Skip to comments.House Democrats Fail Democracy 101
Posted on 08/04/2007 5:09:06 AM PDT by Kaslin
Last night on the House floor – that sprawling, brawling arena that was like a second home to me during my 22 year career in Congress – it seems pretty clear that a crime was perpetrated against the rule of law and the American people. A combination of arrogance and incompetence on the part of the Democrat leadership left the Rules looking like a prisoner at Abu Ghraib. Not bad for a Thursday night.
Here’s how it went down. The House of Representatives, like all democratic legislatures, provides for what is called a “Motion to Recommit.” It’s one of the many minority rights built into the structure of the legislative process. Basically, a properly led majority party in the House – unlike in the Senate – can pass pretty much any bill it wants to. It can swat down minority amendments, or even disallow their introduction in the first place. In order to give minority members a semblance of dignity in such circumstances, they are usually permitted one more vote, before a major bill’s final passage, to send the bill back to committee. A good example of this would be a budget bill: Republicans don’t want to just vote against the Democrat budget, so they propose their own in the form of the motion to recommit, so at least they can have something they’re for. Now, because majority parties are in control of things and presumably have competent leadership, these procedural votes are typically formalities.
Until this year. In the seven months since the Democrats took control of Congress and, as now appears evident, elected the most incompetent speaker in American history, Republicans have passed one motion to recommit after another. They have cleverly written their motions so as to make it difficult for Democrats to cavalierly vote against them. Such was the case last night. Before the vote on the Agriculture spending bill for the next fiscal year, Republicans offered a nifty little motion to recommit so that illegal immigrants would not receive taxpayer funded government welfare. (My compliments to whoever thought that one up.)
Well, because a few of the Democrats can’t afford to have an ad in their next campaign saying he wanted to give illegal immigrants federal funds, Nancy Pelosi’s duct-taped majority sprung another leak. The motion to recommit, whose passage would scuttle the Democrats’ bill offering taxpayer benefits to illegal immigrants, was on the verge of passage, with 215 votes in favor and 213 votes opposed. Yet another ring was about to run around Pelosi and her bumbling leadership team.
Then it happened.
The presiding officer, the guy in the big chair with the gavel, was Democrat Congressman Michael McNulty, who would apparently make a compelling contestant on Are You Smarter Than a Fifth Grader?, gaveled the vote closed – repeat, closed – when it was 215 to 213. Republicans win. Except when McNulty got the tally from the Clerk and realized what happened, he and the Democrat leader conspired to “correct” their mistake, after the gavel had fallen.
Angry Republicans started asking questions, primarily one beginning with the words, “what” and “the”. Republican Leader John Boehner stood up and asked the same question, politely, and all McNulty said was that the “voting machine is down.” (The House’s electronic voting machine doesn’t just “go down”, incidentally: it was more likely turned off to hide the evidence of the crime.) A few minutes of strange rustlings over on the Democrat side of the dais ensued until finally Rep. McNulty spoke up again and said, “The Chair prematurely called the vote at 214-214 [a lie], while there were votes being entered [illegal]. After all the cards [whose?] were added, the final [illegal] vote was 212 to 216, nay. Sorry suckers, it’s Schlitz O’Clock!” (Okay, I added the last part.)
Except here’s the thing. The vote was closed. Not open. Not ajar. Closed. The rules don’t allow for McNulty’s personal problem with premature e-gavel-ation. He screwed up and cost the Democrats the vote. But in Nancy Pelosi’s America, votes only count when Democrats win: so she cheated, and bent a once-proud and honorable political party into an instrument of despotism. Jaw-dropping as it may sound, it’s not an exaggeration to say that for a few minutes last night, the United States was not a representative democracy.
Democrats came out to the floor this morning, admitted they made an honest mistake, and suggested we let bygones be bygones. That’s all well and good, except for this: when a motion to recommit passes, no other votes are taken! The Agriculture bill is sent back to the House committee, not to the Senate for further action. And on top of that, the Democrats even tried to expunge the record. They’re hoping the American people don’t notice. In short, they think you’re even less on the ball than Congressman McNulty.
(And for those of you who are trying so desperately to compare it to the Medicare vote that was held open for three hours, I give you this. The House requires a minimum of 15 minutes for a vote; however, the vote can stay open as long as needed, until the strike of the gavel when the vote is properly tallied. That early morning in 2003, we won, fair and square. Democrats had every right to find it annoying – I would have in their shoes –, but what we did was no way illegal or unruly. What’s amazing is that after we took the Democrats to school for 12 years, they’d still rather cheat than learn.)
Sorry, Mr. Delay.
The rules are whatever the Dems say the rules are.
Both sides acted at times like schoolyard ruffians but I thought the Republicans offered a little more decorum than the Dems.
And the bottom line is...as it has been for over 200 years.....the gavel closes the vote!
This will go down in history as the “bang” heard round the world........
good except for his cheap shot at Abu Ghraib.
Whenever we were faced by Democrat obstructionism in the Republican ruled Senate, “hotheads” suggested changing the rules to give the Republicans the edge. This occurred most notably on the judges. No, Senator Lott and others counseled, some day, if we are in the minority, you will be grateful that we preserved the great minority traditions of this hallowed body. To which, we, the hotheads, replied, do you think for one minute that the Democrats will not change the rules to their advantage if that is what their agenda requires?
It pains me to say, “We told you so.”
I doubt it. How much MSM coverage have you seen? And I’ll bet the coverage you have seen explains it away as a clumsy mistake and plays up Boehner’s admission that he thinks it’s just a minor slip up.
So now there is a precedent that the House leadership can ignore the votes of its members.
David Horowitz has repeatedly reminded us that the truth to the left is that which advances their goals; factuality is irrelevant. After decades of vote fraud and judge made law I suppose it is only logical that the rats see no problem with recounting House votes.
This event, which the rats got away with, which will not get widespread play in the old media, only underscores the fragility of our republic.
On some of the “other” sites, the Lefties are praising the speaker for this great strategy move and urge that it be used many more times. I bet the House computer will now have many more hiccups and the Chair many more “pre-e-gavelations”.......
......and it will happen again and again until one party rule is cast in steel.............
It’s not like the Republican Party doesn’t already have enough “damaging info” to use against the Congressional Democrats when the ‘08 general elections really start to pick up the attention of a majority of voters. It definitely will be very sad for all of us if the Republican Party at every political level truly doesn’t take full advantage of all of the Democrats troubles at every political level to win the majority of ‘08 races from the Presidency on down. “Conservatism! Not Socialism!” should be one of the conservatives battle-cries from now on.
Where’s the Boehner/Murtha episode? That was a riot.
Not sure of all the facts but Boehner tried to introduce something to condemn an action by Murtha and the dems went absolutely ballistic.
I didn’t see it, but I can only imagine. The left does not like when the tables are turned on them
There has to be some mechanism -- I guess ultimately the courts -- that would require the Dems to deal the vote.
A legislative body can't ignore it's own rules.
Not to worry .. Last night at the Kos Konvention .. Howard Dean promised to lead the world to the promise land
Personally, I believe a milestone has been passed today by the Left. This is a socialist, dictatorial move.
...cry havoc and let slip the dogs of war.
Just a preview of what the left will do when it gets full power.
It will even get worse
I doubt any suits will be filed. The House and Senate each write their own rules. As crazy as it seems, no law was broken.
It is a political problem and will be handled in a political fashion. One way perhaps would be for the GOP to not attend any further House business until the rats rescind the bill they sent to the Senate.
Doing nothing on the part of the GOP should not be an option.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.