Posted on 01/20/2010 2:34:03 AM PST by goldstategop
President Obama doesnt know it yet, but Scott Brown did him a huge favor. If, as expected, he becomes the next senator from Massachusetts; and if, as expected, his election dooms the Pelosi-Reid health-care-reform bill, Obama will have an opportunity to lay the entire fiasco at the feet of that troublesome Democratic duo. If hes smart, hell take it.
Supporters of the Pelosi-Reid legislation argue that Democrats must forge ahead and do whatever it takes to pass a bill. As The New Republics Jonathan Chait put it, Abandoning health care reform after theyve already paid whatever political cost that comes from voting for it in both houses would be suicide.
Maybe this holds true for members of Congress in purple districts who voted the wrong way. But not for Obama. Obama is up for election not in 2010, but in 2012. He has three years to distance himself from this debacle, and he will have more freedom of movement if he cuts his ties now and denies conservatives the large red target the Pelosi-Reid bill has become.
Why? Because the Pelosi-Reid health-care reform is objectively bad law. Mandates forcing individuals to buy coverage are hugely unpopular, even with the subsidies the bill would provide. Mandates forcing businesses to buy coverage for their employees would hit small and mid-size businesses hardest. There is no good time to saddle these businesses with additional costs and regulations, but right now is probably the worst time. More important, Americas reliance on employer-provided health insurance is one of the biggest problems with its health-care system. The third-party-payer problem drives the runaway cost of care. Meanwhile, Americans are often stuck with the jobs they have, fearful to strike out on their own and lose their health insurance.
The Pelosi-Reid legislation would not free us from this system; it would entrench it. It would exacerbate health-care-cost inflation by subsidizing insurance and expanding Medicaid. It would cut Medicare, not in a smart way that relies on competition to bring down costs, but by eliminating the private sector and relying on governments power to dictate payment rates to doctors and hospitals. According to the bills own defenders, its other attempts at cost control amount to little more than a handful of pilot programs. And as if health-care-cost inflation werent bad enough, the Senate version of the bill includes an excise tax on health-insurance premiums that would, over time, hit an increasing number of middle-class premium payers unless, of course, they belonged to a union, in which case the Democrats are hard at work carving out an exemption just for them.
As Ramesh Ponnuru and Yuval Levin explained recently in National Review, conservatives cant wait to run against this bill in 2010. I am personally a little sad that it looks like it wont pass. After studying how Republicans were able to repeal a similar set of reforms in Kentucky, I became convinced that Obamacare could be repealed and replaced with a better set of reforms. I actually think it would have been easier to get the right reforms in place as part of a package that repealed parts of Obamacare, because it will be years before Congress wants to touch health care again if the Pelosi-Reid legislation fails.
That would be unfortunate. The system really does need reforms such as the tax-law change John McCain proposed in 2008.
Another unfortunate aspect of the failure of the Pelosi-Reid legislation is that it would free Obama to do the hard pivot to jobs that, according to his aides, waits in the wings. In Obama-speak, jobs bill means another stimulus package, and judging from the bill that the House passed last month, the next stimulus package is likely to be as ineffective as the first, if not as costly.
At the same time, the public might welcome any sign that the president has turned his attention from fusing large chunks of the private sector to the government. The election of Brown provides Obama with an opportunity to abandon cap-and-trade, health-care reform, and other aspects of his domestic agenda that have proved to be tremendously unpopular. Remember: Bill Clinton also failed to pass a health-care-reform bill, yet he prospered as the administrator of a divided government and went on to a comfortable victory in 1996. The hard pivot Obama needs to make is to the center, and Tuesdays results free him to make it.
"Show me just what Mohammed brought that was new, and there you will find only things evil and inhuman, such as his command to spread by the sword the faith he preached." - Manuel II Palelogus
I couldn't get pass this. Looking for good news for Obama in this election is like looking for a needle in a haystack.
It is as likely as the undocumented Marxist releasing his BC.
But there's nothing whatsoever in the public record that suggests that he is smart. Crafty? Yes. Smart? Very, very unlikely.
Nope. Insert buzzer here. Wrong, with a capital “W”.
It’s waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay too late for this. Obama OWNS this health care steaming pile, and there is NO getting away from that. Everyone knows it, everyone has heard him shove it down our throats at every turn.....hell, that narcissist even convened a special session of Congress JUST to preen and preach about the wonders of Obamacare (which could have easily been summarized as: “It’s all about....MEEEEEEEEE!”).
No, this clown was stupid and arrogant enough to not only bet his own ranch on this, but the ranches of virtually every Democrat in Congress.
They’re all toast; no running away from the dead bodies with a smoking gun in his hand.
This would require demonstration of an attribute of which so far BO has shown himself totally incapable of demonstration... humility.
No way Obama will run to the center. He is still on a Kamikaze mission for our country and economy. It is deeply embedded into his mindset.
The President moves where he is told to move.
Magnanimous with a sense of fair play?
Not a chance in hell.
Exactly!
about as likely as pigs flying, hell freezing over, Hitler stopping the holocaust, Stalin starting to feed the starving masses, or Mao ending his march to the sea....
I agree. His arrogance is breathtaking. Bill Clinton, who just wanted to be liked by everyone, was smart and pragmatic enough to do so after the '94 elections. No way do I see Obama doing the same thing.
It may be getting really crowded under that bus.
Exactly!
But he has done us a favor by showing just how far Left the entire Democrat Party truely is!
Don't believe their 'talk' of fiscal responsibilty or national defense.
Not a single one of them stood up against their leadership.
They all need to go-period!
What do you mean "return to the center"?!?! He's never been close to the center. We'll be lucky if he moves from far left to left.
exactly!!
The Anointed One may take us all on a military crusade. I smell a guy who would like nothing better than to become a wartime President, like his idol FDR. Yeah, baby! That's the way to get Healthcare ... start a really big war!
Hey, Barry, how about POCKEE-Stahn? Perhaps our LERPs teams could find some hidden archives detailing your youthful visits. Pull ALL the guys outa Iraq, and march'em to Afghanistan, and then over the border into POCKEE-Stahn.
Get set for Tail-Wagging-The-Dog.
This morning, I couldn't agree with her more...;)
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.