Skip to comments.The Pro-Life Leader Who Is Also an Exorcist [Renowned exorcist - HARRY POTTER opens gates to evil]
Posted on 11/22/2010 10:20:36 AM PST by null and void
click here to read article
I just think we need better brooms.
You very clearly have NO clue about these books.
Since when did you get the right to rebuke me? You’re not my mother, who loves HP too by the way. We could call it free speech. Along with free speech comes freedom of the press. Rowling can write what she wants, just like you can try to be my mom.
And it only takes one individual to start. One individual says that the 10 Commandmants are offensive. Then the government steps in a bans the Commandments are removed from public sight. One individual says that there should be a gay pride parade, and others stand up with him and agree. But the 10 Commandments would never be removed from public sight, and there would never be gay pride parades.
“When you submit ideas that seem contrary to known facts, and cannot explain the inconsistency, you failed.”
I’m sorry, you’ve lost me.
If media had no power to influence then no one would spend money on advertising.
I disagree. The HP series has led to hours upon hours of deep discussion with both of my sons about loyalty, the corrupting influence of power, that the choices we make show us who we are, etc.
One of the things I enjoyed about the books is that there is a very clear distinction between the good and the evil (and BTW, it has nothing to do with wizard vs muggle). Evil is explained; we know what it does, how it acts, and what motivates it. The one character we were uncertain about led to spirited discussions about how we could discern if he was good or bad. What does he DO? Who trusts him and is THAT person seeing clearly?
The magic in Harry Potter is not real. It is just as fake as the fairy godmother in Cinderella. Even at 3 years old my kids weren't stupid enough to think that a pumpkin could really turn into a carriage. It's pretend.
If media has the power to influence, why doesn't reading about murder in the newpaper make you want to commit murder, if reading about it in a novel does?
You can't have it both ways, claiming the power of the media to influence you is absolute when you're reading a work of fiction, and indiscernible if you're reading a factual account, without explaining why they are different.
no door should be opened to the enemy.
Particlarly one involving
witchcraft of any kind.
glorifying human ‘magical’ efforts etc.
And for all the Baptists, I will also be drinking a glass of wine while reading a book that will open up a hell mouth!
You can take it personally if you want. But all I'm doing is saying you're in error when you claim that opining on someone choice of literature is like Nazi Germany.
By your logic, an individual must not opine against a gay pride parade for that may open up Gov't intrusion against the gays.
We could call it free speech. Along with free speech comes freedom of the press
Exactly. Everyone is free to state their opinion. We state those opinions everyday on FR.
By your logic we should say nothing when the press is in error. You do not make sense, my friend. The written word is not sacrosanct. In fact, when one gets published one opens oneself up to all kinds of opinions...positive AND negative. As it should be in a free society.
If that’s what helps you sleep at night. . .
Yes, knowing we still have freedom to express our opinions as individuals does, in fact, help me sleep at night.
As long as it doesn’t contradict what you like to think.
As long as what doesn't contradict what I like to think?
And what do I like to think?
Your animosity toward fantasy literature: You don’t like HP and you have no problem with “rebuking” me for it. Going to give my son a bath now. Later, when I read HP during my bath, I will post if the gates of evil opened up in my bathroom. Have a good evening!
I’m nearly done with the Half Blood Prince audiobook. I *shudder* CLEAN while I listen to them. I love Jim Dale’s renditions.
I wouldn't classify a difference of opinion as a "rebuke" but obviously you can if you like.
You were the one that said I needed a rebuke. Just quoting the source. Good night, pouring a second glass of wine and watching the game with my hubby.
My dear, you totally need a house elf.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.