Posted on 05/07/2008 9:16:44 AM PDT by NormsRevenge
More than two years after a precedent-setting move by the federal government cleared a path around environmental laws and legal challenges, the construction of a stretch of border fence across a deep canyon known as Smuggler's Gulch is set to begin next month.
The project will require cutting earth from surrounding hills and filling in the canyon with more than 2 million cubic yards of dirt, an operation so large that critics fear disastrous environmental consequences.
According to the latest plans from the U.S. Customs and Border Protection, the project will consist of constructing an earthen berm across the canyon to support a 15-foot secondary steel-mesh fence and all-weather patrol and access roads.
The agency said a $48.6 million contract was awarded this year to the Keiwit Corp., a construction and mining firm based in Omaha, Neb.
Elsewhere along the U.S.-Mexico border, fence construction has ranged from about $2 million to a little more than $3 million per mile, he said.
“Certainly in some areas, it is easier to construct than it is in others,” said Barry Morrissey, a spokesman with U.S. Customs and Border Protection in Washington, D.C. “Just based on the geography there, this particular segment posed some unusual challenges.” The terrain is what concerns the critics, who fear that sediment from the project will harm the Tijuana River estuary, where millions in state and federal tax dollars have been spent to restore wetlands.
The fence in the Smuggler's Gulch area west of the San Ysidro port of entry will stretch for about 3.5 miles. More fencing to the east and west of that segment will add another mile. Combined, the new fencing will complete a 14-mile run of contiguous secondary fence running inland from the Pacific.
In February 2004, several environmental groups, including the Sierra Club and the San Diego Audubon Society, filed suit in federal court to stop the project. The same month, the California Coastal Commission stalled construction after ruling that it would cause environmental damage.
The following year, however, federal legislation granted the Department of Homeland Security the authority to waive all laws and litigation standing in the way of fence construction. In September 2005, Homeland Security Secretary Michael Chertoff set a precedent by exercising the waiver authority in San Diego.
In December of that year, the lawsuit was thrown out of court; later that month, a federal judge in San Diego ruled that the waiver authority was not unconstitutional.
Since then, as the federal government rushes to have 670 miles of pedestrian and vehicle fencing in place by the end of this year under the 2005 Secure Border Initiative, the department has waived environmental and other restrictions impeding construction elsewhere, starting last year in Arizona.
On April 1, two additional waivers cleared the way for fence construction in California, Arizona, New Mexico and Texas, with one waiver encompassing roughly 470 total miles.
Meanwhile, National Guard troops in San Diego County have been doing preliminary construction along the border, including building access roads.
As construction approaches Smuggler's Gulch, environmentalists are trying to find last-minute ways to reduce the environmental impact, especially sediment damage to the estuary at Border Field State Park.
“When you put a lot of sediment into an estuary, it changes the function and structure of the estuary, until it compromises the function,” said Mike McCoy of the Southwest Wetlands Interpretive Association, a plaintiff in a 2004 suit.
McCoy and representatives from the local Audubon Society, the Save Our Heritage Organisation and other groups met last week with Rep. Bob Filner, D-San Diego, to discuss a draft of an alternative fence and border security plan.
The alternative proposal would involve spending $70 million for fence construction to instead replace the existing primary fence – there is older fencing at the bottom of the gulch – with a sturdier one. It also calls for hiring additional Border Patrol agents, dedicating money toward agent housing, improving existing border roads and providing enhanced sensor technology.
Smuggler's Gulch gets its name in part from liquor smuggling from Mexico during Prohibition, said Border Patrol Agent Jason Rodgers. While agents have seen increased human-and drug-smuggling traffic there in recent months, including a recent large marijuana seizure, “I wouldn't say it's one of our worst areas,” Rodgers said.
Nonetheless, the Smuggler's Gulch fence is necessary for border security, said Rep. Duncan Hunter, R-Alpine, a longtime proponent of the project who championed the waiver authority in Congress.
“If we are really going to have an effect on controlling our border, we can't be having eight-to 10-year delays on these really small sections,” Hunter said. “I think we actually waited a full year on a study to see if the gnatcatcher would fly over the fence. While we were analyzing that, tons of cocaine were coming over that border.”
Still not good enough IMHO.
Plug it in at both ends and create the worlds biggest bug zapper, then they will know we mean business...
I reckun that’s a bit more humane than using Trebuchets to send ‘em back to Mejico. ;-) (/sarc)
They do leave a mess, huh?
It’s costing a lot of dineros to clean up some of those areas, lots of money.
related thread
Groups Struggle to Clean Up Mess Illegal Immigrants Leave Behind
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/2012493/posts
“critics fear disastrous environmental consequences.....”
I fear disastrous American sovereignty consequences a lot more....
Hey, the Mythbusters showed that all you have to do is get a bunch of surgical tubing and the right kind of seat and it works just great. All you have to find a pond for them to land in and all is well! ;-)
see, now your messing with the water quality. maybe if we encapsulated them in NERF material.;-)
I’d love to see the before and after photos.
They do leave a mess, huh?
Lets send Ted Kennedy in there and he can sing his Mexican songs while he’s picking all that crap up...
It’s about time to close down the border.
ping
Lets send Ted Kennedy in there and he can sing his Mexican songs while he’s picking all that crap up...
—
I think the uN and Amnesty Int’l may have a legitimate gripe if he did,, something about cruel and unusual punishment/torture to the surrounding wildlife and those hiding behind the bushes. (no, not those Bushes) ;-)
Why do I get the feeling that once again this is just political posturing? I’ll believe it when I see it!
Your house is on fire. You don’t call in people to assess the possible damage done by water runoff, excess foot traffic on the grass, sound pollution due to sirens, etc.
You put the fire out first.
Nope, just aim for the surf and all you have to worry about is the eventual oil slick on their beaches.
You need to post this picture on this other thread also- some are wondering how much trash illegals could be leaving behind.
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/2012493/posts
Looking east on the Mex side of the border with the Existing double fence.
BUMP
Maybe we should have contracted the Israelis to build it! LOL
Like pulling teeth! LOL
If Bush had deployed troops & the Corps of Engineers after 9/11 to the border; we would have had a secure border by now...on both ends of the country!
I live in San Diego. We also have this rather large oceanfront bordering on Mexico where there is no fence. You can surf or fishing boat into America from Mexico.
Thank you Duncan Hunter!
And yet he still gets ripped by those who are never happy.
What a great idea. Gather all that trash up and CHUCK it over the boarder. What fun! Maybe we could make a Holiday out of it. Chuck-O De Trash-O !
Maybe they should use a solar power sound system featuring the looped song stylings of Yoko Ono.
“MAKE THEM PAY DEARLY FOR TRESSPASS”, I say.
I think the uN and Amnesty Int’l may have a legitimate gripe if he did,, something about cruel and unusual punishment/torture to the surrounding wildlife and those hiding behind the bushes. (no, not those Bushes) ;-)
Wandering Ted Kennedy in the desert would be an eyesore for sure....He would probably end up like Chevy Chase from the movie Vacation....
Jamese777, I see in post #2 that it shows “proposed additional fencing”, so what type of fence is there at the moment? Thanks.
“Jamese777, I see in post #2 that it shows “proposed additional fencing”, so what type of fence is there at the moment? Thanks.”
See post #21 for pictures of the fencing. Click below for an additional photo of the fence.
http://www.sandiego.edu/tbi/images/border_fence.jpg
What an amazing picture.. that is exactly what the river bed looks like coming out of TJ, but I guess Bob Filner, wears blinders when he passes that area...if he ever does..When he was first elected in his first month, the whole river backed up and flooded the area out..it was a disaster.. I remember I went to some of the home owners meetings with him, to get aid.. and some how he manged to get Mexico aid before the US side of the border.. and when I questioned this, he said that it was easier to get money to Mexico than to the US, and besides it was only 25.000 dollars..
Yep.
Thanks for the link.
I hope we get a good, tough and long-lasting fence down here in South Texas.
The environmental folks have to think about the CO2 emissions and the dreaded urban sprawl that will be vastly reduced with millions of fewer illegals in the US.
I am far more concerned about the trash that makes it through.....
ping
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.
