Skip to comments.McCain: Waterboarding didn't get bin Laden
Posted on 05/04/2011 10:46:17 PM PDT by rabscuttle385
Sen. John McCain denounced advanced interrogation methods like waterboarding Wednesday amid a growing debate over its effectiveness reopened by the killing of Osama bin Laden.
McCain told reporters leaving an intelligence briefing for senators by CIA director Leon Panetta that he has seen no information so far to indicate that techniques like waterboarding factored significantly in the information gathering that led to bin Ladens death.
So far I know of no information that was obtained, that would have been useful, by advanced interrogation. In fact, according to published reports some of the key people who knew about this courrier denied it, McCain said, careful to note that he was not relaying information from Panettas classified session with Senate Intelligence and Armed Services Committee members.
Where there is published information in the various newspapers and media that the information about this courrier was intercepted conversation between two individuals thats as far as I know, the top Republicans on the Armed Services Committee added. I stand on the side of the United States and by the Geneva conventions, of which we are signatories, which we were in violation of by waterboarding.
(Excerpt) Read more at politico.com ...
Shut up McShame!
Yeah...they broke him....
Senator McCain, have you not yet realized that — outside the Senate and the McCain family — nobody gives a damn what you think?
Good Lord. McCain has really gone senile.
Sen. John McCain denounced advanced interrogation methods like waterboarding....”
You now endorse what, the “pretty please with sugar on top” method? Give it up, John. You had a shot and choked. You could have been a contender. And now you’re just a bum, sucking the gubmint teat for all its worth. I’m disgusted.
South40 to McCain: Stupidity won’t get you elected president. But we’ve already proved that, haven’t we?
Let's see, during WWII, Unlawful Enemy Combatants caught on the Battlefield were interrogated and shot on the spot.
McCain is the best present the Democrat Party has ever had, and sad to say I voted for him in 2008. Too bad he was the only choice against the Lying Commie In Chief we have now.
Actually McCain is right here. McCain got to Osama first and kept talking to him until Osama, in total anguish and desperation turned the gun on himself....
So did Goldwater in his 80’s supporting homos being in the military. It’s strange.
This guy is like a zero/biden hybrid. And he’s on our side!
You early primary states should hang your heads in shame!
If you’re against torture, then why don’t you get your daughter to STFU!!!!!
“McCain: Waterboarding didn’t get bin Laden” and being a pansy didn’t get you the presidency.
You can’t blame the guy really, he’s still suffering flashbacks from his own Vietcong style water torture.
That was my point.
McCain won the nomination because both New Hampshire and South Carolina have open primaries. Democrats crossed over and voted for him to screw up the Republican side. Expect more of the same until those state Republican parties change things. Looking forward to the Romney nomination. NOT!
He more than anyone should understand that his torture has a life-time to never physically heal. Your up and playing Forward in a few days with water on your throat.
Speak for yourself
Sometimes he embarrasses me! He claims to be oh so smart! That is why he lost the 2008 election.
Not much more that I can do but laugh... And the big bad accusation against conservatives is we are single issue voters.... The loons just can’t help themselves.
The MSM has found their man for all the interviews on this issue. Makes me sick
Got so caught up in laughing I copied the wrong link. Duh on me.
So Johnny Boy thinks that enhanced interrogation methods don’t work, that Obama not releasing the photos of OBL is a wise move, and that giving OBL a religious funeral ceremony was just a swell idea. JM is POS of the lowest order.
I am a conservative. McCain is most definitely not on my side.
I'm forever thankful that John McCain picked Gov. Palin as the Vice Presidential candidate. I don't know if she'll jump in this one but i've got a feeling she'll be around in 2016 as well ;o)
McCain is one of the reasons Urkel is now our president. If Dole had somehow run we may have had a chance. ;)
The moron was demanding Gitmo be closed and insisting these murderous scum deserved Geneva protections for years now.
He’s a sick opportunist with an IQ of room temperature.
Am sick and tired of him and his natterings.
The effort to recall him was well underway when we were attacked on 9/11.
From the moment he was elected to public office he has been a traitor to our country and to his fellow prisoners of war.
He tried to convince Kerry to choose him as veep and that is something I will never forget.
He opposed the tax cuts proposed by President Bush.
Too many betrayals to enumerate.
Shut the Hell up, John.
Here is a 2-year-old reply:
Understanding John McCain
McCain's Vietnam experience was so shattering that he sees the world through a new lens, the experience so profound that he has emerged from it with a lifelong commitment to country. This gives credibility to McCain's claim that he is a maverick, beholden not to party but to principle and country.
At the end of his acceptance speech, McCain recited how he came to be utterly broken but then restored, even redeemed with a new commitment to service to others when a fellow prisoner urged him by prison telegraph not to quit and die but instead to carry on the fight out of respect for his comrades who even then were carrying on the fight for him.
Psychologists and scholars of religious experience, especially Christian scholars, have long been aware of the empowering release generated by total surrender of the will. One can describe this in psychological language, or in Biblical language, or even in evangelical idiom.
Whatever language one uses to describe these epiphanies there is no question that very often they are real and long lasting. Psychologists often explain the phenomenon by reference to the ego. An Old Testament scholar might think in terms of the first and second Commandments and the muscular faith which follows adherence to them. Christians speak of dying to the self, picking up the cross and following the Savior to become a new man-to be born again. Perhaps the most famous example is recounted in the Book of Acts which tells that Saul of Tarsus was physically knocked off his horse by the Holy Spirit. Saul experiences an epiphany, Saul becomes Paul, and is transformed from a murderous persecutor of Christians to a fully committed martyr who becomes the great evangelist of the early church, indomitable in spirit, inflexible in commitment, and-like the other disciples- utterly fearless. Significantly, Paul, the newbie Christian, does not shrink later from taking on Peter the acknowledged leader of the disciples "to his face" to dispute matters of doctrine. [The application to the career of John McCain is obvious]
In contemporary history we have the example of George Bush and his transforming encounter with Reverend Billy Graham. Indeed, we have the Reverend Billy Graham's own epiphany in the forest. We have the numberless examples recited daily in meetings of Alcoholics Anonymous. It is from the success of this group that countless so-called "12 step" groups have been formed to apply successfully the same empowering message of surrender. [I refer to the reader to my about page in the account of such an experience by Nathan Bedford Forest]
The important thing to understand about these epiphanies is that when they are genuine they are often life-long and tremendously empowering. Lives really are transformed forever. Criminals go straight, alcoholics stay sober, and the miserable are made happy. In fact, these newly born spirits enjoy their new condition so much that they seek ways to prolong the joy they have obtained in their moment of sweet release. Almost universally, these people find that service to others is the surest way to prolong that wonderful feeling of well-being.
Isolated, sick, starved and beaten beyond human endurance, John McCain ultimately broke and signed a confession which he mistakenly assumed amounted to a betrayal of his country. Who was this wretched man who lay so anguished in that cell? In his memoir and in his speech, McCain described himself as a kind of a hotshot jet jock, a screwup, a discipline problem in school, and an accomplished accumulator of demerits as a midshipman. Evidently, he was also an enthusiastic swordsman. In short, he was an arrogant SOB. Now, in that cell, he had fallen far. The classic description of the crushing of the ego. At this pivotal moment came the means of his redemption via the prison telegraph: Service to others out of love of country. In his speech McCain declared:
"And I wasn't my own man anymore, I was my country's"
And now we know the rest of the story. This is not to say that John McCain was instantly sanctified in all respects, far from it. He still had to swim his way out of a giant mental, moral and spiritual hangover from his ordeal. His screwing around would cost him his marriage before he could swim to shore. Even today, the old self bursts out in temper. But when one lays this template over the rest of John McCains career, one should have little difficulty accepting the story as being essentially true (I for one believe it) and to accept it as a convincing explanation of his career and his conception of his role as president.
Before considering the implications of all of this for conservatives, it is instructive to consider what it means to liberals. [And to compare it to Barak Obama's story]
In a word: "nothing." Liberals do not see it because they cannot see it. They simply do not get it. The whole idea of gaining empowerment through surrendering is as psychologically repugnant to liberals as is the idea of accepting a higher authority in their lives. Consider the Democrat party to be a gigantic creaking contrivance to legitimatize liberals in their insatiable quest to feed their egos. The job of this machine is to provide rationalizations. The obvious examples are sex without consequences and abortion without guilt. These examples demonstrate that the rationalization machine can be quite deadly as it kills 3 to 4 million babies a year. The pernicious doctrines emanating from The Frankfurt School such as moral relativism, feminism, and critical theory find application not just in cultural issues like abortion which kill babies but across the board, touching all government policy and every aspect of our lives.
To repeat, the whole purpose of this Democrat apparatus is to turn thinking on its head and provide a language to liberals so they can continue to play God (especially with other people's lives). Liberals will never about-face and cast away everything that feeds their ego addictions. That is why we hear them using English words but it comes out as a different language.
What about the implications for us conservatives of John McCain's epiphany?
Well that of course depends on how John McCain defines putting country first. It's quite clear that he is not replaced his giant ego trip with a classic Reaganesque conservative philosophy. The danger for conservatives is that John McCain has no identifiable framework, no principled political philosophy upon which to identify the nation's interest.
The great danger to us conservatives, and of course to the nation as a whole, is that John McCain operates ad hoc.
This is what George Will has been alluding to in his column in which he expressed his dismay that McCain has called for the firing of SEC Chairman Cox, "It is arguable that, because of his inexperience, Obama is not ready for the presidency. It is arguable that McCain, because of his boiling moralism and bottomless reservoir of certitudes, is not suited to the presidency. Unreadiness can be corrected, although perhaps at great cost, by experience. Can a dismaying temperament be fixed"
We know what Barak Obama's vision for America is, it is written down, not in his own autobiographies, but in Saul Alinsky's Rules for Radicals. We know also that John McCain has been intensely energized with a vision for America. We're just not quite sure what it is that informs that vision.
McCain is so bad, I wonder how anyone voted for him in the primaries.
“McCain is so bad, I wonder how anyone voted for him in the primaries.”
Millions of demoRat astroturfers, liberal GOPers, and “independents” got the man the liberal media wanted them to get.
McCain is on a real mission to validate the left. He’s a commie. Interesting to see he is completely out of the closet on his views in the ‘twilight’ of his career.
War hero. That was his ticket.
Okay... this lemming is following your lead.... ; ~ )
They have Biden... we have McCaniac.
Its in the water in AZ. I kid you not! People retire down there and they start to go wacky. I sincerely think it is to much sun.
Can’t that man just go away.
Perhaps he is in mid stage dementia????? It happens.
John McCain is one person whose grave I’d love to dance on.
Then he has been that way for the last 15 years. His stupid statements just didn’t start.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.