Skip to comments.Clutching frantically to 'Heller,' 3rd Circuit OKs Ban on Unnumbered Guns
Posted on 07/30/2010 8:50:32 PM PDT by Rabin
click here to read article
Almost true but not quite. You can make your own firearm from scratch (or at least the receiver, which otherwise would be the serialized part) and you don't have to give it a serial number. BATFE encourages you to, so you can "identify it if it's ever stolen", but it's not a legal requirement.
I'm going to try my hand at telling the Wickard case in a soundbite form.
The court found that Farmer Filburn had a complete right to plant excess. He could feed it to his livestock without penalty. In order to avoid the penalty under the law, Farmer Filburn would only have to feed the harvest to his livestock before threshing it, that is, before removing the grain from the chaff.
"Feeding before threshing" has exactly the same impact on interstate commerce as "feeding after threshing."
I haven't figured out a good soundbite to describe the legal nonsense that follows, to this day, a decision that let Farmer Filburn affect interstate commerce with no interference from the government, as long as he didn't thresh the excess of his harvest.
And we’ve all been getting thrashed by WvF ever since!
Actually, no. Even if you roll back interstate commerce "jurisprudence" to pre-Wickard days, when some actual interstate commerce would be a prerequisite for regulation, you're STILL not done. The commerce clause wasn't intended to enable general regulation of interstate commerce (even REAL interstate commerce), but to prevent protectionism by states against goods manufactured in other states, etc., and a few other small concerns, and that was about it.
The requirement that long guns must be serially numbered came in with the 1968 gun control act, passeed after the murder of former president John F. Kennedy and modelled after the German Weapons Law of March 18, 1938, drafted and passed by the then-ruling German National Socialist Party, usually known by as the Nazi Party, the shorthand abbreviation they were tagged with by their Communist adversaries.
Until the 1969 act became law, inexpensive shotguns and .22 rifles generally weren't serial numbered, though most handguns were. But the Democrats in congress in the 1960s wanted to know where even the kids' .22 rifles and single-shot rabbit guns were.
Just like the Nazis did.
If the gun is your property then you should be able to deface it any way you want. Even small infringements are still intollerable.
“I dont have a problem with this. We have a right to bear arms, but nothing says those arms must be allowed to have no serial number. I own a number of guns, and all of them have serial numbers. It isnt a big deal.”
I understand what you are saying, but do you think you should be charged with a felony if you chose to remove the serial number of one of your guns? You own them so who is to say you can’t? Does it hurt anyone?
Laws against obliterated S/N’s are malum prohibitum. They serve no purpose that isn’t accomplished through existing laws. It’s already illegal to possess stolen property.
I agree about the law’s usefulness. However, I don’t see a lot of harm, and would much rather see money and effort spent trying to make it easier for a citizen to own arms in all 50 states. I think Constitutional Carry is just that - a logical interpretation of the Constitution that should be binding everywhere in the USA.
How about GPS safety-locking chips... so that they won’t work in, say, Washington DC?
Actually I am comfortable with the line of reasoning. Try and buy a B-61 on the private market. Look, I agree that serial numbers are indeed innocuous in and of themselves, even valuable when dealing with situations like theft. The problem is the the logic used to require them can easily be extended to require other modifications/conditions that render a firearm unusable for all practical purposes even though it may still be technically functional. Make no mistake that this is one direction we will be heading after the Heller decision.
“The courts” rule many unconstitutional things.
Any “penalty” for an obliterated firearm serial number will just be ignored or served concurrently with whatever sentence a criminal receives...it has absolutely no effect on a criminal...only a law-abiding citizen will ever be affected by these arcane “laws” passed by the real criminal class...otherwise known as “politicians”.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.