Skip to comments.Fox News 'Forbes on Fox' Panel: Detonate Nukes in Gulf to Stop Oil Spill
Posted on 06/05/2010 9:38:26 PM PDT by Rufus2007
How's this for outside-the-box thinking - use nuclear explosives to stop the BP oil spill that is ravaging the Gulf Coast?
According to some of the panelist on Fox News Channel's "Forbes on Fox," using nuclear materials would be a more expeditious way to solve this calamity.
"That's right, nuke it." "Forbes on Fox" host David Asman said on the show's June 5 broadcast. "Some scientists do advocate this. The Soviets apparently succeeded in doing it. Here is the video they say actually shows it. And now some at Forbes' agree, nuke it.
(Excerpt) Read more at newsbusters.org ...
Idiots. THey are already worried about the seabed collapsing and releasing even more oil because of the pressures caving this in (normal pumping replaces oil with mud/water so seafloor collapse won’t occur).
Nuke it and watch the whole ocean floor open up. They were already worried about leaks opening just a couple miles away.
Let’s leave the nuke option for our enemies.
“They were already worried about leaks opening just a couple miles away.”
I really don’t think we need to worry that much. The environmentalists and Dimocratz have assured us that there isn’t much oil near the U.S. so how much more can come up? s/off
As about as stupit as it gets
If they could get a nuke down the hole as the Russians did, they could have already plugged this other ways. Detonating it on the ocean floor is insane.
How is the possibility of a radioactive Gulf a good idea?
These idiots just love to say crap to hear their own voices. Did they even think for a second about the sea floor caving in on the oil cavern and releasing everything? Or about the possibility of a tidal wave being generated? Just armchair masturbating nutjobs. Thank God many of them are losing their jobs. You don’t need idiots spewing crap disguised as news. That just dumbs news down altogether.
Maybe they mean nuke BP Headquarters.
Seabed collapse ? The well is 15,000 ft under the seabed.
There was a technique of using a special dynamite (gives off tremendous heat) to melt/collapse the casing/bore way down the hole in a series of staggered explosions, apparently used by Red Adair for one, could be all those who knew how to do it got laid off in the last decade or so.
Not heard it mentioned at all.
That was suggested by about day three- along with the theory that a North Korean mini-sub operating off a mother ship which had just left Cuba had torpedoed the rig.
Seeing FredZarguna’s post, maybe it was considered after all.
Nuke an out of control oil well 1 mile below the surface, yep that sounds reasonable....does anyone know what will happen when you nuke a oil well spewing oil gas and methane...sounds dumb to me...must have been a member of mensa that suggested it....
Nuk it what you get is a cracked or cratered sea floor...
Basically creating a open pit mine sea floor down in to the that oil reserve.......one total mess
Your trying to seal and bury it, not open it up more
Personal long term I think they will go with a modified dome...leaving the dome open at first and establish a foundation in the sea floor, a seal at the base before you close the top to stop the oil
Drive in to the sea floor A large open medal tube around the well head...basically like a bridge piling
Then you fill the inner area with underwater concrete... to establish a foundation in the sea floor
Once that set up ...the tube bridge piling, now around the well head, has a top that can be fitted after and sealed.
The long term solution will be the relief wells being drilled to intersect with the leaking well. They will take the pressure off the leaking well so it can be effectively capped.
Everything they are doing now is a desperation measure designed to slow the leak until the relief wells are finished in two months.
obama will use this power device to brainwash people and said he saved the day. wow this seems all to real
Why am I envisioning a huge radioactive tsunami?
We can all speculate. I consider the Navy UDT types to have the best divers. Now add the mini subs and surely a solution can be found.
Excuse me, this has done before with success. Brighter men then you have discussed it as a viable option. So STFU.
I agree. Nuking the well would be the biggest frac job in history. It could literally open up thousands of leaks in the ocean floor.
No way we should even consider the option.
Just a thought how to stop the flow of oil coming out of the ground.
Employ a device resembling a canon, in form of a long very heavy metal tube closed on one end with the purpose of launching a projectile. It does not have to have any rifling with the caliber or diameter of the projectile about the same as the bore hole or slightly larger. The projectile could be slightly tapered in front, and be a NONE explosive metal cylinder with a heavy powder charge behind it. Then make an attempt to position it over the original bore hole which may or may not have to be trimmed some what cleaned up to facilitate and allow the entry of this solid metal cylinder or projectile in to the original bore hole.
Then put a heavy powder charge behind this NONE explosive projectile and shoot it in to the bore hole to close it off. Since the projectile would be recessed in this metal barrel or firing tube, arrangements could be made using compressed air to blow out any water first before firing the projectile in to the bore hole, similar to using a torpedo, except in this case the projectile would be none explosive and only used to plug the hole.
The whole contraption in form of a long heavy metal tube could be suspended from cables above and guided over the bore hole and used repeatedly if the initial try would be unsuccessful, then shoot and re-load until the source of the escaping oil is plugged. Also these metal plugs or projectiles could be cast from solid lead what could be easily bored out and restore the flow of oil in a safe manner once its purpose has been accomplished. Even if the first shot would not be successful repeated attempts may cave in the remaining pipe and pound what is left in to the ground, below the ocean floor, similar in effect to a pile driver.
Well this is just a thought or suggestion; shoot something in to the bore hole when everything else failed to do the trick. I am quite certain if a heavy metal dome was fabricated previously to catch the escaping flow of oil in a fairly short amount of time, the contraption as suggested by me could be rigged up just as quickly or even faster. In order to absorbe some of the recoil a large round metal plate could be welded opposite the exit hole for the Bullet causing it to push against the water above it. I wish some one amongst the readers of FR who has connections could direct this suggestion to who ever is attempting to stop the flow of oil as I do believe this actually may work, by pounding it shut and in to the ground.
No NUKES...it could wake up Godzilla!!!
The goal is not to stop the leak, the goal is to stop the leak and have a producing well.
I suspect they don't want to do this though because as long as the pipe is there they still have a chance of getting a productive well out of it. So they'll try everything they can to cap it.
PING! Still under discussion?
Thanks for the ping!
We tried to fracture rock with a nuke to see if we could use them to open up new reserves - the heat from the nuke sealed everything shut, the exact opposite of what they wanted but exactly what needs to be done here.
You’re welcome, as usual!
The upside? It might work.
The downside? The mother of all frac jobs, a destroyed wellhead, a hole in the gulf disgorging more massive quantities of oil and gas--now carrying with it the radioactive by-products of the explosion.
No one wants to clean it up (because the oil is radioactive, or at least the contaminants in it are), no one wants to drill a relief well, no one will work on any rig to do it, and you have the same problems with oil, only now there is no way to control it until the reservoir depletes--which could take decades.
The Ixtoc 1 well took almost ten months to control, blew out more oil and gas, and the Gulf didn't die off. The relief wells haven't failed, because they aren't even done yet. How about giving the tried and true methods of bringing a wild well under control a chance to work before dashing off half-cocked and making a real mess. They take a lot less time to drill than they used to because of the advances made in drilling technology.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.