Skip to comments.Real ID ready for prime time (National ID Cards Mandated in the US)
Posted on 01/11/2008 1:32:19 PM PST by Calpernia
click here to read article
Associated Press Excerpt:
Homeland Security Secretary Michael Chertoff said Friday that if states want their licenses to remain valid for air travel after May 2008, those states must seek a waiver indicating they want more time to comply with the REAL ID Act's new rules.
So far, 17 states have passed legislation or resolutions objecting to the REAL ID provisions, many due to concerns it will cost them too much to comply. The 17, according to the ACLU, are: Arizona , Colorado , Georgia , Hawaii , Idaho , Illinois , Maine , Missouri , Montana , Nebraska , Nevada , New Hampshire , North Dakota , Oklahoma , South Carolina , Tennessee and Washington state.
But Chertoff, as he unveiled final details of the REAL ID rules, said that where a particular state doesn't seek a waiver, its residents will have to use a passport or a newly created federal passport card if they want to avoid a vigorous secondary screening at airport security.
"The last thing I want to do is punish citizens of a state who would love to have a REAL ID license but can't get one," Chertoff said. "But in the end, the rule is the rule as passed by Congress."
"CNN is reporting that the US Homeland Security Department has mandated Real ID for drivers licenses. According to the article, this will not include a 'chip', but a list of options by state. Despite legislation passed in various states and objections by groups such as ACLU, this appears to be a done deal. Without one of the new IDs you will be unable to board a plane after 2014 if you are under 50."
The list of States is somewhat amazing.
One of the reasons why I’m not sure how I feel about Real ID.
Just barcode my forehead and get it over with.
To make things simpler, the ID should be implanted into the right hand.
Many of us knew this was coming down the pike. Of course we were called tin-foilers for saying it.
The Indian and Chinese H-1Bs are going to make a fortune.
Many Americans object to the government forcing them to carry a national identification card, like many other countries do.
My idea is to require everyone to carry a passport at all times. If you are an American citizen, you will carry a US passport which can be used for all identification purposes. If you are a foreigner, you will carry your nation’s passport with the US visa noted in that passport.
If you are a legal immigrant and have permission to work in the US, your passport can be used for that purpose. Of course, illegal immigrants won’t have passports or visas giving them permission to work.
Under fifty? Child bearing years.
I’ve heard that about Federal Building access too.
Why not barcode the area you sit on?
Could one conclude then, that the Federal government is completely aware that there are many phony state drivers liscenses in circulation?
How about the states that demand driver ID's for VOTING. The Feds gonna clean that up too, since they are intimately linked?
“Two more people have been arrested, and 19 others are still wanted, for allegedly getting Rhode Island drivers licenses that were falsified by two clerks at the state Division of Motor Vehicles.
The clerks had sent the licenses to dozens of illegal immigrants and suspected drug dealers whod paid middlemen between $2,500 to $3,000 apiece to conceal their identity with a valid license, according to the state police. Some of the customers have since been rearrested on drug charges in various states where their true identity was revealed by fingerprints but others are on the run.”
The clerks immigration status was also “ in question”
So why do we even bother?
I remember that. But, it was this Real ID that trumped Spitzer and the illegal alien IDs though. Which is why I’m not sure how I feel about this anymore.
The Steamroller and the Chertoff License
An MSNBC report said the final rules were estimated to have cut costs by 75%,
As far as the applicant goes I’m not sure what additional additional info above what they currently provide for a drivers license will be required of them. A birth certificate or passport I’d guess and that maybe basically it...
We’ve already got fingerprints. I don’t see why we need an ID.
Scan the fingerprint, and check the face against the database record that pops up onscreen. They can do that as easily and more securely than checking the data on a card against the face.
“If you are an American citizen, you will carry a US passport..”
The size of a US passport makes it cumbersome to carry around. Besides, carrying a passport at all times poses a greater risk for loss and/or theft. I hope you’ll never experience the problems when losing your passport while overseas on a business trip.
But then you'll have to prove you're under 50. Whuich means you'll also have to carry your Birth Certificate.
Because we’re the American citizens, we pay the taxes and cough up all the money for their socialist programs. Follow the money in this instance is us.
Doesn’t look like there’s room.
This is OK with me but my conservative FRiends won’t like it. Flame at will.
Thank you for the link. Bookmarked.
I think it would be more like:
"El barcode justo mi frente y la consigue encima con, gringo"
And people under 40! I like the new law, but HATE that, once again, baby boomers and seniors don’t have to comply with it.
If under 40s need to comply, then everyone should.
I say youth is wasted on the young.
Knowing Chertoff, I'm sure they've worked out a system that will let them keep track of citizens and their activities, while giving dead people and illegal aliens the right to vote or work without having to pay taxes.
Por ingles, prensa dos.
That's because this used to be free country and there was a reason why we left Europe. Many Americans object to the government forcing them to do a lot of things.
Why does an American citizen need to prove they're supposed to be here, rather than those who are not citizens?
NY Elloit Spitzer want to delay ID cards it until 2018
Check out a few of these links
Spitzer and Cheroff strick a deal it stinks!
Many illegal aliens have no problem passing for citizens. How do you tell the difference between someone with a legitimate right to live in and work in America and someone without that right?
I have no problem with the government requiring everyone to carry an official id card. My thought was that if passports are required instead of id cards there would be less objection. Now passports are required for travel to Canada and Mexico.
Passports need to be the size they are so visas can be stamped inside them.
Passports need to be the size they are so visas can be stamped inside them. A national id card carried by all citizens and aliens that includes information about the person’s citizenship and immigration status makes more sense.
This is bullshit.
Go ahead and ban me.
If Chertoff could get more than 2 out of 10 ID screeners at the airport checkpoints to actually look at the bearer of the ID and compare the picture, I’d be really impressed. I think most of them are just matching the name on the boarding pass to the name on the ID. I would doubt that many of them even check to see if the ID has expired. I’ve been throught checkpoints at 3 different airports this week and have yet to be “eye-balled”.
Start by profiling, do they look like they're supposed to be here? Next, do they speak english? Ask me for my driver's license, I'm happy to show you that.
What I'm not happy about is a jack-booted government thug asking "your papers please."
Part of the Real ID plan being talked about is the fact that it must be carried at all times, I know my DL number and can recite it off to a cop if necessary even if I don't have it on me.
Another part is the proposed RFID chip imbedded in every card, unique to each citizen, that can be tracked by GPS. I don't need the government spying on where I choose to vacation, visit or shop.
No thanks, I don't want to feel like I'm the guilty one in my own country.
“——there are only three sets of people who should be upset by the new Real IDs: terrorists, illegal aliens and swindlers.”
I would not mind seeing the three systems, the ID, the eye scan and the fingerprint. That would help on air travel (and believe me I think of that). AND voter fraud!!!
And speaking of air travel - I have NO problem with taking off my shoes, having my take-on inspected, and if something look suspecious in my luggage PLEASE PLEASE check it out!!!
Vacationing in Mexico in the 70’s, 80’s, & 90’s, I know you had to have ID and not just one piece of ID.
Canada was also very difficult to enter!!
And please carefully check my ID to voting - mail in ballots is just open for fraud!!! Motor Voter Bill is begging for fraud.
I never thought I would say -— illegal alliens & close our borders, but....
we must attend to illegal alliens in our country and close our borders. And deal with the ones who break our rules.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.