Skip to comments.Transgender woman sues hospital (Catholic-Owned Seton Won't Let Her Get Breast Surgery Eeewww!)
Posted on 01/05/2008 10:01:16 AM PST by ProtectOurFreedom
"God made you a man." That's what Charlene Hastings said she was told when she called to inquire about breast enlargement surgery at Seton Medical Center, a Catholic hospital in Daly City. Now the San Franciscan is suing the hospital, claiming officials there discriminated against her because she had a sex-change operation.
Hastings, 57, had already had the major surgery she needed to become a woman. She had chosen a San Francisco plastic surgeon with privileges at Seton to perform the breast augmentation in October 2006. But the surgeon, Dr. Leonard Gray, told her that Seton no longer allowed him to operate on transgender patients, Hastings said. "It's a blatant case of discrimination."
The lawsuit pits the rights of transgendered people against the hospital's rights to operate according to its religious principles.
State law allows religiously affiliated hospitals to refuse to provide abortions, but there is no specific religious exemption allowing hospitals to deny elective surgery to transgender people. Seton is a member of the Daughters of Charity Health System, which operates five Catholic hospitals in California.
"Seton Medical Center provides medically necessary services to all individuals," Nikels said in a prepared statement. "However, the hospital does not perform surgical procedures contrary to Catholic teaching; for example, abortion, direct euthanasia, transgender surgery or any of its related components." The hospital did not comment directly on the lawsuit.
Wertz thinks Seton's policy violates the Unruh Act, a state law that prohibits discrimination on the basis of gender, gender identity or sexual orientation. "There's simply no religious exemption in the Unruh Act," Wertz said.
"This is a civil rights story," he said. "It is about transgender people being able to use businesses and other facilities on an equal basis as other people. If you took out 'transgender' in the lawsuit
(Excerpt) Read more at mercurynews.com ...
There's a pic of "Charlene" in the paper today, but it's not online. Probably a good thing, too. If you haven't hurled after reading the story, the pic would have certainly sent you over the top.
The lawsuit was filed Dec. 21 in San Francisco Superior Court. How do you suppose it will turn out? [purely rhetorical question]
Why is it that it’s the ‘you can’t legislate morality’ liberals who are always trying to use the law to force their values on others? [Rhetorical question]
Radical cutitoffomy, to be precise.
I've been waiting for this type of slippery slope with the words again. The same thing that invented words like "Undocumented immigrant."
Trangenderism has nothing to do with this. The item in question is a transsexual.
That's what Charlene Hastings said she was told when she called to inquire about breast enlargement surgery at Seton Medical Center, a Catholic hospital in Daly City.
Cut or not, you are still a dude. And you do not pass. - Sorry.
As opposed to the opposite procedure, addadictomy.
The hospital should simply revoke Dr. Gray’s practicing/affiliation rights. He should no better than even attempt to perform this type of butchery at a Catholic Hospital.
It doesn’t matter what these misguided souls do, at the end of their lives they still have the original DNA that they were born with. It would probably be a whole lot better if they tried therapy to accept their birth gender.
Then that law is abhorrent to the Constitution and should be struck down.
Satan's battle against the bride of Christ is in full force both from without, and more dangerously, from within. The pressure on the saints to conform to the world increases every day with the force of the state being advanced incrementally to accomplish this. Our communities have been infiltrated with wolves in sheep's clothing preaching a worldly Gospel, "having the appearance of godliness, but denying its power." We are seeing the chaff blown away and those of true faith must remain strong and steadfast.
I think this has less to do with getting the operation than it has to do with forcing another institution to bow to the perverted desires of a slim sub-set of society.
Without a doubt. He could easily have sought his operation at another hospital more obliging to his aberrant group.
Exactly. Why should a hospital be forced to perform surgery it doesn't think necessary anyway? What if someone wanted a breast implant on the top of his head? Should the surgeon be forced to do that?
How about the other argument used....
“well, my genes make me a homosexual, and you can’t change
that...but if my genes make me feel like a women ,
well I have to change that...” bunch o’hypocritical sophists.
The best argument is this,IMHO,...since the person who wants
the sex change operation usually tells the doc that they
(the patient) feels like a member of the opposite sex already,
than it is apparent that their physical structure does not
effect how they perceive themselves. Therefore changing their organs
will not effect them. So, therefore it is an elective
cosmetic surgery(fill in the word mutilation, for accuracy)
"Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; ...."
I'm certain that there is another hospital in San Fagcisco where the doctor can do his little nip/tuck.
If the hospital is a private one is it still liable?
Hastings, 57, had already had the major surgery she needed to become a woman. Radical cutitoffomy, to be precise.
who did he/she use as the doctor.....lorenea bobbitt?????
Exactly right. However, you can bet that if this hospital were some other “faith,” the ACLU would be doing backflips to ensure that the hospital need not perform procedures in conflict with thier sincerely held beliefs. After all, even Target employees have the right not to handle bacon and pork chops at the checkout stand because it’s “against their religion.” No, this is yet another attempt to force Catholic hospitals to compromise their beliefs or risk losing Medicaid and Medicare funding (though I am not implying that this poor soul’s implant is government funded). Many Catholic hospitals have shut down their ob/gyn departments so as not to be forced to do abortions, and all are in the dilemma of what do do about emergency contraception. But if you are another religion your beliefs are not just respected, they are pandered to.
Uh, BS. It's one more attempt by the idiots on the left to use the courts to achieve what they can't achieve via referendum or in the legislature.
So...breast implants are a civil right. Okay.
I thought the picture of Kerry and Edwards went with the story.
Funny, I missed that amendment in the Bill of Rights. Anybody seen that missing amendment?
Sure I would, if I owned a freak show :)
There was a big Catholic pro-family (that is, anti-”gay marriage,” “transgendered whatevers,” and “all abortion all the time”) demonstration in Madrid, Spain, a few days ago. The Socialist powers that be are now demanding that the Spanish bishops apologize!
Since the Pope issued a message from Rome congratulating the organizers, I guess they’ll be demanding his apology next.
I bet that Rudy would!!
You got that right
So THAT’S why my employees wanted the day off the other day!
I keed, I keed....
First of all, he’s not a woman.
what really makes me mad is these “females” get bigger breasts than some us real women.....LOL!!!
LOL. Now that’s a complaint I never expected to hear!
Agreed. He could simply go back to the hospital that provided him the sex-change operation. So there’s an agenda here that’s more than just the breast enlargement.
Sorry; I don’t buy it. Have your DNA tested if you can’t figure out what sex you are by LOOKING. If you have difficulty dealing with who you are, continue to seek professional help. I have no sympathy for those who are unwilling to accept reality and move on.
You're allowed to hold the Catholic faith. You're just not allowed to practice it.
That's friendly free-world Canada. And in America? Stay tuned.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.