Skip to comments.The Missing Bone Hunters of Politics
Posted on 07/16/2010 12:15:33 PM PDT by Congressman Billybob
On our way through eastern Tennessee on US 26 for the fortieth time, give or take a few, we decided to visit the Gray Fossil Museum. It is one of the most extraordinary preserves of fossilized bones of long-extinct creatures ever found.
An excellent book describes how this sink hole that preserves thousands of whole skeletons of ancient creatures was discovered, preserved and exploited. The book is The Bone Hunters by Harry Moore.
In some cases, the scientists can identify a species from a single tooth. Compare paleontology to political science. We know more about the life and death of creatures which lived three million years ago, than we do about types of governments which have died within the memory of living people.
The first fact a tooth can give us about a long-dead creature is whether it is an herbivore, living on vegetation, or carnivore, living on animal flesh. There is a simple characteristic which divides governments into two, opposed categories.
When I taught American Political Theory in college, decades ago, I would begin the class opening night, before anyone had bought the books or begun the readings. I would ask a victim (excuse me, a student) to stand up and offer a definition of a government. Several students would offer descriptions based on justice, democracy, etc. Then I would ask them if the people who ran Nazi Germany, or Russia under the Bolsheviks, or Cambodia under Pol Pot, were governments. They had to concede that these were both governments and blood-thirsty tyrannies.
In short, a government is a group of individuals who have the permanent power of life and death over the residents in an area large enough to be called a nation. Notions such as justice, democracy, etc., come later, if at all.
We did have political bone hunters at the highest level of government in the United States at one time. The books that Thomas Jefferson loaned to his friend James Madison to prepare for a certain meeting in Philadelphia in 1787 gave a history of failed republics. There were only a few dozen republics in the known history of the human race, when the Framers began their work at the Constitutional Convention.
The Framers were students of governmental failures. By studying the deaths of other republics they learned the principles which allowed them to create the longest surviving constitutional republic in human history. For what is government but the greatest of all reflections on human nature?
As James Madison continued this thought in The Federalist, No. 51, If men were angels, no government would be necessary. If angels were to govern men, neither external nor internal controls on government would be necessary. In framing a government which is to be administered by men over men, the great difficulty lies in this: you must first enable the government to control the governed; and in the next place oblige it to control itself. A dependence on the people is, no doubt, the primary control on the government; but experience has taught mankind the necessity of auxiliary precautions.
This is the exact opposite of a government which has, and uses, the capacity to drag any citizen into the street and shoot him, hack him to death with swords, or beat him to death with rocks, depending on the era and development of the nation, or tribe.
In the PhD program at American University we read and discussed a book which posed the question whether political science was really a science (like the hard sciences like physics and mathematics). The conclusion was that it was not, and could not be due to the difficulty of accurately quantifying the related variables.
The only hard numbers in poli-sci are election results. And examples as varied as Venezuela and Chicago demonstrate, these are also variables.
But this is no excuse for modern theoreticians in poli-sci, whether professors in ivory towers or politicians in elected office, to ignore, or worse to falsify, the examples of history. There are almost no programs or policies being considered in the US today that do not have a track record of prior use.
And, those records are mostly of failures, as were the examples the Framers had before them in Philadelphia. Sometimes failures are the best possible sources of guidance for the future. But this whole lesson is lost on entirely too many members of the Obama Administration, leaders in Congress, leaders in the American press, professors in college, etc.
We need bone hunters in politics today. That is the lesson I learned from a sinkhole full of fossils in Tennessee, this week.
About the Author: John Armor practiced before the Supreme Court for 33 years. John_Armor@aya,yale.edu His latest book, to appear in September, is on Thomas Paine. www.TheseAreTheTimes.us
- 30 -
John / Billybob
I hope this isn’t another Bawney Fwank thread...............
The books that Thomas Jefferson loaned to his friend James Madison to prepare for a certain meeting in Philadelphia in 1787 gave a history of failed republics. There were only a few dozen republics in the known history of the human race, when the Framers began their work at the Constitutional Convention.
If you have a list of these books, could you please post it?
Reported Attack Page!
This web page at www.chronwatch.com has been reported as an attack page and has been blocked based on your security preferences.
Attack pages try to install programs that steal private information, use your computer to attack others, or damage your system.
Some attack pages intentionally distribute harmful software, but many are compromised without the knowledge or permission of their owners.
I didn’t have any problem. If someone does steal my identity I hope they have better with it luck than I had.
I got the same thing. Perhaps Liberals got their fingers into Firefox’s Attack Page listing? I’ll err on the side of caution.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.