Skip to comments.Obama Abruptly Sacks Bio-ethics Panel Critical of Embryonic Stem-Cell Research
Posted on 06/23/2009 4:21:10 PM PDT by topher
Tuesday June 23, 2009
Obama Abruptly Sacks Bio-ethics Panel Critical of Embryonic Stem-Cell Research
By Peter J. Smith
WASHINGTON, D.C., June 23, 2009 (LifeSiteNews.com) – The White House has dismissed the members of the President’s US Council on Bioethics just a few months before their mandate expires, indicating their services are no longer required by the President and that he is looking for a more “practical” advisory board.
The New York Times reported that Reid Cherlin, a White House press officer, told the paper that President Barack Obama saw them as "a philosophically leaning advisory group" designed by the previous Bush administration, and he wanted to appoint a new bioethics commission which instead "offers practical policy options."
Dr. Alta Charo, an ethicist at the University of Wisconsin, told the Times that a new bioethics commission should form an ethically defensible public policy for the government instead of being what she said “seemed more like a public debating society.”
The presidential council’s mandate was set to expire in September. The group still had one last meeting and some reports to finish, including one on organ markets, before they were abruptly dissolved with one day’s notice.
The move has prompted speculation that the advisory committee’s public dissent from the President’s executive order to fund new lines of embryonic stem-cells and begin cloning human embryos for scientific research may have precipitated their dismissal.
Earlier in March, 10 out of 18 members of the council had issued a public letter to President Obama expressing their dismay, calling the decision to devote taxpayer dollars to such embryo-destroying research “a step backward,” because it did not respect the moral and ethical reservations that still exist among the American public.
Obama’s executive order overturned restrictions put in place by the Bush Administration, and instructed the National Institute of Health to develop new guidelines and put them in place by July 7.
Dr. David Prentice, a Senior Fellow for Life Sciences at the Family Research Council noted in an article on the FRC blog that Obama likely dismissed them before the expiration of their work since, “It would be embarrassing to have another round of criticism from an existing ‘President’s Council.’”
President Bush had created the President's Council on Bioethics in November 2001 as an advisory board on bio-ethical issues after he decided to allow federal funding for human embryonic stem-cell research, but limited the research to 21 stem-cell lines already in existence. That council replaced an earlier advisory bioethics committee to President Clinton, which had expired by then.
"We have to ask why the President has disbanded this effective and well-regarded council,” protested Daniel McConchie, Vice President of Government Affairs for the Americans United for Life (AUL). “Is this a move toward a council that is more of a rubber stamp of his administration's priorities, rather than a group that actively debates current issues with all perspectives having a seat at the table?"
Dr. Peter Lawler, a member of the terminated bio-ethics council, states that President Bush had convened a council not for the sake of giving his policies an imprimatur, but had given them “the additional mandate of public education, of developing a national dialogue on controversial bioethical issues.”
“The truth is that the Kass Council was full of experts who disagreed on what the science says about who we are,” writes Dr. Peter Lawler, a member of the disbanded council, in a reflection written for the Weekly Standard.
Lawler points out that the council’s experts, such as Robert George of Princeton, leading neuroscientist Michael Gazzaniga, Francis Fukuyama, all had profoundly differing views on the status of human embryos.
“I want to emphasize that this was a scientific dispute on the moral implications of what the studies show conducted at the highest level,” wrote Lawler. “Socratic dialogue illuminated the disagreement and allowed those involved to remain friends in common pursuit of the truth, but no expert consensus emerged.
“No Council member was ideological in the sense of having anything but the highest respect for and full openness to what we can learn from science. And if expert means being a genuine scientific authority, they were all clearly among our nation's most formidable experts,” he said.
“There's no substitute, in a democracy, for thinking together about who we are before deciding what to do, and it's not ‘anti-science’ to sometimes conclude that science alone doesn't resolve every dilemma we face about human freedom and dignity.”
A view of the reports by the US Bioethics Council and previous commissions can be obtained here
Copyright © LifeSiteNews.com. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-No Derivatives License. You may republish this article or portions of it without request provided the content is not altered and it is clearly attributed to "LifeSiteNews.com". Any website publishing of complete or large portions of original LifeSiteNews articles MUST additionally include a live link to www.LifeSiteNews.com. The link is not required for excerpts. Republishing of articles on LifeSiteNews.com from other sources as noted is subject to the conditions of those sources.
Sort of like some former IG's...
Obama, is, of course, fully within the conrol of “The Lord of the Flies” ~ witness his quite extraordinary action the other day to snatch a fly out of the air and instantly dispatch it to wherever flies go.
Uhbama's vision for our nation, the change he talks about, is not change at all, it has been done throughout history in other nations and FAILED.
Uhbama and rahm cannot learn from history because they are in love with Soros money (I am not kidding-Soros is a man who would destroy our nation, he wants to, in fact.) and in love with their own ideas of a liberal utopia.
They are like mean little schoolground bullys who never grew up to look at the horrific, spirit crunching impact of their filthy big government agenda. Their mantra " we won". Sick bunch of American haters.
It is impossible for any man or woman of substance to respect these mini-tyrants.
Since the FBI is investigating Walpin-gate, I wonder if that means that a new FBI chief will be announced suddenly...
“the Presidents executive order to fund new lines of embryonic stem-cells and begin cloning human embryos”
“Presidents executive order” “cloning human embryos”
Awww...what’s the matter with Zero? Is he afraid he won’t have a world of “little B.Husseins” running around?
He’s an a$$-O!
Obama negatively regards the council as “a philosophically leaning advisory group”.
Yet, questions of ethics, whether “bio-ethics” or otherwise, are, by their nature, questions of a “philosophical” nature (as in values and value judgments) more than a “practical” nature ( as opposed to: is it possible?).
Science untethered to ethics has no place in a moral society, and particularly not science that involves human life directly.
Yet again, G.W. Bush’s stem-cell policy results reflected a less politicized scientific research result than Obama’s, because the actual science of stem cells has demonstrated that embryonic stem cells are unnecessary for releasing the full medical potential of stem cells.
Obama seeks to ignore the actual, current and ongoing science of stem cells and pretend, in total untruthfulness, that stem cell research is standing still and unable to reach its potential without embryonic stem cells. He simply wants to be sure that another category of potential election campaign donors are not left out of his government handouts.
The brother of White House Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel, Dr. Ezekiel J. Emanuel, a noted bioethicist, is advising the Obama administration on health care reform.
Dr. Emanuel is the Chair of the Department of Bioethics at The Clinical Center of the National Institutes of Health and a breast oncologist.
Dissent will not be tolerated!
The “hits” just keep on coming!
I am the Messiah - you shall have no gods before me. And I say destroying babies isn’t immoral.
Reid Cherlin, a White House press officer, told the paper that President Barack Obama saw them as "a philosophically leaning advisory group" designed by the previous Bush administration, and he wanted to appoint a new bioethics commission which instead "offers practical policy options."
bump & a ping
How convenient. The cronism and corruption is staring everyone in the face, yet the media says nothing. Zip..Zero..Nada.
Kill kill kill kill kill kill the innocent, reward the killers, and then fire anybody who objects.
Tyranny, plain and simple.
LOL. But the pantywaisted poof said that he would have a team of rivals. Yes Men were not allowed!
Her Stalin is gonna use Gitmo as his gulag. That’s why he wants it emptied now. He plans to fill it with dissenters, oh sorry, rightwing extremists.