Skip to comments.Opinion: Bin Laden assassinated not martyred (Does this make the rookie Hussein a war criminal?)
Posted on 05/03/2011 4:26:53 AM PDT by Libloather
Opinion: Bin Laden assassinated not martyred
By Parag Khanna, Special to CNN
May 2, 2011 12:34 p.m. EDT
In the decade since 9/11, many senior al Qaeda leaders and operatives have been killed in Iraq, Afghanistan, Pakistan, Yemen, Somalia and elsewhere, yet still all of these countries remain fragile at best and collapsed at worst.
For Osama bin Laden's assassination to become a turning point rather than a Pyrrhic victory, the narrative of the event must be dramatically shifted away from rhetorical overtones about a "war of ideas" or "struggle for soul of Islam" towards a more neutral and universal appeal to a global rule of law.
President Obama set the right tone with his statement on Sunday evening that the "United States is not -- and never will be -- at war with Islam. ... Bin Laden was not a Muslim leader. He was a mass murderer of Muslims." For his criminal atrocities, bin Laden was assassinated, not martyred.
That it was American counterterrorism operatives who conducted the assassination on the sovereign soil of a foreign country is an even more important marker. Many see the assassination of rogue individuals as a violation of sovereign immunity and even "playing God," a right that no nation can arrogate to itself. This is false. It is a powerful symbol of our collective evolution that individual perpetrators are targeted for their crimes rather than entire societies punished in wars.
(Excerpt) Read more at cnn.com ...
Capitol Hill Blue: George W. Bush: War criminal? Last Updated: May 29th, 2004 www.capitolhillblue.com/artman/publish/article_1904.sht... - 29k - Cached - Similar pages
Is Bush a War Criminal? As noted in my previous article "Is Bush a War Criminal," this problem is of great consequence to future of freedom and global peace. ... www.earthside.com/bush-war-crimes.html - 33k - Cached - Similar pages
Bush at the UNa war criminal takes the podium. By Bill Vann 24 September 2003. ... www.wsws.org/articles/2003/sep2003/bush-s24.shtml - 26k - Cached - Similar pages
Iraq war: suspected war criminal at the side of Bush? By Peter Schwarz 27 March 2003. ... www.wsws.org/articles/2003/mar2003/iraq-m27.shtml - 14k - Cached - Similar pages < More results from www.wsws.org >
MSNBC - Memos Reveal War Crimes Warnings... January 25, 2002, in which he strongly urges Bush to stick ... it "substantially reduces the threat of domestic criminal prosecution under the War Crimes Act ... http://msnbc.msn.com/id/4999734/site/newsweek / - 46k - Cached - Similar pages
Guardian Unlimited Politics | Special Reports | Bush is a war criminal, Livingstone tells rally Gaby Hinsliff Sunday May 23, 2004 The Observer Ken Livingstone yesterday demanded that President Bush be ... http://politics.guardian.co.uk/gla/story/0,9061,1222823... - 31k - Cached - Similar pages
Is Bush a War Criminal? by Georg Hoffman-Ostenhof. Profil, Vienna, Austria, Oct. 7, 2002. . ... George W. Bush a war criminal? ... www.thirdworldtraveler.com/International_War_Crimes/Bus... - 8k - Cached - Similar pages
The Free Press -- Independent News Media - Bob Fitrakis... war plans. Once enacted, these plans made George W. Bush a war criminal, just like the Nazi generals at Nuremberg. Bush, supported ... www.freepress.org/columns/display/3/2004/873 - 16k - Jun 12, 2004 - Cached - Similar pages
"Bush's War On Cops" by Benjamin Wallace-Wells... Their focus became understanding the criminal mind and thwarting its ambitions. ... The Bush administration's choice to go to war without a broader coalition ... www.washingtonmonthly.com/features/2003/0309.wallace-we... - 43k - Cached - Similar pages
George W. Bush: War criminal? Is Pope John Paul II telling the world... ... From Capitol Hill Blue www.interesting-people.org/archives/interesting-people/... - 9k - Cached - Similar pages
WorkingForChange-So, is Bush a war criminal? www.workingforchange.com/comic.cfm?itemid=16976 - 18k - Cached - Similar pages
Josh Woodward: bush: war criminal? Via Derek, here's an interesting article from the SF Chronicle that points out that going to war with Iraq would be a war crime. ... www.joshw.org/d/692.html - 16k - Cached - Similar pages
Bush is a war criminal Bring him to justice. The Bush administration in its wheeling and dealing to find a workable ... http://congress.org/congressorg/issues/alert/?alertid=5... - 33k - Cached - Similar pages
Bush At UN- A War Criminal Takes The Podium Bush came before the body as an unrepentant war criminal, whose actions had violated the UN Charter and international law by waging a war of aggression as ... www.countercurrents.org/us-vann250903.htm - 27k - Cached - Similar pages
George Bush: Idiot or War Criminal? Editorial. February 10, 2004. Does this mean, then, that Bush is a war criminal, or is there another choice? ... www.thousandreasons.org/opinion/0210b04.html - 12k - Cached - Similar pages
The-Amazing.US: Simply American: Bush the War Criminal by Rob Kaper, Fri April 23, 2004 12:11pm PDT Bob Fitrakis ... http://the-amazing.us/simplyamerican/4450 / - 11k - Cached - Similar pages
United Press International: Iraq: Efforts to try Bush as war By GHASSAN al-KADI Published 3/29/2003 9:18 AM. BAGHDAD, Iraq ... www.upi.com/view.cfm?StoryID=20030329-082443-4948r - 9k - Cached - Similar pages
Blair (and Bush), The War CriminalNews: ( Print ). Posted on 2003-04-01T02:53:39:00-08 Over at the BBC : If Britain had made it ... www.peerfear.org/rss/permalink/2003/04/01/1049194421-Bl... - 27k - Cached - Similar pages
Exposing Bush the liar, the mass murderer, the war criminal. 04/06/2004 12:49. ... George W. Bush is a war criminal, a mass murderer and a barefaced liar. ... http://english.pravda.ru/mailbox/22/98/387/12429_Iraq.h... - 39k - Cached - Similar pages
Exclusive: Tom Morello - 'George Bush is a war criminal' - "Bush should be tried in an international court as a war criminal. This renewed sabre rattling is both dishonest and disingenuous. ... www.nme.com/news/103541.htm - Similar pages
Rumsfeld as War Criminal? Could face Death Penalty?... would be no real concern about anyone in the administration being prosecuted as a War Criminal. There was no concern that anyone in a Bush administration would ... http://atheism.about.com/b/a/086991.htm - 19k - Cached - Similar pages
Is Bush a War Criminal... By Dave Chandler. If American citizens who were opposed to the invasion of Iraq had been wrong, if the French ... www.opednews.com/chandler%20is_bush_a_war_criminal.htm - 20k - Cached - Similar pages
Scoop: Dame Anita Roddick Bush Is A War Criminal George W. Bush is a war criminal, businesses are "more powerful than religion" and Wal-Mart is evil, according to The Body Shop's founder, Dame Anita Roddick. ... www.scoop.co.nz/mason/stories/HL0403/S00065.htm - 28k - Jun 12, 2004 - Cached - Similar pages
Scoop: Judgement In The People Vs George Walker Bush... INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL TRIBUNAL FOR AFGHANISTAN ... against the Defendant, George Walker Bush, President of ... forces for serious crimes ; waging a war of aggression ... www.scoop.co.nz/mason/stories/WO0403/S00215.htm - 101k - Jun 11, 2004 - Cached - Similar pages < More results from www.scoop.co.nz >
Conspiracy Planet - 9-11: Unanswered Questions - War Criminal .... Richard Myers: Why NORAD Stand Down on 9/11 by CONSPIRACY PLANET 9-11: George Bush, Pentagon Lies & Lies & Lies... by JOHN JUDGE War Criminal Kissinger in... www.conspiracyplanet.com/channel.cfm?channelid=112&cont... - 21k - Cached - Similar pages
Conspiracy Planet - Media Liars - War Criminal Propagandist www.conspiracyplanet.com/channel.cfm?channelid=97&conte... - 20k - Cached - Similar pages < More results from www.conspiracyplanet.com >
Message Boards: Is Bush a War Criminal?... www.news-journalonline.com/cgi-bin/forum/ultimatebb.pl?... ;f=30;t=001306 - 101k - Cached - Similar pages
Is Bush a War Criminal? (6th May, 2003). www.aghilham.com/warandpeace/warcriminal.html - 23k - Cached - Similar pages
Bush a War Criminal?... www.rv.net/forum/index.cfm/fuseaction/thread/tid/138894... - 33k - Cached - Similar pages
George Bush cheats by appointing the war criminal Henry Kissinger ...... www.cyber-spy.com/electronics-design/electro-16326-2991... - 17k - Cached - Similar pages
Re: George Bush cheats by appointing the war criminal Henry ...... Online NewsHour: Shields and Brooks -- June 11, 2004... story today about the note Reagan left on the desk when the elder Bush succeeded him ... I think until this Iraq War, I think the contra fight about the Nicaraguan ... www.pbs.org/newshour/textonly/focus1.html - 25k - Jun 12, 2004 - Cached - Similar pages
Crimes... of International Law: 9/11 CRIMES OF STATE: Bush Administration Culpability. ICC to Get Evidence of 'Illegality' of War. The International Criminal Tribunal for ... www.thefourreasons.org/crimes.htm - 39k - Cached - Similar pages
Attack on Iraq Could Turn Bush into Criminal... by Thomas Walkom. There are many good reasons for Canada's decision not to join US President George W. Bush's war against Iraq ... www.commondreams.org/views03/0318-02.htm - 16k - Cached - Similar pages
United Youth International... Bush a War Criminal? Author: Jillian | United States | Posted ... would remain without US support. What do you think? RE:Bush a War Criminal? ... www.unitedyouth.org/index.php?fuseaction=client.view_me... - 29k - Cached - Similar pages
America's shame : GW Bush : A war criminal in the Whitehouse OPERATION IRAQI FREEDOM "MISSION ACCOMPLISHED". GW Bush : statesman or war criminal? Operation Iraqi Freedom? Mission Accomplished? ... www.president-bush.com/iraqi-freedom.html - 5k - Jun 12, 2004 - Cached - Similar pages
The New Yorker: Fact... Last year, the Bush Administration was privately given a memorandum by an ... such as Fahim and General Abdul Rashid Dostuman alleged war criminal and gunrunner ... www.newyorker.com/fact/content/?040412fa_fact - 69k - Cached - Similar pages
BUSH MUST BE TRIED AS A WAR CRIMINAL! ... Once enacted, these plans made George W. Bush a war criminal, just like the Nazi generals at Nuremberg.'. ... www.surfingtheapocalypse.net / cgi-bin/forum.cgi?noframes;read=1796 - 8k - Cached - Similar pages
Students Movement Calls For Trial of Bush as War Criminal From AxisofLogic.com Iran/Persia Students Movement Calls For Trial of Bush as War Criminal By Apr 19, 2004, 21:54. April 18, 2004 ... www.axisoflogic.com/artman/publish/printer_6681.shtml - 7k - Cached - Similar pages
CNN.com - US launches cruise missiles at Saddam - Mar. 20, 2003... attack as 'criminal'. "Coalition forces have begun striking selected targets of military importance to undermine Saddam Hussein's ability to wage war," Bush said ... www.cnn.com/2003/WORLD/meast/03/19/sprj.irq.main/ - 46k - Cached - Similar pages
President George W. Bush is a war criminal. Bob Fitrakis President Sat Jan 3 www.apfn.net/messageboard/01-06-04/discussion.cgi.10.ht... - 10k - Cached - Similar pages
Exposing Bush the liar, the mass murderer, the war criminal... recent history of the country. Let this document prove as ... www.apfn.net/messageboard/ 04-15-04/discussion.cgi.6.html - 21k - Cached - Similar pages < More results from www.apfn.net >
Dubbydub - Visual Anti Bush Blog: War Criminal www.dubbydub.com/blog/archives/000041.html - 15k - Cached - Similar pages
Exposing the lying, mass mudering, war criminal ... George W. Bush is a war criminal, a mass murderer and a barefaced liar. Let this document prove as testimony for any institution ... www.politrix.org/modules.php?name=News&file=article&sid... - 26k - Cached - Similar pages
George W. Bush Banana Republic War Criminal bush, the oilwarrior and environmental protection pig. "There ought to be limits to freedom." George W. Bush. Can you trust the US government? ... www.graphiccastle.com/bushsucks.html - 6k - Cached - Similar pages
Bush n Blair... draped in black in protest at the visit of Bush and Blair.The statues in Carlisle Circus were dressed in Tee-Shirts saying "Ireland War Criminal Bush out" and ... http://homepage.mac.com/grow/PhotoAlbum21.html - 17k - Cached - Similar pages
International War Crimes Tribunal... President Bush violated the Charter of the United ...committed crimes against peace, war crimes and ... and numerous US criminal statutes in ... http://deoxy.org/wc/warcrim2.htm - 47k - Cached - Similar pages
Protest against the visit of war criminal George Bush to the UK The main protest is to be on Thursday 20 November at 2pm. Assemble ... www.mpacuk.org/mpac/data/ef61a4b3/7528c5b4.htm - 3k - Cached - Similar pages
Bush - The War CriminalSan Francisco Peace March, March 15, 2003. www.brumm.com/antiwar/mar15/013.html - 2k - Cached - Similar pages
Fables of the reconstruction: US Troops Destroy Iraqi Homes On ...... James Hickey is a war criminal. ... personnel out of Afghanistan (so much for our War on Terror ... thanks to our intrepid CIC, Osama bin Ladins 'useful idiot' Bush). ... http://mithras.blogs.com/blog/2003/11/us_troops_destr.h... - 49k - Cached - Similar pages
GWB - Thief, Liar and War Criminal... So when can the rest of the world do a Noriega-style snatch (don't forget that was Poppy Bush who established the precedent ... http://demsjapan.typepad.com/blog/2003/11/gwb_thief_lia... - 40k - Cached - Similar pages
The Angry Liberal - The Middle East: Our War Criminal is Better than Your War Criminal. So Bush thinks Yasser Arafat should leave office because "Peace requires a new and ... www.theangryliberal.com/07-24-02.htm - 10k - Cached - Similar pages
Bush is a war criminal, so everyone who isn't IS better! www.fateswarning.com/fwboard/messages/3263.html - 4k - Cached - Similar pages
GHWBush is a Traitor and War Criminal... GHW Bush is a war criminal and an enemy of humanity, a planet killer and an international tyrant (treaty breaker/ military conqueror). ... www.counsel.net/chatboards/1st-amendment/topic67/1.09.0... - 25k - Cached - Similar pages
War Criminal Bush Sought Ways to Commit Atrocities Without Being Held Accountable!!! Tuesday 05.18.04 <11:25 pm>. Memos Reveal War ... www.tblog.com/templates/index.php?bid=spymaster&static=... - 10k - Cached - Similar pages
Bush: war criminal? 2004 UPDATES Like President Richard Nixon during the Vietnam war, "president" GW Bush should be opposed as a modern war criminal. ... http://alancanfora.com/nwspage.asp?id=101 - 32k - Cached - Similar pages
Islam Online- News Section... against visiting US Vice President Dick Cheney, demanding he be tried as a war criminal. ... with a petition to prosecute US President George W. Bush and his ... www.islam-online.net/English/News/2002-03/14/article34.... - 48k - Cached - Similar pages
Voice of Revolution... April 21, 2004. GEORGE W. BUSH APRIL 20 VISIT Buffalo Says: War Criminal Bush, Get Out of Buffalo! ... www.usmlo.org/archive2004/2004-04/vor040421.htm - 10k - Cached - Similar pages
Was George "Poppy Boyington" Bush a War Criminal? Did Ensign George Herbert Walker Bush commit a war crime as a Navy pilot during World War II? He may have. ... www.washingtonfreepress.org/05/InvestDig.html - 7k - Cached - Similar pages
Iraq - Bush's threats of war - criminal politicking with Blair in tow. On 5 September ... www.union-communiste.org/?EN-archp-show-2002-6-475-2436... - 25k - Cached - Similar pages
4/16/11 - Explosive Bill Ayers Interview: John McCain Is a War Criminal & Pentagon Is a Terror Organization
Someone needs to alert those whores on The View that they were calling President Bush a thug and criminal for the very actions that garnered the intelligence for the military to find bin laden and obama to take the credit for his kill.
So what happens when a foreign government kills one of our congressman or senators that they don’t like?
The Bin Laden kill for all it’s symbolism and “justice” sets us on a slippery slope of international “justice” and weakened sovereignty. If we can cross any border and openly kill people at will, what stops others from returning the favor?
We are permitted to “capture” enemy combatants and criminals and deliver their person to trial.
We are permitted the lawful mechanism for legitimate law enforcement or military personnel to execute the use of deadly force if the target party resists with such deadly force as to threaten the life of those enforcing legitimate rule of law.
It sounds complicated, but it is in fact a very simple thing.
It is illegal for any American government apparatus to assassinate in a premeditated manner.
I dont consider it an assassination but a kill. He was not a political leader but a paramilitary commander. It hasnt been uncommon to target military leaders, command and control has long been a legitimate target.
I believe that law was changed a few years back.
Isn't that what bin Laden's people have been doing to us for the last 10+ years?
We’re in a war.
Smell the java.
Your analogy is not congruent with the situation.
At what point does assination actually become execution.
The execution of a death warrant is not assassination. Likewise the death of Admiral Yamamoto by P 38 was killing of an enemy commander by military order.
The death of Osama was not an assassination. The death was the result of the execution of a military order
“So what happens when a foreign government kills one of our congressman or senators that they dont like?”
Those remaining order the most powerful military in the world to destroy that government.
When one country merely protected the organizer of 9/11, we responded by taking out it’s government and took out another dictator just because we were so pissed off.
“what stops others from returning the favor?”
At base, all society is built upon an understanding of who can beat the crap out of who else. Everyone follows rules because it is, on the whole, more comfortable and productive to adhere to agreements rather than fight. Sometimes, however, someone gets out of hand and we have to return to basics.
The “no assassinations” mantra is, on the whole, for the benefit of those at the top - professional courtesy, a la sharks and lawyers.
Pakistan has nukes.
Based on your argument, they should nuke DC if they are unhappy with our violation of their sovereignty.
Just playing devil’s advocate. Either the Obama admin is deserving of a whole lot more credit for negotiating a quiet deal on Bin Laden, or we’re potentially opening ourselves up to a serious pushback.
Just as the American revolution proved, the biggest, baddest military with the fanciest tools doesn’t guarantee absolute protection. A modicum of restraint can go a long way as well.
“Based on your argument, they should nuke DC if they are unhappy with our violation of their sovereignty.”
They would like very much to, and would if we would not respond by turning Pakistan into a glass parking lot.
Parag Khanna is Director of the Global Governance Initiative at the New America Foundation
Steve Coll is president of New America Foundation, and a contributor at The New Yorker magazine. Previously he spent 20 years as a foreign correspondent and senior editor at The Washington Post
Google’s Eric Schmidt is on the Board of Directors
It is indeed valid to target and kill, in a premeditated manner, one who has derived a position of opposition to ones being.
You haven't been to the WTC lately, have you?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.