Skip to comments.Echoes of Carter
Posted on 04/14/2011 5:00:05 AM PDT by SJackson
Do you ever get the feeling that youre really living in a television program? For 2011 America, the rerun we are collectively forced to act in is That 70s Show.
Supermarket prices have skyrocketed. An energy crisis looms. The economy sputters along. Back then, the president imposed price controls on oil as a misguided means to keep consumer costs under control; now, the president is poised to implement price controls as part of his health care plan. People talk openly of an America in decline.
We may have traded in CB radios for Facebook, streaking for celebrity sex videos, Betamax for Blueray, and eight-tracks for MP3s. But the similarities between our times and those times are uncanny.
I believe we can have a foreign policy that is democratic, that is based on fundamental values, and that uses power and influence, which we have, for humane purposes, Jimmy Carter announced at Notre Dames 1977 commencement ceremonies. The 39th president committed America to regarding human rights as a fundamental tenet of our foreign policy.
Sometimes, the course of history poses challenges that threaten our common humanity and our common security, Barack Obama explained in his recent televised address on the Libyan intervention. He continued that America, by working alongside allies, should see that the principles of justice and human dignity are upheld by all.
One hears the echoes of Carter not only in the call for a foreign policy occasionally divorced from national interest and tethered to human rights. The echoes reverberate loudest in the manner foreign policy is carried out in the Middle East. The Carter administration in 1979, and the Obama administration in 2011, cheered on the fall of a garden-variety strongman as the dawn of something better.
The Shah of Iran, like Egypts Hosni Mubarak, was a U.S. ally in an unfriendly region. Both were sick old men who had ruled their countries for more than a generation. Mubarak stood by an unpopular peace treaty with Israel while the Shah supplied the Jewish state with oil. Both men stood athwart religious fanatics threatening their regimes. Both sometimes did so through unsavory means.
By dwelling on the ways in which the Shah and Mubarak were like other Middle Eastern rulers, and overlooking the ways in which they differed from neighboring strongmen, Presidents Carter and Obama undercut longtime U.S. allies. The local currents were probably too strong for distant presidents to hold back regional change in 1979 and 2011. But transfixing on the human rights abuses of the dictator in power left them blind to the human rights abuses that might follow their departures.
When events went sour in Iran and Egypt, President Carter and President Obama reversed course on support for dictators who had supported the United States.
We encouraged him to hang firm and to count on our backing, Carter confided to his diary regarding the Shah on November 2, 1978. But within two months, as he explained in his memoir Keeping Faith, that backing had backtracked: The reports I was receiving from the CIA, the State Department, and from diplomats of other countries, led me also to feel the Shah would have to leave. Worse than Carters vacillating, which took on comedic proportions during the on-again off-again invitation for asylum to the ailing Shah, was the administrations forked-tongue policy. Whereas Carter publicly backed the Shah, U.S. Ambassador to Iran William Sullivan, and numerous figures within Carters State Department, undermined the Shahand Carters stated policy. Ambassador Sullivan, Carter recalls in Keeping Faith, was recommending that we oppose the plans of the Shah, insist on his immediate departure, and try to form some kind of friendship or alliance with Khomeini . Sullivan thought we should not oppose Khomeinis take-over because his rule would lead to democracy.
Thirty-three years later, top Obama administration officials were similarly all over the board in their take on Mubaraks continued rule. I would not refer to him as a dictator, Vice President Joe Biden said of Mubarak on PBS Newshour on January 27, and rejected the idea that the Egyptian leader should resign. Hillary Clinton similarly characterized Mubaraks government as stable. Within days, the president called for an orderly transition in Egypt that must be meaningful, it must be peaceful, and it must begin now.
The world still deals with Carters Iranian missteps. Should the Muslim Brotherhood or worse fill the leadership void in Egypt, the world may be reeling from the fallout three decades from now. The downside of allowing human rights to guide foreign policy is that often human rights paradoxically suffer. Anyone watching that 70s show could have avoided replaying those mistakes in this 70s show.
Ironically, the president who Obama so resembles on Middle Eastern policy is not impressed with his efforts. I dont have any feeling of success for what President Obama had done in the Middle East, remarked Jimmy Carter at the LBJ presidential library in February. Tellingly, Carter concedes that Obama had dealt with the Egyptian crisis about the same way Id have handled it if Id been in office.
The original 70s show ended when a Democratic president lost his reelection bid and his successor more than halved top tax rates, backed the Fed in tightening money, lifted price controls on oil, and pursued Americas just interests abroad that ironically achieved his predecessors unrealized aim of furthering human rights. Next year, American viewers determine whether this low-rated 70s repeat gets cancelledor reruns in syndication for a four more years.
Daniel J. Flynn is the author of Why the Left Hates America, Intellectual Morons: How Ideology Makes Smart People Fall for Stupid Ideas, A Conservative History of the American Left, and the forthcoming Blue Collar Intellectuals. He writes a Monday column at www.humanevents.com and blogs at www.flynnfiles.com.
Article printed from FrontPage Magazine: http://frontpagemag.com
URL to article: http://frontpagemag.com/2011/04/14/echoes-of-carter/
This article nails it. I wake up every day thinking I am reliving 1978 all over again.
On Saturday, April 16, 2011, there will be exactly 570 days left until America has the chance to vote this incompetent fool out of office.
570...that’s ten days for each of Barry’s 57 states.