Didn't look like him either, check out his eybrows compared to 2003 image, different curve entirely.
Something about the eyes, too. It’s grainy and hard to tell, but when Fox showed the side by side still he looked quite a bit older even with the black beard, and the angle of the eyes and the way they sit in relation to the nose seemd wrong.
It looked as if they found a cousin who looked pretty similar but had a parent who was significantly uglier than Osama’s parents.