Posted on 01/13/2008 1:42:30 PM PST by Congressman Billybob
That's what they all say, say.
As a poetic device, that is called Synecdoche.
John / Billybob
Nor “Frankly, Scarlett, I don’t give a damn.”
I looked it up.
John / Billybob
It seems so obvious. Why can't we fix it faster? Like yesterday?
The government’s failure to stop illegal immigration should not be the backbone of a new government boondoggle that allegedly provides a fix for their ineptitude of the initial premise.
There are immigration laws already in place.
Government makes excuses why they cannot enforce the laws.
So their better idea, that makes government look like it is legitimately trying to solve the problem they have created, by not enforcing the current laws, is to impose on the “subjects” another program they will ultimately fail to deliver on.
We are born in a State. We live in a State. We are educated in a State. We learn to drive in a State. The State issues our birth records. We live under State Laws.
I am a citizen of my State first. I am not a subject of the federal kingdom. There is nothing wrong with the State recordkeeping. There is nothing wrong with State law enforcement.
But there is everything wrong with a federal mandate that forces me to obtain permission and travel documents within my own country when I am already a legal resident.
The Real ID is a distraction ploy. The American citizen is NOT the problem. The problem is with the illegal immigrants and the governments inability or willingness to enforce those SPECIFIC LAWS related to immigration.
They can’t even build a damn border fence. I bet in monetary cost, a border fence would be much less costly than duplication of ID documents already held by lifelong American citizens.
Checking people at the borders makes much more sense, just because of the low volume, than auditing CITIZENS.
Those 12 million illegals didn’t cross the border all at the same time. They came one at a time, and they can be sent back one at a time, even if it takes 10 years to do their job the Feds told us they would do.
There are many movie quotes which are misremembered. Such as Strother Martin as the Warden in “Hud.” He did not say to Paul Newman digging in the hole, “What we have here is a failure to communicate.” Not quite that.
John / Billybob
There will still be, BTW, some differences between the licenses issued by the various states.
John / Billybob
It seems unfair to me that we REQUIRE non-Americans to break our laws in order to qualify for American welfare benefits. If there is no citizenship requirement for welfare and other benefits (in-state tuition, medical care, etc.) then we should not require non-Americans to come here to collect the benefits. We should do the right thing and deliver the benefits to them in their home countries. Basically, every person in the world should immediately become "quasi-American-citizens" with all the rights and privileges of American citizenship.
Or.....
...maybe we could limit the rights of American citizenship to American citizens.... I'm just saying...
You make some very good points that I hadn’t considered.
We do have a problem with forged identification or ID that was obtained using forged documents.
Hopefully the steps my state is taking will allowed those using phony drivers licenses to be apprehended.
Thanks for your input.
p,s The bast_rdized quote you DO use is from Blazing Saddles, not Treasure of Sierra Madre.
Now go ahead and get the last word.
John / Billybob
Thanks for the response.
I will say that this is becoming our defacto national ID card, and I think that will be problematic.
Which means that the so-called "problem" of mass deportation is entirely bogus.
Those illegal aliens got here through their own actions, including a lot of planning, exertion, and risk. They can, just as, or more easily, go back to Mexico on their own, if conditions are made (like employment) so that is in their better interest.
Funny, they say that George Bush was such a great poker player at the Skull and Bones. He, dragging along the American taxpayer, has been totally snookered by the Mexican government.
It is incomplete to look at the whole illegal alien thing without invoking Mexico, its government, its criminal institutions, as almost an enemy, or at least hostile neighbor. Mexico has adequate natural resources for its own.
So much for the current administration's "foreign relations" experience.
This is bad, bad stuff
That drawing in post #29 - where did you get a picture of Rage Boy’s family reunion?
You are correct. He didn’t say anything quite like that, or anything else, in “Hud” :)
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.