Mark Steyn: Windmills of Your Mindlessness [Flight 93 memorial]

NRO ^ | February 13, 2009 | Mark Steyn

[Tolik]

The "war on terror" went away with George W. Bush, but there's still a postscript here and there to be attended to. If you're one of the dwindling band of Americans interested in the Flight 93 memorial, this exchange with the presiding honchos of the "Circle of Embrace" (formerly the "Crescent of Embrace") makes for glum reading:

“In your depiction, who is breaking the circle?”

“The passengers and crew,” said [Memorial Project Manager] Reinbold.

“But the circle is a symbol of peace,” Rawls continued. “Who broke the peace? It was the TERRORISTS who broke the peace on 9/11.”

Reinbold countered that that the circle is also a Druid symbol, and a Christian symbol.

“But it is still a symbol of peace,” said Rawls, especially as the Memorial Project is using it, with the circle being broken on 9/11, “so who breaks it?”

“It was the passengers and crew,” [Deputy Superintendent] Newlin repeated, elaborating that: “They are the one’s who brought the plane down.”

“You don’t think it was the terrorists who broke the peace?” Rawls asked.

“They TRIED to break the peace,” said Newlin, “but they failed.”

“Really?” asked Rawls: “They failed to break the peace? What about the 40 murdered heroes?” But Reinbold and Newlin were done talking.

I've no idea whether the conversation is accurate in all its particulars: It seems perversely obtuse, even for the midwives of this wretched memorial. But let's not get into the weeds of what the "circle" means. To wind up chasing these guys through the circles in their circles and the wheels within their wheels is to lose sight of why "Let's roll!" wound up as a Crescent roll. There shouldn't be any limpid circle of effete hand-wringing in the first place. It's not what this thing was about. As James Lileks wrote here a couple of years back:

If 9/11 had really changed us, there’d be a 150-story building on the site of the World Trade Center today. It would have a classical memorial in the plaza with allegorical figures representing Sorrow and Resolve, and a fountain watched over by stern stone eagles. Instead there’s a pit, and arguments over the usual muted dolorous abstraction approved by the National Association of Grief Counselors. The Empire State Building took 18 months to build. During the Depression. We could do that again, but we don’t. And we don’t seem interested in asking why.

9/11 was Pearl Harbor and the Doolittle Raid on the same morning—Flight 93 serving as the latter. If the stone eagles aren't an option, I'd rather see Todd Beamer, Thomas Burnett, Jeremy Glick, Mark Bingham, and the other forgotten heroes of 93 in the pose from that Incredibles poster below with "LET'S ROLL!" chiseled in ka-powie Marvel Comics Jack Kirby lettering. Their story is one of action, not limp enfeebled passivity. Which says more about America today? What those guys did? Or how our culture chooses to memorialize them?

[Tolik]

mind boggling!

 This ping list is not author-specific for articles I'd like to share. Some for the perfect moral clarity, some for provocative thoughts; or simply interesting articles I'd hate to miss myself. (I don't have to agree with the author all 100% to feel the need to share an article.)

I will try not to abuse the ping list and not to annoy you too much, but on some days there is more of the good stuff that is worthy of attention.

You are welcome to browse the list of of truly exceptional articles I pinged to lately. Updated on February 10, 2009.  on  my page.
You are welcome in or out, just freepmail me (and note which PING list you are talking about).

Besides this one, I keep 2 separate PING lists for my favorite authors Victor Davis Hanson and Orson Scott Card.  

Moral Clarity BUMP !

[FlashBack]

Steyn is a great writer...always great as a pinch-hitter for Rush/Hannity too!!

[mojito]

So depressing.

What has happened to us?

[Congressman Billybob]

This limp-wristed approach to the Islamofascists will surely get more Americans killed. I spit on Americans who are this stupid and self-destructive. See below.

Congressman Billybob

Latest article, "Offending the Islamofascists"

The Declaration, the Constitution, parts of the Federalist, and America's Owner's Manual, here.

[Tolik]

Mark Steyn’s stuff is here!

[steve8714]

One of these guys has to be an architect or an artist.

[Tallguy]

Depressing... It’s hard not to think that America’s best days are behind her when you read stuff like this. And I agree with Steyn. If we were still ‘great’ the World Trade Center towers would have been rebuilt to their former glory by now. It’s not even on the radar screen.

[Red Boots]

Nobody should ever go there. Instead we should make our own memorial, nearby, in our own way, and everyone should go there. Set up a national shrine, or whatever occurs when people go there, that is completely outside the government. What do they have to do with it anyway ?

[chimera]

I'm with you and James Lileks on this one. Right after 9/11 happened and there was this seemingly endless wrangling over what to do with that site, I said the very best “memorial” would have been to rebuild what was there before, bigger and better. But we're going on 10 years after and all we have to show is a lousy hole in the ground, and a blizzard of paperwork going back and forth between lawyers, politicians, and bean counters. As soon as that site was cleared, the steelwork for new towers should have been going up. Instead, we've pissed it all away.

[Tolik]

Say what you want about Donald Trump, but if he got the bid, it would had been done long time ago.

[livius]

This is insane. Who is “Newlin,” anyway?

[livius]

Ah, Newlin is a Deputy Park Superintendent. He’s either dumb as a post or a Muslim convert.

[Arkady]

A few points:
Steyn and Lileks are awesome.
Add in the horrid memorial in AZ.
There are currently hundreds of replies to posts on this same page about stupid comments by janeane garofalo and some story about boomer navel-gazing but only a dozen on this one.
Shame on freepers.
That these memorials have been hijacked should be rallying points and something we can do something about. Build them back, build them right and at least give them the same amount of attention.
What, not as sexy as the umpteenth story about pregnant moms or arlen specter?

[kellynla]

BTTT

[the OlLine Rebel]

“Which says more about America today? What those guys did? Or how our culture chooses to memorialize them?”

Unfortunately, cynic that I am, the latter says more. We have to really have our chips down, and our face against the wall, before we really do anything of strength and courage anymore.

I REALLY have to visit Shanksville before they put this monstrosity in place. My aunt/uncle live only an hour from there and we visit sometimes. When we next go, we should go out to Shanksville before it’s ruined.

Thanks for the note. Didn’t know they’ve changed the name to try to hide some more - “circle”.

[the OlLine Rebel]

“Add in the horrid memorial in AZ.”

Huh???

[toothfairy86]

Does smearing it with bacon grease constitute vandalism? I live about an hour away from it. It may require a road trip in the near future.

[Dionysius]

Anybody got an architect’s drawing of this obamination?

[messierhunter]

“It was the passengers and crew,” [Deputy Superintendent] Newlin repeated, elaborating that: “They are the one’s who brought the plane down.”

Beyond insulting. I think this whole debate illuminates how corrupt and worthless our government is. Where was the government on 9/11? It was "We the People" who stood up on 9/11 to defend our nation, and today it is the government that pisses on their grave.

[Hildy]

We are weak...civilization is always held up by the fittest..survival of the fittest. The definition of fittest changes...at first it was “most physical”...then it was “highest intellectual”..and now it’s the “strongest-willed” And who exactly fits that description now? Not us. But you know who.

[Hildy]

Check this out: Michelle Malkin on AZ 9/11 Memorial

[the OlLine Rebel]

Maybe we can meet together there some day, when my family goes up to Cumberland for a vacation. Preferably this year!

[chimera]

Not a bad idea. It isn't always the most popular guy who ends up getting the job done.

This whole WTC rebuilding fiasco has shown just how weak-willed we've become as a people. If we'd been like this after the Pearl Harbor raid we might still be to this day "debating" the best way to rebuild that facility and take the fight to the enemy.

[popdonnelly]

Mr. Newlin is wrong. It was Ziad Jarrah, the hijacking pilot, who decided to bring the plane down in Pennsylvania, as evidenced by audiotapes.

[mick]

This makes me so sick I am at a lost to believe we have sunk so low that this artist is allowed to do this without being tarred and feathered.

Toynbee speaks about Challenge and Response. Civilizations grow greater or die according to it's responses to challenges.

I will tell you this, friend.....we will keep drinking from this bitter cup until we get so low that we will be sick of ourselves and our children begin hating us....then and only then, I predict, will America rise up and settle historical scores...and if we are to be truly healed it must start with the traitors of the sixties....you will know this nation is regaining it's health when obscenities like this memorial are destroyed by the government and traitors like Jane Fonda, if still alive, will be tried as a traitor, convicted, and hung, and the media applauds!

And if we never regain that strength of righteous hatred that we had after Pearl Harbor we will be finished and deserve it.

[neverdem]

Interesting times, indeed.

[knews_hound]

Thanks for the heads up Tolik.

Pinging the Mark Steyn Ping List.




On or off, please FReepmail me.

Cheers,

knewshound

knewshounds blog

[Moonman62]

Why don’t a bunch of people get together and make a human cross, and memorialize the occasion with some aerial photographs?

[netmilsmom]

I’m tired of being chastised.

You post once a month and now come here and say “Shame on freepers”.

First of all, it’s FReepers.
Second, you have no clue what we each have done.

I’m part of the Smackdown list, attempting to take down terrorist videos on YouTube,
I’m on the Digg list trying to get conservative values into the “New Media”
I’m Twittering and writting Congress critters. At this point, I don’t really care about the Shanksville Memorial. I have bigger things to think about than this crap. It won’t matter at all what you think when the Marxists take over and you chastise us for letting this happen?

What have YOU done?

[COUNTrecount]

Thanks!

[dennisw]

All I want to know is when is Mark going to sub for Rush again? He is a bit torrent seeder of wit and witticisms

[dennisw]

There is a tune that goes-— “Don’t doubt yourself babe”

[Arkady]

“I don’t really care about the Shanksville Memorial.”

33 replies and one flametard. Gee, I feel so rebutted and chastised. Thank you for taking time away from washing the dishes, single-handedly sealing the border and writing the constitution on the head of a pin.

[netmilsmom]

Go back to the DU, nimrod.

[netmilsmom]

>>There is a tune that goes-— “Don’t doubt yourself babe”<<

I’m sorry if I offended you. Seriously.
It’s just that I’ve seen tons of these “FReepers should be ashamed of not doing enough.” When it seems like we are the ONLY ones who are acting on the theft of our freedom and liberty.

How many of us are military or family of?
How many actually lost loved ones on 9/11?
How many have given time, sweat and tears to TRY to make the country better?

I’m weary of FReepers slamming FReepers, stating that we do nothing. We do a lot. The DC people are heroes and none of us deserve to be chastised for inaction.

Again, sorry.

[Victoria Delsoul]

Thanks for posting this.

Steyn is always right on target with his comments.

[Hetty_Fauxvert]

“Which says more about America today? What those guys did? Or how our culture chooses to memorialize them?”

There really are Two Americas today. There are what I think of as “real people” — the people who live more or less normally, raise their families, try to get or keep a reasonable job, love their country and their families passionately, and are ready to “roll” when that awful occasion presents itself...

And then there are the Chattering Classes. The ones who parse everything so much that there’s nothing left when they get through — no love, no resolve, no heroism. The Chattering Classes have corralled our media, they have captured our schools, they have a lock on what is considered “art” — and I guess they have a lock on what is an appropriate memorial, as well.

We must take our country back. Peacefully, quietly, but we must take it back.

[MaggieCarta]

This limp-wristed approach to the Islamofascists will surely get more Americans killed. I spit on Americans who are this stupid and self-destructive. See below.

I absolutely loved your line, It is right to call the Islamofascists "beardless cowards."

From the article: There shouldn't be any limpid circle of effete hand-wringing in the first place.

[MaggieCarta]

Thanks for the ping!

Steyn will be visiting Hillsdale College in March. If I attend his lecture, I'm afraid that he might have me arrested as some kind of slobbering stalker. No, really, I'm harmless...

[dennisw]

Don’t be sorry. I was complimenting you

[netmilsmom]

Thank you. Thank you so much!!!!

[Tolik]

The vast majority of people who voted for Obama fit you definition of “real people” — the people who live more or less normally, raise their families, try to get or keep a reasonable job, love their country and their families passionately, and are ready to “roll” when that awful occasion presents itself...