Skip to comments.General Jones shoots Israel
Posted on 12/06/2008 5:48:35 AM PST by danny1961
General James Jones, Obamas choice for National Security Adviser, again revealed his staggering ignorance. The general might be an authority in conventional warfare - though it is unlikely, given his mere few months battlefield experience in Vietnam. General Jones pushes his hallmark solution for the West Bank: IDF moves out and NATO troops move in. The proposal reveals Gen. Jones complete ignorance of anti-terrorist warfare.
IDF is the only army in the world which curbed terrorism: from near-war levels in 2000-2003 to near-absence today. The success is due to two factors: extremely exhaustive intelligence and freedom of operations. IDF runs tens of thousands of Arab agents, from taxi drivers to the Ramallah government figures who squeak on terrorist attempts in progress. Some work for money, others are blackmailed and threatened. IDFs Mishtarah Aravit, the Arab Police unit, do the things which make Guantanamo a kindergarten. No Palestinian, a commoner or official, is immune from Jewish teenagers in the Arab Police squad. That might not be nice, but Jewish bodies blown in terrorist acts were way worse.
Unlike IDF, NATO troops dont know the art of vast intelligence networks; they dont even have a reasonable number of Arab interpreters. There is no way NATO soldiers would hang a Palestinian official by his [not neck] to force information from him. They will not blackmail Palestinians in terrorist-ridden villages with eviction of their relatives from Israel. They wont risk their lives very night in inconspicuous, mostly unreported raids of bomb labs. Besides all the training and operational issues, NATO troops just have no incentive for such activities.
US troops, the best of NATOs, cannot curb terrorism in Iraq despite massive presence on the ground and serious collaboration by the Iraqis. Whatever calm was there for a few months is mostly attributable to Sadrs decision to calm down to allow the US an honorary withdrawal. There might have been an US-Iranian arrangement to curb Shiite terrorism in Iraq in return to the US limiting itself to worthless sanctions against Iran and opposing Israels strike. US troops failed in terrorist warfare in Lebanon, Somalia, Vietnam, and other places. There is no chance of them securing the West Bank against Palestinian terrorism.
NATO troops are no different from the UN peacekeepers who failed miserably in Sinai in 1967 and now in Lebanon. Under the UNIFIL nose, Hezbollah increased its rocket arsenals fourfold since 2006 ceasefire. UNIFILs Italian contingent concluded a separate ceasefire with Hezbollah which wont attack their installations while the peacekeepers turn a blind eye to weapons smuggling.
General Jones wants to sweeten the pill of forcing Israels withdrawal from the ancient Jewish lands of Judea and Samaria by the fake security offered by NATO troops. In 1956, Eisenhower lured Israel into withdrawal from Sinai by promising to keep the Tiran Straits open; when Egypt closed them in 1967, the only thing the US did was to push Israel to refrain from preemption. IDF learned the lesson and protest vociferously the NATO deployment.
Jewish ultra-leftist Martin Indyk, ignorant and arrogant as always, has a suggestion of his own: US nuclear guarantee to Israel. According to his plan, US will promise to nuke Iran if it nukes Israel. Thats quite a post-mortem comfort for the fried Jews. Iran lost millions of its people in the war with Iraq which is certainly less relevant to the mullahs than annihilation of the Zionist entity; the US reprisal is not a great threat, then. The reprisal is non-credible: if the US objects to mere attack on Irans nuclear facilities now, whats the probability of America nuking Irans population centers? Minus one hundred percent, to be exact. Indyks plan is another sweet pill for Israel: this one, to accept the American ban on attacking Iran. Incredibly, Jews believe that Indyk is pro-Israeli.
With friends like these ones, who needs enemies?
There’s no doubt in my mind that the new administration will turn its back on Israel at some point. By the time people wake up to that fact, it will be too late.
To make matters worse they will turn their back on America.
You gotta wonder...
Obama: Man of the World
By NICHOLAS D. KRISTOF
Published: March 6, 2007
Mr. Obama recalled the opening lines of the Arabic call to
prayer, reciting them with a first-rate accent. In a remark that
seemed delightfully uncalculated [...], Mr. Obama described the
call to prayer as "one of the prettiest sounds on Earth at
Send treats to the troops...
Great because you did it!
I think Iraq pretty well qualifies. The Brits in Malaysia and N. Ireland and the Filipinos, for that matter. Even the Euros beat the Red Brigades. Massive terrorism was destroyed in numerous S. American countries and is presently on its last legs in Colombia.
This notion that terrorism cannot be beaten is just not proven by the facts. That said, putting NATO in is perhaps the most idiotic idea for dealing with the ME ever presented. It presumes that all the two sides need is to be separated. In fact, one side is determined to destroy the other, which only wants to be left alone.
Terrorism would promptly be turned on the NATO "ocupiers," quite possibly in their home countries as well as in Palestine.
One could deduce, without a brain, that we have mental retards in office in DC with more on the way. Pray! God, help us all for we are doomed.
There’s a lot of these resume building, worthless “generals” around, usually backstabbers, ticket puncher (those that served know of what I speak) types. They just show up to get credit then it’s “been there, done that” and on to the next ribbon.
A kid that we know made his way through OCS got his butter bar, then 1st LT, showed up in Iraq for three months comes home with a BRONZE STAR. I was outraged and started writing officers and NCOs I know requesting the citation behind that decoration. Confirmed that he didn’t do a DAMNED thing to earn such an award, I was advised that it happens all too often with these little perfumed princes. John Kerry comes to mind—and others.
I could live with it better if they weren’t so dangerous, everyone treating them like they actually did something.
So, everyone who doesn’t support Israel’s interests over ours is the spawn of Mohammad.
US peacekeepers didn’t work out in Lebanon under Reagan, either. They are targets, and their hands are tied.
Rev. Wright preaches that today's real Jews are the Black man, women and children. Only they will inherit the Kingdom of God.
I dare any of you to watch You Tube. If you don't get sick, your not human.
After reading the bio of General Jones in Wikipedia, he seems like a very smart fellow with a sharp memory. During his active duty career he spent a long time in DC ... I wonder how the heck he got along with BHusseinO ...
“Theres a lot of these resume building, worthless generals around,”
True warriors are NEVER welcome in Washington as they
are treated like a pit bull..good when needed but too dangerous to their masters..
It is totally naive to believe that this is ignorance and not a shift in policy. Crisis is opportunity (Rahm Emanuel - 2008). Had Bush followed the Obama crisis model after 911, we would no longer have a congress or a Constitution. The new administration is about power and central control.
To achieve that, you have to scare the sheep into cooperation. Watch for a new crisis every time they want more of your freedom.
And now you know why they are retired. One nice thing about the service is that if you SCREW UP, you are gone. Period! Just ask our little metrosexual general who tried to start a war with Russia on an air strip.
That will never happen.
“US will promise to nuke Iran if it nukes Israel. “
add that Promise to the list: Promise to Kurds to uprise against Saddam 1991, promise to defend S Viet Nam circa 1975
the word of our government is worthless. And Israel knows it.
Ø is a disaster waiting to happen.
We have no intelligent people in power.
A refreshingly objective analysis. lol
June, 1968, to December, 1968?
Gadzooks! This clown has only two months... more combat experience than Office of the President-Elect nObama!
God help the former United States of America!
That's true! Just ask... any of us!
"In January 1967, Jones was commissioned a second lieutenant in the U.S. Marine Corps. Upon completion of The Basic School at Marine Corps Base Quantico, Virginia, in October 1967, he was ordered to the Republic of Vietnam, where he served as a platoon and company commander with Golf Company, 2nd Battalion, 3rd Marines. While overseas, he was promoted to first lieutenant in June 1968.
Returning to the United States in December 1968, Jones was assigned to Marine Corps Base Camp Pendleton, California, where he served as a company commander until May 1970."
October, 1967, to December, 1968?
Gadzooks! This clown has only 1 year, two months... more combat experience than Office of the President-Elect nObama!
God help the former United States of America!
Very scary stuff, Mr Robot!!
Be Ever Vigilant!!
Well, he certainly hasn’t spent any time on active duty since Vietnam, although he seems to have steadily climbed the career ladder.
One thing stood out for me, apart from his recent role in advising the Senate, which may have endeared him to Obama:
“Remaining in Washington, his next assignment was as the Marine Corps liaison officer to the United States Senate, where he served until July 1984. In this assignment, his first boss was John McCain, then a U.S. Navy captain. He was promoted to lieutenant colonel in September 1982.”
FYI: The number of terrorist attacks worldwide is WAY higher than what is reported in the image provided. Per the FBI; over 14,000 terrorist attacks took place in 2006 alone, resulting in more than 22,000 deaths, of which, approx. 28 of those deaths were Americans. The majority of the attacks were in Iraq and Afghanistan. Having said that, the rest of the world knows all too well, the pox that threatens their daily existence, otherwise known as terrorism. America, on the other hand, is fast asleep.
Correction to my post: I see that the subject figure in your post, only involves Islamic terrorist attacks. I reported a figure involving ALL known terrorism organizations and their attacks in my post. My mistake.
Enlightening post about how Israel keeps terrorist Muslims at bay. It’s hard work.
Not empty promises to nuke Iran if they hit Israel. No one can depend on such drek after Obama takes us out of Iraq prematurely
Careerists. Washington in general is full of them--look at the resumes of Obama's appointments--hardly an honest, real-life job anywhere in the combined histories of the lot of them. Why expect the high branches of the military tree to be any different.
Roger that Steamburg. I see you get it.
One of Reagans' few serious errors--putting "peacekeepers" in where there was no peace to keep. At least he learned from it and never tried it again, more than can be said for most of the rest of Washington.
Israel is a big aircraft carrier for the US in the middle east.
The only thing that has been proven to end or combat counter insurgency is intel and the judicious use of violence to combat support, funding and shelter of the guerillas.
The term is "developmentally disabled", and comparing the developmentally disabled to those in office in DC is an insult to the developmentally disabled.
Executive Order 10997: All electrical power, fuels, and all minerals well be seized by the federal government.
Executive Order 10998: All food resources, farms and farm equipment will be seized by the government. You will not be allowed to hoard food since this is regulated.
Executive Order 10999: All modes of transportation will go into government control. Any vehicle can be seized.
Executive Order 11000: All civilians can be used for work under federal supervision.
Executive Order 11490: Establishes presidential control over all US citizens, businesses, and churches in time of "emergency."
Executive Order 12919: Directs various Cabinet officials to be constantly ready to take over virtually all aspects of the US economy during a State of National Emergency at the direction of the president.
Executive Order 13010: Directs FEMA to take control over all government agencies in time of emergency. FEMA is under control of executive branch of the government.
Executive Order 12656: "ASSIGNMENT OF EMERGENCY PREPAREDNESS RESPONSIBILITIES", "A national emergency is any occurrence, including natural disaster, military attack, technological emergency, or other emergency that seriously degrades or seriously threatens the national security of the United States. Policy for national security emergency preparedness shall be established by the President." This order includes federal takeover of all local law enforcement agencies, wage and price controls, prohibits you from moving assets in or out of the United States, creates a draft, controls all travel in and out of the United States, and much more.
Send treats to the troops...
Great because you did it!
The U S State Departments’ website may be useful to your quest. The data is for the year 2006.
Send treats to the troops...
Great because you did it!
How about we get the U.S. GOVERNMENT out of the picture so Israel can do what she needs to for her own protection. The aid going to Israel from our FedGov could be made up in private contributions. Many, many Evangelical Christians would be PROUD to contribute and it would remove any “veto authority” now exercised by the president and the congress over how Israel protects her own borders as SHE deems necessary. Then we’d have no more of these absurd “peace plans” which only serve to DE-stabilize the whole area and make their proponents out to be the braying jackasses we all KNOW they are.
Then we don’t have to have snide comments like yours rolling about the internet.
No, June 1968 was when he was PROMOTED, not when he got in-country. THAT was October of 1967. You cut and pasted without READING??????
“So, everyone who doesnt support Israels interests over ours is the spawn of Mohammad.”
Sounds like you agree with Gen Jones, thinking that supporting the interests of the schmuckistinians over Israel’s benefits the U.S.
Why don’t you give us a list of the benefits we in America accrue from Israel as an ally vs what we could get from the “palies”.
Feel free to research medicine, technology, computer science...include the mig Israe handed over to us, our bases for weapons storage in Israel, their taking out Saddams’ nukes before the gulf war...
start anywhere you want...
But remember the IDF is the “gold standard” when it comes to how terrorism is to be fought. The other forces learned so much from them. Even now the IDF is training the Indian army in fighting against terror in light of the Mumbai attacks.
I'll buy that. Although they didn't enhance that reputation in their most recent bout with Hezbollah in Lebanon.
No, as my post #24 indicates, I cut & paste... while drinking heavily!
No. My point was simply that is someone appears to not make Israel’s security the most important thing in the world, they are attacked by those who appear to think Israel’s safety is more important that the US’s.
It’s about the DS reaction people - not the value of a particular position on a particular argument
This article & the blog it comes from is addressed primarily to an Israeli audience.
“My point was simply that is someone appears to not make Israels security the most important thing in the world,..”
Gen. Jones’ job should be to make AMERICA’S ALLY the most important thing in THAT REGION,..”
Instead he works to build up palie forces, and by advocating NATO troops as buffers (replacements!) tween the palies and the IDF, he REDUCES Israel’s security AND puts NATO troops (potentialy Americans) in jeopardy, with NO POTENTIAL GAIN FOR AMERICA OR ISRAEL.
If you have a fact or opinion otherwise please present it.
” they are attacked by those who appear to think Israels safety is more important that the USs.”
Poor attempt to slander American defenders of Israel. NO ONE here claimed “Israels safety is more important that the USs.” As a matter of fact, no one brought it up except YOU.
But lets be clear: do you think destroying Israel’s security interests will enhance America’s security interests?
In other words, you believe that *sskissing the babykilling, jihadi scum by handing them more weapons & territory will make them more likely to NOT attack the U.S.?
Please let us know of ANY instance where placating muslims does NOT push them to demand and fight for more...
From the article:
“US troops, the best of NATOs, cannot curb terrorism in Iraq despite massive presence on the ground and serious collaboration by the Iraqis. Whatever calm was there for a few months is mostly attributable to Sadrs decision to calm down to allow the US an honorary withdrawal.”
Huh author sounds just like Obama.
To quote Sgt Hulka: “Lighten up, Francis.”
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.