Skip to comments.Huckabee Pardons Under Scrutiny (Note: 2x The Total of 3 Predecessors' Combined)
Posted on 12/10/2007 4:07:14 AM PST by AmericanInTokyo
By ANDREW DeMILLO, Associated Press Writer Mon Dec 10, 3:10 AM ET
LITTLE ROCK, Ark. - As governor of Arkansas, Mike Huckabee had a hand in twice as many pardons and commutations as his three predecessors combined.
The case he's asked about most concerns the parole of a castrated rapist who later killed a woman.
Although the Republican presidential contender plays down any personal involvement in that release, Huckabee granted 1,033 pardons and commutations in his 10 1/2 years as governor of Arkansas. The acts of clemency benefited the stepson of a staff member, murderers who worked at the governor's mansion, a rock star and inmates who received good words from their pastors.
"It seems to be true at least anecdotally that if a minister is involved, (Huckabee) seems likely to grant clemency," prosecutor Robert Herzfeld said in 2004 after successfully battling the then-governor over the release of a killer.
Whitewater figure David Hale, a government witness in the trial that forced Gov. Jim Guy Tucker's resignation and let Huckabee ascend to the office, was pardoned after being sentenced to 21 days in a state insurance case. Huckabee complained it would cost too much to hold him. The price tag: $1,200.
Rolling Stones guitarist Keith Richards received a gubernatorial pardon for a 1975 traffic offense. Huckabee prepared the paperwork to clear the rock star's good name after he met him at a North Little Rock concert, .
During his years as governor, Huckabee granted clemency an average of about once every four days. Huckabee's successor, Mike Beebe, has issued 40 so far this year, fewer than one a week. Bill Clinton, Frank White and Tucker granted 507 clemencies in the 17 1/2 years they served as governor.
The most-discussed clemency case during Huckabee's tenure involved Wayne DuMond, who was castrated he said by masked men who attacked him at home while awaiting trial on charges he raped a teenager in 1984. Though Huckabee did not pardon DuMond nor commute his sentence, two members of a state parole board maintain that he pressured them to make a decision in the case.
Huckabee denies any such pressuring and notes that it was his predecessor, Jim Guy Tucker, who reduced DuMond's sentence, making him eligible for parole. Still, Huckabee has acknowledged his interest in gaining freedom for DuMond predated his term as governor.
Huckabee says there's nothing in his record to indicate he's soft on crime. While the number of pardons exceeded those of his predecessors, so did the size of the state prison system and so did the number of people executed.
Prosecutors say Huckabee was more inclined to release or reduce the sentences of prisoners if he had direct contact with them or was lobbied by those close to him.
Some inmates who benefited from some sort of personal connection:
_James Maxwell, who killed a pastor of the Church of God in Arkansas. Maxwell worked at the Governor's Mansion when Huckabee announced his intent to reduce his prison sentence.
_Samuel W. Taylor, convicted on a drug charge. A prosecutor said the man had told him Taylor's sister had gone to school with Huckabee. Huckabee said the sister didn't influence the decision. Taylor subsequently was arrested on another drug charge.
_Donald W. Clark, convicted of theft. Huckabee's pastor recommended leniency for Clark, whose stepmother worked on Huckabee's gubernatorial staff.
_Robert A. Arnold Jr., who was convicted of killing his father-in-law. Arnold's father, a former mayor of Hope, Huckabee's hometown, said he was a casual friend of the governor.
_A pastor who promoted Huckabee among blacks urged the governor to grant clemency to John Henry Claiborne, who was sentenced to 100 years for a 1994 armed robbery, according to a 2004 report in the Arkansas Democrat-Gazette. Huckabee made Claiborne eligible for parole after receiving a letter from the Rev. Charles Williams, who told the newspaper he had helped win "many, many" clemencies from Huckabee.
_Denver Witham, convicted of beating a man to death with a lead pipe at bar, had his sentence commuted by Huckabee. The action drew the ire of prosecutors who speculated that Huckabee's act of clemency was related to Witham, who was lead singer in a prison band, being a fellow musician.
Huckabee has repeatedly faced criticism from prosecutors over his clemency policies. And in 2002, Ashley Stevens, the 1984 rape victim, joined Angela McCoy, the daughter of the Rev. Billy Price Bennett who was shot to death in 1979 by James Maxwell, to campaign against Huckabee's re-election.
"I just thought that the power of executive clemency was being exercised on the wrong folks," said Pulaski County Prosecutor Larry Jegley, a Democrat who also campaigned against Huckabee.
As for DuMond, the convicted rapist initially was sentenced to life plus 20 years for his conviction in the 1984 rape of Stevens when she was a teenager, but Tucker reduced the sentence to 39 1/2 years, making DuMond eligible for parole.
While Huckabee told reporters last week that DuMond's file was waiting for him when he took office, his interest in the case started two years earlier after he met with DuMond's wife, Dusty. When he took office, she contacted Huckabee again. "He said if he was ever in a position to look into it he would try to remember it," said Dusty DuMond in a 1996 interview with The Associated Press.
Stevens met with Huckabee and his staff in 1996 to discuss his intent to grant clemency.
"I could tell he had already made up his mind," Stevens told the AP last week.
Huckabee argues that it was Tucker's decision to reduce DuMond's sentence that made him eligible for parole, and he maintains he had little if any role in his release. Still, Huckabee had publicly questioned DuMond's guilt and met privately with the state parole board.
What happened at that meeting has been the subject of debate. Two members of the board have said Huckabee pressured them for a vote. In a lengthy statement issued this week, Huckabee's campaign denied that he discussed DuMond's parole with the board but said he did talk with board members about the inmate's clemency request
OPEN CELL DOORS FOR JESUS.
That is, when you get up on Monday morning....
President Bush said we want Osama bin Laden “Dead or Alive.”
President Huckabee will grant him a full pardon.
For those of you who would have voted for Dukakis, if only he were a Republican!
Remember all of Bill Clinton’s last minute Presidential pardons?
Just imagine what Huckabee’s would be like!!
Believe me, they are watching the US elections closely.
They wonder what is in store for themselves from 2009, and if things will get rough or if they will have a pushover.
We might always want to put ourselves in the shoes of Kim Jong il or Hugo Chavez or Osama Bin Laden, and figure out who they would most fear in the Oval Office. And vote accordingly.
Sometimes clemency is a solution. I wonder if those who got off the hook and went straight will come to Huckabees defense. I’ve visited some people in prison, and many of them are kept alive with a hope that their sentences will be reduced. It’s difficult, I hate to disqualify a man just because he believed that some people behind bars had gone through a metamorphis and changes of them doing the same thing were nihl. I tend to be lenient and give people the 2nd chance. I guess that is why they have executive priviledge, so that they can on certain recommendations over ride the sentence of the court.
Are you some kind of bleeding heart liberal... like Huckabee?
Well, let us get into it and investigate.
Let us see with the recidivism rate was for the folks he set free. That would be an excellent study. I would not be afraid of its ultimate results, either way--although I have my own conjecture.
The innocent people they raped and murdered didn’t get a chance to change.
Is there any wonder the Left is pimping this boob?
Good point, GM, good point.
Thanks for your input, newbie-san. ;-)
Clemency for armed robbers? Clemency for somebody who beat a man to death with a pipe in a bar? Clemency for the murderer of a minister?
I notice you are relatively new here. Primary voters are certainly entitled to all information about a possible candidate they are voting for. So far, most posters on this thread haven’t done anything but express dismay at the number and nature of the pardons that Huckabee granted, not to mention the personal connection he had to several of them.
Doesn’t that bother you in the least??
Surely you jest? Who cares if they were violent repeat offenders, he pardoned murderers. What part of murder are you not understanding? So they didn’t get out of prison and kill someone else yet, so it is ok? Once you murder another innocent human being outside a mutually combative or self-defense paradigm, jail is where you belong.
I must concede that I also am against life sentences. Spending the rest of your life in prison is no life. I think if you receive a life sentence they should just put you down after 5 years, especially when the evidence is irrefutable. Give that 50k a year it costs to house and imprison these scum back to the taxpayer.
Thank you for your input.
It seems the SHM (Stop Huckabee Movement) is in full swing this fine morning.
I am the governor and I want you to be free. I can arrange that, if you promise not to rape any more cheerleaders. Will you try to be a good doo-be? Please think about a life without rape and murder, OK? Would that be alright with you?
Your Pal and Ticket to Missouri,
Well now, writing a hot check is a far cry from beating somebody to death with a pipe, now isn't it?
I'll ask you again. Doesn't it bother you whatsoever that he had personal ties to many that he pardoned?
BTW how long have you been pro-Huckabee?
He DID want to do it. He announced his intention, and then, by law, had to wait 30 to 90 days to make the final decision. But the public objected. Four days before the deadline, the parole board gave DuMond parole. Only after that did Gov. Huckabee send the letter to DuMond that said,(in effect)....Dear Mr.DuMond: Since you are getting paroled, you no longer need me to commute your sentence.
So we should just let Huck ride to the top and say nothing? I have been told I was trashing Rudy, Fred and now Hucklebee. I seem to have hit the trifecta. I am not sure about Mitt they usually just post me some info to try to put a spin on whatever I posted.
No one is trashing anyone. If you as a Steeler fan, posted Tom Bradys statistics, or wrote about one of his bad games, that isn’t bashing. Hucklebee has had a lot of bad games and Tom Brady isn’t running for the leader of the free world.
I think we have already filled the quota on ex Arkansas Governors as POTUS.
What does that matter? At least several of his early releases/clemency/commutation/etc. cases DID repeat offend - with the most notorious of the cases Huckabee had a hand in - Dumond, not only re-offending, but then murdering in the state Huckabee brokered the release too.
Please read the article!
A pastor who promoted Huckabee among blacks urged the governor to grant clemency to John Henry Claiborne, who was sentenced to 100 years for a 1994 armed robbery, according to a 2004 report in the Arkansas Democrat-Gazette. Huckabee made Claiborne eligible for parole after receiving a letter from the Rev. Charles Williams, who told the newspaper he had helped win "many, many" clemencies from Huckabee.
Huckabee deserves to be scrutinized as heavily as anybody else. There’s a lot of questionable stuff here.
LOL! I love FR Humor!!
Sure, we can save resources and dump juries, since their decision is wrong. Does anyone think that the intent of the executive pardon system is to willy-nilly decide which convicts have a minister friend and which do not?
Perhaps Arkansans can tell us also, what kind of judges did Huckabee appoint? With these pardons it almost looks as if Huckabee was more soft on crime than Clinton!
Yawn. Nice try but you still don’t win the Kewpie doll.
Find a credible source that points to Reagan pardoning twice more convicts than his previous three predecessors combined, pardoning some of them for votes as well as personal relationships, and we’ll talk.
“It seems the SHM (Stop Huckabee Movement) is in full swing this fine morning.”
And from what I can see for good reason.
So, an article describing verifiable actions of a former governer who is running for POTUS and exposes his ENORMOUSLY high rate of pardons along with the relational circumstances surrounding many of them should be minimized or ignored by those reading?
Please newbie. Don’t blame me if your guy’s past leniency can’t stand up to voters scrutiny and standards. If his actions as governor generate concern about his judgement , why shouldn’t we quite reasonably be concerned about the MUCH more weighty decisions he’d be making as POTUS??
How defensive you are to call my posts “attacks”. There’s blood in the water on this issue and it’s by the Huckleberry’s own hand....over and over again apparently.
BTW, do you read taglines?
The huck fans can excuse anything. Just watch.
As a recent new member, you are aware that you signed up for Free Republic, a Conservative Forum...
BTW, Fred Thompson, since like I said, I do both, attack other candidates (what most normal folks call telling the truth) and support a Conservative for the office of President...
I can see a lot of valid reasons for all of this. First, Huckabee can just be one of those Christians who really takes the forgiveness and mercy aspect of the religion to heart.
People with some contact to him get pardoned? Wow, whooda thunk it? You can’t pardon someone you’ve never heard of, and having some kind of personal contact method helps you hear of them.
This minister? It’s not vote buying. They obviously get along well together minister-to-minister. Williams knows how to talk to Huckabee to get across that someone has changed. Williams of course looks after his flock, so will bring people he thinks deserve clemency to Huckabee.
I believe Huckabee is an honest man, and all of this can be explained simply by him having bleeding-heart liberal tendencies.
I will try an respond to your post later, must leave for appointment at the moment.
Ok, however this is an election, everything is on the table.
BTW Mitt has his own issues with crooks...
Perhaps something in the tag line...
Ah, your new tag helps...