Skip to comments.Alternative remedies at risk with McCain's dietary supplement regulatory bill: 101
Posted on 02/26/2010 3:13:44 PM PST by La Lydia
lternative remedies such as natural health supplements using vitamins and herbs, natural herbal remedies and holistic treatment are at risk...Senator John McCain proposed The Dietary Supplement Safety Act (DSSA ), February 4, 2010, to put the Federal Drug Administration (FDA) in charge of regulating natural health supplements. Alternative remedies are protected because they are classified as food. However, the new bill reduces potency a product with 1/2 carrot's worth beta carotene for example and provides a list of acceptable ingredients.
This is the same FDA that allows dangerous prescription drugs on the market with long lists of side-effects. Watch any commercial on television that has 15 seconds on therapeutic effects of the drug and 45 seconds on side-effects including 4-hour erections and sudden death.
The new bill even requires minor adverse effects from natural health supplements to be reported which is believed opens the door of harassment and allowing the FDA to pull products from shelves they deem appropriate. A dietary supplement which contains a new dietary ingredient shall be deemed adulterated under section 402(f) unless there is a history of use or other evidence of safety.
This wording means new ingredients can be squashed. The difference between regulation of drugs and natural health supplements is astounding. What is suggested is drugs are safe and food is not. If alternative remedies are to be protected, many feel this bill needs to be stopped...
(Excerpt) Read more at examiner.com ...
McCaine, go to h@ll!
Ditto. Is he being 0’s lackey and out to destroy any possible means we have of caring for ourselves. He cannot leave the Senate soon enough, IMO.
Edited to add: Is it possible to stock up?
Some choice we had in the last election - McLooser or the O’Fuehrer.
Here's what happened in Canada:
"Canada's pharmacy regulation organization, The National Association of Pharmacy Regulatory Authorities (NAPRA), issued a directive in late January telling druggists to stop selling unlicensed natural remedies. This comes from a 5-year old program to regulate natural health goods...NAPRA issued the ultimatum despite the fact that the Health Canada system is backlogged heavily in the approval process for dietary supplements. Makers of natural-health products are now bracing for widespread layoffs, millions in losses, and worse as their products are removed from drug store shelves throughout the Great White North.
"The directive from NAPRA hinges on a 2004 regime set in place by Health Canada to regulate the natural health and remedies market. These products had been virtually unregulated before and are now suddenly pending approval by Health Canada, who allowed the products to continue sales provided they had applied for approval. HC found itself suddenly buried under tens of thousands of applications as everything from St. John's Wart to Kelp await approval as dietary supplements.
"The pharmacy regulators, of course, aren't interested in this waiver and have asked their member pharmacies (virtually every drug store in Canada) to stop selling the products until they're approved.
"In the case of Canadian regulation of dietary supplements and remedies, it is obvious what happens when Big Pharma-controlled organizations get the ability to control their natural medicine competition. Now, in the United States, Senator John McCain of Arizona wants to make that the reality here too.
"Here in the Land of the Free (to get injections) and Home of the Brave (few who refuse the needle), our ability to choose for ourselves what type of medical treatment we prefer is once again being threatened."
Sure, but vitamins do lose potency over (an extended) time. Cool dark places are ideal.
I'm sure this will be the immediate response if this bill passes. Plus there will certainly be a huge black market for supplements smuggled in from Mexico and Canada. Plus the difficulty that the government will have in pushing their regulations onto Internet based companies that can pop up and disappear overnight. I think enforcement would be a real problem.
This effort by McCain is just one more nail in his liberal coffin. I've had enough of this guy to last a lifetime.
Looks like McCrazy has no idea about the passions he will stir with a turkey bill like this one.
I say it’s dead ... whether he knows it or not.
The Supreme Court just nullified an aggregious part of McCain-Feingold, the part that criminalized political speech 60 days before an election, and here he goes again with another hair-brained bill, trying to get a political gain to get re-elected.
I wish the people in Arizona would call him home and let him retire. It would do my heart good to see a picture of him relaxing in an inner tube on Lake Havasu. That is where he belongs now, not in Washington trying to create more government control as this dietary supplement bill that nobody wants.
The people in Washington had better start listening. See the CNN Poll at this link:
He only has one co-sponsor, Dorgan, and I don’t see people rushing to him to sign up. It has been sent to the appropriate committee, HELP, but as far as I can tell, the committee has scheduled no action on it. This needs to be monitored. Nor can I find any companion legislation in the House.
I don’t know what political gain he hopes to get from this, other than some big donations from pharmaceutical companies. There are a lot of small businesses in Arizona that manufacture and sell supplements. They can’t be all that happy with him at this point.
Juan McLame is an @$$hole.
John McCain comes up with some of the most blatant intrusions on the rights of ordinary Americans that I’ve ever seen from any member of Congress, Democrat or Republican. The supplement industry is fine - who besides the pharmaceuticals and McCain is asking for this?
I’m praying on my knees that my state has learnt its lesson and will give McCain a retirement this November. We need to stop romanticizing him or getting teary-eyed come elections and give him the door.
I doubt Harkin, chair of HELP, will want to touch it. Can remember reading in newspaper about how he takes bee pollen supplements for his allergies. Claimed it is the only thing that ever worked, all the drugs sucked, etc.
On the House side, if Waxman has anything to do with it, am skeptical that he’ll move anything that he hasnt written himself. As you know, ego happens up there.
That is the only positive thing I have ever heard about Harkin in my life. Usually I think he is a raving loony. I guess this is his “broken clock” moment.
Snip: The 2010-2011 seasonal flu vaccine will include the H1N1 swine flu vaccine, as the pandemic virus appears to have replaced the seasonal H1N1 virus covered by previous vaccines. The new seasonal vaccine will also include protection against the predominant "Perth" H3N2 type A and "Brisbane" type B flus.
Every member of Congress needs to get the H1N1 vaccine they recommend to the peons.
So, no shot for me again this year, eh?
good Lord, not again.
We have to fight this every 15-20 years.
Bottom line: the pharma's want to control all those billions going to vitamins/supplements. They, nor the gov't, care a white about safely. I have had 5 or 6 different prescription meds given to me over the past few years that, after I researched the side effects, opted not to take, only for them, subsequently, to be taken off the market for killing people.
Name me one case of a death due to natural vitamins/supplements.
I have used them for decades, My 2 sons and daughter used them - and our doctors can't understand why we are so healthy...indeed, my oldest son, 57, has the health of a 27 year old. His doctors now want to run tests to see HOW, especially as he has epilepsy. They don't want to hear about natural vitamins/supplements.
My 2nd son had a heart attack following an insanely long plane trip - a clot in his leg traveled up and he was minutes from dying.
After he got back on his feet, they had him on 3 meds and scheduled a check up in 3 months. (He's a long-hauler - not known for a healthy liefstyle - sitting for 10 hours a day driving and eating on the road.
He missed his 3 month check up - made it at 6 months. the doctor ran all the tests and smiled, tells him the regiment was working - that he was in excellent health! I'd like to do a video of you to show my other truck driver patients how it's done."
My son told him: "Well, I have a confession to make. The only prescription I've been taking is the enalapril. the other two were $300 a month and with no insurance, I couldn't do it. I've been using things like folic, cod liver oil, CoQ10,..." The doctor stopped him, rather chagrined and just said. "Well, keep it up.". He didn't want to hear any more. (My son cooks all his meals in his trucks - many with a crock pot, and lots of fresh fruits, vegs, and nuts.)
I had a heart attack due to stress and chemicals at work over 15 years ago. It left me with CHF and a bunch of prescripts. I, too, only took the enalapril....and the vitamin-supplement routine.
With CHF, I was expected to get progressively worse and to have 'checked out' long before now. Instead, I'm stronger than ever. Doc didn't want to hear about my natural regimen. Actually, the last doctor was 2 times removed from the doctor I had at the time of attack. He said: "I don't think you could have had a heart attack". (All the records were in the file.)
My daughters little girl had a very bad bout with retrovirus when a baby during an epidemic on base where they lived. For the next 8 years, she suffered from stomach pain after eating.
They took her to doctor after doctor, to specialists in Maine, Canada and Texas as they went from base assignments. Nothing.
My daughter had to keep her on tums. and in researching online, she came across something with the same symptoms: celiac disease, or "leaky gut". the doctors pooh poohed her.
Then they transferred from the Navy to the Coast Guard and got stationed in Florida. she went to a health food fair where a Naturopath was offering blood test analysis for $50. (In Florida, one must also be a full fledged physician in order to practice naturopathy.)
She asked him to do her daughter. He took a drop of blood and put in his - I forget what its called, but it allows him to examine it right then and there. Without knowing her medical history or anything about her, he turned to her and said, "Honey, does your tummy hurt after you eat?"
Yep. Celiac disease - prescription: a gluten free diet.
She took her to her regular doctor and told her the story. "Well," doc huffed, " I guess if you try it and it works, you'll know."
It worked immediately. And that poor little girl had suffered for 8 years. (In looking up the causes of the disease, I found that one indicator is having retrovirus in your past. So, not only did all the doctors not find the problem, they never connected the past history.
I could go on - but you get the drift.
NOW: Naturopathy is not allowed to be covered by insurance. THAT would be a health care bill I could support. Think of the billions of dollars it could save - and the lives and suffering. But the politicos and their pharma friends will never let it happen.
the FDA should be abolished not expanded. We have the RIGHT to put what we want into our own body’s.
They (FDA) tried this in 2007. FDA Docket number 2006D-0480
There was a public comment period to which I responded. I can’t believe we see this coming back around AGAIN. This time as legislation.
Repeat after me....”McCain is a PROGRESSIVE and therefore a danger to our Constitution!”
This seems to be out of the blue. Does anyone know why Juan McCain is pushing a bill to regulate supplements? Has he pushed this in the past, or does big Pharma fill his campaign coffers?
McCain is a Soros puppet. Freedom and liberty are not on his radar screen.
Send this to Arizona and McCain competition and uses it to Kill McCain re-election efforts!
McCain is a threat to the freedom of Arizonans just as he is a threat to the freedom of all Americans.
There was a similar bill back in the mid-90s.
Find a reliable source for your black market vitamins.
You don’t want to get the stuff cut with strychnine.
What are you talking about?
Orin Hatch has been opposing these vitamin/supplement regulation schemes for years. One of the few things I like him for. Lot of vitamin/health food manufacturers in Mormon-Land
At the health care summit on Thurs he mentioned that he sold insurance in his youth. I was impressed to learn that he hasnt been part of the windbag class his entire life.
I think most health-food claims are horse crap, and that high doses of vitamins give you nothing more than expensive urine, but Johnny Mac is way off base here. Let people throw their money away any way they want. This is none of the gooberment’s business.
Steve Belcher and more than 100 other people were killed by ephedra.
L-tryptophan killed at least 19 and as many as 300 people.
The herb Aristolochia fangchi has caused more than 70 cases of complete kidney failure and is known to cause cancer.
I say, let people buy all the expensive and toxic herbs they want, and kill themselves off as fast as possible. None of my business, or the government's, except insofar as it removes idiots from the gene pool.
It was not the L-tryptophan, but a batch that was contaminated - Japanese. However, they yanked L-tryptopahn off the shelves.
That's okay, I get it naturally in things like bananas and turkey.
I don't take things that have been cobbled together by man - nor herbals from, say, Japan/China. My rule of thumb is that the herbs we need are natural in the area of the world we live in... I wouldn't take things like Shark cartilage, either - it's from a different species, for crying out loud. I stick to natural supplements/vitamins from my health food store and from the fields and woods. For ex: I grow and make my own St. John's Wort for tincure - and oil. Ditto comfrey. I'm aware of the hawkers out to make money - most sell their snake oil on line. Like anything else, people have to use their heads. The gov't wants to take all decisions out of our obviously inferior hands. I will also be a little ole granny, after the mandate for mercury light bulbs goes into effect, that burns contraband light bulbs - ones I can SEE with and paint under. I'll make my own decisions - not that I won't be wrong at times. After all, I'm not omniscient, like our politicians.
Does anyone know when this is - I've been stocking up - but probably need more.
I wish they would stay the hell out of our business - there are much more dangerous Rx products out there by prescription.
Leave our damn vitamins alone McCain - I’m sad that he was the only choice we had to beat the one :( I had to vote for Mc but ugh!
No, vitamins and herbs all have a shelf life. Dried herbs can last longer but even they lose potency as they age.
When aspertine came along, some asserted that it caused health problems. The fed/guv said yes that’s right, but it doesn’t affect enough taxpayers to warrent pulling it off the market$.
Snips: I know Im not the only one. Ive talked to others who have similar problems and there have been some reports about CFLs increasing migrants, depression, and worsening symptoms in diseases such as Lupus. Traditionally healers, such as Barbara Ann Brennan, have long advised to never do healing work under fluorescence lighting of any kind to avoid making yourself ill. These lights drain our energy and especially for us in a healing profession this can be very dangerous.
Studies have also show that children do much better under normal lighting. From Earthwatch - Compact Fluorescents vs. Full Spectrum Bulbs
As Dr. Havas states - Compact fluorescent lights (CFL) produce radio wave frequencies. These frequencies radiate directly from the bulbs and go on the electrical wiring in the home or school causing poor power quality or dirty electricity. The closer you sit to the bulb the greater your exposure. Because the high frequencies travel along the wire you can be exposed in other rooms of your home as well as the room that contains the CFL.
Also new research has come to light that indicates that CFLs emit a high humming sound that is not in our range of hearing but is in the range of hearing of cats and dogs. Can you image hearing a high pitched humming sound all day long. It would be enough to drive you nuts! Many pet owners report that their cats or dogs do not want to be in rooms with CFL bulbs on and will become anxious if they are forced to be.
Calls to the fools in DC 24/7 are in order. I would love to see the fools in DC shove the curly flight bulbs up their Elitist rears.
Thank you for this article. Opposition is growing fast! Here’s a link to another ally: http://salsa.democracyinaction.org/o/568/t/1128/campaign.jsp?campaign_KEY=26714
Thank you for this article. Opposition is growing fast! Here’s a link to another ally: http://salsa.democracyinaction.org/o/568/t/1128/campaign.jsp?campaign_KEY=26714
I could swear but can’t prove that when I worked under many of those during the day - I felt dizzy and somewhat sick feeling. But when I went home that would disappear.
I certainly don’t want them in my house - the kitchen I have now has them, but I don’t use that since the dining room is right next to kitchen and over sink has regular light bulbs - thankfully!!
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.