Skip to comments.Climate change 'makes birds shrink' in North America
Posted on 03/12/2010 10:55:45 AM PST by NormsRevenge
Songbirds in the US are getting smaller, and climate change is suspected as the cause.
A study of almost half a million birds, belonging to over 100 species, shows that many are gradually becoming lighter and growing shorter wings.
This shrinkage has occurred within just half a century, with the birds thought to be evolving into a smaller size in response to warmer temperatures.
However, there is little evidence that the change is harmful to the birds.
Details of the discovery are published in the journal Oikos.
In biology, there is a general rule of thumb that animals tend to become smaller in warmer climates: an idea known as Bergman's Rule.
Usually this trend can be seen among animal species that live over a range of latitude or altitude, with individuals living at more northern latitudes or higher up cooler mountains being slightly larger than those below, for example.
Quite why this happens is not clear, but it prompted one group of scientists to ask the question: would animals respond in the same way to climate change?
To find out, Dr Josh Van Buskirk of the University of Zurich, Switzerland and colleagues Mr Robert Mulvihill and Mr Robert Leberman of the Carnegie Museum of Natural History in Rector, Pennsylvania, US decided to evaluate the sizes of hundreds of thousands of birds that pass through the Carnegie Museum's Powdermill ringing station, also in Pennsylvania.
They examined the records of 486,000 individual birds that had been caught and measured at the ringing station from 1961 to 2007.
(Excerpt) Read more at news.bbc.co.uk ...
Nice one. Did this latest BS come from the University of East Anglia too?
So hummingbirds used to be bigger?
It made some birds become foxes and one bird became a deer.
Hold muh beer while I watch the birds shrinking.
The university experts told me so. My taxes paid for their research grants so I’m proud of them!!!!
"It's climate change!"
Birds are shrinking? Watts up with that?
imagine hummers with 6 foot wingspans. :-)
Warmer air and higher humidity leads to less air density, should not lead to smaller wings.
Plus, let’s see “bird size” data from the warm period called The Medieval Warm Period. Called that by everyone except the UN Warmists, who took the inconvenient warmth off their database.
There is also the theory: Economy of purpose!
When the food supply is abundant they don’t have so far to travel to eat - don’t need wide bodies. When the food supply is scarce their metabolism needs to be fast.
After I give it some more thought, I’ll research it and let you know what I find. It helps to have an open mind or an empty one.
Cool, so BBC, why the heck should anyone care? It can’t be controlled in any form by us.
...and the “bird killer” wind turbines will finish the job, thanks to the hypocrite environmentalists.
Alternative theory: natural selection due to the increased presence of large glass-walled buildings in urban environments. Small birds maneuver more easily, are faster, and tend to smash into reflective glass panels less frequently. I have just as much evidence to prove my theory as they do theirs.
The government solution to this is to make your wallet and income shrink.
physical adaptation to one’s environment is nothing new.
I wish the wild turkeys around here were bigger but the hills are pretty lean pickings on this side of the valley.
Maybe the birds they couldn’t catch weigh more.
If you really want to understand some impact of man on birds (migration and bodyclocks), go to a large grocery store parking lot sometime at midnight. With all of the light noise, you will find hundreds of birds still awake chirping away.
Has nothing to do with “rising temperatures”, has to do with easier eating. Go where it is safe enough to not freeze.
I’ve also seen some odd waterfowl walking in neighborhoods at night (2 foot tall birds).
On average, the decline in mass of spring migrants over the 46 year study was just 1.3%," says Dr Buskirk.Looks like academic standards are declining. This is well within error of measurement area. It's not only the social science faculties that are full of morons today. It is spreading. Idiocracy is approaching.
"For a 10g warbler that's a loss of just 130mg."
But some species are losing more weight.
For example, the rose-breasted grosbeak has declined in mass by about 4%, while the Kentucky warbler has dropped 3.3% in weight and the scarlet tanager 2.3%.
This has been a cold winter. Perhaps those hatched out this spring will grow larger and develope longer wing spans.
Or the smaller size of song birds could be caused by the condition of the world economy. Fewer people putting out wild bird food
Jail birds on the other hand seem to be getting much fatter.
My first question is who are we paying to study almost half a million birds?
Then why are people in the southern US so much fatter than people in the north?
Downsizing as the economy worsens isn’t unusual. Birds will just have to do their part!
Oh ye of little faith, the enlightened MSM shall carry the water for our beloved Patron Saint Algore.
Based on 100 years of photographic evidence - it is very clear that (Western) humans have increased in volume. We are now enormous - up down and all around.
Humans live 70+ years. We changed in just four generations.
Birds live 2-5 years - Avian generational change has taken much longer. It may be cyclical - they get big & get smaller or cross breed or become extinct. Didn’t Darwin explain that?
Hmm, global warming causes bias in balances used in the field!
Or, are the birds killed, then weighed, or captured, weighed in the field, or captured, brought to a lab then weighed?
a simple shift in protocols or in the precision and accuracy of the equipment could account for a 4% delta.
Stop making any sense! Climate change is the reason we all don’t have our own unicorns and rainbows, please just go along with it and smile and nod like everyone else... lol
Ok, all sarcasism aside, how can the people who write this stuff be so blatantly stupid? Is there a course on how to be so mentally ill that you’ll state anything as fact?
Too funny. “Scientists” seeing things that they want to see.
Oh climate change, is there nothing you can’t do?
****how can the people who write this stuff be so blatantly stupid?****
Mandated for tenure;)
Drink spew alert!!!!
I’m sure they’re right but i always thought warm= greater size due to among other things,more food.
Climate change ‘makes birds shrink’ in North America shortly after a previous climate change made them shrink from dinosaurs...
That's a premise easily disproven by McDonalds' rule. I live in a warm climate (southern CA) and when I'm eating McDonalds burgers in my parked car I'm besieged by flocks of pot-bellied sparrows and seagulls begging French fries and other greasy morsels. Some of those birds are getting hugh!
So the birds are losing some of their obesity.
You would think that would make liberals happy. Especially Michelle Obama.
Now, if she could just get ‘the children’ to eat like birds.
Seems that snowbirds are getting bigger to
The fraud and dishonesty just keep on coming... (see words in caps below)
“Climate change ‘MAKES birds shrink’ in North America”
In the article...
“Songbirds in the US are getting smaller, and climate change is SUSPECTED as the cause.”
And they have the audacity to call this crap science?!!
What I SUSPECT is that the people that did this so-called study that arrived at this “conclusion” are bird brains. And I’m more confident of my conclusion than of theirs.
Then explain dinosaurs.
They would say, "It is so obvious! Dinosaurs don't have thumbs!"
"For a 10g warbler that's a loss of just 130mg."
Yeah, but did they account for the bird's "Poopy time".
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.