Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Jon Stewart: You know who was a war criminal ? Harry Truman
Hot Air ^ | April 29, 2009 | ALLAHPUNDIT

Posted on 04/29/2009 7:22:04 PM PDT by RobinMasters

Via Goldfarb, the key exchange comes at around 5:50. Hundreds of thousands of lives saved by averting a U.S. invasion of the Japanese home islands, and all this tool can do is point a finger and mumble “yes” in response to whether Truman’s a war criminal or not. Behold the face of mindless anti-torture absolutism. Like what you see?

(Excerpt) Read more at hotair.com ...


TOPICS: Foreign Affairs; News/Current Events
KEYWORDS: comedy; hiroshima; imperialjapan; jonstewart; truman; warcriminals; wwii
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-5051 next last

1 posted on 04/29/2009 7:22:04 PM PDT by RobinMasters
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | View Replies]

To: RobinMasters

2 posted on 04/29/2009 7:24:16 PM PDT by SandRat (Duty, Honor, Country! What else needs said?)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: RobinMasters

Just when you think he can’t get any more idiotic:

Hey Jon

Go take a memory walk thru Bataan or Dachau and get back with us.


3 posted on 04/29/2009 7:25:32 PM PDT by A_Former_Democrat
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: RobinMasters

Does Stewart, in his limitless wisdom, know what Japan’s Unit 731 did during the war?


4 posted on 04/29/2009 7:25:42 PM PDT by GOPGuide
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: SandRat

In any moment of decision, the best thing you can do is the right thing, the next best thing is the wrong thing, and the worst thing you can do is nothing.
Theodore Roosevelt

It behooves every man to remember that the work of the critic is of altogether secondary importance, and that, in the end, progress is accomplished by the man who does things.
Theodore Roosevelt


5 posted on 04/29/2009 7:25:52 PM PDT by Patrick1 (I'm not calling in sick; I'm calling in gone!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: RobinMasters

Sadly the current Socialist in office would agree.


6 posted on 04/29/2009 7:26:39 PM PDT by Dallas59 ("You know the one with the big ears? He might be yours, but he ain't my president.")
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: RobinMasters

Even one of my presumably liberal professors said Turman made the right decision. The Japanese were prepared to fight to the last man. An invasion would have cost millions of lives on both sides.


7 posted on 04/29/2009 7:26:56 PM PDT by SMCC1
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: RobinMasters

The only crime Truman committed was relieving MacArthur.


8 posted on 04/29/2009 7:28:25 PM PDT by dfwgator (1996 2006 2008 - Good Things Come in Threes)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: RobinMasters

I wonder if Stewart thinks FDR is war criminal material as well for OKing the firebombing of German cities? He’d squirm a bit on that one, I suspect.


9 posted on 04/29/2009 7:29:01 PM PDT by Mr. Mojo
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Patrick1

I’ve been hearing this same Lefty Lamentation about Truman since I entered College in 1967.


10 posted on 04/29/2009 7:29:20 PM PDT by SandRat (Duty, Honor, Country! What else needs said?)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 5 | View Replies]

To: RobinMasters
The Rape of Nanking


11 posted on 04/29/2009 7:29:27 PM PDT by GOPGuide
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: GOPGuide

Just in case the mental midget googles himself after the show...

http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-backroom/1521072/posts
Unit 731 - Research and Bump List. Gets Disturbing, Read at Your Own Risk


12 posted on 04/29/2009 7:29:43 PM PDT by Calpernia (DefendOurFreedoms.Org)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 4 | View Replies]

To: GOPGuide

Just in case the mental midget googles himself after the show....

http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-backroom/1521072/posts
Unit 731 - Research and Bump List. Gets Disturbing, Read at Your Own Risk


13 posted on 04/29/2009 7:30:28 PM PDT by Calpernia (DefendOurFreedoms.Org)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 4 | View Replies]

To: RobinMasters

I don’t have the stomach to watch. I suppose his audience cheered?


14 posted on 04/29/2009 7:31:04 PM PDT by Roscoe Karns
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: RobinMasters

Other than an end to slavery, nazism, fascism and communism and the preservation of our liberty, war has never produced anything of value.


15 posted on 04/29/2009 7:33:17 PM PDT by muir_redwoods ( O.B.A.M.A. = One Big Asinine Mistake, America)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: SMCC1

More proof that the effete fools on the left value their moral purity more than the lives of million of their countrymen. What a staggering level of conceit.


16 posted on 04/29/2009 7:34:56 PM PDT by Old North State
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 7 | View Replies]

Well this is a complicated topic as Japan had surrendered before the bombs were dropped.


17 posted on 04/29/2009 7:40:24 PM PDT by Republic_of_Secession.
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: RobinMasters
Did Jon say that “we can hold our heads high” in regards to taking a so-called moral ground? Considering what Islamic extremists do to Christian and Jewish captors perhaps that was a poor choice of words. Besides, what nation has ever won a war by taking the high moral ground and not by killing as many of the enemy as possible. The insane stupidity of liberals is mind boggling.
18 posted on 04/29/2009 7:46:18 PM PDT by EAGLE7 (They make take our lives but they'll never take our freedom!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Republic_of_Secession.

They did? I thought they refused to surrender even after the first bomb.


19 posted on 04/29/2009 7:47:46 PM PDT by Borges
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 17 | View Replies]

To: Republic_of_Secession.
Well this is a complicated topic as Japan had surrendered before the bombs were dropped.

They offered a conditional surrender and were refused. They didn't accept unconditional surrender until after the bomb on Nagasaki. They may have or may not have been prepared to accept a conditional surrender or, just as likely, wanted to fish for additional concessions.

20 posted on 04/29/2009 7:48:58 PM PDT by luvbach1 (Worse than we could have imagined.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 17 | View Replies]

To: RobinMasters

I despise this bastard and anyone that admires him.

LLS


21 posted on 04/29/2009 7:49:42 PM PDT by LibLieSlayer (hussein will NEVER be my President... NEVER!!!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: muir_redwoods
Other than an end to slavery, nazism, fascism and communism and the preservation of our liberty, war has never produced anything of value.

Unless maybe you consider the revolutionary war which produced the USA.

22 posted on 04/29/2009 7:50:26 PM PDT by Bullish ( Reality is the best cure for delusion.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 15 | View Replies]

To: SMCC1

And don’t forget that the Japs slaughtered 100,000 Filipinos in early 1945 as they were leaving the Phlippines. The moronic Stewart probably knows nothing about the Manila Massacre.


23 posted on 04/29/2009 7:50:37 PM PDT by texasmountainman (Who is John Galt?)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 7 | View Replies]

To: Mr. Mojo
I wonder if Stewart thinks FDR is war criminal material as well for OKing the firebombing of German cities?

Almost as many people died at Dresden as died from both nukes in Japan. But the left will never admit that.

24 posted on 04/29/2009 7:51:02 PM PDT by buccaneer81 (Bob Taft has soiled the family name for the next century.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 9 | View Replies]

To: Borges

I believe it could be said that they were “seeking terms”, but our policy was of course, “unconditional surrender”, and this is what they balked at even in the face of annihilation.


25 posted on 04/29/2009 7:52:42 PM PDT by dr_lew
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 19 | View Replies]

To: RobinMasters
And UK and France are the aggressor nations for starting WW2 (Because they declared war on Germany but Germany had not attacked the UK and France, only Poland)....
26 posted on 04/29/2009 7:52:49 PM PDT by tophat9000 ( We are "O" so f---ed)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Bullish

umm, it was meant as sarcasm. Pretty obvious sarcasm at that.


27 posted on 04/29/2009 7:55:02 PM PDT by muir_redwoods ( O.B.A.M.A. = One Big Asinine Mistake, America)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 22 | View Replies]

To: texasmountainman

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manila_Massacre


28 posted on 04/29/2009 7:56:02 PM PDT by packrat35 (You could make a fortune as a politician if you have the moral standards of a convicted pedophile)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 23 | View Replies]

To: RobinMasters

What channel is your show on John?
Ohh thats right, Comedy Central.


29 posted on 04/29/2009 7:57:48 PM PDT by Proud_USA_Republican (Trust unto God and He shall direct your path)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Old North State
More proof that the effete fools on the left value their moral purity more than the lives of million of their countrymen. What a staggering level of conceit.

You got it. And also a staggering level of hypocrisy, considering most of these same people heartily approved of using whatever interrogation methods were necessary when emotions were running high in the months following 9/11/01. But after a few years of pathological Bush/Cheney-hatred nothing else mattered but punishing them. ....even if it meant compromising our national security.

I guarantee you that if a terrorist org ever succeeded in taking out any one of their favorite government Rat nannies these same hypocrites on the left would be calling for methods to be used on the terrorists in question that make waterboarding appear like a pleasure cruise by comparison.

30 posted on 04/29/2009 7:57:58 PM PDT by Mr. Mojo
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 16 | View Replies]

To: tophat9000

Yeah, let’s gloss over Dr. Veesenmayer’s setting up of puppet regimes in other countries for take over.


31 posted on 04/29/2009 7:59:43 PM PDT by Calpernia (DefendOurFreedoms.Org)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 26 | View Replies]

To: RobinMasters
I think Stewart needs to figure out what kind of bloodbath it would have been if there had been an Allied invasion of Japan. The comination of American and British Commonwealth forces invading first Kyushu and then the Kanto Plain of Honshu would have have easily cost Americans over one million casualties from the dug-in, very fanatical defenders (analysis of the Kyushu defenses after the war showed the Allied landing during Operation Olympic would have suffered huge numbers of casualties).

By the way, one wonders what would the Soviets have done if World War II had continued after August 1945. Would they have tried to invade Hokkaido from Sakhalin Island, and eventually invade the Tohoku region of Honshu?

32 posted on 04/29/2009 7:59:45 PM PDT by RayChuang88 (FairTax: America's economic cure)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: texasmountainman

It does not matter whether Stewart and liberals like him are aware of all the atrocities committed by the Japanese, communists or whoever. They argue that for us to inflict harm on them would make us no better than them. He showed that liberals are prepared to sacrifice American lives on the altar of their moral beliefs. It’s as if these liberals are stuck in moral adolescence, recalling the admonishment of their parents regarding the local bully that to strike ‘Johnny’ back after he hits you makes you no better than him. Liberalism is indeed a mental disorder.


33 posted on 04/29/2009 8:00:08 PM PDT by EAGLE7 (They make take our lives but they'll never take our freedom!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 23 | View Replies]

To: muir_redwoods

Yeah, I know. So what?

Maybe you didn’t see the sarcasm in my reply?


34 posted on 04/29/2009 8:00:25 PM PDT by Bullish ( Reality is the best cure for delusion.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 27 | View Replies]

To: RobinMasters

Stewart is a moron. If Truman could have ended the war by dropping two bombs, or three bombs, or no bombs, he should have done what was necessary.


35 posted on 04/29/2009 8:01:23 PM PDT by popdonnelly (The greatest crimes in history have been perpetrated by governments. You've been warned.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: buccaneer81
The Left also ignores the firebombings of Tokyo, which killed over 100,000. And I believe the reason for that is that if they admit that the Tokyo bombings were war crimes, they'd have to then admit the same about Dresden and Hamburg. ...which of course were during their hero FDR's time. And criticism of FDR is verboten under any circumstances.

(For the record, I personally don't think any of the above acts of war were war crimes).

36 posted on 04/29/2009 8:09:10 PM PDT by Mr. Mojo
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 24 | View Replies]

To: Mr. Mojo
(For the record, I personally don't think any of the above acts of war were war crimes).

Correct. They were justified.

37 posted on 04/29/2009 8:12:50 PM PDT by buccaneer81 (Bob Taft has soiled the family name for the next century.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 36 | View Replies]

To: Mr. Mojo
I wonder if Stewart thinks FDR is (a) war criminal

Was FDR a war criminal by liberal logic? ...

Well FDR died April 12, 1945...but one month before under FDR...

THE FIREBOMBING Of Japan ..Start March 9 1945

On March 9, 334 B-29s took off from Guam, arriving in Japan under good weather conditions. The planes were stacked up from 4,900 ft. to 9,200 ft. They dropped one 500 pound cluster of fire bombs every 50 feet. The target area was 3 by 5 miles, containing a large industrial complex, however each square mile held over 100,000 civilians. The bombs fell, and within thirty minutes the resulting fires were out of control, driven by 40 mph winds. Tokyo, hit by strings of incendiaries, became a holocaust. Water boiled in the canals after the temperature reached over 1800 degrees F. For three hour the B-29s kept coming. Only a few fighters appeared causing little damage. We lost 14 planes with damage to 42. An official Japanese count reported nearly 84,000 killed, 41,000 injured, and over 250,000 buildings destroyed in this one raid. 16 square miles burned out. The Japanese called the raid "Slaughter bombing". LeMay was driving his crews to exhaustion, as he launched four more raids in the next eight days against Osaka, Kobe, and twice on Nagoya. In only five raids the B-29s wiped out 32 square miles in four major cities. The population of Tokyo dropped to half as panic stricken civilians fled. Washington was finally satisfied that fire bombing was the answer to crushing the Japanese , and sent LeMay a list of 33 additional Industrial targets, and gave the resupply of incendiaries to XXI Bomber Command the highest priority.

The bombing of Kobe was a little different. Napalm bombs were in short supply so 2,355 tons of magnesium thermite bombs were used. The thermite bombs burned with an intensity of 2300 degrees F. Three square miles were incinerated and substantial damage was done to the aircraft plant, dock area, and the Kawasaki shipyards which built submarines. The morale of the Japanese people hit bottom as industries were wiped out, and city populations dropped.

http://b-29s-over-korea.com/firebombing/firebombing3.html

38 posted on 04/29/2009 8:14:20 PM PDT by tophat9000 ( We are "O" so f---ed)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 9 | View Replies]

To: RobinMasters

A lot of good people gave their lives so that oxygen wasters like this can procreate. A whole generation of them breeding and producing even more ignorant offspring.


39 posted on 04/29/2009 8:16:29 PM PDT by ChildOfThe60s (If you can remember the 60s........you weren't really there)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: A_Former_Democrat

Many who spent time in a Japanese concentration camp, after hearing about the atomic bombs, complained: “Why only two?”


40 posted on 04/29/2009 8:16:40 PM PDT by 353FMG
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 3 | View Replies]

To: 353FMG

Those bombs in the end, saved a hell of a lot more Japanese lives than American lives.

And we were lucky that Hirohito wasn’t offed by Tojo and Crew, or else we probably would have had to drop a few more on them.


41 posted on 04/29/2009 8:17:57 PM PDT by dfwgator (1996 2006 2008 - Good Things Come in Threes)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 40 | View Replies]

To: RobinMasters
Ignorance of history is no excuse for being a dumb-ass.
42 posted on 04/29/2009 8:18:40 PM PDT by MaxMax (America's population is 304-Million. Obama must punish America for the other 4.7 Billion)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: RobinMasters
When you think about John's position it is the epitome of selfishness and a blinding narcissism. He is willing to let other die as long as it helps him feel good about himself. Thomas Sowell in his book Vision of the Anointed dealt with this Liberal pathology quite well. It is as if they never had to grow up.
43 posted on 04/29/2009 8:19:22 PM PDT by kimoajax (Rack'em & Stack'em)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Republic_of_Secession.

The Japs did not surrender before the nuke. Is that you John?


44 posted on 04/29/2009 8:21:27 PM PDT by MaxMax (America's population is 304-Million. Obama must punish America for the other 4.7 Billion)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 17 | View Replies]

To: RobinMasters

Save for later watching. It’s bedtime for the old folks.


45 posted on 04/29/2009 8:22:25 PM PDT by ChildOfThe60s (If you can remember the 60s........you weren't really there)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: popdonnelly

J. Stewart is just another f lib. JAFL. Truman was an artillary officer in WWI. Roosevelt was not in the military. The libs hate those that fight for this country. Fits the template.


46 posted on 04/29/2009 8:24:26 PM PDT by Texas resident (Older but smarter)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 35 | View Replies]

To: RobinMasters

This is just disgusting. Proof that the left is pro-fascist. Sick......


47 posted on 04/29/2009 8:34:00 PM PDT by PoliticalEthics
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: RobinMasters
Jon Stewart is trying to do Dennis Miller..
BUT hes way not smart enough..

Its like Stewart Smalley(SNL) trying to do Professor Irwin Cory..

48 posted on 04/29/2009 8:35:11 PM PDT by hosepipe (This propaganda has been edited to include some fully orbed hyperbole....)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: tophat9000

I wrote this in response to a paleconservative’s article reflecting on the death of General Paul Tibbets.

A Counter Reflection on General Tibbet’s Death and the A Bomb

I read Chris Check’s reflections on the death of BG Paul Tibbets with great interest. Most historians believe that Tibbet’s role in the atom bombing of Hiroshima was the precipitate cause of the conclusion of the greatest man made disaster in all of human history since the fall, the Second World War. Mr. Check expresses reservations as to the necessity of this action, indeed whether or not the theory, practice and technology of modern warfare allows any war to be prosecuted in accordance with just war theory. Mr. Check does not seem to fall into the camp of those historical revisionists who make suspect claims of an imminent Japanese surrender which negated the rationale for using the A-Bomb. Instead he offers a pointed criticism of the fact that the Bomb was even employed and a concomitant reappraisal of Gen. Tibbet’s role on that historic mission.

The vital works of the great philosophers Cicero, Aristotle, Augustine of Hippo, St. Thomas Aqinas, or Hugo Grotious attempted to codify the requirements for just war. These men spoke to the notion that any war, or acts performed pursuant to it, must conform to certain principles which would allow the waging of war within a synthesis of classical Greco-Roman, as well as Christian, values. Just war theory can be meaningfully divided into three parts, which in the literature are referred to, for the sake of convenience, in Latin. These parts are: 1) jus ad bellum, which concerns the justice of resorting to war in the first place; 2) jus in bello, which concerns the justice of conduct within war, after it has begun; and 3) jus post bellum, which concerns the justice of peace agreements and the termination phase of war. I wish to examine Mr. Check’s premise concerning Gen Tibbets and the Hiroshima A Bomb. in light of all three of these just war considerations.
1. Jus ad bellum: The US was negotiating in good faith with Japanese diplomatic envoys for a peaceful resolution to the crisis occasioned by the Japanese occupation of French Indohina and FDR’s subsequent oil embargo right up to the moment Japanese naval aircraft bombed Pearl Harbor. This despite US expectations of an imminent attack by Japan on the US sphere of influence, most notably the Phillipines. The deaths and wounding of almost 3600 Americans, and the destruction of 6 battleships, 3 destroyers, 3 cruisers, hundreds of aircraft and port facilities amply satisfied the justification for a recognition of the state of war existing between the US and Japan. President Roosevelt’s ringing speech to Congress requesting a declaration of war promised that the US would “win through to inevitable triumph, so help us God.” Germany’s declaration of war on the US followed three days later. There is little doubt that the Jus ad bellum consideration was met.
2. Jus in bello: This aspect of the just war principle is the most problematic for those such as myself who defend the use of the A Bomb. It is an inherently monstrous act to use a weapon of the indiscriminate nature of the Hiroshima A Bomb on a target peopled largely by civillians, thereby violating the subsidiary rules of discrimination, porportionality, and minimum force. But we are not about to revert to conducting war with serried ranks of Phalanxes drawn up against each other with no civillians in sight. No side will yield the percieved advantage of technology. “End justifies the means” arguments are also singularly unpersuasive to me. Notwithstanding that we can acknowledge, for instance that a discussion of the abortion evil should allow for the admitttedly rare “physical life of the mother” exception. Commensurately an argument can be made for the unique qualities of the Second World War as an exception to the discrimination and minimum force rule if not the porportionality argument. Any study of this issue must include context. That context was total war against an unrelenting foe whose national character and policies contributed to a racially tinged (on both sides) struggle of the utmost savagery. The slaughter and barbarity of the Pacific war was enhanced by the Japanese refusal to contemplate the shameful reality of surrender no matter how hopeless the situation, and their near total disregard for the accepted conventions of legal conduct in war. I think that I can show that a greater evil would have been done by allowing the continuation of that war rather than to shock the Japanese people into an abrupt surrender by the use of nuclear weapons.
The invasion of Japan was in the offing. At the Potsdam Conference of 24 July 1945, the Allied position was that the ‘Japanese forces would be disarmed’ Japanese sovereignty would be limited to the four main islands of Japan ‘and such minor islands as we shall determine’ and ‘respect for fundamental human rights’ would be established. The message ended with this: ‘We call upon the Government of Japan to proclaim now the unconditional surrender of all the Japanese armed forces, and to provide proper and adequate assurances of their good faith in such action. The aternative for Japan is complete and utter destruction.’
The implementation of these publically stated objectives required the complete defeat of Japan and it’s occupation. The militarists controlling Japan were determined to resist even unto the destruction of Japan. Prime Minister Suzuki Kantaro was willing to negotiate peace thru Switzerland or the Soviet Union, but War Minister Anami Korechika and the Chiefs of Staff Gen. Umeza Yoshijiro and Adm Toyoda Soemu insisted on ‘ prosecuting the war to the bitter end in order to uphold our national essence, protect the imperial land and (incredibly) achieve our goals of conquest’. The Japanese correctly deduced the objectives of Operation Downfall, the proposed US invasion scheme which was divided into two phases, Olympic, the invasion of Kyushu and Coronet, the invasion of the main island of Honshu. Accordingly the Japanese prepared Operation Decision (Ketsu-Go) which envisaged the deployment of over 2 million troops along the coast to repel Allied landings, to be reinforced by four million armed forces civillian employees and a civillian militia of old people, school children of both sexes numbering 28 million. An invasion of Japan would have been D-day magnified a thousand times, it would have been Stalingrad from the sea. For instance, The 2nd Marine Division was slated to be in the initial assault. It no longer appears in the plans for Operation Olympic after D-Day + 4. The assumption is that it would have ceased to exist or be combat ineffective. Other units are similarly omitted.
An actual model exists for such speculation, the Battle for Okinowa. Pre invasion Okinowa was populated by 574,368 Okinowans.. Take a trip to Okinawa and visit Peace Prayer Park. It’s easy to find. It is right next to the Suicide Cliffs just down the road a ways from the Japanese Naval Underground Headquarters. There you will see the names of 200,656 men women and children inscribed on black marble slabs who died on that island in the last battle of World War II. Those slabs reveal the following death toll: Japanese 188,136
From other prefectures (soldiers and civilian employees) 65,908
From Okinawa (soldiers and civilian employees) 28,228
From Okinawa (civilians fighting in battles) 56,861
From Okinawa (non-fighting civilians) 37,139
Americans 12,520
Following the battle there was not one thing on the island growing or man-made that was over 24 inches high. The entire population of the island was 574,368 and there were 4.72 artillery shells fired per person during the battle. The land war on Okinawa was soul destroying brutal as American soldiers and Marines doggedly attempted to break the ferocious Japanese resistance. Names like Sugar Loaf and Kakazu Ridge still invoke nightmarish memories from Okinawa veterans. The US Navy suffered the worst pounding in its history, with over 5000 sailors killed and 35 ships sunk by Kamikaze attack.
People extrapolate from 48,000 American and 230,000 Japanese casualties at Okinawa to 500,000 American and millions of Japanese casualties for mainland invasions. Those estimates could have vastly understated the actual causalities. Japan’s 374,000 mountainous square miles mathematically enables over 500 defensive redoubts comparable to General Ushijima’s formidable Okinawa constructions such as those on the Shuri line that inflicted most Okinawa losses. The War Faction adopted the motto of “100 million Japanese deaths” for planning final mainland battles. Besides kamikazes, redeployed Kwantung divisions, and bamboo spears for civilians, the allies faced biological warfare. Occupation searchers uncovered large stockpiles of viruses, spirochetes, and fungus spores throughout rural Japan. One delivery plan directed Japanese to infect themselves and then surrender. The “Greatest Generation” and their parents would have been enraged to discover a political cabal who satisfied their moral orthodoxy by condemning over 500,000 Americans who might otherwise have been saved.
Hiroshima was a target with military value. It was headquarters for the 2nd Japanese Army, charged with the defense of the southern island of Kyushu, the objective of Operation Olympic, whom the United States would have been fighting had the invasion commenced. It also had numerous factories producing military goods. The city was a communications center, a storage point, and an assembly area for troops. Both Command & Control and military production facilities are legitimate military targets.
Other consequences of other than a rapid end to the war were the slow starvation of the Japanese people. Their island nation’s food supplying merchant fleet was at the bottom of the Pacific, with 5 million tons of it put there by the extraordinarily successful American submarine campaign. In the summer of 1945 Field Marshal Terauchi had openly ordered prison camp commanders to slaughter the Allied prisoners in their control (who were dying at a 33% death rate) at the onset of the invasion. The brutal Japanese occupations of the conquered Asian nations were killing tens of thousands of civilians a month in China, Malaysia, Burma, Singapore, the Solomons, Thailand, and anywhere that the Greater East Asia Co-Prosperity Sphere sent its soldiers, inflamed by the Japanese militarist’s corrupted code of Bushido to rape, pillage and kill without mercy. Millions of Asian civilians were killed and others in China served as guinea pigs for Unit 731’s depraved medical experimentations into human vivisection, disease infestation and other atrocities more horrifying than the vilest of Josef Mengele’s worst inspirations. Japanese scientists performed tests on prisoners centering on the plague, cholera, smallpox, botulism and other diseases. This research led to the development of the defoliation bacilli bomb and the flea bomb used to spread the bubonic plague. Some of these bombs were designed with ceramic (porcelain) shells, an idea proposed by Shiro Ishii in 1938.
These bombs enabled Japanese soldiers to launch biological attacks, infecting agriculture, reservoirs, wells and other areas with anthrax, plague-carrying fleas, typhoid, dysentery, cholera and other deadly pathogens.
Additionally, infected food supplies and clothing were dropped by planes into areas of China not occupied by Japanese forces. These activities continued until war’s end.

The Japanese had concocted a plan to launch M6A1 Seiran floatplane bombers from their huge I-400 class subs to drop bombs loaded with biological agents such as plaque and Anthrax on the West Coast of the US. The ships had sailed with a target date of 15 August 1945. Only the end of the war on 14 August occasioned their recall before they reached landfall.
In the afternoon of August 14, Japanese radio announced that an Imperial Proclamation was soon to be made, accepting the terms of unconditional surrender drawn up at the Potsdam Conference. That proclamation had already been recorded by the emperor. The news did not go over well, as more than 1,000 Japanese soldiers stormed the Imperial Palace in an attempt to find the proclamation and prevent its being transmitted to the Allies. Soldiers still loyal to Emperor Hirohito repulsed the attackers.
That evening, General Anami, the member of the War Council most adamant against surrender, committed suicide. His reason: to atone for the Japanese army’s defeat, and to be spared having to hear his emperor speak the words of surrender.

Foreign minister Shidehara wrote, “If we continue to fight back bravely, even if hundreds of thousands of noncombatants are killed... there would be room to produce a more favorable international situation for Japan.”

“Due to the nationwide food shortage... - it will be necessary to kill all of the infirm old people, the very young, and the sick.

Admiral Onishi: “If we are prepared to sacrifice 20 million Japanese lives in kamikaze effort, victory will be ours.”

“With luck, we will repulse the invaders before they land.” - General Yoshijiro Umezu

“Who can be 100% sure of defeat?” - War minister General Anami

All said in the August 9th meeting of the 6 man ‘Supreme Council for the Direction of the War’ held in Tokyo. I would ask that you carefully consider the date as you ponder the Japanese willingness to surrender.
Another item for your consideration: The bomb also stopped Soviet expansion in Asia. The U.S.S.R. declared war on Japan on August 8 and if the war had continued the U.S.S.R. would have invaded and occupied large parts of northern China and northern Japan. The U.S.S.R would have had a presence in the Far East as in Eastern Europe.
As it was, the Soviets occupied North Korea and set up a Stalinist regime that troubles the world to this day. Imagine the Soviets with a Stalinist puppet government in Northern Japan. You don’t have to wonder, you have the examples of East Germany, or North Korea, as opposed to West Germany and South Korea.
This certainly cannot be attributed to the foresight of the Allies, as the Soviets entered the war against Japan in response to the Allies importuning Stalin at Yalta. It was about the only commitment he kept, since he saw an opportunity for territorial aggrandizement. But it is an admittedly unforeseen and fortunate subsidiary result of the rapid end of the war.
The world was spared the future horror of nuclear combat thru the instructive example of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Had the wartime use of nuclear weapons remained theoretical, rather than concretely manifest in the vaporized victims of World War II, it is far more likely that they would have been used in super power showdowns at the Berlin Wall or the Cuban Missile Crisis. The example of the relative firecrackers of the WWII A-bombs may have stayed the fingers on the thermonuclear button. The planners of the Manhattan Project did not consider this , but it is something worthy of our consideration.

The exceptionally brutal nature of the war against Japan requires that the jus en bello aspect of just war theory be considered in light of the extraordinary evils that were stopped or prevented by a sudden end to the war, bought about by the A Bomb. The Japanese could view it as a force of nature against which they were helpless to resist, and therefore serve as a legitimate rationale for surrender for a people that viewed that as an absolute disgrace. At the very least, the proportionality rule seems to be honored by using a horrendous method for the purpose of forcing an end to the war and stopping even greater continued slaughter and atrocity.
3, Jus post bello: Despite the unremitting nature of the total war against Japan and the unparallelled level of atrocities committed by Japan, it was not transformed into a post Punic Wars Carthage. The US extended it’s protections to her against the Soviet Union, demilitarized her, helped it to create a classically liberal representative democracy, with the emperor Hirohito demoted from demigod status. The US was instrumental in elevating Japan into a rehabilitated and respected player on the world stage, a leader in technological innovation and manufacture and a reliable ally against Soviet expansion in the Pacific. Even though considerable US self interest was involved, the US occupation of Japan was conducted with a magnanimity uncharacteristic of the likely aftermath of one of the most savage conflicts in human history. Even though the Japanese surrendered unconditionally, utterly defeated; they are a better world partner for the effect of the generous American peace terms and post war assistance. The Jus post bello criteria was more that adequately satisfied by the exemplary American post war treatment of Japan.
Finally, a word about Gen Tibbets. Before his service in the Pacific, Gen. Tibbets served with the 97th Bomb Group of the 8th Air Force. The 97th BG served as the model for the famous movie Twelve O’ Clock High. Tibbets, as a Major left in charge of the Group, was even depicted in the movie. Armstrong, the new CO of the 97th, appointed Tibbets his XO. He flew a B-17 bomber on 25 combat missions in the most deadly environment that American airmen have ever flown in, the flak and fighter filled skies of the European Theatre of Operations. He later took command of the 509th Composite Bomb Group, the B-29 outfit charged to deliver the atomic bombs. He bought the unit to a peak of efficiency and operational security, vital to maintaining the secrecy of the most important military technological development of the war. He stayed in the Air Force, and participated in the development of the B-47, our first all-jet bomber. In the early 1950’s, he flew B-47’s for three years. He advised on the making of the movie “Above and Beyond,” and was pleased that the famous actor, Robert Taylor, played him. From the 1950’s through the 1960’s he had a number of overseas assignments, including France and India. After his retirement from the Air Force, he became president of Executive Jet Aviation in Columbus, Ohio. For this he has earned the eternal respect and gratitude of his nation. He has not chosen to engage in post modern self flagellation and wear the hair shirt of eternal regret for doing his duty as it was presented to him. He has chosen to accept as his legacy the war ended and the lives saved by his actions rather than fixating on the awful human cost of the bombing. He had earned that right a hundred times over. He has said that he does not want a marker on his grave lest it serve as a focal point for demonstrators. That is the only thing that I disagree with him about. He deserves the honor of a proper memorial so that it may be rendered honors on appropriate occasions. Godspeed to you sir. You served your country and the world well.


49 posted on 04/30/2009 8:21:16 PM PDT by DMZFrank
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 38 | View Replies]

“War is cruelty and you can’t refine it.”
William Tecumseh Sherman


50 posted on 04/30/2009 8:26:04 PM PDT by donaldo
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 49 | View Replies]


Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-5051 next last

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson