To be a liberal supreme court justice does not require any intellect; outcomes are based solely on the facts and have absolutely nothing to do with the law. The liberal knows who they WANT to win based on their leftist ideology, and that becomes the law.
And the accuracy of your answer is ... 5-4.
To check, tellme how many 5-4 and 4-5 decisions have been voted recently.
How many times have the communist (er, liberal) SC justices voted the case itself; and how many times have they voted right in the middle of their assigned block?