Skip to comments.Striking changes in Arizona as illegal immigrants flee the state
Posted on 05/15/2008 1:51:56 PM PDT by az4vlad
Since Arizona's local law enforcement began enforcing illegal immigration laws and an employer sanctions law went into effect, illegal immigrants have been fleeing the state in large numbers. The effects have been far-ranging. Commuters are reporting fewer vehicles on the freeways, shortening their rush-hour commutes. What had become a serious transportation problem in Arizona is losing its urgency. English Learner Language (ELL) students started dropping out of school. This helped end a confrontation between the state legislature and a liberal federal judge who had ordered the state to spend more money on ELL classes.
Fewer illegal immigrants are using hospital emergency rooms, so waiting times have decreased. Although the rest of the country is in an economic slump, unemployment is going down in Arizona, from 4.5% in January to 4.1% in March. Day laborers loitering outside of Home Depot and other stores have mostly disappeared, ending months of confrontation between illegal immigrant sympathizers and protesters. Desert lands near the border are returning to their pristine condition and the wildlife is coming back. Identity theft and car thefts are decreasing. No one showed up on May 1 to march in immigrant rallies.
With illegal immigrants leaving, the state will see huge savings as fewer illegal immigrants use social welfare programs and the cost of arresting, prosecuting, incarcerating and deporting them decreases. Arizona is facing one of the worst budget deficits ever, looming as high as $2 billion in 2009, but the situation may resolve itself.
Sheriff Joe Arpaio and Maricopa County Attorney Andrew Thomas are leading the local law enforcement efforts in Arizona against illegal immigration. Arizona is also home to State Representative Russell Pearce, who is responsible for spearheading possibly more laws against illegal immigration than any other state representative in the country. It is also home to Chris Simcox, President of the Minutemen Civil Defense Corps. Other counties around the state are beginning to follow the lead of Maricopa County, signing agreements with I.C.E. to permit their law enforcement agencies to arrest illegal immigrants. Cochise County Attorney Ed Rheinheimer intends to prosecute illegal immigrants for trespassing on public lands. Mesa mayor Keno Hawker recently wrote an op-ed in the East Valley Tribune praising Sheriff Joe Arpaio's sweeps of illegal immigrants. Pima County Sheriff Clarence Dupnik bypassed the Pima County Supervisors when they refused to authorize him to add two Border Patrol agents to his border crime unit, and added them anyways.
Although Arizona's Democrat Governor Janet Napolitano has vetoed most illegal immigration bills since 2002 when she entered office, Arizonans have bypassed her by sending initiatives directly to the ballot. In 2004, voters passed four illegal immigration measures with over 70% yes margins. A law targeting drophouses was signed into law earlier this month. An even stricter employer sanctions measure is currently underway to be on the ballot this fall.
Arizona's llegal immigrants are fleeing to sanctuary cities like San Francisco and states with less enforcement and laws prohibiting illegal immigration like Nebraska, Iowa, and Maryland. Since one out of every illegal immigrant is a felon, the result is felons are disproportionately moving to these places.
Granted there are benefits that immigrants bring to our country. But those benefits are outweighed by the negatives when the immigrants cross illegally. There are too many rules, laws, traditions, and practices in society that conflict with illegal immigrants trying to make a living. Arizona's experiment may end up resolving the illegal immigration problem satisfactorily for all, because once the fiscal expense of illegal immigrants is brought down, revising the laws to permit more immigrants to enter the country legally will become more attractive and realistic.
when is arizona gonna throw don veto napolitano out on her butt ?
Gee, I hope the other states don’t try to steal these ideas from Arizona. ;-)
“Although Arizona’s Democrat Governor Janet Napolitano has vetoed most illegal immigration bills since 2002 when she entered office, Arizonans have bypassed her by sending initiatives directly to the ballot”
SWEET! Damn Liberal figure head.
“Since one out of every illegal immigrant is a felon, the result is felons are disproportionately moving to these places.”
Does that mean that someone actually SAID that every illegal is a felon to begin with for breaking immigration law? How un-PC of them. (FINALLY!) :)
And of course JayNo tries to push us backward with her latest stunt yesterday. She is brazen in her arrogance.
Is this really true? Is it verifiable or merely anecdotal?
Enforce the law, damn it!
I'm going to love watching the landlords who rented to them scatter like cockroaches as the departures spread.
FTA: “Arizona’s llegal immigrants are fleeing to sanctuary cities like San Francisco...”
Good. They can clog the highways even more along with the gays, who are going there to het married.
Same thing happened in Oklahoma and other places that began to enforce anti-illgal immigrant laws.
Yes indeedy, and that the same “someone” is now the candidate for President on the Republican side, it’s certainly an “interesting” occurence coming from his own state!
“...every illegal is a felon to begin with.”
I think it’s a typo. There’s a word missing.
But if it was meant to say that every illegal is a felon, then that would be plain wrong. You may not like it and I may not like it, but just being in the country without proper authorization IS NOT A FELONY.
I was wondering myself how much of this is verifiable.
Illegal aliens, folks, not illegal immigrants. Immigrants describes only people who come here intending to stay, not everyone who comes over the border. The word “immigrant” does not describe everyone who’s part of the problem.
That may be true but many felonies occur after entering. Look at all the document fraud that was going on in Iowa. If Americans did that they could expect jail time but the most these "migrants" will get is a free trip back home, if even that.
>>I’m going to love watching the landlords who rented to them scatter like cockroaches as the departures spread.
You’re already seeing it. It’s bound to be a component of the mortgage default crisis.
All this progress in Arizona—and none of it attributable to John McAmnesty.
“Since one out of every [———] illegal immigrant is a felon, the result is felons are disproportionately moving to these places.
What is this missing number?
I would think it would be easy after the way the states budget has been destroyed by her and her comrades in the legislature.
You know you're going to get some flack for this from the diehard anti-illegal-immigrant crowd.
In any case, I agree with you. The only thing I disagreed with Tancredo on was his wacky idea of making all illegal aliens felons by dint of their coming here illegally.
Making all illegal aliens felons is only going to disrupt the process of their self-deportation.
I may be, but I doubt it’s the main cause. The main cause was floating loans to citizens who couldn’t service them.
Oh man, so many more are going to get rear-ended!
FTA: Arizonas llegal immigrants are fleeing to sanctuary cities like San Francisco...
Good. They can clog the highways even more along with the gays, who are going there to
When her term expires. She’s term-limited.
We're hoping that Obama will appoint her Permanent Latrine Orderly or something that takes her off our hands.
Typo? One out of how many?
Now, I wonder how McCain is going to tell us that enforcement first does not work when it is clearly working in his home state.
I live in Iowa and there are many coming here. ICE just raided a packing plant this week and rounded up 390 of them. Not only were they illegal but some of them were running a meth lab IN the packing plant. If more states would crack down we could make a huge dent in this problem.
So the question now is where are they fleeing to?
Hopefully back to Mexico not elsewhere in the States.
Why? Where is the flack? I am totally against illegal immigration because it is an security issue as well as a social and economic issue. That doesn't change the fact that it is not a felony to be here illegally. Those that seem to think that illegals are just great have a serious misconception of those who are against illegal immigration.
Thanks for catching that typo - it was supposed to say one out of every 10 illegal immigrants is a felon.
My educated guess is either 4 or 5.
I agree that an intended number was left out either in the original report or in a transcription.
That may be true but many felonies occur after entering. Look at all the document fraud that was going on in Iowa. If Americans did that they could expect jail time but the most these “migrants” will get is a free trip back home, if even that))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))
I prefer the word “INSURGENTS” over “migrants”.
“In 2004, voters passed four illegal immigration measures with over 70% yes margins. “
And John McCain came out against it.
>>>>>>You may not like it and I may not like it, but just being in the country witout proper authorization IS NOT A FELONY.
True enough, but every re-entry after an adjudicated deportation proceeding (e.g., by the CIS/ICE immigration court) IS a felony.
When the state gets a voter ID law?
Same here, that's what they are as far as I'm concerned. I do find it amusing though the softer and less threatening terms like "undocumented immigrants" and "migrants" the liberal media likes to use.
IT damn sure should be!
Now you’ve gone and noodled out why she got elected in the first place...she’s worried now because they won’t be there next time to uh...vote.
Stop welfare & require capable to get jobs doing the picking
I agree. Especially since we face the very real threat of infiltration by sworn enemies.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.