Skip to comments.The French Quarter Attack WAS Political…
Posted on 04/17/2010 2:58:20 AM PDT by abb
you have to more or less suspend disbelief not to recognize that.
But based on various agendas, it seems like thats whats going on. Beyond the reactions of left-wing journals, when those sources have reacted to this story at all, we notice that Allahpundit at HotAir.com and Michelle Malkin have both gone out of their way to disparage the idea that the attack had to do with politics.
The attack was political. But, and I think Ive been clear on this and hopefully in this post Ill be even clearer, while it was political it doesnt appear that it was partisan. A distinction like that used to be fairly easily understood.
For those who dont grasp the difference between political and partisan, its pretty simple. In our modern parlance, partisan means Republicans vs. Democrats. Political can include everything else. Like, for example, anarchist revolutionaries.
How do we know this attack was political? Well, three developments in the story of the beating of Allee Bautsch and Joe Brown last Friday in the French Quarter have served to make it almost patently obvious that Bautsch and Brown were attacked out of a political motive
1. Louisiana GOP chairman Roger Villere told Hayride contributor Walter Abbott that he was chased by protestors outside of Brennans into a cab. Villere said that he couldnt leave the restaurant through the front door when it was time to depart the fundraiser because the protestors had blocked that entrance; and when he and his group left through the kitchen to the back door, they were seen and pursued. Villere caught a cab in the nick of time and made a getaway.
2. The police report of the incident makes clear that when Bautsch and Brown left the restaurant an hour or so later, there were still protestors on hand. Those protestors immediately set to making catcalls to the couple, and as they headed for the car they immediately realized they were being pursued just like Villere had been. The fact that the demonstrators pursued both Villere AND Bautsch and Brown is a chilling one; it also calls into doubt any explanation for the attack other than a political motive. While the NOPD has obviously taken scrupulous pains not to make public statements to the effect that politics was involved, the police have also not ruled it out. Sgt. Nick Gernon of the 8th District, who is heading the investigation (Ive been reliably informed that despite the widespread disparagement of the NOPD both in the New Orleans area and elsewhere, Gernon is a first-rate detective committed to running a thorough inquiry) has not spoken to the media to date so there is no reason to discount a political motive. And I could have predicted to you from the beginning of this saga that the NOPD was not going to announce a political motive publicly until suspects were identified and arrested; that NOPD Public Information Officer Bob Young let the cat out of the bag and made statements to the effect that politics was involved before hustling back to the status quo was a mere momentary departure from that expectation.
3. Bautschs mother Della Bernings appearance with Megyn Kelly on Fox News, which Connie Hair of Human Events has transcribed, makes clear, as does the police report, that the catcalls and insults hurled at Bautsch and Brown were all about money. The police report quotes Brown as recalling one of them was You think youre f**ing special and that there were comments as to how sharply attired the pair were. Lets remember that both the protest of the Southern Republican Leadership Conference venue at the Hilton Riverside and the redirect to Brennans were organized by the Iron Rail Book Collective, whose nature weve documented ad nauseam here the Iron Rail Gang are self-described anarchist revolutionaries, and as Mick Wright at the Tennessee Conservative blog does a devastating job of demonstrating through photo evidence found on the internet from the protests at both venues, they were quite explicit in manifesting that identity during the events in question. Not only that, the Iron Rail people initially bragged about lots of confrontations last Friday and how New Orleans bared its teeth and snarled, and rich plutocrats shat themselves in fear before the light of scrutiny was shone on them at which time rather than issue pointed and explicit denials of any role in what happened to Bautsch and Brown, they took down Facebook pages and YouTube videos which documented their protests both at the Hilton and at Brennans.
I hardly think its necessary to spell this out, but a communist anarchist who makes disparaging remarks based on socioeconomic circumstances about someone he suspects to be a conservative Republican before descending upon said Republican and beating him or her savagely is doing so from a political motive. Economics + communism = politics. Its not brain surgery. Particularly given that the anarchists propaganda both before and after the event was shot through with hateful references to Gov. Bobby Jindals rich friends and so on.
Given that we now know that people who were at the protest at Brennans pursued attendees at the fundraiser on two occasions and successfully attacked attendees once, one has to be incredibly suspicious that Daniel Mauch and Joanna Dubinsky would have gone dark the way they did. Perhaps its not an admission of guilt, but any cop will tell you that its classic guilty behavior. They might as well have fled in a white Bronco.
So obviously this attack was political. But that doesnt mean it was the work of Democrats. There are other people in the world outside Republicans and Democrats. There are the white supremacists, skinheads and neo-Nazi types, for example. And while its a favorite tactic of Democrat political types to paint conservatives as ideological kin to those folks, there are scant few on the mainstream Right with any affinity or common cause at all to be had with that fringe element.
I would like very much to think that anarcho-communists such as those youll find at the Iron Rail Book Collective are analogous to the white supremacist crowd, in that conservatives can agree they dont represent the views of or share any allegiance with the mainstream Left.
It appears fairly clear that last Friday, the Iron Rail Gang was able to bamboozle a few mainstream Democrats, namely some well-meaning but easily duped students and professors at the University of New Orleans, into attending their protest at the Hilton. After all, they roped in a brass band for a second line march on a Friday afternoon, and anyone with a knowledge of New Orleans and its traditions knows that a second line is a good way to draw a crowd in the Big Easy. That the protest was couched in the relatively mainstream policy ends of restoring budget cuts in higher education and rebuilding a public hospital knocked out of commission by Hurricane Katrina when Jindal has chosen a different path was a nice way for the anarchists to put a veneer of respectability on their event. If youll look at the PDF files of the flyers the Iron Rail people created for the event and hosted at their web site (see the single-sided one here and the double-sided one here), they look relatively inoffensive. The two-page flyer says that Jindal and his Republican fat cats are destroying Louisiana healthcare: closing hospitals, firing workers, which is red meat, but not particularly ominous.
But there was also an eight-page brochure the group put together that did not appear on the Facebook event page for the protest (since removed there were 209 people who had RSVPed for the event and from that roster we found Mauch and Dubinsky), and that brochure was much more ominous. It listed several Points of Unity, among them being:
- The SRLC is not welcome in NOLA without a fuss - Recognize healthcare as a basic human right - Oppose police oppression, the prison-industrial complex, and the dominant culture of militarism - Recognize the need for active resistance to confront all forms of oppression, respecting a diversity of tactics
The brochure also contained a map of the five hotels at which SRLC delegates were primarily staying, which is extremely disturbing, on the same page as this statement:
The SRLC is being held the same weekend as the French Quarter Festival. Centered at the Hilton Riverside Hotel at the confluence of Poydras St. and Convention Center Blvd, the SRLC will bring a multitude of unwelcomed outsiders during a traditionally New Orleanian celebration.
On page 6 of the brochure was the following:
Saturday, April 10 all-day Street Theatre & Direct Action We welcome everyone, organizations and individuals alike, to take some time to send their own personal message to the SRLC and its attendees. Saturday is a day of direct action, a time for people to take to the streets, autonomously, and demonstrate their opposition to the policies and politics of the Republican party. While the focus of our Second Line will be about the destruction of health care, inequity and oppression in our city affect all aspects of our daily lives: education, employment, police, the prison-industrial complex, etc. To the streets! Show Jindal his harmful politics are not welcome in New Orleans. Our numbers are many, let our presence reflect our dissatisfaction with the status quo. The Republicans do not offer solutions. The people have the power. Let that be shown.
It must be said that very little happened on Saturday, though before he pulled it down Daniel Mauch posted on his Facebook page that he was open for more mischief and for those interested to call him. Page 6 of the brochure also said:
SRLC attendees will be spending most of their time in the CBD and the French Quarter. Show them that ignoring the health and well-being of the people for corporate profit will not go unnoticed.
Mauch, who talked to Tennessee Conservatives Mick Wright for an hour outside of the Hilton, was in possession of a flyer announcing the afterparty protest at Brennans, which he gave to Wright while scrawling both the address of the Iron Rail Book Collective and the name of the YouTube account which once hosted the protestors video files. On those videos Dubinsky could be seen inviting the protestors at the Hilton to join her at Brennans. As said above, both have taken actions in the last 48-72 hours which can be construed as covering their online tracks.
It is in light of the above that one can conclude, perhaps to the exclusion of anything else, that the attacks on Bautsch and Brown which are documented in the police report and in Bautschs mothers account originated from Brennans protestors. The protests at Brennans were much more hostile and intense than at the Hilton, where a larger group which included more mainstream types constituted the majority of the demonstrators. The brass band wasnt playing at Brennans, either; this was no cute second-line march. The well-meaning folks at the first protest were obviously peeling off by the time the Brennans affair was winding down, and as such this thing wasnt about ordinary Democrats.
As I said above, the group which needs intense scrutiny here are the anarchist revolutionaries of the Iron Rail Book Collective, who organized a party-like protest at the Hilton with the express purpose of distilling it into something much more sinister at Brennans. The attack came from demonstrators at that protest, and as such it was political. It only becomes partisan if, and I very fervently hope there is no reason to believe this would happen, the mainstream Left chooses to stand with, act as apologist for or condone the actions of anarchist revolutionaries.
But for those, including some on the Right, who insist upon distilling all matters political into the neat little buckets of elephants and donkeys this distinction is perhaps impossible to perceive. If thats the case, and if the Right cant distinguish Democrats from anarcho-communists while the Left sees Republicans as a worse political enemy than the students of The Coming Insurrection, we are in a lot more trouble than we think.
Oh settle down... the victims(or at least the mother) don’t want this seen as being “political” so stop pushing it...
You do what you wish to do, and I shall do what I wish. No one made you click on this thread and comment.
Attack on aide not in police log
Broken leg treated as medical crisis
Editorial: The NOPD’s rotten orchard
Put me in the corner of those who think this needs to be shouted from the rooftops.
Thank you for posting it. Another excellent article on the brutal attack by The Hayride.
Of course it was partisan. The writer seems to think that “revolutionary anarchists” are not politically aligned. If so, he understands nothing and should be forced to read Bakunin day and night for a month.
The trending towards sharper and sharper political violence was obvious already during the election (The straight-talk express was shot up at least twice). And I seem to remember a long rash of arsons during the last Bush election.
When news of the maiming first surfaced last Monday afternoon, the State-Run Media in Louisiana immediately spun the story as another typical French Quarter drunken brawl and blamed it on the victims.
By midnight Monday, Scott McKay of The Hayride began piecing together the events of what really happened and who all was involved. And he hasn’t stopped since.
Real, systematic, analytical Big-Boy investigative reporting. The kind the State-Run Media tells us all the time they only are qualified to do.
Right here, right now.
I was happy to see them single out HotAir and Malkin for their willingness to downplay the partisan/political angle.
Beyond that I can’t say much more than what I already posted in the comments at The Hayride (and I can only imagine what blahx3 would think of it).
>>the Iron Rail Gang are self-described anarchist revolutionaries
As someone has pointed out in another thread, and is worth pointing out here, “anarchist revolutionaries” practically means “violent socialists”, if you look at what these thugs really stand for politically.
From another who was on-scene.
In New Orleans, a Secondline to Violence
Are you siding with the anarchists?
Are you kidding?
The link in post 11 really shows the anarchists’ “eat the rich” mindset, with many pics of their signage. Not to mention pics of their masked thugs.
Obama said “If they bring a knife we bring a gun”. He has called for violence from his fringe group. He and the Dems are inciting violence by saying that the tea party is violent when they know full well, it isn't, since the Dem leaders chose to walk through the tea party crowd.
This latest incident needs to be investigated as political. The government chose not to go after the SEIU members who beat up the black guy at one of the rallies. They would only go charge them with a misdemeanor even though the man had to go to a hospital.
One man lost his finger to one of these nut jobs at a rally.
We should demand action against this violence or there is going to be more and more attacks and intimidation with the tacit approval of Obama and other socialists.
The thing that I personally find most amusing, is that, one day soon, these animals will be quite amazed when they show up for a little wilding on a conservative, and suddenly, they are cut in half with a shotgun, held by an old white guy...
They pull a knife, you pull a gun. He sends one of yours to the hospital, you send one of his to the morgue. *That's* the *Chicago* way!
The only way to defeat the gangsta community organizer's mob from Chicago.....
Can’t seem to find any information on legal action....Are charges being filed?
Your response seems whacky.
Sooner or later, someone on the right (Tea Party member) will stop the clock for some attacker. Then, oh then....
They have no suspects in custody yet. When you consider the corruption/incompetence that is the NOPD, one has to despair that every there will be. See my commentary on that very subject.
Is NOPD Fit to Investigate French Qtr Assault?
You wouldn't happen to work for the mainstream media, would you? Or maybe the DNC?
How about hate
The French Quarter attack was perpetrated by haters
I would say so. When a woman is down and one of the perps stomps on her leg and breaks it, I would have to say that qualifies.
It is certainly to the advantage of the business community and city fathers in New Orleans to expose this attack as the political attack that it appears to be.
There are just 2 alternatives, this is a political attack or it’s just a typical street crime event in NOLA.
The second is a lot more devastating to the French quarter community that relies on tourism and encourages people from all over to drink and become vulnerable in the area.
Listen....we are under ATTACK!! in more ways than one. If you need to crawl into a hole go for it.
Lead...Follow...or get out of the way!!
“They have no suspects in custody yet...”
That doesn’t mean they don’t have a good bead on who the perps are, now does it? I would be surprised if they didn’t know and are collecting enough evidence to get warrants.
Do the victims have any say on this issue? Can they file charges?
I think New Orleans long ago gave up trying to keep the French Quarter safe. So they instead decided to market the danger as a sort of "adventure" for tourists and claim that it adds "flavor" to the experience.
To satisfy the blood lust in all of us, I suppose...
The woman is still in the hospital, I think. She's not quite up to doing detective work just yet. If you'll research all the threads on this subject, you'll see pics and videos of many likely suspects. I daresay we FReepers are miles ahead of the NOPD in working the investigation.
Which means these things will continue to happen to Republicans.
Brwn shirts. Watch for glasnacht.
I’m not talking about the victims doing an invesitgation - by ‘they’ I meant the police, who generally keep information close because they don’t want the perpetrators bolting from the city.
In some locales the police can file charges against suspects without the victims being involved but there I don’t know how it is done, in New Orleans.
That will bring martial law. The tea party will be outlawed as a criminal danger.
We are in very deep water on an open sea with the mother of all storms brewing.
What the heck is wrong with Malkin? Why can’t she put two and two together? Why is the GOP itself silent? They must know who did this, in a general way: anarchists, who are leftists by and large, or at least ant-GOP.
Read the article this morning in the Times-Picayune upthread. The oafs at the NOPD didn’t get around to classifying the thing as an assault until Monday when they did the police report.
The NOPD ain’t exactly CSI-grade investigators.
By continuing to report, investigate, blog, tweet and link. The story is now on the front page of the New Orleans Times-Picayune and has made it to Fox News. It took us all week to get it done, but we did. We just have to keep pushing it.
2A makes all the difference.
One poster earlier this week attributed it to a kind of half-assed "battered wife syndrome" on the part of some on our side. I think he has a point.
No **** Sherlock.
After the night of the long knives in which Hitler purged his ranks of purported enemies:
Herr Adolf Hitler, the German Chancellor, has saved his country. Swiftly and with exorable severity, he has delivered Germany from men who had become a danger to the unity of the German people and to the order of the state. With lightening rapidity he has caused them to be removed from high office, to be arrested, and put to death.
The names of the men who have been shot by his orders are already known. Hitler’s love of Germany has triumphed over private friendships and fidelity to comrades who had stood shoulder to shoulder with him in the fight for Germany’s future.
Daily Mail, July 2nd 1934.
...and no one is calling in the FBI?
A city like New Orleans generally has a lot of crime and I doubt the police will give an assault and battery priority over murders, rapes, and robberies involving firearms.
The author is correct in this much, we are in for worse than he thinks...
Is NOPD Fit to Investigate French Qtr Assault?
The very question I posed to Gov. Jindal's press secretary. See the email in my blog. So far, no response.
Yep... it will cost them more than they can know... if they try that crap here.
I think blahblah forgot the “/sarc” tag
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.