Sounds like the plot of every Gilligan's Island.
Posted on 10/07/2010 9:23:46 AM PDT by george76
A former Sea Shepherd activist on Thursday accused the militant conservation group of deliberately sinking one of its own ships as a publicity stunt after a collision with a Japanese whaler.
New Zealander Pete Bethune labelled Sea Shepherd's leadership "morally bankrupt" for allegedly ordering the hi-tech trimaran "Ady Gil" to be scuttled after it collided with a Japanese whaler last January in the Southern Ocean.
Bethune, the Ady Gil's captain, said Sea Shepherd founder Paul Watson ordered the ship's sinking to "garner sympathy with the public and to create better TV" in the publicity battle against Japan's Antarctic whaling program.
"It was definitely salvageable, it was still rock solid from the engine room back," he told Radio New Zealand.
Bethune, who spent five months in custody in Japan earlier this year after illegally boarding the same whaler "Shonan Maru II" a month after the high-seas collision, said he had cut all ties with Sea Shepherd.
"I think an organisation that relies on public money and public generosity to survive has an obligation to be honest," he said.
(Excerpt) Read more at nz.news.yahoo.com ...
I simply don’t understand why whale ships aren’t armed and defending themselves from these idiots. Its happening in international waters, and isn’t much different than whats happening off the coast of Somalia.
That said, a friend of mine told me he watches the cable show about these idiots. I was stunned, and asked ‘Why?!’
He said each episode ends in failure, the whaling ships continue, the idiots get injured, sometimes their boats sink, and they are always frustrated.
Good point....(laughing)
It’s an old trick in the revolutionary’s playbook.
That would be interesting:
Scene I
Pro-Life Activist: "Our Father, Who art in Heaven ..."
Abortionist: "%^#@#^*() *&^%$- ())&*$%#% )(*()& $#$%#%$ !!!!!!!!"
Scene II:
[Obviously pregnant woman approaches]
Pro-Life Activist: "Ma'am, would you like to have some information about your baby?"
Abortionist: "%^#@#^*() *&^%$- ())&*$%#% )(*()& $#$%#%$ !!!!!!!!"
Sounds like the plot of every Gilligan's Island.
Paul Watson will get someone killed.
The Steve Irwin is not double-hulled and should not even be in the Antartic.
'The Price Is Right' Bob Barker donated/bought the Sea Sheppard's a double-hull to give them a 2nd ship.
Japan should deal with them as Pirates, no different from the Somali pirates of Africa.
One worships Mohammed, the other Gaia.
Imagine my surprise.
Bethune, obviously, has found he is no longer of use to Paul Watson, and has received the standard treatment Marxists give to useful idiots, so he drops a dime on Watson. I'll bet he wasn't smart enough to record the order, Japan would have rewarded him and Watson would be in a Japanese jail.
Aren’t they using this fraud to raise funds in the USA? So, isn’t fraud a felony?
I've seen the video of the Japanese ship running into the Ady Gil. Even the Japanese video clearly shows them hitting the ship. I also don't doubt that Bethune made the statement above. However, the incident was over a 1000 miles from the nearest ship that could tow the boat to port. I think it is doubtful that the Sea Sheppard could have affected a successful tow to any port, so the decision was made to scuttle the Ady Gil, partly because it could pose a navigation hazard until it did sink.
Bethune built the ship with his own money and you could tell by the video taken at the time how upset he was. However, this article appears to want you to think that the sinking was purely motivated by seeking sympathy for their cause. I really doubt that. There was simply no way to tow the ship for repairs and they couldn't let it wallow about until Nature sent her to the bottom. I'm uncertain as to why Bethune is making a stink now, months after the incident occurred.
Pete is lucky he didn't get himself and his crew killed.
I see a faint flicker of enlightenment in that statement. Imagine his surprise when he learns about the damage Rachel Carson has caused.
It does.
And a fact related to the three year run of Gilligans Island.
It won its time slot all three years. And then was cancelled.
Right. So Watson 'Svengali'd' the Ady's Captian to sink his own ship, for "better TV", then never aired the footage.....Right. I'm certain Bethune has remorse for his involvement, this sounds like a load of sour grapes.
Pete Bethune Blasts Sea Shepherd In Online Letter Of Resignation (Ady Gil not sunk by Japanese)"
and here's the nasty emails between Bethune and Watson:
Sea Shepherd Emails That Started Online ‘War Of Words’ Released
Since it's information that's already posted I don't think I"ll ping everyone.
Yeah... I wondered how damage to one of the trimeran’s three hulls could have sunk it...
GI had better looking females...
I saw the trailers for this show and thought, "No way I'd watch this crap."
However, you do make a convincing argument in favor of checking it out. :-)
I’ve watched several seasons of the show now. I’m not a fan of the Sea Shepard’s, and in fact do find them pretty inept most of the time.
However - I think there are few points that are indisputable concerning the sinking of the Andy Gil.
1) The entire crew of the Andy Gil was on the back portion of the ship when the collision occurred because they were out of gas. They were un-powered, so couldn’t move.
2) The Andy Gil was rammed by the Japanese vessel which was powered, i.e. could navigate and turn out of the way if the Japanese Captain had wanted too.
3) The Japanese vessel had been previously attacked by the Andy Gil with a Spud gun.
Conclusions I draw from this are that the Japanese vessel intentionally ran over them to destroy the ship. It was an opportunity to get revenge - and the Japanese did.
Now - the “intentional” sinking of the vessel has to be put into proper context. It was a floating hulk. You COULD call it a hazard to navigation possibly. It literally was cut in two by the collision.
Further - the guy making this statement is a wild-eyed fanatic (just like the rest of the Sea Shepard bunch..) with an axe to grind because his 2 million dollar baby got wiped out.
I don’t like the Sea Shepard operation - but then I don’t like the Japanese whaling either. This time - the Japanese are the blame. (Can’t say that often!)
Some of the stunts they have pulled they are very lucky tht some ship hasn’t opened fire on them as pirates.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.