Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

SC rejects Muslim's plea to sport beard [in Catholic school], says no 'Talibanisation of India'
The Times of India ^ | 30 March, 2009 | The Times of India

Posted on 03/30/2009 12:08:35 PM PDT by MyTwoCopperCoins

NEW DELHI: Rejecting the plea of a Muslim student that he should be permitted to sport beard in his convent school, the Supreme Court on Monday observed secularism cannot be overstretched and that "Talibanisation" of the country cannot be permitted.

"We don't want to have Talibans in the country. Tommorow a girl student may come and say that she wants to wear a burqa, can we allow it?", Justice Markandeya Katju speaking for a bench headed by Justice Raveendran observed.

Asserting that he was a secularist to the core, Justice Katju however said religious beliefs cannot be overstretched.

"I am secularist. We should strike a balance between rights and personal beliefs. We cannot overstretch secularism," the judge known for his incisive remarks said.

Justice Katju passed the obsesrvation while dismsissing the petition of the student. Mohammad Salim of Nirmala Convent Higher Secondary School, a government-recognised minority institution in Madhya Pradesh, has sought quashing of the school regulation requiring students to be clean-shaven.

Challenging a Madhya Pradesh High Court verdict that had earlier dismissed his plea, Salim submitted that every citizen was entitled to follow his religious principles and that no one should restrain him from doing so in a secular country like India.

Salim's counsel Justice (retd) B A Khan argued before the bench that sporting beard was an indispensable part of Islam.

But Justice Katju was apparently not impressed with the argument and quipped "But you (Khan) don't sport a beard?" the judge asked the counsel.

The apex court then said that a minority institution has its own set of rules and rights provided by Article 30 of the Constitution and the same cannot be breached by any person.

"If there are rules you have to be. You can't say that I will not wear a uniform I will only a burqa," the bench observed.

The court further said if the student was not interested in following the rules then he has the option of joining some other institution.

"You can join some other institution if you do not want to observe the rules. But you can't ask the school to change the rules for you,"Justice Katju observed.

Appearing for the student, senior advocate B A Khan said that Article 25 of the Constitution guaranteed protection to Salim to pursue his religious practice of keeping a beard and the regulation providing for shaving it off was violative of this provision.

He said the act of the principal to force the student to leave the school for keeping a beard was against "his religious conscience, belief and custom of his family".

Pointing out that Sikh community members were allowed to keep a beard and sport a turban, Salim alleged there was a clear discrimination on part of the school to force him to be clean shaven and this rule was violative of his fundamental rights.


TOPICS: Culture/Society; News/Current Events
KEYWORDS: india; islam; sc; taliban

1 posted on 03/30/2009 12:08:36 PM PDT by MyTwoCopperCoins
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | View Replies]

To: MyTwoCopperCoins

He should move to America. Or France, or England, or almost anywhere in the West.


2 posted on 03/30/2009 12:10:49 PM PDT by swarthyguy ("We may be crazy in Pakistan, but not completely out of our minds," ISI Gen. Ahmed Shujaa Pasha)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: swarthyguy

The judge or the student? LOL!


3 posted on 03/30/2009 12:11:30 PM PDT by MyTwoCopperCoins (I don't have a license to kill; I have a learner's permit.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: MyTwoCopperCoins

The student! The judge would be ostracized.

I doubt any US or Western judge would rule like this Indian one.


4 posted on 03/30/2009 12:12:32 PM PDT by swarthyguy ("We may be crazy in Pakistan, but not completely out of our minds," ISI Gen. Ahmed Shujaa Pasha)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 3 | View Replies]

To: MyTwoCopperCoins
"You can join some other institution if you do not want to observe the rules. But you can't ask the school to change the rules for you,"Justice Katju observed.

Wow, what common sense! Maybe we should start outsourcing our judicial decisions to India, too!

5 posted on 03/30/2009 12:14:22 PM PDT by Albion Wilde ("Praise and worship" is my alternate lifestyle.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: swarthyguy

No thanks, the less Muslims here the better.


6 posted on 03/30/2009 2:30:41 PM PDT by Islaminaction
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 4 | View Replies]

To: MyTwoCopperCoins

A Muslin student in a CONVENT school wearing a beard? Can’t they just ask her to wear a vail?


7 posted on 03/30/2009 5:10:50 PM PDT by goldi
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: MyTwoCopperCoins

1. No one asks Sikhs to shave their beard, Not even the Indian Army that is the best example for uniformity and discipline. Why ?

Muslims are to be blamed first for not keeping their label. Including the lawyer who was questioned by Justice.

2. This is also an example for the injustice done to the Muslim community that has never been questioned.


8 posted on 03/31/2009 12:38:11 PM PDT by Selil Moideen (beard katju islam justice supreme court)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Selil Moideen

Because the institution, as the result of the fact that it is minority-run, has special laws that benefit it.

As for public positions, for example, the Navy, Muslims are allowed to keep their beard. A man won a case to do so, recently.

That said, if hate-literature laws are applied to the Quran, how would you feel when it’s banned as a result? Aren’t Muslims getting a free-pass on that?


9 posted on 03/31/2009 12:53:48 PM PDT by MyTwoCopperCoins (I don't have a license to kill; I have a learner's permit.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 8 | View Replies]

To: MyTwoCopperCoins
I think you are referring to Indian AirForce case where the Supreme Court ruled that IAF ban on beard for Muslims is justified and valid. So no beard in armed forces either. The only unit which is allowed to sport a beard is the Navy Marcos (Marine Commandos). This is because they are deployed in Kashmir and work mostly undercover. Sporting a beard helps them gel with the local polulation. I have heard a few units of Rashtriya Rifles (a counter terrorist paramilitary force manned mostly by Indian Army personnel) and Army's Para Commandos are also allowed to sport beards during their stints for counter terrorism duties in Kashmir.
10 posted on 04/04/2009 4:32:22 PM PDT by An_Indian
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 9 | View Replies]

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson