Skip to comments.Left-Wing Blame Game Won't Work With Arizona Tragedy
Posted on 01/10/2011 4:57:00 AM PST by Servant of the Cross
As the nation reeled from news that a gunman had shot a group of Arizona citizens including Congresswoman Gabrielle Gifford, an all-too-predictable response emanated from some on the left. Despite news reports suggesting that the shooter, Jared Lee Loughner, was simply insane a devotee of Karl Marx and Adolf Hitler, who believed in mind control and conscience dreaming, and who was convinced he would become the treasurer of a new currency many left-wingers sought to attribute his despicable acts to a conservative political agenda.
New York Times columnist Paul Krugman wrote, We dont have proof yet that this was political, but the odds are that it was. Democrat Congressman Bill Pascrell of New Jersey denounced an aura of hate fed by certain people on Fox News. The National Democratic Jewish Council insisted that building levels of vitriol in our discourse . . . have surely contributed to the atmosphere in which this event transpired. The local sheriff in Arizona, a Democrat, weighed in with his own political diagnosis, insisting that the shooting rampage was how [unbalanced people] respond to the vitriol that comes out of certain mouths about tearing down the government. The anger, the hatred, the bigotry that goes on in this country is getting to be outrageous.
Those playing the blame game against all facts and logic are following a well-worn precedent. Anyone who remembers the Clinton years will recall that the then-President used the bombing of the Oklahoma City federal courthouse in April of 1995 as a way to discredit conservative talk radio the voices that had just played a central role in helping Republicans retake the House of Representatives for the first time in forty years.
In the wake of the Oklahoma City bombing, President Clinton condemned loud and angry voices in talk radio for spreading hate and leaving the impression by their very words that violence is acceptable. Thereafter, the Detroit Free Press published an interview with the President urging talk radio how hosts to reject all rhetoric fostering hate and division and encouraging violence.
The gambit succeeded in large measure for Clinton, slowing the momentum of the 94 Republican revolution, putting conservatives on the defensive and allowing the then-President who had been forced to assert his own relevance -- to retake the initiative. Given the political difficulties now confronting President Obama, who faces a newly-minted Republican majority in the House of Representatives after an electoral wipeout worse than 1994, its no wonder that some of his partisans would seek a page from the Oklahoma City playbook.
This time, however, theyre destined to fail. Heres why:
First, now there is Fox News and the conservative blogosphere, neither of which existed in April of 1995. They enable the widespread dissemination of information rebutting efforts to equate Loughner with garden-variety conservatives or Tea Partiers or blame his acts on the statements of public figures. For example, when left-wing bloggers invoked a bulls-eye graphic that had appeared on a year-old campaign map from Sarah Palin as a reason for the violence, right-learning bloggers like VerumSerum were quick to point out that similar graphics have been used by the Democratic Leadership Council. Liberals no longer have the media playing field all to themselves.
Second, at least some respected media figures have wearied of the ongoing efforts to use national tragedies for partisan political gain. Howard Fineman and Howard Kurtz neither of them conservatives have called a halt to opening rhetorical fire, as Kurtz put it, in the wake of such attacks.
Third, almost 16 years after Oklahoma City and after seeing similar gamesmanship in the wake of crimes like the Holocaust Museum shooting -- Americans have become skeptical of cynical efforts to stigmatize entire ideologies based only on the actions of lone, clearly deranged criminals. Thats especially true where, as here, theres no real evidence that the suspect actually subscribed to any coherent political creed.
Finally, the political climate has changed, drastically, since 1995. Many (if not most) Americans have just endured two years in which a liberal majority has governed against their own expressed wishes. By doing so, liberal politicians from the President on down -- have aroused widespread, deep-seated opposition among the electorate to an unprecedented degree. In such a climate, people will find it easier to distinguish between insane criminals and law-abiding dissenters from government policy, because they are likelier than ever to be dissenters themselves.
Given all of this, those on the left would be best advised to avoid cheap blame-seeking for political gain. If they persist in the dishonorable effort to discredit the beliefs of millions of Americans based on the criminal actions of just one, ironically, they may hurt their own cause most, further convincing Americans of what so many already know: That the left is simply out of touch.
Breaking: Democrats Plotted to Blame Tea Party for Slaughter
Democrats plotted to blame the tea party patriots for yesterdays slaugher in Arizona.
A democratic operative admitted this to The Politico."
Arizona Shootings: 'It Was a Colossal Failure of Journalism'
There is no evidence that Loughner was a Sarah Palin fan.
There is no evidence that he was associated with the Tea Party
"He disrupted class frequently with nonsensical outbursts,"
said one student who had attended a pre-algebra class... with Loughner.
In mid-December, Loughner wrote on his MySpace page,
"I don't feel good: I'm ready to kill a police officer!"
Loughner listed Mein Kampf and the Communist Manifesto
among his favorite books..."
These people are nuts!! -- but NOT stark raving mad nuts like mass murderer Jared Lee Loughner who apparently had a crush on Gabby Giffords whom he was insanely fixated & psychotically obsessed upon for three years.
Just what in God's name does Governor Palin or Rush Limbaugh or Glenn Beck or Newt Gingrich or ANY conservative have to do with the broken brain of this pathetic 22 year old?????
AND why did that local sheriff who is blaming political discourse for this mass murder permit such a severely sick individual to purchase a gun and stalk the Congresswoman who'd recently gotten married to a NASA astronaut?
Isn't local LE culpable for not merely ignoring this obvious psycho, much less permitting him to purchase the Glock?????
There needs to be an investigation of each “Laughner” TEA Party page that went up on FB and MySpace as soon as Loughner’s name was released. The names of these lying, leftwing maggots should be available to everyone for any future legal actions.
Good article...total craziness to attribute this guy’s acts to anything other than “insanity.” My caution would be there are those on the right that, in response, try to link the guy to left wing groups. Linkage of any sort, considering the guy’s unintelligible rants on the internet, is wrong.
Playing defense against the MSM attacks on the right is one thing, defining blame to the left for this guy’s actions is another. It’s a fine line, but we need to walk it.
What absolutely fries me is when someone tries to use a tragedy to make political hay. If down the road it comes out that the person was politically or religiously motivated, so be it. But in the midst of the tragedy, slinging mud is wrong. Sympathy toward the victims and their families should be where our minds and hearts are focused.
It will work so long as Big Media keeps up the drumbeat- the accusations of Palin and Tea Party people without acknowledging any contrary information. Most folks won’t really believe it but they will have a new queasiness about conservatives that they know. They will say that yes, the conservatives’ ideas are right but aren’t they just a little violent? and we need to stay away from that. And they won’t vote easily for conservative candidates.
Terrific roundup. Thanks. :)
If the victim lives and is capable of being in public, just wait till the next election!
If you thought James Brady was bad, you ain't seen nothing yet!
And tho it is only a rumor...I hear that in private, the little tin god is dancing with glee over the shooting!
What was the quote??? "Never let a tragedy go to waste."
He (and the entire left wing) surely won't!
And....OBTW: I've not heard yet a peep from the "Momma Grizzly"!!
Excellent questions, all, Hennie. This will backfire on the leftists. We the People are sick and tired of this exploitation by the left.
On the contrary, rather than 'sacred' I'd say NR is viewed as the 'voice' of the RINO establishment here.
'little tin god'??!!
Could it be the Mama and Papa are gathering ALL the forest creatures together to go against the odds? I do not know this is certain...but I do have to think the War is just beginning...just as I think you and I believe Americans have not yet begun, or perhaps as John Paul Jones said it.
To ignore the fact that people do commit acts of violence for political reasons ignores history. But when we focus on political affiliation as motive for violence, we are only raising the bar for more violence. Unfortuanately, we will never be at a place where a circumstance like the Arizona shootings is understood for what it is..a reprehensible and evil act by a person who may or may not be unbalanced, politically motivated (or whatever) but most importantly, totally responsible for the act itself
...”Excellent questions, all, Hennie. This will backfire on the leftists. We the People are sick and tired of this exploitation by the left”...
I agree. I think a big backlash is coming.
“This will backfire on the leftists.”
Already has. Been hanging out at the Yahoo boards. The lefty moonbats are getting beat like a rented mule. Their lies are getting exposed. This article is correct: The propaganda press has lost its dominance and normal people don’t believe these liars.
Yahoo posters are rightly identifying the leftists as liars, socialists and fascists. Most are also convinced by the evidence that the shooter is mentally deranged. We’re winning.
No need to answer any of these nutcase, leftist accusations. The Democrat Party and the left-wing fools are in a self-destruct mode. They have no idea how devastating the election of November 2, 2010 was for them and their sick and evil programs and causes. We have no POTUS, we have no competent law enforcement, Local or Federal, we have no fair & balanced media. The only thing left for America is our people and the right to vote to change this downward spiral road that the Democrat Party is taking America on!!! IMHO, the election of 2012 will be the “turning point” for this great nation. Americans, it is time to wake up and change America in November, 2012!!!
Agree - I’m even finding some of the posters on the more rational leftie sites saying it’s over. A few of them mentioned Rush coming on today and they’re fearful. And that’s for real! They know they screwed up and gave him an over abundance of meat. :)
Have you added the fake Republican registration form image with Tucson spelled wrong twice?
Potatoes are living things that lie on the ground when it is warm in the year 9,199,374,283,485,202 B.C.E.
Jared Loughner is a living thing that lies on the ground in the year 9,199,374,283,485,202 B.C.E.
Therefore, Jared Loughner is a potato.
There are rational leftist web sites?
The media don’t need to give Gov. Palin an opportunity. All she has to do is post to her Facebook page and her views are instantly known: even the most doctrinaire leftist running a major daily or network newsroom doesn’t want to play catchup in reporting what would inevitably be all over the blogosphere in under half an hour.
The dipstick sheriff made it so much easier to discredit the big lie. Not that those scummy left wing pols won’t try to blame Sarah and the tea party.
This is true. But she’ll also want to make sure this post is well thought out and not in the ‘heat of the moment’. The focus should be on the victims and their families right now.
Too sanguine by half! Many of my nonpolitical, "social" interests seem to attract people towards the left end of the political spectrum (typically THEY think they're moderates) and apolitical people who are completely uninformed (ie they parrot whatever the media tells them is The Truth). On those boards, it's all Water is wet. The sun rises in the east and sets in the west. Jared Lee Loughner was inspired by Sarah Palin's rhetoric and is probably a teabagger. The desert is full of sand.
The UK media in the main is blaming SP and the TEA Party, too. :-(
But in the main, what truly matters is that WE let TPTB know we will NOT be made to sit down, shut up, vote for whom we're told, and pay our taxes, which is precisely how "political figures" are already trying to use this heinous crime.
“Rush coming on today and theyre fearful”. They should be, he’s had all weekend to “stew” on all the crap that was put out. Can’t listen to him on radio.....wabc.com streams his show.
The sheriff is exploiting this in a disgusting way, but this is not a fair criticism.
Many on FR fight tooth and nail against any attempt to let local law enforcement even be aware of those who are purchasing guns, much less to have them run background checks on purchasers or give them authority to prevent people from purchasing guns.
If you insist on minimal regulation of gun purchases, you can't then turn around and criticize law enforcement for not preventing wackos from getting guns.
As I understand it, his gun was purchased legally and he passed the FBI instant background check with no problem.
Criticizing law enforcement for not preventing this is like the idiots who criticized the screeners for not stopping the 9/11 hijackers. The hijackers were not stopped because they violated no regulations up to the point they started cutting throats. This nut was not stopped because he violated no laws up till when he started shooting. We don't have "pre-crime" yet in this country.
I’ve been told by other freepers that even though he passed that FBI background check, that he should have also been checked out by the local sheriff.
Who should have called the sherrif? The gun store? Why?
I will get back to you later on.
I will need to go through PAGES of replies, to identify the freepers who explained that the LOCAL SHERIFF contacts people after the FBI check.... maybe???? the FBI paperwork has a carbon copy for local LEOs??? But I don't know, so I will try to find those who explained this to me yesterday.
I was online most of the day yesterday, there is NO way that I can go through MANY pages of replies.
NO way --- so why don't you please just forget that I ever posted to this thread, as there is NO way that I am going to argue about C/C when there are EXPERTS here who know all about the local sheriffs' roles in same.
Thanks. If this is true, it sounds remarkably like the “registration” all good 2A types are always preaching against. I thought the whole point was that the cops or government wouldn’t know who did and did not buy or own guns.
Fine with me. Y’all have a good one.
Although I believe there’s a really big difference between merely purchasing a gun and applying for a concealed carry permit.
As there should be.
Unfortunately, this is all I recall from the interchange.... that they were appalled with the local sheriff in AZ.
Thanks for the tip, who knows, MAYBE I will somehow come across the freeper in question, as it would be very interesting to learn why he was so adament about this issue —— like you, I thought there was a BIG difference between purchasing a gun and applying for a cc-permit.
Instead of " just sayin" ... maybe you should read more.
On the tragedy in Arizona
My sincere condolences are offered to the family of Rep. Gabrielle Giffords and the other victims of today's tragic shooting in Arizona. On behalf of Todd and my family, we all pray for the victims and their families, and for peace and justice. -
Saturday at 1:02pm · View Feedback (32,055)Hide Feedback (32,055) · Share
Notice, he also speculated without having any evidence that Loughner had an accomplice with the guy that was seen with him walking into the store and then the guy walking out by himself. I had a feeling right away that this was just a coincidence and as it turns out, the guy was a taxi driver and he walked into the store with Loughner, because he didn’t have change for the $20 bill the killer gave him
predictably - my liberal “friends” are using this occasion to arrogantly request that we “all” (meaning - conservatives) take this opportunity to re-examine our “rhetoric”
As if I’m going to let some nutcase stifle my freedom to my own opinion.
I’ve seen this happen before, but it seems to be even more bizarre with this case.
Given that Giffords won by a re re recount and that approx. 50% of that country did not want to see her re-elected it would seem that the Sheriff has maligned half the citizens in his county.
We can only hope retirement is in his immediate future.
That's because they know it's going to backfire (no pun intended) on the Dems.
Nice work....I figured it was you as I scrolled.
I am sick of all this bullshit.
A child was murdered for nothing and all we hear about are the grownups.
A sick culture and a sick media.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.