? One culprit is sloppy or uncritical newspaper reporting.

Then I think it is fair to say that America's general stock of perceived wisdom is rife with bad ideas.

2 posted on 02/08/2007 4:26:15 PM PST by IronJack (=)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: neverdem
Illiterate reporting at its best.
"According to the article, new research has found antisocial traits to be inherited rather than acquired (actually such research has been going on for a long time, and the ideas behind it are nothing new). The implication of this research, the newspaper says, is that a bad child would be bad however he or she was brought up."
Unless the heritability of the trait is 100% [which it never is. 70-80% heritability for Spearman's g is at the high end of heritabilities range. Normally they are much lower, and in the formulae they are squared - even 80% becomes 0.64] - so, unless one is claiming 100% trait heritability, there is only a tendency, and never a certainty, of the outcome. Thus, a bad child of the above quotation is likely to turn out bad, no matter the upbringing, but with some luck might escape such a fate [and turn out even worse].
3 posted on 02/08/2007 8:14:37 PM PST by GSlob
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: El Gato; Ernest_at_the_Beach; Robert A. Cook, PE; lepton; LadyDoc; jb6; tiamat; PGalt; Dianna; ...
The Brain Scan That Can Read People's Intentions

Parents' Genes, Not Parents' Arguing, May Cause Children's Conduct Problems

FReepmail me if you want on or off my health and science ping list. Anyone can post any unposted link as they see fit.

4 posted on 02/09/2007 12:18:46 AM PST by neverdem (May you be in heaven a half hour before the devil knows that you're dead.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: neverdem
According to the article, new research has found antisocial traits to be inherited rather than acquired...

For, as Goethe once remarked, when disorder reaches beyond a certain point, people begin to long for the man on the white horse—or in this case, in the white coat.

Osama once remarked {paraphrased}...people will go with the Muslim on the strong horse. Strong horse? White robe? Islam has the cure! (or are the bad-moon gene carrying gang part of the problem?) /sarcasm

Words and Deeds bump!

5 posted on 02/09/2007 3:47:05 AM PST by PGalt
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: wolf24

ping


6 posted on 02/09/2007 2:07:44 PM PST by neverdem (May you be in heaven a half hour before the devil knows that you're dead.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 4 | View Replies]

To: neverdem

To quote a psychobiology professor of mine, "the gene has replaced God."

The same people who mock those who believe in God have created their own god by which the explain all: the gene.


7 posted on 02/09/2007 2:31:40 PM PST by wolf24 ("It's always easy to rally the stupid.")
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 6 | View Replies]

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson