Skip to comments.Is a third intifada brewing?
Posted on 03/10/2008 10:51:29 AM PDT by jhpigott
Bethlehem, West Bank - Fadi al-Amour and his friends high school seniors spent more time last week on the street than in class. Every day, they marched on Rachel's Tomb, guarded by Israeli soldiers, and, along with hundreds of other young Palestinians, pelted the nearest symbol of Israeli power with rocks and Molotov cocktails.
"We were implementing what our leaders in the prisons tell us we should be doing. Even Marwan Barghouthi has warned that this is where we're going: the third intifada," says Mr. Amour, mentioning the Fatah figure jailed by Israel in 2002 for his role in the last intifada, which lasted from 2000 to 2004.
From Gaza rocket strikes and West Bank riots to a deadly shooting inside Jerusalem late last week, many Palestinians are saying or perhaps hoping that these incidents of violence will spark a new, much broader conflict with Israel.
Those who are encouraging a further escalation say it's overdue. Others, including many who remember the misery of past intifadas, worry that this will just drag the Palestinian cause down a dead-end street.
"There might be an escalation in the coming weeks and months, and an escalation has already been going on in Gaza in recent weeks and months," says Ali Jarbawi, a political scientist at Birzeit University, near Ramallah.
But, he says, there might be a danger in rushing to label the events of the last few weeks as the start of another intifada. "People are feeling a sense of despair. They're frustrated by the [new Israeli-Palestinian negotiations] leading nowhere, and [by] the internal situation between Hamas and Fatah," he says. "But I don't see that translating into a concrete, continuous event, which I think is something that defines an intifada. Let's wait and see."
But among many average Palestinians, the feelings that were present during the first intifada (1987-93) and the second one are resurfacing again, and quickly.
On Sunday, at the mourning tent at the family home of Alaa Abu Dhaim, who killed eight Israelis late last week at the Mercaz Harav Yeshiva in Jerusalem before being shot and killed by a security guard, there were many mixed feelings expressed about where Palestinians are headed, as the Islamic militants of Hamas continue to battle Israel on one front and secular Fatah leaders are sitting down at the negotiating table with their Israeli counterparts on another.
Mr. Abu Dhaim, a man in his mid-20s who was due to be married soon, was from the East Jerusalem neighborhood of Jebel Mukaber, meaning he had an Israeli-issued residency card and was free to travel and work in Israel.
For many across the tight-knit community of Jebel Mukaber, there was an acknowledgment that Abu Dhaim's act might be a sign of returning to the days of intifada. There was also much reluctance to see that happen.
"We hope this isn't the start of something bigger," says Mahmoud Abu Dhaim, an uncle of the young man being celebrated as a shahid, or martyr. "For years they've been talking about peace but there's no progress. So now we're going back instead of going forward."
Another uncle, Tawfiq, says his nephew was "extremely normal and showed no sign of political affiliations or training."
Conflicting reports have linked the gunman to Hamas and then to Hizbullah; the green and yellow flags of both movements began springing up in Jebel Mukaber after the news broke. Family members said that Israeli police here told them if the family didn't take down all of the flags, as well as the "shahid posters" that already plastered the walls of the neighborhood, they wouldn't be allowed to have a mourning tent at all.
The celebratory flyers read: "The Islamic Movement in Jebel Mukabar congratulates its people for the martyr Alaa Abu Dhaim, who answered the call to his God in a heroic operation in Dir Yassin." Dir Yassin was the name of an Arab village that existed near the site of the Mercaz Harav Yeshiva until 1948, the year of the war that led to Israel's establishment.
Just as the use of the name Dir Yassin conjures a sense of decades-old revenge so close to Israel's 60th anniversary this May, Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert said that Abu Dhaim's choice of target was itself symbolic.
"The terrorist ... did not choose it by coincidence in his pursuit of victims," Mr. Olmert said at Sunday's cabinet meeting. "Mercaz Harav is a very special place in Jerusalem and for the Zionist movement. It is the flagship of religious Zionism. It is the place from which have come forth the best soldiers for many generations," he said, adding that it "has educated and nurtured tradition and legacy, as part of Israel's resilience."
At Abu Dhaim's home, from which there is a clear view of a West Bank separation barrier cutting through the landscape, relatives and friends said the motivation for the attack might have come from many places, but most palpably, from the recent violence in the Gaza Strip.
Responding to Palestinian missile attacks on its southern communities, Israel launched a short but intensive military campaign on Gaza the week before last, in which approximately 126 Palestinians died in the space of several days. Two Israeli soldiers died in the operation; several citizens have been injured by Katyusha and Qassam rockets launched by Palestinian militants.
According to the Associated Press, Egyptian officials have been meeting with Hamas representatives in an effort to forge some kind of cease-fire between Hamas and Israel.
Up the street from Abu Dhaim's house in East Jerusalem, a group of men who would usually be at work on Israeli construction sites sat drinking coffee together for the day because they deemed the atmosphere too tense to go to work in the Jewish parts of town, due to the yeshiva shooting.
Most had lived through one if not two intifadas. Now in their late 20s and early 30s most were less than enthusiastic about the start of a new intifada and hoped it wouldn't come to be. At the same time, they said, their lives had not improved and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict seemed to be growing worse.
"No amount of violence is ever going to bring peace. But what we see on television of what Israel is doing in Gaza is much more disturbing than seeing an army jeep on my corner," says Mahmoud Abbas, no relation to the president.
For Amour and his friends, they welcome another intifada. About last week's shooting attack in Jerusalem, they said: "Inshallah [God-willing], there should be more operations like this."
Amour, the most vocal of his clique, explains it this way. "We welcomed it completely. And if the Israelis hit Gaza again, things will start up again here."
Has sort of a "Dog bites Man" quality to it....
The other two worked out soo well.
Nihilists, how do you reason with them? They want death, destruction, and have no plans for any constructive future.
Two things. Seal the border, and leave it sealed. There should be no access to Israel overland for a generation.
Secondly, it needs to be repeated, evidently, what should be clear to anyone. There will never be an independent West Bank, and there will never be an independent Gaza. It will never happen. They are not viable, either of them. They have no markets, no source of employment of their own, they are completely dependent on welfare payments from EU, UN, US, the Saudis, smuggling, terror for hire, but they have no productive capacity.
Separate from Israel, separate from Egypt and Jordan, separate from foreign welfare payments, they have no economy of their own.
They are outlaw enclaves, ruled by outlaws.
These territories have been designed to be a cancer on Israel's hide, and that has to end. Seal the border. Access to the world for the West Bank has to be via Amman. Access to the world for Gaza has to be via Egypt, or its own sea coast.
Seal them off from Israel, and they become Jordan's problem, and Egypt's. The rules of the game have to be reversed.
What, did they have to take a break to reload again?
We, the United States, must stop sending them tens of millions of dollars in aid every year. Otherwise they have no reason to change their behavior.
It also has that “Pals are still violent, self-defeating morons/Groundhog Day, the movie” quality.
I agree but I am starting to feel the same way towards Israels leadership. Whats the use in sending them billions year after year with the same result?. Israels attempts at peace with these animals is a joke with us constantly rewarding both sides.
When is Israel going to smash the Palestians? Push them into Jordon and Egypt and sow Gaza and the West bank with mines. Let it serve as an Israeli security buffer.
IMHO, this says more about the sorry state of Israeli leadership than Pali intransigence. Olmert should go, get a hard nose leader in there and things will improve fast.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.