Skip to comments.Pelosiís archbishop slams her rationale for supporting abortion
Posted on 01/13/2010 4:05:52 PM PST by NYer
.- Archbishop George Niederauer responded today to Rep. Nancy Pelosis (D-Calif.) recent comments that she has some concerns about the Church's position respecting a woman's right to choose. Justifying her decision to support abortion by citing her free will is entirely incompatible with Catholic teaching, the archbishop insisted.
Speaker of the House, Nancy Pelosi told Newsweeks Eleanor Clift in a December 21, 2009 interview that she disagrees with the Church on certain issues but considers herself a practicing Catholic.
I have some concerns about the church's position respecting a woman's right to choose. I have some concerns about the church's position on gay rights. I am a practicing Catholic, although they're probably not too happy about that. But it is my faith. I feel what I was raised to believe is consistent with what I profess, and that is that we are all endowed with a free will and a responsibility to answer for our actions. And that women should have that opportunity to exercise their free will, Pelosi said.
Archbishop Niederauer countered in his January 13 column, Embodied in that statement are some fundamental misconceptions about Catholic teaching on human freedom. God gave human beings the capacity to choose between good and evil in order to give them the gift of freedom, even at the cost of many evil choices, the archbishop said.
But this gift of freedom, the freedom wrongly cited in justifying a womans right to choose, among other fallacies, does not justify the position that all moral choices are good if they are free, insisted Archbishop Niederauer, because the exercise of freedom does not imply a right to say or do everything.
Addressing those who advocate for reproductive choice while claiming to be Catholic, Archbishop Niederauer emphasized, it is entirely incompatible with Catholic teaching to conclude that our freedom of will justifies choices that are radically contrary to the Gospelracism, infidelity, abortion, theft. Freedom of will is the capacity to act with moral responsibility; it is not the ability to determine arbitrarily what constitutes moral right.
The belief in the validity of arbitrarily determining right and wrong is widespread both in and outside of the Church, the archbishop noted.
Touching on the meaning of one's conscience, the San Francisco archbishop described it as the judgment of reason whereby the human person, guided by Gods grace, recognizes the moral quality of a concrete act. In all we say and do, we are obliged to follow faithfully what we know to be just and right.
As participants in the life of the civil community, Archbishop Niederauer wrote, we Catholic citizens try to follow our consciences, guided, as described above, by reason and the grace of God. While we deeply respect the freedom of our fellow citizens, we nevertheless are profoundly convinced that free will cannot be cited as justification for society to allow moral choices that strike at the most fundamental rights of others. Such a choice is abortion, which constitutes the taking of innocent human life, and cannot be justified by any Catholic notion of freedom.
Please freepmail me if you want on/off this list
“Speaker of the House, Nancy Pelosi told Newsweeks Eleanor Clift in a December 21, 2009 interview that she disagrees with the Church on certain issues but considers herself a practicing Catholic.”
Yeah? Well, she needs all the “practice” she can get. LOL!
Niederauer - 1
Pelosi - 0
“...she disagrees with the Church on certain issues but considers herself a practicing Catholic.”
That’s a pretty neat trick.
Kind of like I believe that Jesus Christ was just a smart philosopher, but I’m a christian.
No Nancy, you are not the arbiter of Truth.
Tertullian, The Soul 27,3 208 A.D.
“We acknowledge, therefore, that life begins with conception, because we contend that the soul begins at conception. Life begins when the soul begins.”
Tertullian, Apology 9, 197 A.D.
“...murder being once for all forbidden, we may not destroy even the foetus in the womb, while as yet the human being derives blood from other parts of the body for its sustenance. To hinder a birth is merely a speedier man- killing; nor does it matter whether you take away a life that is born, or destroy one that is coming to the birth. That is a man which is going to be one; you have the fruit already in its seed.”
St. Hippolytus of Rome, Philosophoumena, or Refutation of all Heresies, 222 A.D.
“...for this reason women who were reputed to be believers began to take
drugs to render themselves sterile, and to bind themselves tightly so as to
expel what was being conceived, since they would not, on account of
relatives and excessive wealth, want to have a child by a slave or by any
insignificant person. See, then, into what great impiety that lawless one
has proceeded, by teaching adultery and murder at the same time.” 9:12
St. Basil, the Great, First Canonical Letter to Amphilochius, 374 A.D.
“A woman who has deliberately destroyed a fetus must pay the penalty for murder.” 188:1
“Those also who give drugs causing abortions are murderers themselves,
as well as those who receive the poison which kills the fetus.” 188:8
St. Augustine of Hippo, Enchiridion of Faith, Hope, and Love, 23,86, 421 A.D.
“...though I know not whether man can find an answer: when it is that a
human being in the womb begins to live, and whether there is also a
certain kind of hidden life there which is not yet apparent in the movements
of the living being. It seems very rash to deny that those fetuses ever lived,
that are cut away and ejected limb by limb from the wombs of the pregnant,
lest the mothers perish too, if the fetuses be left there dead.”
Religious belief aside, this is an instance of an educated, thoughtful, and very literate man arguing with an idiot. Adding theologoca, elements here, Pelosi, by her position as Speaker and by her clearly irresponsible beliefs of Catholic doctrine is now in the position of leading Catholics and others into Mortal Sin. Excommunication may be the least of her problems.
I didn’t know this was possible. How can she say she is a practicing Catholic if she voluntarily left the church?
Pelosi argues: I believe people have free will; therefore any law that limits freedom to abort is contrary to the Church’s teaching on free will.
Pelosi picked up that particular bit of idiocy from Catholics for a Free Choice. She’s too stupid to realize that it’s an argument against the existence of ANY law.
Does she define herself, then, as a "protestant"?
She disagrees with the Church; she has not left it. Her bishop has met privately with her on several occasions, with no success. He has now adopted a more public forum for admonishing her. I doubt it will have any effect on her.
“Pelosi argues: I believe people have free will; therefore any law that limits freedom to abort is contrary to the Churchs teaching on free will.”
This makes no more sense than to say:
I believe people have free will; therefore any law that limits freedom to commit adultery is contrary to the Churchs teaching on free will.
I believe people have free will; therefore any law that limits freedom to steal is contrary to the Churchs teaching on free will.
I believe people have free will; therefore any law that limits freedom to be racist is contrary to the Churchs teaching on free will.
So Nancy disagrees with God but still considers herself a practicing Catholic? Free will means we have the choice to obey the Commandments or to disobey the Commandments. She is using her free will to allow the murder of the unborn. That is her choice. Nancy Pelosi is profoundly immoral and malevolent. I pray that she repents.
We'll amen, Mr. Archbishop!
Liberals have the most screwed up way of thinking, no matter what their religion.
Note - I am looking for a break down of members of both houses and their professed religion. I'm not Catholic and I know that not every baby killer in congress is Catholic, I want to see which ones profess my religion.
Pelosi is causing grave public scandal by her grave public sin.
Archbishop George Niederauer is causing grave public scandal by refusing to enforce Canon 915. His sin is more grave than hers.
Yet, she has no problem with a law that compels you to buy insurance or go to jail.
By lying -- something she seems to be quite good at.
She may be a 'practicing' Catholic, but she's a practiced liar.
Glad to see her bishop blasting her.
Mandated Abortion Coverage Threatens Health Care Reform, U.S. Bishops Official Says
Alveda King: Reid's Racial Insensitivity Exceeded by Disregard for Unborn
U.S. bishops reactivate nationwide campaign against federal abortion funding
Battle Over Abortion Funding in Congress Pits Catholics Against Each Other
New Catholic mandate on comatose patients
The US Catholic Bishops and Health Care Reform: A Failure of Imagination
US Bishops' Biggest Hope: Life-Affirming Care for All
Abortion Debate Shows the Catholic Bishops' Growing Influence
The Catholic case against health-care reform
Pro-Life Leaders Launch Opposition to Senate Health Bill Following Nelson Amendment Demise
With pro-life amendment's defeat, US bishops urgently call for changes in Senate health bill
More Proof that the US Catholic Bishops are Leading the Charge in Abortion Battle
Bishops Urge Senators to Support [Abortion]Amendment on Health Care; Urge Constituents to Back It
Bishops urged to be tough on pols who would pay for abortion
Health reform still full of thorny problems for Catholics (Vasa comes out for subsidiarity)
How the Stupak-Pitts Amendment May Change Our Politics
Health Care and the Power of the Bishops' Conference
US Bishops: Abortion Isn't Health Care
Denver Archbishop Chaput says promises were broken on abortion
Catholic Bishops: Health Care Bill ... Money-Laundering System for Funding Abortion
Catholic Caucus: The Bishops Go On Offense
US bishops conference mounts late drive against 'unacceptable' health-care reform
Catholic Bishops Urge Members to Oppose Abortion Funding in Health Care Plan [Catholic Uprising!]
Bishops Announce Unprecedented Massive Catholic Opposition to Obamacare
Bishops Call for Massive Catholic Opposition to Abortion in Current Health Care Reform
Archbishop Charles Chaput on the Current Struggle Between Catholics and "Caesar"
The Bishop's Ax Falls on Obama. And on the Vatican Curia (bombshell article)
US Bishops: Heath Package Still Funding Abortions (Urge Congress to Keep Working)
Catholic Bishops Declare They Will Vigorously Oppose Health Care Bill as It Now Stands
Bishops Restate Vow vs. Obamacare's Abortion
Important: US Bishops taking the gloves off on health care reform
BREAKING: Catholic Bishops On Health Care - Change Bills Or Else
U.S. bishops warn of vigorous opposition if Congress fails to fix health care bills
List: *41* Bishops against Obamacare (and counting!)
Bishop Murphy Issues Video Statement on Health Care Reform [Diocese of Rockville Centre]
Health Care Principles [Bishop Samuel Aquila, Fargo, ND]
Florida Bishop [Thomas Wenski] Weighs in on Health Care Reform
ObamaCare and Catholic social teaching [Bishop Neckless]
Some Catholic bishops question gov't health care
Bostons Roman Catholic Cardinal Says He Confronted Obama about Abortion in Health Care Plan....
Iowa Bishop: Dont Be Railroaded into the Current...Health Care Proposals
in a message issued by the Diocese of Sioux City (The Church on Universal Healthcare)
Nazi Health Care A Catholic Bishop Speaks Out Against "End of Life Care" (Germany, 1941)
Bishop Nickless: "No Health Care Reform is Better than the Wrong Health Care Reform"
Cardinal Rigali, Abp. Chaput Intensify Warnings Against Obamacare's Abortion Expansion
Perhaps she needs to watch this DVD. “This is my Body” is a powerful pro-life DVD and the song was written by Dana. Beautiful. Makes me cry every time I watch it.
EWTN runs it regularly and it is for sale on their website.
“Pelosi is causing grave public scandal by her grave public sin.
Archbishop George Niederauer is causing grave public scandal by refusing to enforce Canon 915. His sin is more grave than hers.”
Yup. In an attempt to never use any discipline in favour of being pastoral they fail to teach. Many under-edjumcated Catholics look at how bishops react to pols who dig baby butchery and come to the conclusion that it might upset some bishops occasionaly, but it really isn’t too big a deal. After all the the pols can still claim they are practicing Catholics.
That is exactly the message these bishops send when they refuse to enforce Canon 915. Therefore, their sin is even more grave than that of the recalcitrant politicians.
Just like our precious Kathleen Sebelius. Says she’s a Cathlic but supports baby killers. The man who took out George Tiller is being told he can use a defense that might get him a lighter sentence. We shall see. I’m sure the trial will be a huge circus. Can’t wait until it’s over.
Free will carries with it intrinsically the choice to choose sin.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.