Coming soon to a neighborhood near you.
Posted on 03/21/2008 4:26:10 PM PDT by PROCON
PROVIDENCE — A new initiative borne of a recent incident between a Providence storeowner and two Spanish-speaking customers is asking all Rhode Islanders to help stop hate speech and violence directed at “immigrants and communities of color.”
The “We Can Stop the Hate” campaign was announced at the University of Rhode Island’s downtown campus, a week after published reports about a March 1 encounter between two Dominican natives who are also U.S. citizens, and David C. Richardson, owner of Rhode Island Refrigeration. The incident provoked accusations against Richardson of racial profiling and committing a hate crime.
The “stop the hate” organizers said their coalition of community organizations, government officials, business leaders and community advocates will circulate a petition statewide and ask Rhode Islanders “to pledge against hate speech.” They will conduct educational forums at universities, schools and businesses, among other venues; they said they will take their campaign to the media.
“Rhode Islanders must be educated about the use of hate speech and the growing discrimination and violence against Latinos and other immigrants, both in our backyards and across the country,” said Miguel Sanchez-Hartwein, executive director for the Center for Hispanic Policy and Advocacy (CHisPA) and an organizer of the new initiative.
“Words do have consequences,” said Sanchez-Hartwein. He said rhetoric is often propagated in “a very organized” fashion and uses “code words” such as “an army of invaders” or “an invading force” when referring to immigrants — making no distinction between legal immigrants and those who are here illegally. He said such rhetoric can escalate “into extremist hate speech.”
Sanchez-Hartwein said, “It sometimes takes an incident like an unlawful request of a Social Security card from an individual trying to make a simple purchase to bring these matters to the forefront.”
State Sen. Juan Pichardo, one of half-dozen speakers, said, “We have to elevate the immigration debate. We, as Rhode Islanders, need to make our community stronger. This is no longer about ‘legal’ versus ‘illegal’ immigrants. It’s about all immigrants.”
Pichardo added, “All this hate speech — we need to stop this wave. It’s not the America we pursue to fight for.”
Speakers yesterday included state Rep. Joseph Almeida; Steven Brown, executive director of the Rhode Island Affiliate of the American Civil Liberties Union; Brown University Prof. Cynthia Garcia-Coll; Ramon Martinez, executive director of Progreso Latino; the Rev. Eliseo Nogueras, of the Hispanic Pastors Association of Rhode Island and head of the regional affiliate of the National Latino Clergy and Christian Leaders; and Melba DePeña, executive director of the Providence Human Relations Commission.
Martinez, of Progreso Latino, said one of the initiative’s goals will be “to question claims being made” about illegal immigration and immigrants in general and determine whether “the data is fact, or conjecture?”
The triggering incident occurred when José Genao, a state worker, and a friend went to Richardson’s store to buy a part for a boiler. While Richardson looked for the requested part, he heard Genao and his friend speaking to one another in Spanish.
Richardson then asked the men for their Social Security cards. When they declined to do so, Richardson displayed his membership card for Rhode Islanders for Immigration Law Enforcement (RIILE), a group that advocates curbs against illegal immigration.
Genao said Richardson lifted a phone receiver and told the men he could call immigration authorities “at any time” and make “a citizens’ arrest.”
Richardson said he was acting on his right as an American citizen because he believes that “that majority of people — more than 51 percent — who don’t speak English, are illegal aliens.”
Brown, of the ACLU, called Richardson’s actions “clearly and patently illegal” and said “there are legal remedies available” for people who believe their civil liberties have been violated.
Genoa said yesterday he plans to file a discrimination claim against Richardson with the Providence Human Relations Commission.
Genao said he wants people “to know not to be afraid to report incidents like this” and to make others “think twice” about taking actions similar to Richardson’s. He said that same motivation pushed him to go public with the incident, even when his friend encouraged him “to forget about it.” The friend has declined comment.
Terry Gorman, who founded RIILE in 2006, said he resents the criticisms of his group since the incident at Richardson’s store. That included brief references to RIILE at the “We Can Stop The Hate” campaign.
“I disagree vehemently, that if they’re referring to RIILE as a group that’s spewing hate … they’re absolutely wrong,” said Gorman. “That’s including a mistake made by Mr. Richardson — I don’t believe that to be hate speech either.”
Gorman said, “They can check anywhere they want to check, and prove to me that RIILE has ever spewed any hate to anyone. All we try to do is get the laws of the nation enforced, and support any new legislation that would help alleviate the tremendous illegal alien problem in Rhode Island.”
The Thought Police are coming soon!
“The Thought Police are coming soon!”
From my cold dead mouth !!!
It's still speech, and this is not some third-world hellhole or a failed state where they kill people for violation of speech codes.
They should inflict capital punishment on people who actually attempt to restrict free speech.
I thought all hate speech, unless minorty approved and utilized, was ‘extremist’. < sarc. off >
Good ol' tried and true mantra from Good little socialists....How quaint.
"Hate speech" and violence directed at Natives and people of non-color, however, may proceed unimpeded.
“The “We Can Stop the Hate” campaign...”
Well, this should last until the little leftists down a case of beer and find a new porn site.
"Press one for English, press two for spanish, press three....."
Did they listen to Obama’s speech? It balmed me (a white guy) for all of the problems! He did not acknolege any black involvement in their own plight. They just need more of MY money!
Hate speech as defined by????
Answer: as defined by the reader/listener; and if someone’s sensibilities are bothered, well then we MUST appease such a person AT ALL COSTS!
Free speech? What a concept?
Ah, yes, Re-education camps, thanks Komrade!/LOL
Paging Rev. Wright....Rev. Wright, please pick up the white courtesy phone....
If they want to deal with hate speech there’s a UCC church in Chicago that ought to be checked out
ON THE INTERNET:
It appears that the genuine scum in our country has discovered that they can marginalize those with any objection to them by simply using PC buzzwords.
This went far beyond "thought". The jerk was acting as a self-appointed "I Vant to See Your Papers" Police.
The bottom line is that these men were U.S. citizens and no self-apponited vigilante with a "Rhode Islanders for Whatever Law Enforcement" membership card has a right to demand that you present I.D. to him.
Are you going to allow some bozo to make a "citizen's arrest" on you because you refuse to show him your Social Security card when he demands that you do so?
I don't think so.
************
"Richardson then asked the men for their Social Security cards. When they declined to do so, Richardson displayed his membership card for Rhode Islanders for Immigration Law Enforcement (RIILE), a group that advocates curbs against illegal immigration. Genao said Richardson lifted a phone receiver and told the men he could call immigration authorities “at any time” and make “a citizens’ arrest.”
Now that's true 1930's Germany!
I insist everyone who lives in this country speak English only so that I can know for sure wheter these “guests” are using hate speech in my presence...
We agree.
Some people rally oughta just grow up....and shut up!!
Grim reminders!
You’re welcome PROCON.
I think it’s hateful to invade another country and steal resources and jobs—but maybe that’s just me.
The illegal invaders and their commie supporters expect us to shut up and do nothing about this invasion. The average American could put a serious dent in the number of criminals entering this country if they refuse to patronize any business that employs illegals. I’m sick of these business owners making money off the cheap labor of illegals while we get stuck with the expenses they create.
“... and this is not some third-world hellhole or a failed state where they kill people for violation of speech codes.”
Not yet, anyway.
Si trates de robarme, te mataré.
FTA: “...’immigrants and communities of color.’”
Well, I’m white. And, last time I checked, white was a color. So, I’m a person of color, I guess.
Actually a pure black person would be r,g,b = (0,0,0), hence
no color. A pure white person would be r,g,b = (1,1,1) hence
full color (assuming an RGB color model).
bump
proof that the rgb system was conceived by whites to make blacks “nothing.”
What movie is that image from?
There are white immigrants - Russians, Poles, lots of Eastern Europeans.
LOL
the state workers should have called his bluff.
And then had him arrested by the flatfeet arrest the buffoon for wrongful detention or kidnapping.
Shoe, meet other foot
Ay! caramba — la necesidad del café es en la noche
the state workers should have called his bluff.
And then had him arrested by the flatfeet - nailing the buffoon for wrongful detention or kidnapping.
Shoe, meet other foot
Which means, for all practical purposes, that everybody is the same color.
“There are white immigrants - Russians, Poles, lots of Eastern Europeans.”
Don’t forget the ones that came on the mayflower !
So much for the first amendment.
By all means, shut down freedom of speech to save America.
CWII coming sooner than you think.
“It’s still speech, and this is not some third-world hellhole or a failed state”
Uh, it is too, it’s Rhode Island.
One man’s attitude is nothing compared to using the jackboots of the state to shut people up.
In his neighborhood, they are over run with crimaliens.
He can do business with whomever he wants.
He asked for a card, he didn’t detain anyone. If no card he wanted them to leave, not stay.
My best friend (excluding hubby) came from Vietnam with her family. Father was a French speaking, freedom loving professional, and they were punished for it. Cramming into an overcrowded boat with three young daughters under the age of 4. Then they spent 1-2 years in camps waiting to come here.
Most Americans don’t realize the risks so many took to get here. If they did, perhaps Obama wouldn’t have so much support.
See Post 24.
In his neighborhood, they are over run with crimaliens. He can do business with whomever he wants.
You walk into my place of business. You are an America citizen just like these two men were.
For whatever reason, I, the business owner, do not like the cut of you jib and I demand that you show me your Social Security Card or I will make a citizen's arrest because am a member of "Local Citizens for Law Enforcement".
Questions:
1.) Does my request have ANYTHING to doing with "do business with whomever I want to"?
2.) Would you "show me your papers" as I demanded or would you tell me to stick my request where the sun don't shine.
3.) If you refused to "show me your papers" and I tried to carry out my threat to make a citizen's arrest because of your refusal, would you allow me to make such an arrest since I was merely "doing business" or would the fists fly when I tried to arrest you?
The actions of that man had nothing to do with "thought" or "doing business".
They were an attempt by a private citizen to conduct an illegal search on another private citizen for sensitive private information that can and is used in criminal identity theft and attempting to conduct that illegal search by verbally threatening to use physical force.
If a business owner at his hardware store tried to do that to your wife and actually touched her trying to make his "citizen's arrest", after your wife kicked him in the nuts and called 911, the Police would be dragging that business owner off to jail and charging him, not your wife, with assault and also with attempted robbery.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.