Skip to comments.How Obama can woo low-income whites [Affirmative action for poor whites-even racists can be wooed]
Posted on 08/18/2008 6:04:49 PM PDT by SJackson
Barack Obama has a problem. He really, really doesn't want this campaign to be about race. He wants it to be about change, President Bush, the economy, gas prices, Iraq, Afghanistan -- almost anything else. But it is going to be about race, at least in part. That's the lesson of recent weeks, when the McCain campaign brought up race (on the pretext that Obama had brought it up first). Once the chum was in the water, the media sharks went wild.
Obama should take that as a warning. Race will be central to this campaign because McCain needs it to be. He simply doesn't have many other cards to play. And it will be central because every time Republicans light the match, the press will create a forest fire. Race is just too titillating to ignore.
The history of post-Vietnam presidential elections is littered with Democratic nominees who thought they could run on policy and ignore symbolism. This year, the symbolism will be largely racial. Obama can't avoid that. He needs to control the race debate instead.
Already, there is reason to believe that race is weighing Obama down. A survey this year by CBS and The New York Times found that 94 percent of respondents would vote for a black presidential candidate. But when asked if "most people" would, the number dropped to 71 percent. Notre Dame political scientist David Leege estimates that 17 to 19 percent of white Democrats and Democratic-leaning independents will resist voting for Obama because he is black. And it's a major reason that this election -- despite Obama's myriad advantages -- remains close.
To blow it open, Obama needs to bring Leege's number down. That may be possible, because even racists can be wooed. Think about it this way: Many of the voters who right now won't vote for Obama because he's black would probably vote for Colin Powell even though he's black. That's because they don't see Powell as a racial redistributionist, a guy who would favor his community at their expense. There's no rational reason to believe Obama would either. But that's what many racially hostile white voters assume.
For these voters, Obama can't make race go away by ignoring it. He needs to acknowledge their fears and do something dramatic to assuage them. Paradoxically, his best shot at deracializing the campaign is to explicitly make race an issue.
He can do that with a high-profile speech -- and maybe a TV ad -- calling for the replacement of race-based preferences with class-based ones. That would confront head-on white fears that an Obama administration would favor minorities at whites' expense. It would be a sharper way of making the point that Obama has made ever since he took the national stage (but which some whites still refuse to believe): that he represents not racial division but national unity.
On the merits, there's a lot to say for class-based affirmative action. Over the decades, racial preferences have played a vital role in creating a black middle class, but that middle class is now large and self-perpetuating. It is the poor -- whether urban and black or Appalachian and white -- who truly need a boost today. And that's what Obama himself seems to believe. Arguing that his own daughters shouldn't benefit from affirmative action, he told the Chronicle of Higher Education last year that "we should take into account white kids who have been disadvantaged and have grown up in poverty and shown themselves to have what it takes to succeed." Some of the parents of those white kids fear voting for Obama because they think they'll lose out. If they knew Obama's views, they might change their mind.
The defining American problem of the 21st century may not be the "color line," as W.E.B. Du Bois suggested about the 20th. In an age of growing multiculturalism and growing economic inequality, it may be the class line instead. By calling for a different kind of affirmative action, Obama could acknowledge that profound change -- and help propel himself to the White House.
BTW, this is an outstanding idea, best idea since McNamara's absurd Project 100,000.
I want to see Harvard populated by the dumbest, and Ameican Corporations run by known unachievers.
The authors job is safe.
Obama’s solution? give them robert downey jr makeovers, fake their birth certificates, and include them in for ‘reparations’. /s
I’m pretty sure that “low-income whites” are too busy clinging to their Bibles and guns to care about anything B. Hussein Obama has to say.
Yeah, cracker reparations! A winning issue if ever I heard one! Throw in a couple of free scratch-off tickets and it’s a sure thing.
His outlook on the human condition and individuality would sell better in India.
I can see it now...an Obama bumpersticker...”CASTE your vote for ‘O’ !”
Too bad the author didn't name one of those issue-based Democrats. I am too busy clinging to symbols that I can't think of one right now.
It’s a lie to say that Obama “really, really doesn’t want his campaign to be about race.” That is ALL he wants it to be!!
Easy, buy 'em. That's what this is all about, really. Remember when you heard someone say that when the people learn they can vote themselves largess from the treasury the Republic was finished?
What utter nonsense. At Saddleback McCain showed that experience indeed DOES matter without bringing up race once.
You go girl! Getcha some recreations!!! It’s the MAN holdin ya down baby!
The only person that ever held me down was.........myself..
He’d probably give them some of his supporters to lynch after the election if he thought he could get their votes.
One could take that several different ways...
Trying to be funny.... and failed...
lol I got a kick out of it!
You're ahead, STOP! :>)
That's the real problem, how do you figure out what caste you're in.
If I'm a doin OK white guy, do my kids get to be down and out if they work to put themselves through school?
And what about my put upon grandfather? Don't I get a bump up for him?
I'm speculating, but I doubt he has anything to base that on. If he did, he'd be on TV nonstop. And the pundits would have to stop whining about how people answer race oriented polls dishonestly.
But the press tells us that only Republicans can be racists, so how can this be?
Would the be the Meth Lab voting block?
Oh, for cryin’ out loud - he was using his race and his ‘funny name’ routine when he was campaigning downstate for the Illinois Senate in the 90’s. I’ve read more than one article from the 90’s on it (which is why I always go for the older articles first - they aren’t watered down).
I also read that it seemed to have worked for Illinois. The problem, as we all know, is that it’s not working for mainstream America.
Give me a break.
LMAO! So if you’re rather curvy, in a personal ad you could tag yourself as a BBWBWW! Or BBBWW! Or BWWBB!
Sometimes ya just gotta laugh...
Think about it this way: Many of the voters who right now won't vote for Obama because he's black would probably vote for Colin Powell even though he's black.
Doesn't that sort of prove the point that people are against Hussein Obama for reasons of policy, not race? How do liberals manage to get EVERYTHING BASSACWARDS??
And what about those Democrats that have tried to run on policy rather than 'symbolism'? First, symbols are important. Second, who are they to define what is policy and what is not? Third, even granting this statement, does it cross their minds that their policies might have been rejected by the voters? No, it doesn't
Nothing, that's exactly what it points to.
And what do you do about the fakers?
I knew a rich old Texan, who owned several banks, lots of cattle and big oil interests who would put on his dirtiest overalls and look as scruffy as possible when he went to the doctor, "Just so he don't overcharge me."
Yeah, cracker reparations! A winning issue if ever I heard one! Throw in a couple of free scratch-off tickets and its a sure thing.
You actually put your finger on it. People who say, “My life ain’t so good, I’ll take a chance...”
> And it’s a major reason that this election — despite Obama’s myriad advantages — remains close.
Why would an elitist Socialist “Citizen of the World” who never misses an opportunity to insert foot in mouth not be able to blow away his opponent?
Peter Beinart is considered by some conservatives (NR-Online)to be a fairly level-headed lib. Judging by the howlers in this article, he must be using heavy drugs. The brown acid? So according to this genius McCain will very shortly be making direct comments about Obama being multi-ethnic because really, what else can McCain do Obama is such a perfect candidate? Unbelievable.
A remake of the orginal movie staring barack mcgovern.