Skip to comments.Whose Environment?
Posted on 06/21/2010 7:54:51 AM PDT by Ed Hudgins
I was walking back to the office one day, not long after The Atlas Society moved to Washington, when a young woman accosted me on a street corner. Got a minute for the environment? she asked, thrusting a leaflet in my direction.
Welcome to Washington, I thought. In New York, where I used to live, people passing bills on the street were usually selling one of two things: mens suits or sex. But Washington is a political town. Here we sell causes.
I didnt stop. I didnt have a minute for her, or for much of anything except getting back to work. Besides, it seemed a little presumptuous of her to claim to represent the environment. And what did she mean by the environment, anyway? What does the term refer to? And then it struck me: that is an interesting question.
The street-corner environmentalist expected passers-by to understand what she meant, as do editorialists who speak of environmental policies, as do companies that tout their products as Earth-friendly, as do environmentally conscious consumers who conspicuously drive hybrid cars. No one is puzzled by these references. Everyone seems to understand what the environment is.
Yet environment is a highly abstract concept. It refers to the totality of external conditions that an organism of a particular type can interact with and that affect its survival, as opposed to its internal structure and processes. For every species there is a different environment, set by its nature. The environment of a garden flower in Florida is not the same as the environment of a Siberian tiger. Environment is a relational concept, like husband and wife. You cant be a husband unless...
(Excerpt) Read more at atlassociety.org ...
Few urban environmentalists have any kind of credibility.
Good post. I expect many just won’t get it.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.