“If McCain doesn’t energize Republicans, he loses.”
You mean....fear might not be enough this time?
Fear of a left socialist liberal is a huge motivator. So yes, fear plays a part.
Didn't work for GOP in 1992, 1996, or 2006.
Didn't work for the democRATs in 2000 or 2004.
I won't say absolutely that it wouldn't work, but the track record for fear as motivation to vote isn't good.