Skip to comments.For troops, Afghanistan 'like Vietnam without napalm'
Posted on 10/04/2009 6:22:22 PM PDT by Saije
The men of Bravo Company have a bitter description for the irrigated swath of land along the Arghandab River where 10 members of their battalion have been killed and 30 have been wounded since the beginning of August.
Like Vietnam without the napalm, said Spc. Nicholas Gojekian, 21, of Katy, Texas.
A prime agricultural area of vineyards and pomegranate orchards, the 18 miles of valley that the 1st Battalion, 17th Infantry Regiment patrols includes Taliban insurgents, booby traps and buried explosives...
...So far, the Army mission has been an uneasy mix of trying to woo elders with offers of generators, roads and other improvements while fighting a nasty war with an often-unseen enemy.
Bravo Company arrived in Afghanistan with 24 Strykers, the first of the eight-wheeled combat vehicles outfitted with high-tech communications and surveillance gear to arrive in Afghanistan. One-third of the vehicles are now out of service due to bomb attacks or maintenance.
The bomb threats are so pervasive that Stryker drivers have abandoned some stretches of road in favor of driving through the deserts on different routes. The road to one smaller outpost has so many homemade bombs that the soldiers usually arrive on foot, a treacherous hike due to buried land mines.
We have had enemy contact almost every day, said Lt. Col. Jon Neumann, the commander of the 1st Battalion, 17th Infantry Regiment. Until we do clearing, we cant hold or build here right now, a reference to the U.S. counterinsurgency tactic of clear, hold and build.
Neumann said that a host of factors has bolstered the Taliban in the Arghandab. They include a successful spring insurgency campaign, the death of a strong tribal leader who supported the U.S.-backed Afghan government, and the wounding of a charismatic police chief.
(Excerpt) Read more at seattletimes.nwsource.com ...
Maybe a little ‘Death from Above’ would get the ‘elders’ attention? Why do I get the feeling that that entire COUNTRY is in on this, and will just be milking our resources and the blood of our kids from here on out?
Sorry to be cynical, but this is not going well, and the Poser in Chief hasn’t a clue; nor does he really care!
There is a muzzie in the white hut working for the saudis. Their orders are to humiliate our military and to lose. Hussein’s rules of engagement means our boys are sitting ducks. This is how LBJ ran vietnam but he was not viet cong as someone is a muslim.
I usually don’t agree with you on things because you can be QUITE the curmudgeon, but on this point, you are spot on.
Don’t let it go to your head. ;)
I listen to what the Marine Generals here in San Diego say, not the left wing media sucking the uneducated in with their anti war propaganda.
The left wing media did the same thing with Vietman,
the war was lost not on the battle field but in the livingrooms of America with dolts believing the anti war Left.
I believe you’re right!
The Chinese were reputed to have executed entire villages of Vietnamese over these kinds of things (i.e. assisting or not informing on Vietnamese militia who mounted ambushes against the Chinese invaders), during their 1979 invasion of Vietnam.
Never elect the village 'organizer' to do a man's job AND NEXT TIME GOP ... PUT SOMEONE who has "got a pair" on the ticket and that DOES INCLUDE AN ALASKAN!
First you have to execute the journalists ... then you can get to the ville ...
“Why do I get the feeling that that entire COUNTRY is in on this”
because it is......chump America has built Iraq into a decently modern country as far as infrastructure and industry.....now the afghani’s want theirs.
We don’t need to build nations with the blood of our son’s. What we needed to do was kill bin laden for attacking our country. What we needed to do in Iraq was get the damned oil.We aren’t doing either!!! Get the hell OUT!!!
See? I knew I was right! :)
Is it just me, or does anyone else want to just close the borders and be totally self-sufficient and stop playing ‘watchdog’ for the rest of the world?
We have all the oil and natural gas and fresh water we’ll ever need! We can grow just about any food crop to sustain ourselves (I can live without bananas and a few spices) and aside from a few uneducated doofuses (doofi?) we have very talented people that can build homes and schools and roads and water works, etc. And we could trade with Mexico and Canada for drugs and lumber, LOL!
Why do we NEED the rest of the world? Truth is, we don’t. Screw this Global Economy stuff and the billions we waste on wars. I’ll gladly sacrifce a decade of my life (it wouldn’t take that long) while we re-set our sights to make us a free and independent Nation once again. :)
"Afghanistan's deadly hold on Bravo Company 'Like Vietnam without napalm' "
did not match the source you linked and had to be changed. In order to reduce the number of duplicate threads we have to pull, we ask that everyone use published titles only. Please do not alter any published title nor make up your own version of a published title.
After using Free Republic's search function to verify that a published article has not already been posted, just copy and paste the title found above the article you wish to post. Thanks.
Obama has yet to publish a National Security Strategy as required by Goldwater/Nichols. The US Military is rudderless all over, not just in Afghanistan.
Hopefully (Marine) Judge Carter is also listening. Our troops are being pawned and set up to lose for the glory of allah.
In Vietnam I was with a 155mm self-propelled Howitzer battery. Because of break-downs, we rarely had more than three guns ready. Always waiting for parts. We were hit at our base camp once and fired flechette rounds at the tree line. We sure could have used the three Howitzers that were out of action..
My sentiments exactly. If this effin sob president of ours isn’t going to commit to winning, then we need to get the hell out. It will be a catastrophic mistake to leave for many, many reasons, but I don’t want another of our sons to die for Obama’s sport.
This is by design. He and his bosses in Riyahd know what they are doing.
Let’s finish what we set out to do. That is destroy terrorists in their strongholds and prevent their ability to operate.
“I listen to what the Marine Generals here in San Diego say...”
I wouldn’t recommend paying too much attention to GOs. Particularly ones in the USA.
I’d forgotten that until today reading Zinni’s statements about it- it’s due 150 days after the new administration takes over. By my count we’re somewhere around 250 days.
I’d say this makes Obama the DIC.
(Ditherer in Chief)
Right. This is one world government obama crap. Bring the men home and put the Mexican border and do huge tax cuts and get the engines of economy going before we fade into third world nothingness. NATIONALISM NOW~!@!!!
No need to go any further. Obama and his ilk are welcoming the illegal border crossers with all kinds of perks. He's too much of a coward to defend OUR OWN borders..
Oh, America..what have you done??
The Marines in San Diego have been through many many tours
and the Gen. I speak of is returning in a few months with 10,000 returning Marines based in San Diego to Afghanistan.
Understood. Thank you.
I am curious if he will ever, or can ever, present his National Security Strategy for the US.
We are waiting.
tHIS Link tells you the latest ROEs from Gen. Stanley McCrackhead saying basically that you can’t use CAS against any dwellings where there could be civys, you can’t even enter a home without
Afghan troops going in first and you can’t even shoot at a mosque.
This General is aiding the enemy, plain and simple.
Its bad enough that Obambots are allowing the enemy to hide in Pakistan and Iran, but to worry about alienating the civilians of Afghanistan? Against who? THe Taliban, the same Taliban who cuts of the hands and heads of the civilians if they violate the slightest precept of Sharia Law.
Hey General! Why don’t you go on the Political Offensive and tell the Afghan Civilians that we don’t cut off heads, we educate woman, we free them from Taliban Terror and so forth!
What the heck, its a waste anyway if you don’t get Islam out of the mix. Islam and Freedom don’t coexist. By making mosques sanctuaries you are legitimizing this religion of hate.
Of course Gen. McKook was appointed by B.H. obambi.
chump America has built Iraq into a decently modern country as far as infrastructure and industry.....now the afghanis want theirs
Not much of a deterrent to harboring terrorist is it.
They harbor our enemies. We go in with a million Rules of Engagement so that the only folks getting killed are American, we pay for it in Billions and Blood, We take no Land, we build up their Country all the while being called Infidels then we let them kick US out.
I agree. To cut and run now would be a massive victory for Al Queda, and a huge recruiting booster for them. We need to push through. Take the gloves off.
I don't there were any journalists hanging around in Vietnam at the time. The Chinese would simply have killed them and vaporized the remains. The accounts come from discoveries of mass graves and narratives from survivors who escaped the dragnet. Stuff like this always gets out. The difference is that the Chinese weren't fazed by the accounts - their reaction was denial, and the average Chinese probably thinks the enemy civilian body was too low...
I don't really agree. Iraq was already a decently modern country before we got there. We just got them out from under a despotic regime. Afghanistan will never be even remotely modern. I've never seen anything to suggest that they even want it. But it doesn't matter, all we need to care about is clearing it of muslim fanatics. If it takes another year or ten years, or fifty, as long as our ROE is appropriate. THAT is our only problem. Bad ROE. Gotta fix that.
The insurgency has a “surge” and WE don’t??? Recipe for disaster...Order those damn burkas for Katie Couric, Hillary Clinton and Barbara Streisand NOW!!! The Taliban is coming to America and you better get used to it now.
If it takes another year or ten years, or fifty, as long as our ROE is appropriate. THAT is our only problem.
Time is not on our side. Pakistan has nukes now, in ten years, how many more will have them? Lets keep that in mind. 40,000 more troops going into combat handcuffed is not acceptable. Unless obambi somehow gets out of power or the Congress turns back into GOP control, get out.
More bombs less bullets. Especially Nuclear Bombs. Use ‘em before they use ‘em on US.